Putting the Caliph in His Place is an important contribution to the scholarship on the Abbasid caliphate after its heyday in the 8th and 9th centuries. It focuses on the actions of the caliphs during the Buyid and Selçukid eras in the 11th and 12th centuries. Both centuries have certainly received their share in scholarship—but not from the perspective of the Abbasid caliphs. The scholarly impression has been, by and large, that the Abbasid caliphs were removed from political life with the ascendancy of the Buyids and the Selçuks and remained in the shadow until their eventual demise at the hands of the Mongols in the middle of the 13th century. Hanne argues that the caliphs during these two centuries, although weaker than other rulers, were far from ceremonial fixtures escorted in and out when needed. On the contrary, they emerged as one of the primary regional players in the political, cultural, and military affairs of the 11th and 12th centuries and even expanded their authority in central Iraq.
Hanne identifies three ways in which one may study the caliphate. First, one may examine it as a traditional ruling institution. In their roles as the representatives of the institution, the caliphs carried considerable psychological and moral power in medieval Muslim society as a source of legitimacy, whose importance both regional powers and the caliphs understood. Second, one may study the caliphate from the perspective of household politics, the caliphs as the head of their household. Despite their prestige, the caliphs also had to deal with day-to-day politics, such as mitigating family factions on succession decisions and dealing with matters related to familial affiliation with other potentates in the region. Third, the actions of individual caliphs provide another important parameter to understand medieval politics. By looking into the reasoning behind their actions as individual choices (although informed by their larger role in society), the author not only assesses the motives of the caliphs but also points out how the ability of individual caliphs or lack of it affected regional politics.
As the author acknowledges, the theoretical framework of the study benefits from the work of Mottahedeh and Chamberlain but also incorporates new theories of power to bring to the reader's attention the long-term social dynamics and the patterns of power relations underlying political developments. Instead of relying solely on the notion of the ruler's traditional role in society to explain the state of the caliphate in this era, Hanne looks more carefully at the actions of the caliphs and of other regional powers. He emphasizes the importance of household politics and the attendant conflicts in succession decisions, the impact of centrifugal forces within the family, and the task of maintaining a sustainable support base to back the agendas of the caliphs as important dynamics in the politics of the 11th and 12th centuries. He also illustrates how a series of personal ties of loyalty and the practical and pragmatic needs influencing shifts in loyalty both helped and hampered the conduct of the caliphs and other rulers. Within this framework the author illuminates in chronological order the role of the caliphs and places them within the existing scholarly narrative on the Buyids and the Selçuks.
To elucidate his argument Hanne organizes his study into five chapters and a conclusion. The first chapter, “Revisiting the Caliphate,” is a methodological and historiographical introduction to the study, in which Hanne identifies the scholarly gap he intends to fill. The second chapter, “Reestablishing a Presence,” deals with the struggle of the caliphs to assert and expand their authority and power vis-à-vis regional powers during much of the 11th century. He makes the point that there is a need to conceptualize the caliphs as the primary object of study rather than peripheral figures who appear only in passing. The reader will find useful and substantiated with evidence Hanne's discussion of the pivotal role of Baghdad in power politics and the ways in which Abbasids reestablished their political presence and ideological authority in local and regional levels by creating and maintaining a support base for themselves and by emphasizing their religious prerogatives. Chapter 3, “The Ramifications and Limitations of Power,” is a demonstration of the contestation of power between the Abbasid caliphs and the Selçuks during the final quarter of the 11th and the first two decades of the 12th centuries. Although weaker than their rivals, the caliphs revived their administration, continued to maintain a support base for themselves, took active roles in regional politics, and constituted a real threat to their rivals. Furthermore, the chapter mindfully underscores the painful realization of the Abbasids that the lack of military power allowed them only limited options in pursuing their aspirations.
Chapter 4, “Power as a Means to an End,” examines the restoration of Abbasid military capability and the corollary push for autonomy in central Iraq from 1118 to 1160. Backed by military capability and the revived office of wazir, the caliphs expanded their power and prestige and sometimes even acted in politics as equals among other regional forces. Numerous examples illustrating the handling of the caliphs and their responsibilities as players in regional politics clarify the role of individual caliphs in politics. But the revival of rule paradoxically constrained the maneuverability of the caliphs. Hanne argues that the increase in power precipitated further demands from the caliphs in their capacity as regional players, entangled them more in household politics and domestic conflicts, and tied them to a perpetual effort to maintain a support base for themselves.
Chapter 5, “Limitations in the Maintenance of Power,” continues the discussion through the second half of the 12th century and showcases the inability of individual caliphs to deal with growing challenges that brought additional problems to the Abbasids. Hanne thus argues that al-Mustanjid and al-Mustadiʿ failed to maintain the power of the caliphate even though the Selçuks were no longer a serious threat. Although the prestige of the caliphate grew as an institution, the caliphs in reality were confined to their palaces, worrying about assassination at the hand of their own officials in a way that was very much reminiscent of the late 9th and 10th centuries.
The conclusion duly summarizes the main points of the study and reiterates the need to look at the caliphal institution in a tripartite way to better understand the social forces that contributed to the evolution of the caliphate in later phases. The study is complemented with relevant genealogical tables, an index, a useful glossary for nonexperts, and a selected bibliography.
The author appears abreast of scholarly literature in the field, with which he meaningfully engages to further our understanding of the period. A final note on modern scholarship in Arabic language is in order, however. The author would have done an excellent service to his readers had he also integrated the finding of Arabic scholarship dealing with later Abbasid centuries. Although at times driven by a nationalist agenda, Arabic scholarship nevertheless addresses the history of the caliphate in its later phases and should be taken into careful consideration. Such a minor point notwithstanding, Putting the Caliph in his Place will be of much benefit to specialists as well students in the field.
