The authors of the focal article (Kath etal., Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) briefly mention a Field of Dreams approach to teaching industrial and organizational (I-O) psychology. Namely, if you build an interesting and engaging class that creates “buzz” among students, they will come. We agree with this assertion, as well as their specific points on how and why to make an overall better class experience. However, given their limited space for suggestions, we would like to offer additional ideas for doing just that. Specifically, we want to suggest that instructors actually show a movie like Field of Dreams! Although this particular movie is not the most I-O-relevant film (albeit themes such as teamwork and motivation are certainly there for discussion), many movies, televisions shows, podcasts, memes, and so forth can create a fun and stimulating atmosphere that is conducive to material retention.
The focal authors reference tying the concepts in our field to the actual work environment, which is an excellent way to put them into a real-world context for students, and get them thinking how and why these factors are relevant to their future jobs. However, not all college students have had jobs or are even ready to think about what the working world will look like for them. On one hand, as professors and I-O psychologists, it is our responsibility to help them start thinking in that direction. However, we also have the ability to put the concepts into a context that they care about now, such as pop culture, and jump start their ability to notice I-O psychology all around them. In short, not all 18- to 22-year-olds want to think about work, but all (or at least almost all of them, and we as instructors) do enjoy fun!
The crux of the focal authors’ argument is that students will connect more to the material when it is applied to specific examples. Within this idea, social cognitive theory (SCT) shows that humans often learn better from experience than from purely hypothetical scenarios, even when that experience comes vicariously through watching others (Gibson, Reference Gibson2004). Thus, we suggest using widely shared experiences from popular culture. Cognitive psychology shows that through “mirror neurons,” people actually experience what they see on a screen the same as they would if they were in the scene themselves (Gallese & Guerra, Reference Gallese and Guerra2012). This is why people feel uncomfortable watching certain scenes of The Office; they are actually feeling some portion of what it would be like to be in those scenes. As an extra bonus, many such stories are informed by the real-life experiences of the writers (Fischer & Kinsey, Reference Fischer and Kinsey2019), connecting them to those real-world work experiences, as is suggested above. Once students have experienced the same example for whatever I-O topic is to be discussed, it will allow for a conversation that is based on deeper understanding while still allowing additional personal experiences to be integrated into the discussion.
Furthermore, although there is some debate about attention spans, and they certainly vary from student to student, it is often suggested that instructors break up lectures with other activities to keep students more engaged (Wilson & Conyers, Reference Wilson and Conyers2011). Injecting clips and other media into your course can help create this variety and limit cognitive fatigue, giving students a better chance to maintain attention and retain material. Another advantage is that adding aspects you personally find fun and interesting can increase your own engagement with your class. We have found in our own teaching that an instructor that brings genuine excitement for material to class is noticed by students and often creates a positive feedback loop; students are energized by the instructor’s enthusiasm, increasing instructor motivation, and so on. We also suspect that many readers of this commentary have also experienced how quickly a similar cycle can work in the negative direction, for example when teaching material that is not personally interesting and/or when the aspects that are instrinsically interesting have not been incorporated into the class.
As an instructor, you have probably been watching a movie or show and had that “a-ha” moment and thought, “That was a perfect examples of what I was just teaching in class last week!” When this happens to us, we try to write down that example for future use in the classroom. Fortunately, we are not limited by having only our own experiences to access for examples of I-O psychology issues that appear in pop culture because other teachers and researchers have created lists that can be easily referenced when putting a course together. A few articles have provided several examples of specific scenes that would be great for using in classes (e.g., Casper etal., Reference Casper, Champous, Watt, Bachiochi, Schleicher and Bordeaux2003; Kernodle, Reference Kernodle2009), and the University of Maryland program also has a very helpful list on their website (2019). Similarly, there are a growing number of podcasts that are related to I-O psychology (SIOP Conversation series, Dept. 12) and making I-O psychology more relatable (Worklife with Adam Grant). Even some popular podcasts that are not specifically about work often touch on I-O psychology because of how ubiquitous it is in daily life (e.g., Revisitionist History by Malcolm Gladwell, Stuff You Should Know, Freakonomics Radio). We recently created a Google Doc repository that we hope will be a living document for these and other pop culture resources for I-O psychology instructors to use and contribute to.Footnote 1
Further, more students these days are interacting with the meme culture, and this provides teachers with quick, funny, and interesting ways to communicate I-O psychology concepts to students. Memes are useful because they often take only a single picture or gif, allowing instructors to easily put them into slides for students to read/interpret on their own. Memes can be incorporated into the instructor’s slides or lecture about how these concepts work in the real world or used to as catalysts for a more in-depth discussion. Instructors can also use them as class activities or assignments by having students create their own I-O-related memes. If “meme hunting” is not something you personally enjoy, there are several amazing resources and social media pages already in place to provide them to you. On Instagram alone, you will find @iopsychmemes, @orgpsych, @hr.memes, @humanresourcesmemes, @workpsych, and @consultinghumor, just to name a few that regularly put out thought-provoking and informative memes for you to use.
These resources and suggestions are far from exhaustive, but we wanted to provide some specific examples for those of you who are just getting started with this pedagogical tool. Additionally, a simple google or YouTube search using the terms workplace, organizational, or I-O psychology (or better yet, specific concepts that you plan to teach) should uncover plenty of examples to use in your classroom. We highly recommend using these and other avenues when trying to incorporate pop culture into your teaching.
We do want to mention one caveat with this approach that instructors should be aware of. The focal article mentioned the importance of recognizing and promoting diversity in the classroom, especially in I-O psychology where we teach these concepts, and we wholeheartedly agree. We will also be the first to admit that the use of pop culture has the potential for groups of students to be less inclined to understand the value of it and/or get lost in the references. Namely, one such group could be international students, who may not have been exposed to the same pop culture as have American students and instructors so might miss more subtle jokes in movies and television due to language differences or nuances. Students who come from different ethnicities, geographical regions, gender, generations, and so on than the instructors may find the specific examples exclusionary or unrelated. As a case study, while creating and hosting an “IO Summer Movie Night” series, the second author found that it was nearly impossible to find films that specifically dealt with racial issues in the workplace in a way that engaged current students and matched more current themes on the issue. Even putting group membership and intersectionality aside, there are some students who simply are not into movies, television, memes, and pop culture. However, assuming that you still wish to use pop culture as a pedagogical tool for its positive benefits, we suggest two main solutions to minimize the issues.
First, never make pop culture references the sole method by which you relate the class topics to the real world for the students. We tend to use at least three to four ways to reinforce an important concept to students (e.g., definition, real-world example, movie clip, activity and/or discussion), and if you build an overall engaging and informative class, we have found that most students will enjoy the class overall and forgive the occasional indulgence into movies, references, and/or jokes that they may not personally appreciate. In fact, the first author can attest to the number of times students have rolled their eyes at his “Dad jokes” in class, only to later say how much they enjoyed overall the attempts to inject humor and pop culture into the class. The authors of the focal article have given you numerous ways to create that type of learning environment in your own course, and what we are suggesting should only be one such arrow in your quiver.
Second, we recommend using a diverse set of examples, including some that may not be in your normal, personal-viewing repertoire, as well as allowing the students to choose and bring in their own examples at times. Commit to being open to watching or engaging with the examples your students bring to you as way to expand your own horizons and increase your bank of pop culture examples. We specifically use an assignment where students pick a movie to watch and then tie three I-O concepts (broad or specific) to various parts of the movie.Footnote 2 This allows the students to pick something of interest to them as long as it pertains to work in some way, and you can and should further include permitting students to specifically pick their preferred medium, such as books or podcasts. We fully expect that students may start using Tiktok videos in the near future, and so long as they can describe the “scene” and articulate how it relates to I-O concepts, we suggest permitting it!
Finally, these experiences can be partially constructed outside of class if you cannot find the class time to devote to whole movies or even clips. The aforementioned “I-O Movie Nights” mentioned were opened up to all students and faculty in I-O programs to watch relevant movies online and discuss them through a virtual media. This could be done for individual classes for students who are interested in different perspectives by combining several schools or clubs like Psi Chi or by folding into existing initiatives like the one started by Professor Baldwin.
In short, there are a number of useful tools to help make our I-O classes more interesting, especially to younger students. Through the use of pop culture in the classroom, those without job experience need not be excluded from the same understanding and connection with materials as students who have had jobs. Psychology as a whole helps create more well-rounded people through a deeper understanding of human behavior. Given that people spend approximately one third of their adult lives at work, they would similarly benefit from a deeper understanding of humans and work regardless of whether their future career paths take them into I-O psychology. Using teaching examples that are relatable to more students will deepen that understanding while also making classes more fun, and thus more popular, helping to expand knowledge of I-O psychology among college students and grow the field. For once you have built this kind of pedagogical foundation in your courses, “they will most certainly come.”
The authors of the focal article (Kath etal., Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) briefly mention a Field of Dreams approach to teaching industrial and organizational (I-O) psychology. Namely, if you build an interesting and engaging class that creates “buzz” among students, they will come. We agree with this assertion, as well as their specific points on how and why to make an overall better class experience. However, given their limited space for suggestions, we would like to offer additional ideas for doing just that. Specifically, we want to suggest that instructors actually show a movie like Field of Dreams! Although this particular movie is not the most I-O-relevant film (albeit themes such as teamwork and motivation are certainly there for discussion), many movies, televisions shows, podcasts, memes, and so forth can create a fun and stimulating atmosphere that is conducive to material retention.
The focal authors reference tying the concepts in our field to the actual work environment, which is an excellent way to put them into a real-world context for students, and get them thinking how and why these factors are relevant to their future jobs. However, not all college students have had jobs or are even ready to think about what the working world will look like for them. On one hand, as professors and I-O psychologists, it is our responsibility to help them start thinking in that direction. However, we also have the ability to put the concepts into a context that they care about now, such as pop culture, and jump start their ability to notice I-O psychology all around them. In short, not all 18- to 22-year-olds want to think about work, but all (or at least almost all of them, and we as instructors) do enjoy fun!
The crux of the focal authors’ argument is that students will connect more to the material when it is applied to specific examples. Within this idea, social cognitive theory (SCT) shows that humans often learn better from experience than from purely hypothetical scenarios, even when that experience comes vicariously through watching others (Gibson, Reference Gibson2004). Thus, we suggest using widely shared experiences from popular culture. Cognitive psychology shows that through “mirror neurons,” people actually experience what they see on a screen the same as they would if they were in the scene themselves (Gallese & Guerra, Reference Gallese and Guerra2012). This is why people feel uncomfortable watching certain scenes of The Office; they are actually feeling some portion of what it would be like to be in those scenes. As an extra bonus, many such stories are informed by the real-life experiences of the writers (Fischer & Kinsey, Reference Fischer and Kinsey2019), connecting them to those real-world work experiences, as is suggested above. Once students have experienced the same example for whatever I-O topic is to be discussed, it will allow for a conversation that is based on deeper understanding while still allowing additional personal experiences to be integrated into the discussion.
Furthermore, although there is some debate about attention spans, and they certainly vary from student to student, it is often suggested that instructors break up lectures with other activities to keep students more engaged (Wilson & Conyers, Reference Wilson and Conyers2011). Injecting clips and other media into your course can help create this variety and limit cognitive fatigue, giving students a better chance to maintain attention and retain material. Another advantage is that adding aspects you personally find fun and interesting can increase your own engagement with your class. We have found in our own teaching that an instructor that brings genuine excitement for material to class is noticed by students and often creates a positive feedback loop; students are energized by the instructor’s enthusiasm, increasing instructor motivation, and so on. We also suspect that many readers of this commentary have also experienced how quickly a similar cycle can work in the negative direction, for example when teaching material that is not personally interesting and/or when the aspects that are instrinsically interesting have not been incorporated into the class.
As an instructor, you have probably been watching a movie or show and had that “a-ha” moment and thought, “That was a perfect examples of what I was just teaching in class last week!” When this happens to us, we try to write down that example for future use in the classroom. Fortunately, we are not limited by having only our own experiences to access for examples of I-O psychology issues that appear in pop culture because other teachers and researchers have created lists that can be easily referenced when putting a course together. A few articles have provided several examples of specific scenes that would be great for using in classes (e.g., Casper etal., Reference Casper, Champous, Watt, Bachiochi, Schleicher and Bordeaux2003; Kernodle, Reference Kernodle2009), and the University of Maryland program also has a very helpful list on their website (2019). Similarly, there are a growing number of podcasts that are related to I-O psychology (SIOP Conversation series, Dept. 12) and making I-O psychology more relatable (Worklife with Adam Grant). Even some popular podcasts that are not specifically about work often touch on I-O psychology because of how ubiquitous it is in daily life (e.g., Revisitionist History by Malcolm Gladwell, Stuff You Should Know, Freakonomics Radio). We recently created a Google Doc repository that we hope will be a living document for these and other pop culture resources for I-O psychology instructors to use and contribute to.Footnote 1
Further, more students these days are interacting with the meme culture, and this provides teachers with quick, funny, and interesting ways to communicate I-O psychology concepts to students. Memes are useful because they often take only a single picture or gif, allowing instructors to easily put them into slides for students to read/interpret on their own. Memes can be incorporated into the instructor’s slides or lecture about how these concepts work in the real world or used to as catalysts for a more in-depth discussion. Instructors can also use them as class activities or assignments by having students create their own I-O-related memes. If “meme hunting” is not something you personally enjoy, there are several amazing resources and social media pages already in place to provide them to you. On Instagram alone, you will find @iopsychmemes, @orgpsych, @hr.memes, @humanresourcesmemes, @workpsych, and @consultinghumor, just to name a few that regularly put out thought-provoking and informative memes for you to use.
These resources and suggestions are far from exhaustive, but we wanted to provide some specific examples for those of you who are just getting started with this pedagogical tool. Additionally, a simple google or YouTube search using the terms workplace, organizational, or I-O psychology (or better yet, specific concepts that you plan to teach) should uncover plenty of examples to use in your classroom. We highly recommend using these and other avenues when trying to incorporate pop culture into your teaching.
We do want to mention one caveat with this approach that instructors should be aware of. The focal article mentioned the importance of recognizing and promoting diversity in the classroom, especially in I-O psychology where we teach these concepts, and we wholeheartedly agree. We will also be the first to admit that the use of pop culture has the potential for groups of students to be less inclined to understand the value of it and/or get lost in the references. Namely, one such group could be international students, who may not have been exposed to the same pop culture as have American students and instructors so might miss more subtle jokes in movies and television due to language differences or nuances. Students who come from different ethnicities, geographical regions, gender, generations, and so on than the instructors may find the specific examples exclusionary or unrelated. As a case study, while creating and hosting an “IO Summer Movie Night” series, the second author found that it was nearly impossible to find films that specifically dealt with racial issues in the workplace in a way that engaged current students and matched more current themes on the issue. Even putting group membership and intersectionality aside, there are some students who simply are not into movies, television, memes, and pop culture. However, assuming that you still wish to use pop culture as a pedagogical tool for its positive benefits, we suggest two main solutions to minimize the issues.
First, never make pop culture references the sole method by which you relate the class topics to the real world for the students. We tend to use at least three to four ways to reinforce an important concept to students (e.g., definition, real-world example, movie clip, activity and/or discussion), and if you build an overall engaging and informative class, we have found that most students will enjoy the class overall and forgive the occasional indulgence into movies, references, and/or jokes that they may not personally appreciate. In fact, the first author can attest to the number of times students have rolled their eyes at his “Dad jokes” in class, only to later say how much they enjoyed overall the attempts to inject humor and pop culture into the class. The authors of the focal article have given you numerous ways to create that type of learning environment in your own course, and what we are suggesting should only be one such arrow in your quiver.
Second, we recommend using a diverse set of examples, including some that may not be in your normal, personal-viewing repertoire, as well as allowing the students to choose and bring in their own examples at times. Commit to being open to watching or engaging with the examples your students bring to you as way to expand your own horizons and increase your bank of pop culture examples. We specifically use an assignment where students pick a movie to watch and then tie three I-O concepts (broad or specific) to various parts of the movie.Footnote 2 This allows the students to pick something of interest to them as long as it pertains to work in some way, and you can and should further include permitting students to specifically pick their preferred medium, such as books or podcasts. We fully expect that students may start using Tiktok videos in the near future, and so long as they can describe the “scene” and articulate how it relates to I-O concepts, we suggest permitting it!
Finally, these experiences can be partially constructed outside of class if you cannot find the class time to devote to whole movies or even clips. The aforementioned “I-O Movie Nights” mentioned were opened up to all students and faculty in I-O programs to watch relevant movies online and discuss them through a virtual media. This could be done for individual classes for students who are interested in different perspectives by combining several schools or clubs like Psi Chi or by folding into existing initiatives like the one started by Professor Baldwin.
In short, there are a number of useful tools to help make our I-O classes more interesting, especially to younger students. Through the use of pop culture in the classroom, those without job experience need not be excluded from the same understanding and connection with materials as students who have had jobs. Psychology as a whole helps create more well-rounded people through a deeper understanding of human behavior. Given that people spend approximately one third of their adult lives at work, they would similarly benefit from a deeper understanding of humans and work regardless of whether their future career paths take them into I-O psychology. Using teaching examples that are relatable to more students will deepen that understanding while also making classes more fun, and thus more popular, helping to expand knowledge of I-O psychology among college students and grow the field. For once you have built this kind of pedagogical foundation in your courses, “they will most certainly come.”