Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-m6dxt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-19T05:07:11.529Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Unsteady dynamics of turbulent flow in the wakes of barchan dunes modulated by overlying boundary-layer structure

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 June 2021

Nathaniel R. Bristow
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556, USA
Gianluca Blois
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556, USA
James L. Best
Affiliation:
Departments of Geology, Geography and GIS, Mechanical Science and Engineering and Ven Te Chow Hydrosystems Laboratory, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1301 W. Green St., Urbana, IL 61801, USA
Kenneth T. Christensen*
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556, USADepartment of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Earth Sciences, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556, USACO2 Storage Division, International Institute for Carbon-Neutral Energy Research (I2CNER), Kyushu University, Japan
*
†Email address for correspondence: kenneth.christensen@iit.edu

Abstract

The dynamics of turbulent flow structures in the wakes of barchan dunes is investigated to understand the complex, long-range interactions that occur between these three-dimensional bedforms. High-frame-rate stereo-particle image velocimetry measurements are collected from the cross-stream plane in a refractive-index-matched flume, wherein rigid models are immersed in the logarithmic region of a turbulent boundary layer. Through application of Taylor's hypothesis, limited-domain pseudo-three-dimensional reconstructions of the flow are made, wherein coherent structures are identified in the wake of an isolated barchan that resemble hairpin-like vortices. Amplitude modulation analysis, based on wavelet decomposition of velocity fluctuations and swirling strength, suggests a correlation between the shedding of these coherent structures and the passage of large-scale motions (LSMs) aloft in the turbulent boundary layer within which the barchan dune is immersed. Impulse analysis of shear stress events shows that, while the hairpin-like structures predominantly induce ejections of low-momentum fluid, the intermittent passage of an overlying high-momentum LSM yields intense sweep events as they impact the wall. Similar flow dynamics is found in dune–dune collision configurations involving barchan dunes arranged in tandem, with the exception that significant flow asymmetries are introduced, resulting in structures resembling single-legged hairpin-like (or ‘cane’) vortices being identified in conditional averages. These results provide insight into both the morphodynamics of dune interactions as well as the interactions between boundary-layer structure and roughness elements protruding into the log layer.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.The morphologies and configurations of the barchan dunes studied herein: (a) isolated case; (b–d) collision cases. Green lines mark streamwise positions of the spanwise–wall-normal measurement planes that were unchanged for all configurations. (e) Shows a streamwise–wall-normal (x–y) view of the isolated barchan; the mean slopes of the stoss and lee sides along the dune centreline are indicated by the red line. Adapted from Bristow et al. (2018).

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Photograph of the stereo-PIV experimental set-up in the LS-RIM; (b) top-view schematic representation of the stereo-PIV arrangement. Reproduced from Bristow et al. (2020).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Incoming smooth-wall boundary-layer conditions, with comparisons to LES (Eitel-Amor et al.2014) and hot-wire (Örlü & Schlatter 2013) data from comparable Re. The model height $H^{+}$ is indicated by the vertical line.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Probability distributions of the durations of streamwise swirling motions ($\lambda _{ci,x}$) compared with the durations of Reynolds shear stress quadrant events, all for the isolated barchan case.

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a,b) Isosurfaces of 3-D swirling strength from the isolated case showing reconstructions from time series of cross-plane stereo PIV measurements collected at $x/H=5$ and 6, respectively; (c–f) conditionally averaged 3-D flow obtained in the measurement plane sampling events with consistent spanwise swirling ($\lambda _{ci,z}$); and (g,h) conditionally averaged 3-D flow obtained sampling on ejection events ($u<0$, $v>0$). Isosurface colours in (a,b) and (g,h) indicate the sign of streamwise swirling component ($\lambda _{ci,x}$), while isosurfaces themselves are extracted from $\lambda _{ci}^{*}=0.04$ for (a,b) and $\lambda _{ci}^{*}=0.03$ for (g,h). Isosurfaces in (c,d) plot conditionally averaged data from $x/H=5$ and isosurfaces in (e,f) plot data from $x/H=6.5$, both extracted using $\lambda _{ci}^{*}=0.026$. Isosurface values are chosen in each case to minimize visualization of noise and maintain consistency between data from the two measurement planes. Cross-sectional planes in (c–f) display in-plane velocity vectors overlaid with contours of $u$ and streamwise swirling, $\lambda _{ci,x}$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Comparison between conditionally averaged ‘ground truth’ flow fields and conditionally averaged reconstructed flow fields in the wake of the isolated barchan. (a–d) swirling strength; (e–h) Q2 event probabilities.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a,b) Examples of pre-multiplied wavelet power spectra of (a) $u$ and (b) $\lambda _{ci,z}$ from a grid point near $(y/H,z/H)= [1,0]$ in the measurement plane at $x/H=5$ for the isolated case; (c) global wavelet power spectra of $u$, $\lambda _{ci,z}$ and $\varPhi '_{\lambda _{ci,z}}$, normalized by respective maxima for visual comparison of frequencies associated with peaks. Solid lines indicate data from grid point near $(y/H,z/H)= [1,0]$ in measurement plane at $x/H=5$ and dashed lines from $x/H=6.5$. Horizontal dashed lines in (b) and thin vertical dashed lines in (c) indicate frequency band integrated over for $\varPhi '_{\lambda _{ci,z}}$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Amplitude modulation coefficients from measurements at (a–c) $x/H=5$ and (d–f) $x/H=6.5$, all at ($y_{ref}$, $z_{ref})/H = (1,0)$ in wake of the isolated barchan, plotted as a volumetric velocity field, where colours denote the modulation coefficient associated with $u$. (a,d) Plot the slice of the flow field along $\Delta z/H=0$, (b,e) along $\Delta tU_c/H=0$ and (c,f) plot the previous two slices along with the slice at $\Delta y/H=0$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Amplitude modulation coefficients from (a) measurements in the relatively unperturbed region upstream of the isolated barchan at a reference location of $(x_{ref}, y_{ref}, z_{ref})/H = (-2.5,1,-4)$ and (b) measurements in the wake of the smaller upstream barchan at a reference location of $(x_{ref}, y_{ref}, z_{ref})/H = (-2.5,0.5,-1.75)$. Coefficients are plotted as a velocity field, where colours are the modulation coefficient associated with $u$, taken from $\Delta tU_c/H=0$, and vector components are $R_v^{a}$ and $R_w^{a}$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.(a–d) Average impulses from each of the four quadrant events, as indicated. (e) Disparity between $Q_2$ and $Q_4$ event distributions. Data taken from $x/H=5$ for the isolated case, plotted with streamwise flow into page.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Spatial distributions of average (a,c) $Q_2$ and (b,d) $Q_4$ events, in terms of (a,b) event duration ($T_Q^{*}$) and (c,d) event stress ($S_Q^{*}$). Data taken from $x/H=5$ for the isolated case, plotted with streamwise flow into page.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Disparity between distributions of $Q_2$ and $Q_4$ event (a) durations and (b) stresses. Data taken from $x/H=5$ for the isolated case, plotted with streamwise flow into page.

Figure 12

Figure 13.The $Q_2$ (a) and $Q_4$ (b) event duration and stress distributions, conditioned on corresponding impulses above threshold $J_t$. (c) Disparity between panels (a,b). Data taken from $x/H=5$, plotted with streamwise flow into page.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Conditionally averaged flow fields from the isolated case associated with (a,b,d,e) $Q_4$ events and (c,f) $Q_2$ events. (a,d) Isosurfaces of swirling strength coloured by its spanwise swirling component ($\lambda _{ci,z}$) with in-plane vectors in the centreline x–y plane overlaid; (b,c,e,f) isosurfaces of $u$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Impulse differences between $Q_2$ and $Q_4$ events in the interdune region during collision cases A–C. Dashed lines in (b,d,f) indicate DBD stoss side topography transected by measurement plane.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Isosurfaces of 3-D swirling strength from collision cases B and C showing (a,b) reconstructions from time series, (c,d) flow reconstructions conditionally averaged on ejection events ($u<0, v>0$). Isosurface colours indicate the sign of streamwise swirling component ($\lambda _{ci,x}^{*}$), while isosurfaces themselves are extracted from $\lambda _{ci}^{*}=0.03$ in (a,b) and $\lambda _{ci}^{*}=0.025$ in (c,d). Isosurfaces in (a,c) plot conditionally averaged data from $x/H=-2.5$ in collision case B and isosurfaces in (b,d) plot data from $x/H=-1$ in collision case C. Isosurface values are chosen in each case to minimize visualization of noise.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Comparison of isosurfaces of swirling strength reconstructed from the $x/H=6.5$ measurement plane in the wake of the isolated barchan, using (a) uniform convection velocity, $U_c=0.35U_e$ and (b) spatially varying convection velocity equal to the local mean streamwise velocity, $U_c(y,z)=\langle U(y,z) \rangle$.

Figure 17

Figure 18.Differences between $Q_2$ and $Q_4$ for average (a,b) impulse, (c,d) duration and (e,f) stress, comparing results obtained (a,c,e) without any thresholding, and (b,d,f) a minimum duration threshold of four measurement time steps applied. All data from $x/H=5$ for the isolated case.