Ontiveros provides stimulating insights into the cultural politics of the Chicano movement during the period of the 1960s and 1970s. The span of the book is wide-ranging, as it covers the role of the media, the visual arts, theatre, and literature in shaping a sense of Chicano identity which has been influential on contemporary culture.
One of the most striking sections in the book is that which focusses on the media. Ontiveros has made new use of archival evidence in order to show how mainstream television networks portrayed Chicano activists as a threat to a stable sense of law and order. For example, the analysis of NBC's coverage of the anti-Vietnam War protests by Mexican Americans in East LA on 19 August 1970 reveals “how the networks privileged the police perspective over movement points of view” (59). The choice of certain camera angles, the presence of a voice-over commentary, and the lack of opportunity for Chicanos to be interviewed on camera caused a biased view of the protests to be recorded. However, despite the problems inherent in the reporting of Chicano issues by mainstream television, Chicano activists created their own print media, which offered them a way to become “cultural producers” of their own narrative history (68). Newspapers such as El Malcriado, which first appeared in 1964, succeeded in drawing attention to injustices experienced by Mexican American farmworkers. The Chicano prison population also produced “pinto (inmate) periodicals” such as Aztlán which undermined the mainstream media's attempts to demonize inmates (78).
Visual art provided another outlet for Chicano activism. Ontiveros draws an interesting link between the emergence of an ecological consciousness and an ongoing focus on social injustice. A key artist to consider in this context is the Texan Santa Barraza. Inspired by Mexican artists such as Frida Kahlo, as well as by the European Renaissance tradition, Barraza illustrates “the inventiveness of Chicano/a art, which frequently uses dominant traditions to challenge dominant ideologies” (122). Ontiveros offers a detailed analysis of key works such as Renacimiento (1980), which presents the image of a woman and baby alongside a maguey cactus, associated with Aztec beliefs regarding death and regeneration. Although the woman in the picture is presented in the traditional role of mother to the child, Ontiveros argues that she simultaneously embodies a sense of cultural power which is progressive.
Ontiveros also considers the important contribution provided by El Teatro Campesino, which was founded in 1965 as a result of social unrest related to the Californian grape strike. The theatrical actos performed by the group drew attention to the problems inherent in laws governing immigration from Mexico to the US. This style of theatre used minimal props and it was often performed on the tops of trucks. Ontiveros analyses the influence of the Mexican relajo performance style, which features a pelado or “underdog” whose role is to use humour to subvert social institutions and to provide a sense of cathartic release for the working-class spectator (137). He also considers the impact of the 1971 skit Soldado Razo. This focusses on a Mexican immigrant who hopes that his decision to fight in Vietnam will ensure legal citizenship for his family, but his death underscores the shattering of this dream. The presence onstage of the character “Muerte” (death) echoes the Mexican “Day of the Dead” convention (143).
In the final section of the book Ontiveros focusses closely on Sandra Cisneros's 2002 novel Caramelo. This tells the story of the upbringing of the protagonist, Celaya Reyes, whose journeys from San Antonio to Mexico dramatize tensions concerning racial and gendered identity. Although Cisneros is an established writer whose work has already been well researched by other critics, Ontiveros provides some useful insights regarding the ways in which Cisneros highlights the problems of homophobia and sexism which threatened to destabilize the Chicano movement. Ontiveros argues that Cisneros's novel offers a challenge to the view which is sometimes presented that feminism was responsible for the demise of the movement.
In the Spirit of a New People is a thought-provoking book which should be an important read for anyone researching 1960s and 1970s Chicano cultural politics, and it should have a wider appeal to scholars in American studies.
