This is a text that can be described as being analytically challenging, empirically well-grounded and politically engaged. It develops a theoretical interpretation of the dynamic of global capitalism as manifested in Latin America, and conceptual and political issues are approached in a manner that avoids overgeneralisation on the one hand and dismal empiricism on the other. The study is organised into six chapters and the full text is approximately 400 pages, which leads me to suggest that the argument might have been more effectively deployed if its length had been trimmed somewhat; in any event, it can hardly be described as a ‘slim volume’ (p. xii).
The first chapter boldly sets out the author's overall theoretical and political position, whereby it is made abundantly clear that the book's analysis of Latin America and global capitalism is to be situated in a Marxist frame. In fact, the preface indicates that the author intends to develop a critical Marxist approach to globalisation and usefully underscores that globalisation is not a neutral process, since it involves both losers and winners and new relations of power and domination (p. xiii). Moreover, it is argued that capitalist relations are deepening, in the sense that they have penetrated and commodified, at an accelerated pace, ever more institutions of social and cultural life. The author's own take on global capitalism emphasises what are called the ‘three planks’ of transnational production, a transnational capitalist class and a transnational state, which for Robinson have already supplanted, or at least are in the process of supplanting, the national state as the key driving force of global capitalism. In his discussion of the posited ‘epochal shift in world capitalism’, Robinson highlights three aspects of his thesis on the transnational state, a concept which is quite central to the general argument: economic globalisation has its counterpart in the emergence of a transnational state which functions as the collective authority for a global ruling class; the nation-state is being transformed and absorbed into the larger structure of the transnational state; and this emergent transnational state institutionalises new class relations between global capital and global labour.
The author's argument is pursued through a careful examination of how the dynamic of global capitalism is having an impact on Latin America. Two linked chapters deal with the upsurge of non-traditional agricultural exports (such as cut flowers in Ecuador and Colombia, fruits and wines in Chile, soy production in the Southern Cone, and winter fruits and vegetables in Central America), maquiladoras and industrial subcontracting, transnational services and the new global tourism, and the export of labour and import of remittances. Chapter 4 deals with transnational class formation in Latin America and includes revealing sections on the ‘Wal-Martization’ of commerce, and transnational migration as it is developing in Latin America. Chapter 5 examines the ‘antinomies’ of global capitalism and the ‘twilight’ of neoliberalism, wherein Robinson identifies what he calls three dimensions of an expanding crisis of global capitalism, namely, a crisis of social polarisation, for which the author presents a useful statistical substantiation, a crisis of over-accumulation, and a crisis of state legitimacy and political authority. Finally, the author discusses the new forms of resistance to global capitalism in Latin America, with special emphasis allotted to the rebellion of indigenous peoples, the immigrant rights movement in the United States and the Bolivarian programme initiated by Hugo Chávez. The author concludes with a brief foray into the theme of barbarism, socialism and alternative futures, within which four possible scenarios are sketched out: global reformism based on global Keynesianism, global fascism, a global anti-capitalist alternative, and a collapse of global civilisation.
As a way of engaging with Robinson's argument I want to consider one or two aspects of his theoretical framework, especially as regards the question of what the author calls a ‘new cycle of resistance’ to global capitalism. At different points in the text the author stresses the point that, following Gramsci, hegemony is a richer concept than domination, and a counter-hegemonic project would need to develop a politics within which popular democracy and socialism were connected. In his discussion of the Venezuelan caracazo, Robinson suggests that shifting the balance of the struggle for hegemony toward the popular classes undermined the efficacy of neoliberal policies and that in actual fact the caracazo constituted the first mass uprising in Latin America against neoliberalism (p. 325). Subsequently it is argued that the cases of Venezuela, and perhaps Ecuador and Bolivia as well, show that popular forces and classes must win state power and utilise it to transform production relations and the larger socio-political relations of domination, without subordinating their own autonomy; a confrontation with global capitalism beyond the nation-state requires national state power (p. 344). Finally, Robinson asserts that the axis of an anti-capitalist and universalist struggle must be ‘the new global working class’ (p. 358).
From these passages and related sections, the reader is left with some doubts about the continuing viability of the analytical centrality of class and the status of hegemony. At times the text reads like a newer version of the old ‘capital logic’ school whereby the economy is always determinant in the last instance, and social and political outcomes can be read off from the economic structure. Equally, not enough thought is given to the distinction between the transnational and the global, and the complexities of social and political subjectivity are too easily straitjacketed into an all-encompassing category of class.
Notwithstanding these critical points, Robinson has provided us with a stimulating, incisive and thoroughly researched text which deserves to be read by social scientists in general and Latin American specialists in particular.
