At first read, the subtitle of James Lang's book Cheating Lessons: Learning from Academic Dishonesty seems an oxymoron. When we hear about or see an instance of student cheating, we often think of missed rather than gained learning opportunities. And through an extensive review of the literature on the presence and persistence of cheating in higher education, the data Lang shares indicate that anywhere between 65 and 87 percent of college students do admit to some form of cheating (whether cheating on a test, padding a bibliography, plagiarizing, etc.); enough to give any higher-education faculty member pause.
Our first instinct is to ask: What compels students to engage in acts of academic dishonesty? Why do so many students cheat? Lang urges us to move beyond considering the dispositional factors associated with cheating (gender, age, membership in a fraternity or sorority) to instead understand “cheating as an inappropriate response to a learning environment that isn't working for the students” (2). In this statement, readers come to recognize the import of Lang's subtitle: we should be learning from academic dishonesty. In other words, the prevalence of student cheating should send a message to those of us who teach in higher education, prompting us to take a hard look at our classrooms and our own teaching. What follows in Lang's book is a unique and much-needed exploration of what we, as faculty, can do to inspire and energize our students. Deterring cheating becomes a welcome byproduct of creating intrinsically motivating, relevant, learning-centered classrooms.
In part 1 of the book, Lang lays out four essential conditions that allow cheating to flourish: an emphasis on performance, high stakes, an environment based on extrinsic motivation, and a low expectation of success. One of Lang's strengths is his ability to make concepts come alive through illustrative cases. We come to understand the essential conditions through stories of bribery in the Olympics of ancient Greece, incidents of rampant cheating on high-stakes civil-service exams in Imperial China, the scandal in the Atlanta public schools where teachers and administrators modified student responses to state assessment tests, and a study of cheating behavior among five-year-olds attempting to complete a staged (and impossible) task of blindly throwing a ball at a target to win a prize.
In the second section, and unquestionably the highlight of the book, Lang invites us on a journey through the teaching lives of award-winning faculty members who serve as a guide for developing climates that counter the essential conditions and instead foster intrinsic motivation, focus on personal mastery, lower stakes, and instill self-efficacy. As readers, we are transported into the classrooms of exceptional teachers; from Andy Kaufman's class on Russian literature where students teach and learn about literature and life alongside prison inmates, to John Boyer's World Regions class of 2500+ students, where students build an individualized way to demonstrate their learning, choosing from a variety of assessments. Lang couples richly descriptive examples with recent research from cognitive psychology on how to best support student learning.
What Lang offers us is a rare window into excellent teaching going on across higher-education institutions and disciplines, stimulating readers to think about what is possible in their own classrooms. It also serves as a reminder that as faculty we tend to be well trained as scholars of our disciplines but need to seek out opportunities for dialogue and development when it comes to pedagogy and the practice of teaching and learning in the professoriate.
At the end of Lang's book, I am reinvigorated about my teaching. At the same time, I am left with lingering questions, with one disquieting undercurrent that remains unexplored in the text. Lang argues, from a solid research base, that rates of cheating in higher education have been stable, and the dire or “alarmist” (16) messages that cheating is on the rise are simply not supported. True, the numbers generally agree with Lang, but what he does not address is the rising normality that students associate with cheating today, and the acceptance, even moralizing, of unethical behavior. So while cheating is not a new phenomenon, this normalization of cheating is.
Such normality is not without cause. The performance focus and extrinsic reward systems that often creep into our classrooms are a reflection of a society where getting ahead of the next guy is a primary value, and the financial and social rewards for such “success” are significant. Alongside runs a culture where materialism, greed, and entitlement can flourish, and those who have privilege and wealth have the most to lose (see, for example, D. Callahan, The Cheating Culture: Why More Americans Are Doing Wrong to Get Ahead [Harcourt, 2004]). Cheating can be (and is) used as a mechanism to sustain privilege and further status, sometimes under the guise or unconscious belief that such cheating is justified because it helps maintain one's “rightful” or “entitled” place in the social, professional, and economic hierarchy. In education, the culture encourages students, particularly those from upper-middle-class and affluent communities, to see cheating not as a compromising of their values but rather as a warranted and morally sound mechanism by which to attain the status they believe they are afforded.
This justified use of cheating to gain advantage requires us to go beyond considering how students learn into the realm of the sociopolitical. It invokes questions like: What gets to count as knowledge? Who gets to define success? How is knowledge, or simply the appearance of having knowledge, used as social and political leverage by those who are more powerful to subordinate and silence those with limited power? Exploration of such questions may lead higher-education faculty to examine not only how we structure our learning contexts, but what and whose curriculum we teach. They may compel us to dialogue with our students about how to conduct scholarship for the collective or social good. They may incite us to consider the messages our institutional policies and practices send—from what goes into our admissions decisions to what gets valued for tenure.
Ultimately, both learning and sociopolitical factors should play a central role in conversations about academic integrity, and Lang is clear about where he places his focus. He has written Cheating Lessons “as a teaching faculty member and for teaching faculty members in all disciplines first” (3). Toward this end, readers will be hard-pressed not to follow the journey on which Lang takes us. His book, indeed, provides higher education faculty with “lessons” on transforming classroom cultures and encourages us to remember that how we invite our students into the work of a discipline matters deeply for their learning and integrity. Lang thus succeeds in producing a text that will compel faculty to be inquirers into our own teaching practice in ways that create inspiring and innovative contexts for our students, leaving the sociopolitical for others to take up.
