Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:14:33.338Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Secondary instability and subcritical transition of the leading-edge boundary layer

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 March 2016

Michael O. John*
Affiliation:
Institute of Fluid Dynamics, ETH Zurich, Zurich 8092, Switzerland
Dominik Obrist
Affiliation:
Institute of Fluid Dynamics, ETH Zurich, Zurich 8092, SwitzerlandARTORG Center, University of Bern, Bern 3010, Switzerland
Leonhard Kleiser
Affiliation:
Institute of Fluid Dynamics, ETH Zurich, Zurich 8092, Switzerland
*
†Email address for correspondence: john@ifd.mavt.ethz.ch

Abstract

The leading-edge boundary layer (LEBL) in the front part of swept airplane wings is prone to three-dimensional subcritical instability, which may lead to bypass transition. The resulting increase of airplane drag and fuel consumption implies a negative environmental impact. In the present paper, we present a temporal biglobal secondary stability analysis (SSA) and direct numerical simulations (DNS) of this flow to investigate a subcritical transition mechanism. The LEBL is modelled by the swept Hiemenz boundary layer (SHBL), with and without wall suction. We introduce a pair of steady, counter-rotating, streamwise vortices next to the attachment line as a generic primary disturbance. This generates a high-speed streak, which evolves slowly in the streamwise direction. The SSA predicts that this flow is unstable to secondary, time-dependent perturbations. We report the upper branch of the secondary neutral curve and describe numerous eigenmodes located inside the shear layers surrounding the primary high-speed streak and the vortices. We find secondary flow instability at Reynolds numbers as low as $Re\approx 175$ , i.e. far below the linear critical Reynolds number $Re_{crit}\approx 583$ of the SHBL. This secondary modal instability is confirmed by our three-dimensional DNS. Furthermore, these simulations show that the modes may grow until nonlinear processes lead to breakdown to turbulent flow for Reynolds numbers above $Re_{tr}\approx 250$ . The three-dimensional mode shapes, growth rates, and the frequency dependence of the secondary eigenmodes found by SSA and the DNS results are in close agreement with each other. The transition Reynolds number $Re_{tr}\approx 250$ at zero suction and its increase with wall suction closely coincide with experimental and numerical results from the literature. We conclude that the secondary instability and the transition scenario presented in this paper may serve as a possible explanation for the well-known subcritical transition observed in the leading-edge boundary layer.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2016 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Steady secondary baseflow $\boldsymbol{u}_{B}$ visualized by ${\it\lambda}_{2}$ isosurfaces, coloured by the local streamwise velocity component $w$. The stability analysis of § 3 is carried out at some position $z=z_{0}$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a–c) The three primary disturbance velocity components $\boldsymbol{u}_{1}^{\prime }$ at $z=14$, (d) total streamwise velocity component $\boldsymbol{w}_{B}$ of the secondary baseflow ($\boldsymbol{w}_{SH}+\boldsymbol{w}_{1}^{\prime }$) and sectional streamlines at $z=100$. Arrows indicate the primary disturbance vortex orientation. (a) $\boldsymbol{u}_{1}^{\prime }(x,y)$, (b) $\boldsymbol{v}_{1}^{\prime }(x,y)$, (c) $\boldsymbol{w}_{1}^{\prime }(x,y)$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Streak amplitude $A_{st}(z)$, (2.2), for various primary vortex configurations at large times. (a) Disturbance amplitudes $A_{1}=\{0.01,0.02,\ldots ,0.10\}$, $r_{1}=3.0$, $Re=300$, ${\it\kappa}=0.0$ (secondary disturbance parameters $A_{2}=0.001$, ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.21$). (b) Vortex radii $r_{1}=\{0.5,1.0,\ldots ,4.0\}$, $A_{1}=0.10$, $Re=500$, ${\it\kappa}=0.2$, $A_{2}=0$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) A typical secondary eigenspectrum of antisymmetric modes obtained for $Re=400$, ${\it\kappa}=0$, ${\it\gamma}\in [0.5,5.0]$. (b) Eigenspectra of secondary antisymmetric instability for $Re\in \{100,200,300,400,500\}$ (colour sequence: blue, green, yellow, orange, red) and ${\it\gamma}\in [0.5,5.0]$ (branches), ${\it\kappa}=0$. An enlargement of (b) is illustrated in figure 5.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Closeup of figure 4(b): eigenspectra of secondary antisymmetric instability for $Re\in \{200,300,400,500\}$ (colour: green, yellow, orange, red) and ${\it\gamma}\in [0.5,5.0]$ (branches), ${\it\kappa}=0$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Six selected normalized secondary eigenmode velocity magnitudes $|\hat{\boldsymbol{w}}(x,y)|$ highlighted by circles on the antisymmetric branches depicted in figure 4(a). Red indicates regions of high velocity magnitude $|\hat{\boldsymbol{w}}|$. The white curves are sectional streamlines of the secondary baseflow $\boldsymbol{u}_{B}$. The branches and wavenumbers illustrated are (a) $A$, ${\it\gamma}=0.9$, (b) $B$, ${\it\gamma}=0.8$, (c) $D$, ${\it\gamma}=2.5$, (d) $E$, ${\it\gamma}=2.5$, (e) $F$, ${\it\gamma}=0.8$, (f) $I$, ${\it\gamma}=0.9$. $Re=400$, ${\it\kappa}=0$. Colour bar see figure 2.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Dependence of the eigenmode of branch $C$ (cf. figure 4b) on the wave number ${\it\gamma}$, $Re=400$, ${\it\kappa}=0$. (a) ${\it\gamma}=0.50$, (b) 0.60, (c) 0.70, (d) 0.80, (e) 0.90, (f) 1.00, (g) 1.10, (h) 1.20, (i) 1.30, (j) 1.40, (k) 1.50, (l) 1.60, (m) 1.80 (n) 2.00, (o) 2.50, (p) 3.00.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Secondary stability diagram of the SHBL secondary baseflow as defined in § 2 without wall suction. The lines show contours of the temporal growth rate $c_{i}$ of the most amplified (or least damped) mode (values are indicated). The thick line is the neutral curve $c_{i}=0$. Secondary instability is observed for Reynolds numbers $Re$ as low as $175$. The open circles illustrate the parameter combinations $\{Re,{\it\gamma}\}$ for which stability equations (3.3) were solved.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Marginally stable secondary eigenmode of branch $G$ at (a) $Re=200$, ${\it\gamma}=1.0$ (b) $Re=300$, ${\it\gamma}=1.3$ (c) $Re=400$, ${\it\gamma}=1.5$ (d) $Re=500$, ${\it\gamma}=1.8$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Vortex of the baseflow $\boldsymbol{u}_{B}$ (turquoise) and a superposition of the baseflow and the antisymmetric secondary $G$ mode (gold) illustrated by ${\it\lambda}_{2}$ vortex structures, ${\it\lambda}_{2}=-0.02$. (a) $Re=200$, ${\it\gamma}=1.3$ and (b) $Re=400$, ${\it\gamma}=1.6$. Secondary disturbance velocity maximum $A_{2}=0.1$.

Figure 10

Figure 11.(a) Branches of symmetric modes (blue dots) and antisymmetric modes (red squares) for $Re=400$, ${\it\gamma}\in [0.5,5.0]$, ${\it\kappa}=0$. (b) Vortex of the baseflow $\boldsymbol{u}_{B}$ (turquoise) and a superposition of the baseflow and the symmetric secondary $G$ mode (gold) illustrated by ${\it\lambda}_{2}$ vortex structures, $Re=200$, ${\it\gamma}=1.3$. Secondary disturbance amplitude $A_{2}=0.1$, ${\it\lambda}_{2}=-0.02$.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Typical Fourier–Hermite spectral energy densities $e_{k,n}(z)$ for (a) a symmetric secondary disturbance, ${\it\kappa}=0.6$, ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.21$, (b) an antisymmetric secondary disturbance, ${\it\kappa}=0$, ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.16$. $Re=370$, $A_{1}=0.1$.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Simulations with identical baseflows $\boldsymbol{u}_{B}$ ($Re=300$, ${\it\kappa}=0.4$, $A_{1}=0.1$) disturbed at secondary disturbance frequencies (a) ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.63$, (b) ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.31$, (c) ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.21$. ${\it\lambda}_{2}$ isosurfaces of the instantaneous flow $\boldsymbol{u}$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Spatial energy growth rates ${\it\beta}$ of (a) antisymmetric secondary instability mode $e_{1,2}$ and (b) symmetric secondary instability mode $e_{1,1}$ as functions of ${\it\omega}_{2}$. $Re=370$, ${\it\kappa}=0$, $A_{1}=0.1$. The dotted curve in (b) illustrates the growth rate ${\it\beta}^{G}$ estimated by Gaster’s transformation (4.4).

Figure 14

Figure 15.(a) Secondary vortical structures from DNS, illustrated by the ${\it\lambda}_{2}$ vortex criterion applied to the full velocity field (${\it\lambda}_{2}=-10^{-4}$), $Re=370$, ${\it\kappa}=0$, $A_{1}=0.10$, ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.63$. (b) Secondary eigenmodes from SSA, illustrated for three periods by the ${\it\lambda}_{2}$ vortex criterion applied to the full velocity field (amplitude of secondary disturbances $A_{2}=0.09$, ${\it\lambda}_{2}=-2\times 10^{-3}$), $Re=400$, ${\it\kappa}=0$, ${\it\gamma}=0.8$. Isosurfaces in both figures are coloured according to the local streamwise velocity component $w(x,y,z,t)$ (red: high velocity; green: low velocity).

Figure 15

Figure 16.Spatial energy growth rates ${\it\beta}$ (4.3) of the secondary symmetric mode $e_{1,1}$ as a function of $Re$ and wall suction strength ${\it\kappa}$ for $A_{1}=0.1$, ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.21$. Filled circles denote positive, open circles negative growth rates ${\it\beta}$, their radii indicate the magnitude of ${\it\beta}$ (not to scale). The solid curve (Arnal et al.1997) and the dashed curve (Poll & Danks 1995) show experimental results for the transition Reynolds number $Re_{tr}({\it\kappa})$. For comparison, six DNS for parameters close to these curves were tested for transition: the three DNS below the curve of Poll & Danks (1995) clearly showed transition to turbulent flow (circles), and three DNS above the curve showed return to laminar flow (squares). The small black area in the bottom right corner represents the region of primary linear instability.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Illustration of subcritical transitional flow (${\it\lambda}_{2}$ vortices coloured by local streamwise $w$ velocity component) due to a symmetric secondary instability at $Re=250$, ${\it\kappa}=0$, $A_{1}=0.12$, ${\it\omega}_{2}\approx 0.31$, ${\it\lambda}_{2}=-10^{-4}$.