Introduction
The second half of the twentieth century witnessed the emergence of a new brand of evangelicalism, which pursued a more engaged faith in society. In post-war America, ‘new evangelicals’ began, from the mid-1940s, to emerge from the tensions between two groups which were increasingly divided from the late nineteenth century onwards and which, by the 1920s, were generally known as modernists and fundamentalists.Footnote 1 This new evangelical group attempted to depart from the militant separatism of fundamentalism by taking a more positive attitude toward mainline Christianity, while distancing themselves from the theological ethos of modernists. From this new evangelical movement, there emerged in the United States and elsewhere during the 1960s and 1970s those now widely described as ‘the evangelical left’ or ‘progressive evangelicals’ who urged more progressive socio-political engagement.Footnote 2 Most Latin American countries in the post-war period were in socio-political ferment under repressive military regimes. It was in this context that the Latin American evangelical left started to emerge from the 1960s.Footnote 3 This emergence of ‘new evangelicals’ or ‘the evangelical left’ has drawn scholarly attention and the theme has been covered by many scholars, particularly in relation to America and Latin America.Footnote 4 However, it has not been substantially analysed in relation to Asian countries, such as South Korea, which provide a compelling example of interactions between the various centres and peripheries of evangelicalism in different national contexts, and offer a useful comparison to the American or Latin American stories.
This article brings to the fore this Korean story by analysing a Christian student group that emerged from the evangelical majority of Korean Protestantism and experimented with new forms of evangelical socio-political engagement from 1986 to 1989. In Latin America especially, student experience and organizations were at the forefront of this new evangelicalism. This article focuses on one such organization in South Korea, which formed at the Seoul National University (SNU) and will hereafter be referred to as the SNU evangelical network.Footnote 5 Although this student group was on the periphery of Korean evangelicalism, its attempts to redefine evangelical identity challenged the prevailing evangelical interpretation of socio-political issues and Christian mission in significant ways. This article explores the socio-political and ecclesial background of its activities. It also looks at the tension between this group and mainstream evangelicalism, and its contribution to the wider Korean evangelical community. Based on in-depth research of Korean primary sources mostly unutilized in Anglophone scholarship, as well as on oral interviews with its key members, this article examines how a new evangelical group on the periphery of Korean evangelicalism challenged the centre. This study argues that the SNU evangelical network, despite its marginal position, created meaningful spaces for alternative perspectives within Korean evangelicalism.
Young Korean Evangelical Students in the Socio-Political Turmoil of the 1980s
In the 1980s, South Korea was in socio-political turmoil under the new authoritarian regime of Doo-Hwan Chun. General Doo-Hwan Chun had led a military coup on 12 December 1979, immediately after the fall of Chung-Hee Park’s regime which had lasted eighteen years. In 1981, Chun established his own government. The emergence of the new authoritarian regime provoked a nation-wide pro-democracy movement. Over the course of the 1980s, the pro-democracy movement against Chun’s authoritarian regime became more popular and radical than that against Park’s regime in the 1970s.Footnote 6 Student groups continued to play a key role in the pro-democracy movement of the 1980s, as they had in the 1970s.Footnote 7 Like Park’s regime, Doo-Hwan Chun’s regime sought to suppress the pro-democracy movement. For instance, in May 1980, there were pro-democracy protests by citizens in the southern city of Gwangju, known as ‘the Gwangju Uprising’, which had originated in student protests. Observing the brutal suppression of these student protests by Chun’s regime, many ordinary citizens became involved and the uprising developed into a city-wide pro-democracy movement.Footnote 8 However, armed troops dispatched by Chun’s regime violently quelled the uprising, which resulted in 166 deaths, 64 missing and 3,139 injured.Footnote 9 A collective memory of the uprising and a feeling of the indebtedness to the Gwangju citizens’ sacrificial efforts for the pro-democracy movement played a formative role in that movement throughout the 1980s.Footnote 10
University campuses were a flashpoint of conflict between fervour for democratization and the zeal of the authoritarian government for suppressing disorder. Seoul National University’s campus was a major site of such conflict. In May 1986, SNU students demonstrated against Chun’s authoritarian regime, remembering the Gwangju Uprising, and were confronted by riot police. Against the backdrop of this growing tension between student protests and riot police, an evangelical Christian event called ‘A Great March for Jesus’ was held on the campus on 20 May. During the event, around 1,000 evangelical students gathered to proclaim God’s sovereignty over their campus and over the socio-political turmoil of Korean society by prayer, praise of God and a march on the campus.Footnote 11 The event took place at the university plaza, in which university students often staged pro-democracy demonstrations.Footnote 12 This implies that the event was intended to provide an evangelical alternative to the student protests.Footnote 13 At the time, most mainstream evangelical churches and student ministry organizations were focusing on evangelism, and largely remained silent about socio-political issues except through prayer.Footnote 14 For instance, the Campus Crusade for Christ in Korea hosted the World Evangelization Crusade in Seoul in August 1980, three months after the Gwangju Uprising. The event succeeded in drawing a total attendance of 16,350,000 and in encouraging approximately 1,000,000 participants to volunteer for one-year-long overseas missions.Footnote 15 Yet no mention was made during the event of the oppressive measures taken by Chun’s authoritarian regime against the uprising, or of its victims.
The conservative socio-political and missiological tone of mainstream Korean evangelicalism was partly rooted in the Western Protestant mission to Korea, which started in earnest from the late nineteenth century. Most Western Protestant missionaries came from America.Footnote 16 They were by and large pietistic in theology and quietist about socio-political issues.Footnote 17 The South Korean context after the liberation in 1945 from Japanese colonial power and the Korean War of 1950–3 stimulated this conservative tone among Korean evangelicals, largely due to a further influx of North Korean Protestant Christians into South Korea, most of whom were conservative in theology and in their stance toward socio-political issues. Their settlement and the subsequent expansion of their influence in South Korea contributed to the conservatism of Korean evangelicalism.Footnote 18 The post-liberation context also provided many Korean evangelicals with a strong rationale for acknowledging and even supporting authoritarian governments for the sake of national security against communist North Korea. While remaining silent about the pro-democracy movement which stood against these regimes, these churches primarily focused on the task of evangelization.
The ‘Great March for Jesus’ reflected the quietist socio-political and missiological tone of mainstream Korean evangelicalism, engaging in spiritual activity rather than political agitation. However, the context of the campus at the time meant that the ‘Great March for Jesus’ aroused resentment. Other university students disapproved of the fact that Christians were praising God in the month in which many were remembering the Gwangju Uprising and mourning its victims.Footnote 19 They also complained that the evangelical event took place in the same plaza as that used by the pro-democracy movement. As a result, they seized the main platform and drove evangelical students out of the university plaza.Footnote 20 This strong reaction from their fellow students aroused considerable uncertainty among the evangelicals, but they continued their rally by marching on the campus.Footnote 21 However, not long after they started to march, they heard some shocking news. During a demonstration against the government in another area of the campus, an SNU student had set himself on fire, crying: ‘Let’s remove the military regime from power’.Footnote 22 On learning this news, a group of evangelical Christians in the march split off to discuss in private approaches to societal issues.Footnote 23 Jong-Chul Lee, a key member of the group, recalled later that this incident, which ‘was engraved deep’ in their hearts, led them to recognize ‘the void’ in their understanding of political issues on the campus and in wider society.Footnote 24 This experience sparked intense discussions among the group members about their role as evangelical Christians in addressing societal issues. Following these discussions, a subset of students from this group, driven by their newfound awareness, decided to take concrete action. These students – who came from different departments across the campus and had all been raised in evangelical churches or involved in evangelical parachurch organizations, such as Korean chapters of InterVarsity Fellowship and Campus Crusade for Christ – concluded that the socio-political situation required a response on campus which differed from their current evangelical perspective.Footnote 25 As a result, they formed the Christian Culture Society and University Christian Newspaper to study, discuss and practise Christian social engagement, and to share with other evangelical students what they had learnt from their experience through the Society.Footnote 26 These students – comprising approximately twenty to thirty members and including key leaders such as Jong-Chul Lee (the University Christian Newspaper’s editor-in-chief), Wook Yoo and Eun-Seok Choi – together with their newly established organizations, constituted what we have termed the SNU evangelical network. This was the start of an endeavour by the SNU evangelical network to redefine evangelicalism.
Redefining Evangelicalism from the Margins
The attempt of the SNU evangelical network to redefine evangelicalism from the margins began by challenging the prevailing approaches to socio-political issues and Christian mission among mainstream evangelicals at the centre. The network criticized the understanding of the gospel and Christian mission among many mainstream evangelicals as partial. They saw it as paying attention only to individual salvation and evangelism, while being content to remain on the sidelines in terms of contemporary socio-political issues.Footnote 27 Furthermore, the network recognized that Korean evangelical churches had been influenced by more conservative American missionaries who insisted on the theological principle of separation between church and state.Footnote 28 In contrast, the network argued that through insisting on the principle of separation, the churches had remained silent about socio-political issues including violent and repressive measures by Chun’s authoritarian government, and that remaining silent about the existence of an unjust authoritarian regime signified tacit approval.Footnote 29 Moreover, the network observed that although the Korean evangelical churches claimed the principle of separation between church and state, in reality they often took a pro-government stance.Footnote 30 The network believed, however, that the Christian gospel and mission embraced more than individual salvation, and that Christian faith necessarily encompassed a societal dimension.Footnote 31 A 1988 article in the University Christian Newspaper highlighted this point:
The core of the Gospel of Jesus Christ was to proclaim the Kingdom of God. His missional focus and historical awareness were to realise the Kingdom of God where the poor and the captives were hearing good news of liberty and where justice and peace were prevailing. … While traditional [evangelical] churches have remained at an elementary level of salvation by being preoccupied with the vertical dimension (of the Gospel), the Kingdom of God movement includes the horizontal dimension between human and human.Footnote 32
In pursuing what has been termed a more holistic understanding of the gospel and Christian mission – a theological approach that integrated both individual spiritual salvation and active engagement with socio-political issues, in contrast to the mainstream evangelical focus primarily on individual salvation – the SNU evangelical network continued to hold an evangelical identity.Footnote 33 They believed that, in the words of a key member, ‘the evangelicalism in which we believe can embrace all societal issues’.Footnote 34 At the same time, most members of the SNU network sought to distance themselves from the more liberal wings of Korean Protestant Christianity, such as groups following liberation and Minjung theologies, which adopted radical approaches to addressing socio-political issues and played a major role in the democratization movements of the 1970s and 1980s.Footnote 35 In this sense, their endeavour to challenge a conservative-leaning socio-political and missiological orientation in mainstream evangelicalism through pursuing a holistic understanding of the gospel and Christian mission was not an attempt to abandon their evangelical identity, but to reinterpret and redefine it.
This attempt to redefine evangelicalism was influenced by many theological ideas. A list of Christian books recommended by the University Christian Newspaper displays a range of theological sources, which was notably broad considering the preponderance of Presbyterians in South Korean evangelicalism.Footnote 36 In 1982, Presbyterianism was the largest denomination within South Korean evangelicalism, constituting 56.3% of the entire Korean Protestant population, with Methodism following at 11.6%.Footnote 37 Despite this Presbyterian dominance, the list included Baptists (George E. Ladd and C. René Padilla), evangelical Anglicans (John Stott and Reuben A. Torrey III), a Mennonite (Ronald J. Sider), pre-Reformation Catholics (St. Augustine and Thomas à Kempis), post-Vatican II Catholics (Leonardo Boff and In-Seok Seo), a Dutch Reformed theologian (Bob Goudzwaard), as well as the Presbyterians Harvie M. Conn and Francis Schaeffer. This wide variety of writers with diverse denominational and theological backgrounds reflected the SNU evangelical network’s effort to legitimize their work of redefining evangelicalism.
Three points should be noted in relation to the SNU evangelical network’s embrace of this wide range of theological sources. First, the range arose from their search for a holistic understanding of the gospel and mission beyond a mainstream evangelical perspective, which was perceived as ‘limited’ or ‘partial’. For instance, an article in the University Christian Newspaper in April 1987 recommended reading Bible Studies on World Evangelization and the Simple Lifestyle (1981), written by Reformed missiologist Harvie M. Conn.Footnote 38 That article also highlighted the need for Korean evangelical churches to adjust their view of the Christian gospel in a more holistic direction:
The Gospel of the Kingdom of God … has been interpreted with a focus on personal ethics. As a result, the understanding of evangelism and Jesus Christ has been reduced merely as verbal proclamation of the Gospel and as the Saviour, not the Lord. This interpretative tendency also has caused an extreme conflict among us between personal and social salvations, and a difficulty in understanding the relationship between evangelism and social responsibility. This book helps us to move from an extremely spiritualised understanding of the Gospel … into an incarnated one.Footnote 39
Second, a global evangelical impulse toward a more holistic approach to the gospel and Christian mission was observable. John Stott’s Christian Mission in the Modern World (1975) was listed among the books recommended by the University Christian Newspaper. This was published the year after the 1974 International Congress on World Evangelization, held in Lausanne, Switzerland.Footnote 40 Stott, who was the chairman of the drafting committee for the Lausanne Covenant, acknowledged the missional significance of both evangelism and social justice in this book, as did the Covenant.Footnote 41 However, the Covenant’s dual accent in Christian mission attracted contested interpretations among global evangelical constituents.Footnote 42 Despite these differing interpretations, Stott’s understanding of mission as expressed in both his book and the Covenant was broader than that which he had articulated at the 1966 World Congress on Evangelism held in Berlin.Footnote 43 Christian Mission in the Modern World was translated into Korean in 1981.Footnote 44 Books by representatives of the American and Latin American evangelical left also featured in the list. Anabaptist Ronald J. Sider came to broader evangelical prominence in the 1970s,Footnote 45 and Korean translations of Sider’s Rich Christians in an Age of Hunger and Evangelism and Salvation and Social Justice were published in 1981 and 1987.Footnote 46 InterVarsity Press Korea expanded Sider’s Evangelism, Salvation and Social Justice by adding an article written by C. René Padilla and the Wheaton Statement (titled ‘Transformation: The Church in Response to Human Need’) published by the Consultation on the Church in Response to Human Need in Wheaton, Illinois, in June 1983. Thus, the Korean version of Evangelism, Salvation and Social Justice had co-authors. The Latin American evangelical left had started to redefine evangelical understanding of the gospel and Christian mission from the 1960s, in distinction from the views of American and Latin American conservative evangelicals.Footnote 47 They developed a new evangelical theological formula of Christian mission which sought a more holistic approach, known as misión integral (complete mission), a term which the Ecuadorian C. René Padilla appears to have coined in 1973.Footnote 48 This attempt by the Latin American evangelical left to redefine evangelicalism influenced the subsequent Korean attempt, primarily through the publication of translations of their books. For instance, Is Revolution Change? (1972), edited by the British Christian economist Brian Griffiths (another book recommended by the University Christian Newspaper), included chapters by Padilla and by the Puerto Rican Orlando E. Costas. This book was translated into Korean in 1989.Footnote 49 It argued that ‘a violent and total revolution’ was ‘no panacea for society’s problems’.Footnote 50 This stance against violent revolution resonated with two experiments conducted by the SNU evangelical network, which will be discussed in the next section. The 1987 translation of Evangelism, Salvation and Social Justice included a chapter on evangelism and social responsibility, written by Padilla. Although it was not included in the list of the books recommended by the University Christian Newspaper, Costas’s Christ Outside the Gate: Mission Beyond Christendom (1982) was also translated into Korean and published in 1987.Footnote 51
Third, the SNU evangelical network’s acceptance of diverse theological ideas showed their eclecticism for the sake of social engagement. In interviews conducted by this author, members of the SNU evangelical network tended to hesitate to pick a particular theological idea which was most formative for them at that time.Footnote 52 This hesitation was in stark contrast to former members of the younger evangelical pastoral network. That network, primarily Presbyterian in nature, made its own attempts at redefining evangelicalism through the formation, in March 1988, of the Youth Evangelical Fellowship of Korea, which overlapped with the efforts of the SNU evangelical student group.Footnote 53 Most members of this pastoral network were actively involved in university student ministry, leading to close connections and collaborations with the SNU evangelical student network, notably through their frequent contribution of articles to the SNU evangelical network’s University Christian Newspaper. Footnote 54 Unlike the eclectic approach of the student network, former members of this pastoral network recalled in interviews with this author that the Lausanne Covenant was the most important theological foundation in their journey of redefining evangelicalism.Footnote 55 The Youth Evangelical Fellowship of Korea, formed by the pastoral network, was also based on the Lausanne Covenant.Footnote 56 In the words of members of the network, the Covenant was ‘the key theological foundation’ and ‘a ray of light’ to them, and its impact was comparable with the explosion of ‘a nuclear bomb’.Footnote 57 In contrast, former members of the SNU evangelical network were much less enthusiastic than the pastors’ network in acknowledging the significance of the Covenant in their process of redefining evangelicalism.Footnote 58 Rather, in interviews, they tended to highlight that responding urgently to the context of socio-political turmoil was their most important agenda. One member of the pastors’ network acknowledged this tendency among the SNU evangelical network, recognizing that the student network tended to accent more direct engagement in the socio-political context than the evangelical pastors’ network.Footnote 59 The major interest of the pastors’ network was to form a theological foundation for engagement through embracing the influence of theological ideas, particularly the Lausanne Covenant, and to provide other Christians with that foundation. The SNU evangelical network, on the other hand, laid its emphasis on urgent engagement in the socio-political context, which led its members to draw on a range of theological ideas if they thought these ideas strengthened their responses to the context. Based on this eclecticism, some members of the SNU evangelical network embraced the influence of liberation theologians and social scientific analyses such as Marxism, and thus placed themselves at or even beyond what mainstream evangelicals regarded as the boundary of evangelicalism.Footnote 60 However, although all members of the SNU evangelical network agreed on the need to redefine evangelicalism, they differed on the issue of how far they were prepared to move toward the liberal end of the theological spectrum. This difference was a source of fragility in their collaboration, which became a major limitation of the emerging new evangelical group in the late twentieth century.
The issue of how far the new Korean evangelicals were prepared to move in their theology was particularly important, because most Korean Protestant Christians were evangelical. A 1982 government statistic estimated that, at that time, Protestants constituted around 20% of the whole population, with Roman Catholics roughly at 4%.Footnote 61 Over 90% of Korean Protestants, according to Timothy Lee’s estimation, were evangelical in the early 1980s.Footnote 62 The Korean context contrasted thus with Latin America, where evangelical Christianity was a religious minority and Roman Catholics the majority. The experience of social isolation as a religious minority within a predominantly Catholic society had exerted an influence on the development of the Latin American evangelical left.Footnote 63 In contrast, the Korean counterpart emerged from a context where evangelical Christianity constituted the great majority of Korean Protestantism, and its mainstream inclined to the conservative end of the spectrum in socio-political and theological aspects. In the Korean context, a radical move toward the liberal end, as defined by mainstream evangelicalism, was more challenging and riskier than in Latin America. Mainstream evangelical challenges to the radicalism of the new evangelical group became more apparent after the 1980s, when the group gained more influence over Protestant Christians. However, this challenge is already observable in the case of the SNU evangelical network. For instance, the fourth issue of the University Christian Newspaper on 5 March 1987 contained many articles showing sympathy with social scientific analyses, such as Marxism.Footnote 64 Amongst mainstream evangelical students, this provoked serious concern about the periodical. For them, the tone of those articles sounded very similar to that of the radical student pro-democracy movement and the periodical looked as if it had embraced the influence of the radical student movement without applying an evangelical filter.Footnote 65 Facing this challenge from mainstream evangelical students, the editorial board of the periodical attempted to persuade their readers of the necessity of accepting social scientific analyses of social structures.Footnote 66 In their view, evangelical Christianity had not yet developed comparable analytical tools for understanding social structures, making these social scientific approaches necessary. The editorial board also stressed that this did not mean completely embracing the analyses without any criticism from the Christian perspective.Footnote 67 However, despite these arguments in defence of the position taken by the journal, concerns among mainstream evangelical students about it persisted.Footnote 68
In this way, the redefining work of the SNU evangelical network on the periphery of the evangelical majority of Korean Protestantism challenged the prevailing evangelical interpretation of socio-political issues and Christian mission. However, in redefining evangelicalism, the members of the SNU evangelical network varied on how far they were willing to travel. The differences among them produced a divergence between moderate and radical pathways of redefining evangelicalism. This divergence would later be reflected in the wider new evangelical movement. Two experiments conducted by the SNU evangelical network represented these two divergent pathways.
The Two Divergent Pathways of New Evangelical Experiments
The more moderate pathway of redefining evangelicalism was symbolized by the formation in 1987 of the Association of Evangelical Youth and Students, and its launching of a campaign for a fair election. In 1987, one year after the SNU evangelical network started an endeavour to redefine evangelicalism, the June Uprising against Doo-Hwan Chun’s regime occurred across Korea.Footnote 69 As a result of this nation-wide uprising, Chun’s regime came to an end, although he nominated his political successor, Tae-Woo Roh. The constitution was revised in favour of a direct presidential election system which had been abolished in 1972 by Chung-Hee Park’s regime. The SNU evangelical network saw the revival of a direct election system as ‘an opportunity given by God for democratisation’.Footnote 70 At around the same time, in 1986, the National Citizens’ Movement for Free Elections in the Philippines launched a nation-wide campaign to guard the presidential election from any attempts of election malpractice by dictator Ferdinand Marcos. The Filipino campaign directly inspired the SNU evangelical network to form the Association of Evangelical Youth and Students in November 1987 and to launch its campaign for a fair election.Footnote 71
As the inclusion of the term ‘evangelical’ in its name shows, the association adhered to an evangelical identity. However, for its members, being evangelical implied neither remaining silent nor confining themselves to prayer about socio-political concerns (the position taken by most mainstream evangelical Christians), but rather a deep involvement in those issues. In other words, the association was founded on the basis of ‘the absolute necessity of social practices based upon evangelical faith’.Footnote 72 What was meant by ‘evangelical faith’ here was a new or redefined form of evangelicalism, founded upon a more holistic understanding of the gospel and Christian mission than that held by most mainstream evangelicals.Footnote 73 The association recruited young evangelical Christians to train them as election observers and counting overseers, dispatching them to various electoral districts.Footnote 74 Young evangelical Christians who belonged to the youth groups of mainstream evangelical local churches and evangelical campus ministry organizations, such as Korean branches of the Intervarsity Fellowship and the Campus Crusade for Christ, enthusiastically participated.Footnote 75 As a result, the association succeeded in attracting around 2,000 young evangelical volunteers.Footnote 76 Reporting this success, they discerned that enthusiastic participation from young evangelical Christians was a sign of their ‘thirst for social justice’.Footnote 77 Furthermore, this success was backed up by the association’s moderate approach to social engagement. In an interview with the author, Wook Yoo, the president of the association and a key leader of the SNU evangelical network, said that the success of the association in attracting many young evangelical participants reflected the fact that the association’s approach to social engagement was not so radical even for mainstream evangelical Christians.Footnote 78
For some members of the SNU evangelical network, the association’s moderate approach represented ‘the minimum’ which could be expected of anyone with ‘the least Christian conscience’.Footnote 79 They were open to the influence of more liberal theologies, such as liberation and Minjung theologies, as well as Marxist-type social scientific analysis, which many mainstream evangelical Christians viewed as boundaries which evangelicals should not cross. They thought that the task of redefining evangelicalism needed to go further than what the association proposed. In this regard, they had been conducting a more radical experiment in the form of a base community. Base communities were small groups of local Christians which aimed to live out the teachings of liberation theology.Footnote 80 In Latin America in 1978, there were over 100,000 base communities.Footnote 81 In April 1987, a pastor closely associated with the SNU evangelical network initiated a base community in a shanty town of Seoul. Some members of the student network were closely involved in the community from its start. The community consisted of around a dozen members. Living with poor neighbours in the town, they engaged in various relief activities, such as running daycare centres and tutoring poor children in the area.Footnote 82
Those of the SNU evangelical network who were involved in the base community believed that this was an evangelical alternative to the radicalized student pro-democracy movement. At the time, the student leadership of the democratization movement was inclined to accept Marxist social analysis and sought the fundamental transformation of society by confronting imperialistic and capitalist forces.Footnote 83 However, for those of the SNU evangelical network participating in the base community, this pro-democracy movement with its Marxist influence tended to focus only on the political dimension of human life, whereas humans were complex beings with many other dimensions.Footnote 84 Complaining about this tendency, they advocated for the base community as a form of social engagement based on a more holistic understanding of humanity:
There is now a tendency in universities … to overstate politicisation concerning humanity. In other words, we are forced to perceive that the authentic practice was … to make people conscientized and organised political agents by helping them recognise the structural evil in our context. … However, a human being is … a complex and holistic reality. … If we stick merely to a political movement, the true liberation of humanity is not realised. … The growth and intensification of the base community is … a key to the transformation of society. The political movement might change an external dimension of human life, but the Community transforms its essence.Footnote 85
However, although some of the SNU evangelical network saw the base community as an evangelical alternative to the radicalized student pro-democracy movement, many other evangelical Christians criticized their approach to social engagement as too radical and as beyond acceptable evangelical boundaries.Footnote 86 For many Korean evangelicals at the time, liberation theology was not a Christian theology, but rather a socio-political ideology moulded by Marxism, which replaced a Christian concept of salvation by political liberation.Footnote 87 Thus, embracing the influence of liberation theology was seen as irreconcilable with being evangelical, because liberation and evangelical theologies had distinct frameworks.Footnote 88 Other members of the SNU evangelical network were also sceptical, for similar reasons, both about embracing liberation theology’s influence and regarding the radical experiment by some members of their group.Footnote 89 Through involvement in the base community, some members of the SNU evangelical network attempted to redefine evangelicalism in a more radical way. However, in doing so, they were seen as crossing a boundary from evangelicalism to ‘liberal’ or ‘radical’ theology.
Conclusion
The SNU evangelical network emerged on the margins of Korean evangelicalism. On the campus in the 1980s where the student pro-democracy movement and governmental oppression confronted each other, evangelical students struggled with the prevailing evangelical approach to socio-political issues and Christian mission. As a result, they started an endeavour in 1986 to challenge the prevailing approach through their own redefining actions. The formation of the Association of Evangelical Youth and Students and its campaign for a fair election, and the base community, were different expressions of this endeavour. However, although the SNU evangelical network’s experiments were pioneering, their direct influence remained limited. It failed to significantly alter conservative predominance among Korean evangelicals. The limited impact of these experiments can be attributed to the deeply entrenched conservative nature of Korean evangelicalism, which posed significant challenges for the SNU network in pursuing a more holistic approach to evangelical identity. Furthermore, the evangelical student endeavour did not last long, which contributed to the limited impact of their experiments. Facing the issue of moral failures among the network leadership, their bond of trust and respect collapsed, and it resulted in the dissolution of the network in September 1989.Footnote 90
Nevertheless, their pioneering work of redefining evangelicalism had an enduring impact upon specific segments of Korean evangelicalism, particularly in inspiring and shaping subsequent new evangelical movements and initiatives. For instance, their launch of a campaign for a fair election through the Association of Evangelical Youth and Students set a precedent for similar types of campaigns initiated by new evangelicals in the 1990s.Footnote 91 The periodical Gospel and Context, which published its first issue in January 1991 and subsequently became a flagship magazine of Korean new evangelicalism, originated in the University Christian Newspaper of the SNU evangelical network.Footnote 92 Those who had been members of the student network played a central role in the early stage of this periodical. The formative role of the SNU evangelical network in relation to the Korean new evangelical group was similar to the importance of student groups in shaping the Latin American evangelical left.Footnote 93
The SNU evangelical network’s experience also prefigured the divergent approaches which later emerged among new evangelical groups and their differing receptions among broader evangelicalism. Two experiments conducted by the SNU evangelical network exemplified the moderate and radical paths, along with their respective outcomes, that would be seen in future new evangelical efforts. These experiments were the Association of Evangelical Youth and Students’ campaign for a fair election, and the base community. While the former was acceptable to mainstream evangelicals and gained some support from them, the latter was challenged and suspected. This pattern was repeated among new evangelicals in the 1990s. For instance, a campaign for fair elections initiated in 1991 by the Christian Ethics Movement of Korea, which favoured the moderate way, gained significant support from mainstream evangelicals.Footnote 94 However, the periodical Gospel and Context which sought a more radical approach to socio-political and theological issues suffered in the 1990s, facing frequent challenges from mainstream evangelical readers, and finding itself struggling with chronic financial difficulties.Footnote 95 In contrast to Latin America, the Korean context was marked by the presence of an evangelical majority. Its mainstream had a conservative-leaning socio-political and missiological orientation. In this Korean context, the task of redefining evangelicalism was always under pressure. Those who took a radical move toward the liberal end of the evangelical spectrum had to face continuing challenges from mainstream evangelicalism. Facing these challenges, they tended to take one of three options: adopting a more moderate tone; continuing to redefine evangelicalism with a radical spirit on the margins of evangelicalism; or leaving the evangelical camp altogether. For instance, Jong-Chul Lee, a key figure in both the SNU evangelical network and the periodical Gospel and Context, departed in 1993 from the evangelical to the more liberal Christian camp, complaining about the rigidity of evangelical boundaries in which he felt ideological confinement.Footnote 96 Those who took a radical path while managing to maintain an evangelical identity were on the margin of the margins in the Korean context.
Ultimately, the story of the SNU network illustrates the complexities of redefining evangelicalism from the margins within a predominantly conservative evangelical context. While unable to alter the evangelical landscape fundamentally, these marginal experiments created small but significant spaces for alternative voices and approaches within Korean evangelicalism. This demonstrates that limited and short-lived movements operating from the periphery can contribute to the ongoing dialogue and evolution of religious thought and practice, even in contexts where conservative traditions remain strong.
