When you arrive in Great Britain, everything will be new and strange, and you will certainly want a little time to settle down before you think of starting a family or adding to the one you have. The FPA, however, with headquarters in London, wants to help you to have your babies when you want them, so they will be born when you are well and have a home and are able to take care of them.Footnote 1
These words appeared in a 1957 Family Planning Association’s (FPA) leaflet aimed at women who migrated to Britain from the ‘West Indies’.Footnote 2 This leaflet invited the reader to visit an FPA clinic, where a female doctor would explain methods of birth control. A significant number of leaflets were sent to national family planning branches in the Bahamas and Barbados.
This example served as an entry point for exploring family planning policies aimed at migrant women between 1950 and 1970 in Britain, through the case study of the FPA. The FPA was the leading British voluntary organisation providing family planning services before the National Health Service (NHS) took on the responsibility of contraception in 1974 and used the FPA as its agent. This article, therefore, analyses how the FPA participated in the racialised construction of the ‘immigrant’ woman between the 1950s and late 1960s.
The intertwinement of race, sexuality and reproduction has a long history that traces back to the colonial era. Philippa Levine has argued that ‘colonists in Africa, in Asia, and in the Caribbean shared this homogenised view of non-Western peoples as morally lax and sexually unencumbered’.Footnote 3 She showed that the control of sexual practices was central to the politics of Empire and that the alleged sexual excess of colonial subjects was taken as a mark of their inferiority.Footnote 4 In addition, in the interwar years, ideas and prejudices around race featured heavily in eugenic considerations about differential fertility in the Empire.Footnote 5
Post-war migration generated political and public anxieties, prompting tighter immigration controls and race-relations legislation, even as it brought cultural diversity and economic benefits.Footnote 6 Scholars have addressed the relationship between race and health, highlighting the ways in which migrant communities were associated with diseases and unhealthy behaviours and the presence of structural racism in the healthcare system.Footnote 7 Moreover, political actors in post-war Britain conflated race with anxieties about migrant fertility and sexuality, thus fuelling xenophobic politics.Footnote 8 Recent work by Rob Waters shifts focus to the tensions surrounding the integration of migrant communities into British society.Footnote 9 He challenges the divide between institutional racism and the resistance it provoked by examining how integration itself was racialised. In doing so, he also draws out the class prejudices of middlebrow Black Caribbeans in London.
This article highlights tensions between progressive and repressive views of migrant women’s family planning needs. It situates these tensions within national debates about migrants’ place in Britain and global anxieties about population growth in ‘developing countries’. Through its work with migrant women, this article argues, the FPA performed a policy of liberal assimilationism whereby it encouraged migrant women to integrate into British society through the use of contraception and the teaching of norms around ‘modern’ family size, namely a small family size based on the model of the White middle-class family. In this process of liberal assimilationism, FPA members re-affirmed a colonial and racialised distinction between ‘non-modern’ and ‘modern’ sexual behaviour. As will be made clear, migrants were often portrayed as having large families, sometimes outside marriage, and as being unwilling or unable to plan their families. A paradox therefore existed within family planning services: although FPA workers aimed to provide non-discriminatory services that empowered migrant clients, they often reinforced racial distinctions in their work by focusing on certain groups of migrant women, who were perceived as having excessively high fertility or as being more promiscuous. To a certain extent, the FPA’s work could therefore be understood as a way of preserving the ‘whiteness’ of certain spaces. As will become clear later in this article, high fertility was presented by the mass media as posing a direct threat to White British claims to housing, good education and welfare services.
This article draws on the archives of the FPA and the Eugenics Society (ES), as well as media coverage and public debates on migration. These sources, however, do not capture the perspectives of the Caribbean and South Asian women who encountered, or were imagined to encounter, these initiatives. Their absence was not incidental: as Kennetta Hammond Perry notes, such omissions reflect how Black people were denied authority in contexts where whiteness stood as the default source of expertise.Footnote 10 This article originated from a larger research project that sought to document minoritised women’s experiences with sexual and reproductive health.Footnote 11 Calls for oral history interviews with women from the global majority have so far yielded testimonies mainly from women who encountered those services in the 1980s and 1990s. Similarly, the scarce traces of women’s experiences gleaned from community health workers’ archives mainly document the 1970s and 1980s.Footnote 12 Consequently, this article cannot fully address migrant women’s experiences with contraception and family planning between the 1950s and late 1960s. Instead, it focuses on how the FPA’s work produced a racialised, homogenised image of the ‘migrant woman’ through efforts to promote contraception, family planning and population control. These practices also reinforced racialised, gendered and classed notions of ‘modern’, ‘respectable’ and ‘rational’ sexual behaviour – ideals rooted in White, middle-class norms.
Studying the racialisation of family planning services complicates the typical celebratory narratives about the liberalisation of sexuality in 1960s Britain.Footnote 13 The 1960s is seen as a period of sexual revolution through shifts in governance, with permissive legislative changes that prompted the advent of an (unstable) sexual regimeFootnote 14 and of the sexual liberal subject who ‘claimed for equal rights under the law, in politics, in economics, in social matters and in sexual matters’.Footnote 15 However little research has examined how migrant women fit within this broader narrative. By focusing on the FPA, this study complicates existing accounts of sexual liberalisation, revealing that migrant communities and non-White British citizens were often treated differently from White British citizens.Footnote 16 Although the organisation attempted to target specific migrant groups, it ultimately produced a monolithic image of the migrant woman. This was a racialised and gendered image of excessive and irresponsible fertility, requiring regulation through birth control. This framing drew on political and media debates not only about overpopulation in the Caribbean and India but also on the legacy of empire with its understanding of the excessive fertility of former colonial subjects.Footnote 17
FPA, the ES and Population Explosion
In Britain, family planning services were pioneered by voluntary organisations in the interwar years.Footnote 18 The first birth control clinic was opened in London in 1921 by the famous birth control activist, feminist and eugenicist Marie Stopes. Its aim was to provide contraceptive advice and devices to poor married women. Soon after, similar clinics opened throughout Britain, and several birth control organisations emerged. The birth control movement was driven by a combination of concerns about improving women’s health, feminist efforts to empower women with control over their fertility and eugenicist concerns regarding differential fertility rates.Footnote 19 Lay women activists, mainly from the middle and upper classes, and women doctors played a central role in establishing and managing these birth control clinics, while many male doctors remained at first reluctant to provide contraceptive advice well into the late 1920s.Footnote 20
State support remained limited. Until 1930, with memorandum 153/MCW, the Ministry of Health blocked the provision of birth control information through Maternity and Child Welfare Centres, and even then advice was permitted only on narrow medical grounds for married women. In response, several birth control associations merged in 1931 to form the National Birth Control Association, which became the FPA in 1939. The FPA sought both to expand contraceptive services across Britain and to campaign for wider access. The FPA, as a voluntary organisation, had a board committee composed of high-profile doctors and scientists. Finance was a consistent issue; centres were funded by nominal clinic charges, some local authority grants, but mainly by voluntary funds. This precarious financial situation was not aided by the fact that the FPA remained a controversial organisation with little official support until the end of the Second World War. To gain legitimacy and attract support, the FPA adopted a discourse of sexual respectability centred on White middle-class values of self-control, responsibility and rationality.
After the creation of the NHS in 1948, family planning remained largely outside state provision and continued to depend on voluntary organisations such as the FPA, Marie Stopes clinics and general practitioners.Footnote 21 From the mid-1950s, in the context of post-war reconstruction and increasing attention to national and international fertility, the FPA gained greater recognition. This led to increased funding and significant influence over contraceptive standards, research and policy.Footnote 22 Its work expanded rapidly, serving 330,000 people through 270 clinics in 1957 and over 800,000 by 1972.Footnote 23
In 1961, the pill was first prescribed in FPA clinics before it was authorised for married women on the NHS. In 1964, debates took place within the FPA regarding the possibility of opening clinics to unmarried women, but fearing to lose its hard-won legitimacy, a motion was passed against it.Footnote 24 Yet, as this article later demonstrates, the marriage policy was not upheld in the case of Caribbean women. It was only in 1967 – when the Family Planning Act authorised local authorities to provide birth control to all women regardless of marital status, and the Abortion Act legalised abortion by registered practitioners – that FPA clinics finally opened their doors to unmarried women. In 1974, the NHS incorporated family planning, and contraception became free to all women regardless of age or marital status.
The FPA had a long history of collaboration with the ES; the two associations shared the same premises in London since the early 1930s and some members were active in both institutions, such as chairwoman Margaret Pyke. Eugenic ideas about differential class fertility featured heavily in the discourse of the FPA, but racial concerns were largely absent in the domestic family planning movement in the interwar years while they were present in the colonial empire, notably in the field of colonial demography.Footnote 25
The ES was founded in 1907, and it aimed to promote public awareness about eugenic problems, notably the existence of hereditary qualities – both positive and negative – and the need to encourage social responsibility with respect to these qualities. In the 1930s, with the arrival of a new generation of scientists and under the leadership of its new secretary, C. P. Blacker, the ES began to abandon the strict hereditarian views and conservative politics of its early years; Blacker gave the Society a new focus on birth control and population planning.Footnote 26 As recent studies have shown, eugenics was reinvented and reconfigured after the Second World War and should be considered an ‘ongoing political regime’.Footnote 27 After the war, eugenic concerns about differential fertility took on a new meaning in relation to the idea of ‘problem families’ and in relation to ‘immigrants’ fertility’.Footnote 28
These concerns were very much present within the work of the FPA. The FPA launched the Domiciliary Family Planning Services in the late 1950s to provide contraceptive advice at home for women who could not or would not attend regular FPA clinics. These services specifically targeted ‘problem families’Footnote 29 and were funded by the ES. ‘Problem families’ usually referred to large families facing poverty and deprivation. From the 1960s, those targeted by the Domiciliary Family Planning Services also included migrant women who came from countries experiencing dramatic population growth.Footnote 30 Race and class intersected in the provision of contraception.
In the post-war years, fears over population growth were gaining prominence in a context characterised by Cold War tensions. Experts and politicians in Western countries feared that rapid population growth in developing countries would increase the risks of severe resource shortages, poverty and political instability, which they deemed a fertile ground for communism.Footnote 31 As a result, international organisations were created to tackle this ‘population bomb’ through the spread of what was considered the ‘modern’ ideal of the small nuclear family via the dissemination of contraceptive information and devices, the ‘modernisation’ of sexual practices, and the lowering of fertility in developing countries. Organisations such as the International Planned Parenthood Federation and the Population Council were founded in 1952 in London and New York, respectively.
This fear of excessive fertility was also present in international development policy that linked population control to economic development and modernisation.Footnote 32 A modern subject was therefore understood as one who could control their fertility, thereby helping to overcome poverty and contribute to the economic modernisation of their country. Financial aid was therefore often made conditional on the implementation of family planning programmes in ‘developing countries’. It was therefore no coincidence that this same framework, and the same understanding of excessive fertility, shaped British official perceptions of colonial subjects and, later, post-colonial migrants.
These international concerns had national repercussions. From the late 1930s, with the rise of tensions in the colonies, the Colonial Office began to address the ‘population problem’ of the colonies.Footnote 33 Publications such as W.M. Macmillan’s Warning from the West Indies (1936) and Lord Hailey’s An African Survey (1938) circulated and were sent to the Colonial Office, directly linking the poverty of these regions to population growth. Nicole Bourbonnais has demonstrated the centrality of the West Indies Royal Commission, established by the Conservative-dominated British coalition government in the autumn of 1938 to investigate the unrest, as a key channel for spreading ideas about Caribbean population and fertility. The Commissioners argued that the ‘lack of family life’, ‘high illegitimate birth rates’ and ‘promiscuity’ that were presumed to be prevalent among ‘a people whose immature minds are too often ruled by their adult bodies’Footnote 34 were obstacles to social progress. They contended that addressing these issues would also help reduce ‘overpopulation’. The report from this Commission was published in 1945, at a time when a broad consensus had emerged in Britain that overpopulation was the ‘principal problem in the West Indies’. Racialised ideas about the supposed high fertility of Caribbean people circulated widely among British officials. As Ittmann observes, even in the 1950s, beliefs in the inferiority and incapacity of colonial subjects persisted, despite the fact that overt expressions of racism had become increasingly politically unacceptable.Footnote 35
The Caribbean islands were not the only colonies where overpopulation created anxieties for British policymakers. India was also perceived in similar terms, as Sanjam Ahluwalia has shown. The 1931 census triggered fears and sparked intense discussions around India’s so-called ‘population problem’. By the 1940s, this expression had become naturalised in popular discourse on demography and birth control in India, even though there was no consensus among colonial officials regarding any specific policy on birth control.Footnote 36 Sarah Hodges has demonstrated how in the interwar years, discussions on population were interlinked with broader discussion on the backwardness of India; therefore, population as a problem, and more specifically excessive reproduction, was also understood within a framework of modernity.Footnote 37 The idea of India as a backward country was reinforced by the sensational release of Katharine Mayo’s book Mother India in 1927 and its numerous editions. As Mrinalini Sinha has shown, the book contributed to spreading the vision of India as ravaged by social ills, ‘as they affected the position of women, whose roots Mayo traced to an inherently backward Hindu culture’.Footnote 38 One of the key indicators of ‘social degeneration’ as identified by the book was the alleged sexual obsession of the Hindus ‘that was manifest in practices such as child marriage and premature maternity’. This book not only created a sensation in Britain and the United States but also generated international protests towards its imperial depiction of India. After the Second World War, India became the first state to formally adopt family planning as part of its public health initiative, when it set up a Ministry of Health and Family Planning in 1951.Footnote 39
Overpopulation also became a concern for eugenicists in Britain, such as Colin Bertram, president of the ES, who wrote about the impact of population growth on world resources and exacerbated negative stereotypes of ‘hyperfertility’ in the developing world. The Eugenics Review published many articles on world population trends and family planning work.Footnote 40 In addition, Charles Paton Blacker, president of the ES between 1931 and 1952 and administrative chair of the International Planned Parenthood Federation from 1953, was also a leading figure in the British FPA. The ES provided office space to the International Planned Parenthood Federation in London. The idea of population explosion was also discussed with regards to the fertility of migrants who travelled to Britain from developing countries and the fear of racial mixing.Footnote 41 For instance, Bertram authored a broadsheet on West Indian Immigration on behalf of the ES; he sent this document to MPs and the broadsheet received large media coverage.Footnote 42 In it, he shared his concerns about the number of migrants entering the United Kingdom and suggested research on ‘the degree and results of race mixing so far’. Eugenics and racist concerns about the quality of the population were made clear through the fear that the ‘quality of the human groups’ might be endangered by race mixing and that ‘West Indians’ were ‘invaders’ who posed a threat to Britain, ‘when a community of predominantly one race is invaded by a small number of men of a different race, they tend to mate with women of inferior social and biological standing, and the chances against their offspring are still further weighted’.Footnote 43 This broadsheet used the language of race inferiority at a time when racial ideology and race as a biological category were ostensibly debated, and at times discredited and condemned, notably via an educational campaign by UNESCO set up in 1952 and aimed at ‘disseminating scientific facts designed to remove what is commonly known as racial prejudice’.Footnote 44
The FPA was also shaped by the theory of problematically high fertility in developing countries. In 1957, the Association for its 30th birthday, published an edited collection, The Human Sum, which gathered papers by renowned scientists and warned over population growth and food resources. Among its authors was the vice-president of the FPA, Julian Huxley, an evolutionary biologist and eugenicist who believed that race was a meaningless concept in biology. He was especially interested in world population and issues of poverty. The FPA was a national branch of the International Planned Parenthood Federation, and the FPA’s executive committee member Margaret Pyke was a founding member. In addition, the FPA launched a Family Planning International Campaign in 1964 to gather funding to enable the International Planned Parenthood Federation and the FPA to ‘respond to request for practical help where the need was most urgent, and by research and development programme in this country and overseas, to improve the effectiveness of the help given’.Footnote 45
South Asia’s overpopulation constituted a major concern for the FPA. An entire file in the FPA archives contained clippings of British and international newspapers covering the population explosion in India.Footnote 46 In these articles, India’s population growth was portrayed as out of control, with warnings that it could double within the next thirty years. Despite government efforts to reduce the birth rate, Indian families were said to be living in dire poverty, particularly among the rural and lower classes and castes, because of their lack of motivation to control their fertility.Footnote 47 This view undoubtedly informed the understanding of India and, more broadly, South Asian’s fertility in Britain.
Therefore, these narratives and newspaper articles on population explosion that circulated widely within Britain helped construct a racialised understanding of Caribbean and Indian overpopulation, which, in turn, influenced the British construction of a narrative around an alleged ‘influx’ of Commonwealth and postcolonial migrants. The fear around population growth abroad sat hand in glove with a new focus on migrants’ fertility. Women from former colonies who migrated to Britain and settled in working-class neighbourhoods became the objects of specific FPA policies, and racialisation played out in the work of the FPA.
West Indian Women and Family Planning
The post-war era witnessed over half a million non-White migrants arriving in Britain from various regions of the British Commonwealth from the late 1940s to the early 1960s.Footnote 48 In this context, the fear that ‘foreigners’ would reproduce at a much higher rate than the ‘local’ population gave rise to a new definition of what it meant to be ‘British’.Footnote 49 Hostility towards migrants was rationalised by recourse to racial stereotypes that emphasised degeneracy, social disorder and problematic sexuality.Footnote 50 During the late 1950s and the 1960s, what became a concern for the newspaper was not only the number of migrants but also their fertility rate. These concerns around fertility reflected social anxieties towards miscegenation, as exemplified by the Nottingham and Notting Hill race riots that were triggered by the mixing of Black and White individuals.Footnote 51 Anxieties loomed large and influenced politics via the Commonwealth Immigrants Act of 1962 which established the principle of limiting immigration from ‘non-White’ Commonwealth countries. This legislation abolished the automatic right of entry previously enjoyed by Commonwealth citizens whose passports had not been issued in the United Kingdom or Ireland.
In this context, newspapers started to discuss and debate the birth rate of the migrant population in the early 1960s. For instance, in 1961, The Times published an article entitled ‘Immigrant birthrate soars in Birmingham’.Footnote 52 According to the article, the birth rate among migrants had doubled in some parts of the city. This would prove challenging for schools, which, it was said, had to make ready to welcome more migrant children. In addition, the newspaper tapped into racist prejudice about West Indian children’s school ability; it claimed that West Indian children, unlike Indian and Pakistani children, would not perform well in school, since ‘the young children were frequently put out to child minders while the parents went to work’. The alleged deficiency in educational attainment among West Indian children was implicitly attributed to the absence of their mothers. Moreover, the family atmosphere was deemed unstable, which would potentially lead to a ‘delinquent generation’. This harsh assessment of the state of West Indian families contributed to the development of a narrative that linked fertility rates with social problems.
Within the archives of the FPA, two folders from 1950 to 1963 labelled ‘West Indians’ contain several reports written by FPA members about ‘coloured patients’ and several exchanges of letters between the FPA and the British Caribbean Welfare Services that discussed strategies to encourage West Indians to use contraception. The British Caribbean Welfare Services was set up in 1956 to help new migrants when they arrived in Britain. It consulted with the various Caribbean authorities to assess the migrants’ likely needs and provided welfare officers ‘on the ground’. The British Caribbean Welfare Services was also meant to help Caribbean migrants integrate into British society. These materials conveyed the unease within the FPA regarding the unmarried Black women seeking their services who were mothers or in committed relationships. This lack of matrimonial clarity proved challenging for FPA members, who adhered to a policy of only advising married women or about-to-be married women, a policy rooted in their desire to be perceived as a respectable institution with middle-class values.
In 1957, the provision of contraceptive information to West Indians became an object of discussion between members of the Islington Family Planning Clinic and the national committee of the FPA. Islington members Jean Medawar and Helen Brook shared their concern with Margaret Pyke, the FPA chairwoman, that the clinic was ‘crowded out’Footnote 53 by West Indians. They suggested the setting up of a special session for West Indians, where they could be seen without being pressed about their marital status. Jean Medawar was a member of the executive committee of the FPA, joint editor of Family Planning since 1959. Helen Brook would open the first charity to provide contraceptive information to young unmarried people in 1964, when the FPA debated the possibility of letting unmarried women access its services but decided against it.Footnote 54
Margaret Pyke cautioned about segregation and stressed that West Indians must still be welcome in ordinary sessions. Pyke pointed out that the policy of advising only married women might be a point of contention but suggested that West Indian women living steadily with men should be considered common-law wives. The decision was made for Helen Brook to contact J. D. Profumo, the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Colonies, inviting him to promote the FPA Islington clinic to Commonwealth migrants arriving in the United Kingdom.Footnote 55 In addition, the Islington branch contacted the British Caribbean Welfare Services to discuss the issue and take adequate measures. It invited FPA members to contact them if they had difficulties establishing the marital status of some migrants. In addition, one measure suggested to tackle the issue of providing contraceptive advice to newly arrived migrants was handing out leaflets via family planning clinics in the Caribbean islands to inform future migrants of the services available in London.Footnote 56 In London, the debate showed that FPA members tried to accommodate the family planning needs of ‘West Indian’ women, while paying attention not to encourage segregation.
This debate was not confined to London; a similar debate took place in Birmingham in 1958 but with a different tone. Fears were expressed over the moral standards of the young unmarried West Indian women attending the clinic. A report between the area organiser of Birmingham FPA ‘Mrs Lawrence’ and the Liaison Officer for ‘coloured people’ in Birmingham, ‘Mr Gregg’, warned against providing birth control advice indiscriminately to West Indian girls. Gregg expressed the suspicion that some ‘girls’ were prostitutes, while others had formed temporary attachments to men in order to have a room to live in. Both interlocutors concluded that ‘the FPA were undoubtedly giving birth control to a great many coloured girls who are thus encouraged to live promiscuously’. The report concluded by asking for a policy on this issue: ‘Either we should definitely draw the line somewhere or we must admit that we think it is more important to keep down [the] illegitimate rate than to stick to our “married only” line’.Footnote 57 It was decided that the FPA would provide contraceptive advice for West Indian women who were in long-term relationships and ask the Liaison Officer for help in cases where the marital status was difficult to define.
The contrasting approaches taken by the London and Birmingham branches of the FPA can be attributed largely to the personalities and outlooks of the individuals managing the clinics. As I have argued elsewhere, the Birmingham FPA adopted a notably conservative stance toward unmarried women seeking access to contraception.Footnote 58 This conservatism was evident in its opposition to the 1964 FPA resolution that aimed to open clinics to unmarried women. In addition, as Kieran Connell has shown, a moral panic existed about some neighbourhoods of Birmingham with a high percentage of migrants, such as Balsall Heath, which experienced a high level of prostitution. Several media outlets published sensational articles on the ‘Red District’ of Balsall Heath where White women offered their services to men, with a significant proportion of them being non-White given the demographics of the neighbourhood.Footnote 59 While the FPA was aimed at women, prejudices about loose morals within Black communities might certainly have impacted the ways in people like Mr Gregg considered West Indian women. The more morally conservative orientation of the Birmingham branch, coupled with the personal attitudes of those in charge, and the anxieties towards prostitution shaped its distinctly restrictive approach in comparison with London. Consequently, while London clinics tended to adopt a more pragmatic and inclusive tone towards unmarried and migrant women, Birmingham clinics maintained a more judgemental and exclusionary stance.
This divergence also reflects the influence of what Michael Lipsky has termed street-level bureaucrats, i.e. individuals working within public services who interact directly with citizens but often operate with limited resources and considerable discretion. Such workers, as Lipsky argues, develop coping mechanisms to manage their demanding roles, frequently by psychologically simplifying their clientele and environment.Footnote 60 In the Birmingham context, this process of simplification manifested in the actions of officials such as Mr Gregg, who categorised West Indian women attending FPA clinics in narrow and moralising terms, portraying them as either sex workers or inherently promiscuous.
Once again, the issue of letting unmarried West Indian women attend FPA clinics came up at a centre in Croydon in 1962, and it was decided to consider West Indian women in long-term relationships as being married. What seemed to have prevailed in London and Birmingham and later in Croydon was a policy of advising West Indian women who were in long-term relationships, without asking any questions about a marriage date. On balance, what mattered to the FPA was helping migrant women obtain contraceptive advice, even if it meant not following the FPA rules as such. This policy could show two contradictory ideas. First, that migrants’ fertility was deemed problematic enough to bypass the FPA rules. Second, that the FPA acknowledged that West Indians had different family forms than their White counterparts. For London, it was clear that the idea was to help West Indian women access contraception. For Birmingham, the FPA weighed the concern between lowering the fertility of West Indians unmarried women and encouraging their supposedly loose morals. Although shaped by different rationales in each city, these initiatives marked the beginning of the FPA’s efforts to cater to the needs of migrant clients. This shift could have potentially opened pathways for greater reproductive autonomy among Caribbean women who sought contraception as a means of gaining control over their sexual lives. As these debates show, Caribbean women did turn to the FPA for help. But in the absence of written traces of their experiences, it is difficult to assert that they gained autonomy or found this experience empowering, especially since a few decades later, Beverley Bryan, Stella Dadzie and Suzanne Scafe, in their landmark book The Heart of Race, denounced family planning doctors’ obsession with Black women’s fertility.Footnote 61
Population Explosion and National Clinical Trial
Another aspect of the racialisation of family planning services refers to the implementation of policies aimed at restraining the birth rate of migrants. This occurred against the backdrop of fears about the fertility rate of migrant populations in specific neighbourhoods, as well as accusations that migrant women were placing a heavy burden on the health service. These fears were no longer confined to individuals from Caribbean communities but extended to migrants from South Asia since migration law permitted family reunification.
For instance, in 1965, The Times covered the Cabinet’s reaction to the immigration-cutting plans of Selwyn Lloyd, the chairman of the Conservative Policy Group, who had been studying the impact of immigration. In this article, the political correspondent stressed the burden placed on the health system: ‘one of the matters causing ill-will is the number of maternity beds occupied by immigrant mothers’.Footnote 62 Migrant birth rate statistics were hotly debated at the time since it was difficult to establish precise data. Yet, quoting this number contributed to the creation of a moral, racist panic about migrants’ fertility. The alleged substantial number of births among migrants was deemed problematic not only for the health service, but also due to its repercussions for the educational system, necessitating the creation of new facilities to accommodate migrant children. These anxieties conveyed the fear that what were usually predominantly White British spaces, such as hospitals and classrooms, were now threatened by migrants’ alleged excessive fertility.
This context of the increasing birth rate among the migrant population, albeit exaggerated, gave rise to specific interventions aimed at mitigating this increase but also aimed at encouraging the adoption of ‘British values’ such as small family size. I focus here on one of these interventions, namely a clinical trial on the acceptability of contraceptive methods among immigrant populations in the multi-racial Sparkbrook district of Birmingham, which took place between 1964 and 1967. In the 1960s, the Sparkbrook district was portrayed as an area of decay with the highest proportion of Caribbean and South Asian residents in Birmingham.Footnote 63 There was limited material in the archives on the running of the trial as such, and no report on the data collected. Nevertheless, grant applications for the trial as well as short interim reports allow me to identify the rationale behind it and the process of racialisation that it involved.
This trial was organised jointly by the Birmingham branch of the FPA and the Council for the Investigation of Fertility Control. The trial was based on an initial survey carried out by John A. Waterhouse, a University of Birmingham reader in medical statistics and member of the FPA, and Diana Barbban, from the University of Birmingham’s Department of Sociology, who had examined the pattern of fertility in immigrant groups in Sparkbrook. In 1962, Waterhouse joined forces with Audrey Courts (Chairman of the Birmingham FPA), Lella Florence (President of the Birmingham FPA), Sargant Florence (Emeritus Professor and FPA member) and Francois Lafitte (Professor of Social Policy and Administration at the University of Birmingham and FPA member) to submit a research proposal to the ES. Entitled ‘Enquiry into the fertility of problem families in Birmingham’, this research aimed to test the ‘relative merits and suitability of different contraceptive methods on samples stratified by ethnic, economic and family-size group’.Footnote 64 The research proposal opened with the statement:
In the vicinity of Birmingham there is concentrated a larger group than anywhere else of immigrants, representative of many of the countries most in need of population control. In addition, there are indigenous problem families also for various reasons in need of contraceptive advice, but not likely to seek it for themselves.Footnote 65
Both of these groups, the proposal argued, drew heavily on the welfare services, whether at the local or national level. As historian Dorothy Roberts has argued ‘framing birth control as a cost-reducing and problem-solving measure masks its potential for racial and class bias and coercion, as well as the systemic and structural reasons for social inequities’.Footnote 66
This introduction sheds light on two important issues at play within this enquiry. The first was the use of the concept of population control. Indeed, as became clear later in the proposal, gathering ‘reactions among immigrants of differing origins should throw light also on the acceptability of alternative birth control methods in the under-developed countries, whose standard of living is pinned down by the present population explosion’.Footnote 67 Sargant Florence, one of the authors of the proposal, was an American economist, Professor of Commerce at the University of Birmingham, and an expert on the issues of overpopulation and population control. In several papers, Florence warned against the population explosion in ‘underdeveloped countries’ and recommended the spread of birth control methods to tackle the issue.Footnote 68 This proposal was therefore inscribed with international concerns about population explosion. This also demonstrates that population and family planning experts in Britain applied the same framework of excessive fertility in developing countries to migrant coming from these same countries.
Second, the proposal was presented as a continuation of the work already done by the ES and the FPA around ‘problem families’. The proposal acknowledged the importance of these works by emphasising that ‘they laid [a] valuable foundation on which we can build’.Footnote 69 In particular, Perberdy’s and Morgan’s experience with the ‘mentally handicapped’ was said to be particularly applicable, according to the authors, not only among their own similar groups but also ‘among those immigrant peoples whose knowledge of English language is so poor that their position is closely equivalent’. Importantly, the connection was made between immigrants and the ‘mentally handicapped’, showing the racial prejudices that informed this survey: immigrants were perceived as illiterate and compared to people with learning disabilities.
In the exchange of letters regarding the funding of the survey, Dr Bertram, the president of the ES, suggested that he could fund this research himself thanks to an anonymous donation he received from a US donor to support work carried out on ‘any racial, genetics or biological problems’.Footnote 70 I went through all of Bertram’s correspondence and can affirm that the anonymous donor was in fact Wickliffe Draper, an American political activist, ardent eugenicist, lifelong supporter of strict racial segregation, and founder of the Pioneer Fund in 1937.Footnote 71 The fund financed research that sustained White supremacist ideas and demonstrated alleged hierarchical differences between the races.Footnote 72 Indeed, I found a series of letters between Bertram and Harry Weyher, an American lawyer and president of the Pioneer Fund – a non-profit foundation set up ‘to advance the scientific study of heredity and human differences’ – about the anonymous donation.
Bertram stressed that if the research made it possible ‘to select samples stratified by ethnic, economic and family-size group’, as the memorandum presenting the research project suggested, then the US donor would be satisfied.Footnote 73 Bertram added that the same source had funded another research project in Liverpool that was studying the direct crosses between ‘pure’ West Africans and Liverpudlians.Footnote 74 These letters show how ideas about racial inferiority and biological racism were still held by members of the ES. The FPA agreed to receive money from such a fund. This shows not only the FPA’s reliance on external funding, but also the limits of the liberal stance it adopted and its progressiveness. Indeed, population control policy was explicitly invoked in the opening paragraph of the research proposal, as seen above, and seemed to go against the FPA’s commitment to self-determination in family planning and its emphasis on the right to decide if and when to have a child, as expressed in its famous motto, ‘every child a wanted child’.
The survey, published in the Eugenics Review in 1964, reviewed the fertility rate of migrant couples, divided into four groups – Irish, West Indians, Pakistani and Indian – compared to the English population. Several historians applying the framework of an ‘economy of otherness’ have shown the construction of the Irish as White-Other.Footnote 75 In the trial, the Irish were indeed considered othered and their behaviours were included in migrant and racialised categories. The authors identified a consensus on the ‘ideal family size’ across migrants and English residents; the latter preferred 3.1, the Irish 4.1, the West Indians 3.2 and the Indians and Pakistanis 3.4. According to the authors, the West Indian and English subjects were relatively successful, with their family planning achieving an average family size of three. The Indian/Pakistani and Irish subjects tended to have family sizes of five and six, respectively. For the Irish, their excessive devotion to the Catholic Church was presented as the reason for their high birth rate while no mention of religion was made for the Indian/Pakistani group. For Indians and Pakistanis, a lack of information about birth control was presented as the reason behind their family size. Consequently, the report concluded that there was a need for family planning. As a result, the FPA set up a temporary centre in the neighbourhood to serve the ‘increasing needs of the immigrant population’. A focus was placed on the research side of this clinic in order to ascertain the needs of this ‘diverse population’.
In addition, following this survey, John Waterhouse teamed up with Emeritus Professor Philip Sargant Florence and Francois Laffite to apply to the ES, with the backing of the FPA, to fund the research ‘Trial of relative acceptability of certain methods of contraception among people of varied cultural origins’. They obtained the money as well as a grant from the IPPF, since the trial had an international aspect. In addition, the Family Planning International Campaign, set up by the FPA, also supported the trial with a small donation.
Led by Waterhouse, the study focused again on the Sparkbrook district because, according to Waterhouse, immigrants lived in concentrations that ‘reduced the impact of the indigenous culture, and strengthen their solidarity’.Footnote 76 In other words, migrants created ‘foreign’ areas in British cities and posed a threat to the ‘whiteness’ of urban space. In Waterhouse’s view, Sparkbrook represented the ideal laboratory to study the acceptability of birth control methods because it concentrated migrants from the countries most in need of population control. The aim of the experiment was to assess the subjects’ ‘cultural reactions’ to the acceptability of birth control in order to identify an acceptable way of exporting the method to developing countries to fight overpopulation. We can see here, again, the relationship between the national and international scales. Indeed, Waterhouse, in his application for funding to the ES, explained that:
Any attempt to contain the population explosion requires mass methods readily available, easily managed, and cheap both to produce and administer. Several of the methods now available would meet these requirements. But success or failure ultimately is more likely to be measured by acceptability than by the efficacy of the method.Footnote 77
Moreover, Waterhouse underlined the benefit of the small-scale trial in identifying the unsuitability of a method so that ‘costly mistakes may be avoided’Footnote 78 on a nation-wide scale. Additionally, a Hindu midwife was recruited to undergo training during the trial with the intention of sharing her acquired knowledge upon returning to India.
This clinical trial reflected the desire to reduce the fertility rate of migrant families, since it aimed to test the acceptability of the pill as well as a new, inexpensive intra-uterine contraceptive.Footnote 79 As an anonymous FPA member explained to a tabloid, the trial would make it possible to identify objections based on religious beliefs and to overcome them. This FPA member further stated that
there is a strong prejudice among many coloured races. This is partly because of many husbands’ suspicions that a wife who is ‘immune’ through one or other of the method, can more easily commit adultery. But it is also partly due to a deep-seated almost instinctive hatred of pills and white man’s medicine in any shape and form stemming from Voodoo the influence of the witch doctors and such things.Footnote 80
This quote conveys familiar colonial prejudices that equate racialised individuals with animal and irrational behaviour, while colonisers and English individuals were deemed rational and scientific. Moreover, this quote lumps together all migrants of colour with very diverse national, religious and cultural backgrounds. Finally, it also shows concerns about liberal assimilationism by adopting British norms and ‘rational’ and therefore ‘modern’ sexual behaviours.
Different methods of contraception – two types of contraceptive pill and three different IUDs, one newly designed – were offered free of charge to a sample of 120 young married women belonging to four groups: Indian and Pakistani, Black African and Caribbean, Irish and English.Footnote 81 Florence and Waterhouse, in their proposal to the ES, underlined that ‘the study is a comparative one, in which characteristics of the various immigrant groups, both coloured and whites, are related to each other and to those of the indigenous English population. It cannot be described as racial in any provocative way’.Footnote 82 Despite these remarks, the trial performed a process of racialisation by dividing the sample into four key groups and using the English as a control group, setting them up as displaying the normative behaviour to which the other categories would be compared. This shows that biological racism was still dominant. Moreover, it adds to the existing literature that has shown that poor women and women of colour have been disproportionately used as subjects for experimenting with and trialling new contraceptive methods.Footnote 83 This clinical trial had dual objectives: not only to decrease the fertility rate among migrant populations but also to glean insights into methods that could be disseminated in developing countries to address population growth. By placing the fertility of migrants and their country of origin on a shared continuum, it becomes evident that some women were encouraged to control their fertility.
The trial lasted three years and then ran out of funding. In 1966, the ES flatly refused to give additional funding without providing any reasons.Footnote 84 This lack of funding might be indicative of the unease about directly targeting migrant women in a clinical trial aimed at reducing the birth rate of developing countries as well as that of the local migrant population. Another hypothesis is that it might reflect the opinion that results from the trial were too slow to gather, as exemplified by the lack of outputs from this project, except summary articles about its main aims. I couldn’t find any other traces of this trial in the archives.
South Asian Women and the FPA
From the mid-1960s, South Asians in particular became targets of the FPA’s work as a result of their growing migration. South Asian migrants allegedly cheated the system to allow their extended families to join them. Indians and Pakistanis were portrayed as culturally distinct since they did not necessarily speak English and did not show any strong desire to assimilate into British society. For instance, in 1963, The Times covered the publication of Rashmi Desai’s study on Indian migrants in Britain with an article titled ‘Indians want to preserve identity’.Footnote 85 Dr Desai was a senior research fellow at the East African Institute of Social Research and belonged to the caste elite.Footnote 86 In this article, Indian migrants were cast as wanting ‘integration through voluntary segregation’. Desai depicted Indian unskilled workers, unlike their more elite counterparts, as opportunistic, since they were portrayed as making the minimum cultural adjustment necessary ‘to make money’.
Moreover, in 1968, Mr E. J. Franklin, chairman of the Birmingham Public Health Committee, explained that ‘health services in Birmingham were being maintained only with the greatest difficulty because of the city’s increasing immigrant burden’. For him, the arrival of Kenyan Asians exacerbated the strain on the health system, which was already under pressure because of the high birth rate in migrants, ‘46 per 1000 compared with the city average of 19.4 per thousand’.Footnote 87 In the winter of 1967–8, a significant number of Kenyan Asians who held a UK passport fled the Africanisation policies of Kenyatta’s government. By early 1968, as Becky Taylor has argued, the press started to talk about the ‘Kenyan Asian crisis’.Footnote 88 The Commonwealth Immigrants Act of 1968 sought to address the situation by requiring anyone wishing to enter Britain to prove a ‘close connection’ to the United Kingdom through birth, parents or grandparents, including those who already held passports issued by the UK government. In doing so, it intentionally denied most Kenyan Asian UK passport holders the right to unrestricted entry into Britain.Footnote 89
South Asian women were also depicted as submissive, ignorant and mainly illiterate, whose lack of speaking skills posed a threat to the moral upbringing of their children. In 1971, the British tabloid Evening Standard published an article entitled ‘Children who know too much about sex’.Footnote 90 This article explained that in FPA clinics, young Asian English-speaking children served as interpreters for their mothers who did not speak English. As a result, family planning doctors feared that these children were ‘becoming expert in sex too soon’. Scholars such as Philippa Levine and Antoinette Burton have explored the colonial construction of this set of assumptions and beliefs around race and sex in colonial India, which continued to influence British representation of South Asian women in the postcolonial era.Footnote 91 Antoinette Burton has argued that Indian women were depicted as ‘a helpless, degraded victim of religious custom and uncivilized practices’.Footnote 92
The notion of the South Asian woman as ignorant and submissive deeply influenced the work carried out by the FPA. While the charity simultaneously acknowledged South Asian women’s right to access contraceptive information to enhance their agency and sexual autonomy, this recognition was limited by implicit assumptions about what constituted a ‘good reproductive decision’. Consequently, the FPA’s vision of a modern reproductive subject was narrowly defined: a woman who displayed rational, self-disciplined behaviour, who chose to have a small family in response to her socio-economic circumstances, and who adopted modern methods of birth control to achieve that goal. In doing so, the FPA’s discourse reinforced a particular model of modernity and respectability, one that aligned reproductive responsibility with Western ideals of rationality and progress, rather than accommodating the diverse cultural, social and personal realities of South Asian women.
The arrival of Indian and Pakistani migrants in great numbers in Britain generated debates in the press and tensions with local populations. In this tense context, the FPA recognised the necessity to disseminate information on family planning methods to South Asian migrants and devised several strategies to do so. First, the FPA opened centres in Indian and Pakistani neighbourhood, sometimes as an answer to local authorities’ request. This was the case, for example, in Southall, a major centre of settlement for the Sikh community, where White residents felt threatened by the arrival of migrants. For instance, in 1963, in Southall, 600 residents signed a petition sent to the borough council to prevent ‘colour people to buy houses’.Footnote 93 In this context, the Southall local authorities asked the FPA to help them deal with the fertility of their migrant population by opening an FPA centre in the neighbourhood. Here again, the threat of coloured migrants to White urban space functioned as a catalyst to develop specific family planning services for them.
In an article in Family Planning presenting the work of this new ‘multiracial clinic’, ‘Mrs Heywood’, secretary of the Ealing and Acton Branch and responsible for setting up the clinic, conveyed the usual depiction of South Asian women: ‘We were told that the women in Southall were mainly peasant women who could not read, only spoke Punjabi and were unfamiliar with the concept of family planning’.Footnote 94 She contacted the Indian Women Committee to discuss ways of advertising the clinic. It was agreed that two films produced by the IPPF about population explosion and contraception would be shown at the next meeting of the Indian Women Committee. This reference to population explosion explicitly linked the fertility of migrant women to that of their country of origin, which was widely understood to be problematic and in need of control.
In addition, a tape recording, translated into Punjabi and presenting the work of the FPA, was played at the afternoon postnatal clinic with the hope that women would then attend the family planning clinic once they had given birth. It quickly became evident that language acted as a barrier for many South Asian women seeking assistance. Consequently, the Southall clinic opted to employ South Asian staff members, who spoke the language of their clients and served as interpreters, thereby facilitating better communication and understanding. This strategy would become a common practice in clinics that were in multiracial neighbourhoods.
Other strategies were also developed to spread information on family planning. In 1968, the FPA launched a concerted campaign between the FPA branches of Bradford, London and Birmingham to ‘interest immigrants in birth control methods’.Footnote 95 This campaign relied on film shows, tape recordings, house-to-house visits, leaflets and the involvement of factory personnel officers. In the press conference covering the launch of the campaign, Helen Graham, head of the FPA information services, aware of the potential association between the campaign, racism and population control, asserted that ‘we want to show immigrants what birth control facilities are available to them. We are not concerned with racialism or keeping Britain white’. Helen Graham underlined the positive elements for migrants in using birth control: ‘we merely want to spread the message that it is easier to get a house and that pay packet stretches further if the size of the family is controlled’. The campaign was therefore framed as migrants’ right to family planning information for their own financial benefit but also potentially to alleviate the burden they might represent on the welfare services. It was a campaign that sought to teach them ‘rational’ reproductive behaviours, namely the modern White middle-class model of a small nuclear family in which parents decide on the number of their children according to their financial means.
In an effort to overcome linguistic barriers, the FPA translated its informational materials into Punjabi and Urdu. Nevertheless, as reflected in the organisation’s internal correspondence, the initiative did not yield the anticipated results, and the number of South Asian migrants accessing FPA centres showed little increase. This outcome was interpreted primarily as an indication of the campaign’s shortcomings, rather than prompting reflection on the possibility that South Asian women may not have achieved their desired family size and therefore had limited interest in adopting contraceptive measures.
To increase South Asian women’s frequentation of the clinics, the FPA decided to better understand in what terms a family planning campaign should be couched. Consequently, they solicited guidance from individuals involved in working with and for migrant communities and who ‘had first-hand knowledge of the living conditions, culture, and religious and social attitudes of immigrants living in Britain’,Footnote 96 such as Mary Dines, Immigrant Advisory Officer and Assistant Secretary to the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants at the London Council of Social Services; Sen Gupta, Health Visitor for Southall; Mr H. S. Dillon, General Secretary, Indian Workers’ Association, Southall; and Mr C. Anwar, Welfare Officer, the Pakistani High Commission. As Kalathmika Natarajan has argued, diplomatic actors associated with the Indian High Commission often worked with the British state to impose normative race-class values of hygienic citizenship.Footnote 97 A similar form of collaboration can be seen with the FPA, which worked to teach South Asian migrants ‘modern’ reproductive behaviours.
Culture and religion were therefore perceived as significant barriers to the dissemination of contraceptive knowledge and access. Nevertheless, the FPA’s willingness to better understand women’s lived experiences reflected an effort to promote sexual autonomy among South Asian women. However, this notion of sexual autonomy was, as previously discussed, framed within a narrow, modernist discourse that idealised the ‘responsible’ modern female subject, where decisions were made rationally after careful consideration of the financial situation of the family.Footnote 98
A meeting was convened with the FPA to discuss the reasons why previous leaflets fell short in motivating migrant women to attend the clinic and to identify the main arguments that would prove convincing for migrant couples. The meeting revealed that arguments regarding poverty, housing and education held little sway with South Asian couples, who prized large families, viewing children as financial assets; they believed that they would be able to have housing only if they had large families and wanted their children to benefit from state education. In contrast, what would work would be arguments that emphasised the benefit of spacing the family for the sake of the mother’s health and the health of her children. In addition, it was decided to emphasise the fact that a woman doctor would see the South Asian wife in a family planning clinic but that the husband or a relative was welcome to come alongside. Moreover, the targeted readership should be the wife and the husband since ‘no wife would use family planning without her husband’s approval’.
Following this meeting, a new leaflet with a simple visual approach, reinforced by a short text, was developed. It was translated into Urdu, Punjabi and Bengali. The new leaflet entitled How family planning can help you offered twelve little vignettes, some of them illustrated, that underlined the health benefits of family planning for the wife: ‘a rest between each new baby keeps a wife healthy and fit to look after her home and family’,Footnote 99 while it also stressed that small families will help the husband to financially provide for his family and to afford better food. It then depicted a woman doctor presenting the different methods of birth control to the wife, who was accompanied by her husband.
This new campaign was covered in an article in The Times, which emphasised the anti-racist agenda of the FPA in praising the role of Helen Graham.
Mrs Graham does not claim any right on behalf of the Family Planning Association to impose English norm of social behaviour or even on responsible parenthood on Asian and West Indian society. She sees her efforts as limited to making available one more option to them, the option to choose when their children are to be born and how many they have. To go beyond that would be to enter the dangerous territory of differential birth rates.Footnote 100
This rejection of eugenic thinking contrasted with the idea of differential fertility as promulgated by the FPA through its Domiciliary Family Planning Services, where the fertility of those allegedly a burden to the welfare state was to be curtailed and where Black and South Asian women disproportionately received long-lasting contraceptive methods that were not officially endorsed by the Committee for Safety of Medicines.Footnote 101 Yet, if providing family planning services to Indian and Pakistani migrants was portrayed as a right to information, a racialisation process nevertheless operated that castigated all Indian and Pakistani migrant women as ‘wives’ under the power of their husbands. Indeed, single Indian and Pakistani women did not seem to exist in the narrative for family planning methods, and all the ‘wives’ were in addition been depicted as stay-at-home mothers, unemployed. Moreover, the emphasis put on the financial benefits of family planning nevertheless functions as a conveyer of norms around good and rational behaviours to adopt.
Conclusion
In the post-war years in Britain, the FPA tried to address the family planning needs of migrant women. Race was overdetermined in this context. Race appears as a capacious and multidimensional modality of difference; it was invoked as a marker of high fertility, a signifier of allegedly dysfunctional families, a potential determinant of promiscuous sexual behaviours and a marker of vulnerability. In the work they did with ‘migrant’ women from different countries, the FPA produced a homogenised vision of ‘migrant’ women and simultaneously reinforced ideals about British sexual behaviours, citizenship and legitimate family formations in ways that normalised and validated whiteness. Their work took place in a context where migrants’ high fertility was depicted by the mass media and certain politicians as a threat to White British claims to housing, space and state services.
The FPA first identified West Indian women as targets for their work, then broadened their scope to include South Asian and Irish women who lived in poor and deprived neighbourhoods, eventually focusing only on South Asian women in the late 1960s, when it appeared that their family size remained above the average British family size.
The late 1950s to the mid-1960s was the period of the problematisation of migrant fertility. The media helped to construct migrant fertility as a social problem by extensively discussing the birth rate of West Indians in various cities and portraying it as a social threat to the ‘whiteness’ of urban areas. According to the media, a high number of illegitimate children and an allegedly unstable family environment could fuel delinquency and lead to poor educational outcomes. Simultaneously, the FPA debated extending its provision of birth control advice (hitherto restricted to married women) to unmarried women from the ‘West Indies’. Tensions emerged within the organisation, showing different strategies to deal with migrants’ family planning needs. The FPA ultimately concluded that prioritising the provision of contraception to ‘West Indian’ women took precedence over the organisation’s previous rules.
From the early 1960s, the FPA tried to implement policies aimed at reducing migrant birth rates. The ES played a pivotal role in shaping these policies by providing substantial funding for related research and experiments. I have established a connection between international population control policies, a White supremacist American agency, eugenic ideologies and local experiments conducted by the FPA. This linkage is illustrated through the case of a clinical trial conducted in the multiracial and deprived neighbourhood of Sparkbrook in Birmingham. Concerns around migrant birth rates led to the focus of the trial on evaluating the acceptability of contraceptives in order to export the most acceptable method to developing countries.
Finally, by the mid-1960s, the FPA focused its work on the fertility of South Asian women and the development of targeted information campaigns. These campaigns were not explicitly framed as an attempt to reduce the fertility of these migrants, but rather to expand access to birth control information. This information was meant to enlighten ‘ignorant’ South Asian migrants to the benefits about family planning. In this process, while FPA members were careful to distance themselves from appearances of racism and population control, the initiatives they developed were nevertheless racialised by depicting South Asian migrant women as ignorant and submissive.
Illuminating the paradoxes within the ways the FPA dealt with migrant fertility challenges the understanding of two important aspects of post-war British social history. Firstly, it nuances the dominant feminist narrative of progressive sexual liberation by highlighting the paradoxes within the FPA’s services. Alongside an agenda of empowerment and reproductive autonomy for migrant women, there was also an agenda of liberal assimilationism and control. This tension between empowerment and control can be explained by the model of the modern reproductive subject that the FPA aimed to convey. This is the second addition to our understanding of postcolonial Britain. The FPA played an important role as a vector and supplier of racialised norms and policies around birth control. Family planning services and provision played a role not only in the process of integration and assimilation of migrant populations but also in the stabilisation of the vision of the modern reproductive subject, where modernity was based on White middle-class values of responsibility and rationality, whereby married women controlled their fertility according to their economic situation.
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to the Swiss National Science Foundation for funding this research through the grant (PCEFP1_203399). I would like to thank the reviewers for their thoughtful feedback. I am also very grateful to George J. Severs and Naomi Samake-Bäckert for their comments and brainstorming. I would like to thank Mischa Suter, Roberta Bivins and Jessica White for comments on an earlier version of this paper. I presented parts of this paper at the Reproductive Justice Network, the Gender Workshop at the Graduate Institute in Geneva, the Social History of Medicine Conference in Glasgow and Reproductive Justice Now! in London. I am grateful to all the participants for their remarks and questions.
