The relationship between area studies and political science has long been a source of fertile and sometimes anguished debate. Contemporary Chinese Politics wades into this relationship with the primary aim of showing how the China field is deeply anchored within the discipline. The editors of the book set up three specific goals in this volume. The first is to enable researchers to more effectively use new sources and methods of data collection. The second is to better integrate the study of Chinese politics into the discipline of political science with the goal of mutual benefit. The third is to provide information that may help researchers deal with the logistical and ethical problems of fieldwork research in an authoritarian setting.
The first and third goals are amply met in this book. The volume succeeds splendidly in discussing and evaluating traditional and new methods in the study of Chinese politics, including ethnographies, case studies, surveys, media content analysis, and experiments, as well as the effective use of diverse sources, including archives, elite biographies, and the Internet. In terms of its discussion of methods, sources, and logistical issues involved in archival and survey research, this book is a must-read for graduate students and scholars who need to navigate the murky grounds of field research in China.
On the issue of the relationship between Chinese politics and the discipline of political science—the second goal of the editors—this volume falls short, however. It gives the impression that the relationship between these two fields is largely unidirectional—that is, that political science has influenced the study of Chinese politics primarily in terms of the use of new quantitative methods. The heavy emphasis on survey research (five chapters), as well as chapters by Victor Shih et al., Peter Hays Gries, and Daniela Stockmann all show how cutting-edge quantitative methods can help generate, systematize, and assess new data. On that basis, the emphasis of contemporary political science on quantitative methodology has now decisively influenced a research field that had long been heavily qualitative in nature.
While the book thus clarifies how the China field is integrated in political science due to its absorption of many of the discipline's new methods, it is much less clear about how the field of Chinese politics has in turn influenced political science, or to put it in the editors' terms, led to the “betterment of both.” Part of the problem with the book is that it tries to cover too much ground and in so doing cannot fulfill its three main goals. The division into three parts—“sources,” “qualitative methods,” and “surveys”—does not provide room for a sustained discussion of the relationship between the China field and political science, other than by arguing that China scholars are now utilizing all of the “modern” methods of political science. The larger problem, however, is that some of the chapters, such as those by Xi Chen, Allen Carlson and Hong Duan, Stockmann, Pierre Landry, and Lily Tsai read like a “how-to,” while other chapters, including those by Neil Diamant, Gries, Calvin Chen, Benjamin Read, William Hurst, and Bruce Dickson are much more analytical, discussing in greater depth the substantive research question(s) being pursued and how a particular method or data source helps further the specific question(s). Lest I be misunderstood: The how-to chapters will be very useful to practitioners of particular methods or hunters of particular sources. Yet there is clearly an analytical disjuncture between those chapters that explicitly show how method and theory can buttress each other and those that serve more as handbooks for particular types of research or fieldwork strategies.
To the extent that the editors have made more of an effort to focus the volume on the relationship between methodology and theory and on the broader implications of a particular analytical argument, it could have been much more evident how the China field has influenced, or could potentially influence, political science. For this to have been more explicit, the editors would have had to prioritize the issue of theory much more forcefully and given it at least as much weight as the discussion of methodology and sources. Furthermore, it would have been critical to ensure that all chapters show clearly how methodology and sources address issues of theoretical relevance. Because a few chapters fail to explicate the theoretical returns from particular methods or sources, they give the reader the sense that the methods or data used reflect less a theoretical vision than a concern with methodological rigor and data availability.
This problem at its more general level is in fact highlighted in a concluding chapter by Kenneth Lieberthal, one of the four editors. Perhaps because Lieberthal comes from an older generation of China scholars, his chapter has a dissenting tone to it—dissenting in terms of the direction of political science in general and of some of the key arguments of the volume. He acknowledges the importance of sophisticated methods, but also cautions that such methods, if premised primarily on the cause of rigor, may end up investigating questions of minimal theoretical import. The correlation between rigor and the mundane that Lieberthal posits is by no means automatic, but coming at the end of the book, his piece appears as a plea for carefully assessing the path in which the latest generation of China scholars—and this book—are heading.
The lack of a strong theoretical underpinning to the volume as a whole can also be traced to its uneven structure and the relatively short shrift given to qualitative methods. It is after all not obvious why five chapters on survey research are included but only three on qualitative methods, a much broader category. Given the China field's traditional emphasis on qualitative methods, this area should have been given significantly more assessment. But crucially, I want to highlight here that the editors' lack of engagement with qualitative methods has led them to ignore the central issue linking the China field to political science—that is, the question of “China in comparative perspective.” In their introduction, Carlson and his colleagues take a brief stab at explaining the difficulty of comparing China, but besides discussing problems of typology, internal diversity, and data quality, they do not sustain this question throughout the volume.
It is precisely on this comparative question that deeper engagement with both qualitative methods and theory would have been valuable. While quantitative cross-national analysis may simply make China one more N in a data set, comparative-historical analysis or typological/conceptual analysis—key areas of qualitative methods not discussed in this book—could help place China in a broader comparative theoretical field while still studying it contextually. This thus leads one to ask the following questions. What is the state of the China literature in terms of comparative-historical analysis or typological analysis? What kinds of studies have enabled China to be analyzed in a comparative framework? And what are the consequences of failing to analyze China in a comparative context?
Research analyzing China in an explicit comparative framework is relatively rare, and that perhaps explains the absence of chapters directly addressing the comparative question. Yet the point I seek to make is a broader one, and it is underscored in the book by Lieberthal's observation about the China field's potential contribution to political science. That contribution, he argues, should be to challenge prevailing theories that are based largely on the Western historical experience. Whether through qualitative or quantitative methods, the relationship between the China field and comparative politics can be best assessed in terms of theory building and theory testing. The superb essay by Read, as well as the chapters by Gries, Hurst, and Dickson, provide excellent perspectives on how method and theory can mesh together and build, refine, challenge, and converse with broader theoretical and analytical positions within political science. As a resource for young China scholars—its main audience—this volume has made huge strides. But on the dialogue between the China field and political science, more can—and should—be said.
