This book focuses on the relationship between nationalism and colonialism. It demonstrates that nationalism, as a collective consciousness, is embedded in the very system of colonialism that it apparently was confronting and trying to delegitimize. Conceptualized with high theoretical sophistication, carefully researched and stylistically written, this book provides the reader with a lively and well-grounded impression of how nationalism is shaped through the everyday social and work encounters between educated petty employees, Sudanese males, and colonial authorities.
In Chapter 1, Sharkey conceptualizes colonialism as a practice of everyday life. She argues that nationalism was engrained in the very system of colonialism that it sought to delegitimize. She traces the relationship between nationalism and colonialism by focusing on British educational policy in Sudan, life and education at the elitist Gordon College (opened in Khartoum in 1902), and the experience of the young Sudanese graduates “working under” the British. Through this conceptual frame, the author is able to analyze and follow through on how “educated Northerners imagined a nation that took its territorial shape from the colony but its cultural shape from themselves” (p. 11).
In a delightful writing style in Chapter 2, the author discusses the evolution of the term “Sudanese” and the processes of negotiating Sudanese identity within the context of colonialism and its educational policy. Sharkey argues that the British policy of favoring Arabs (mainly Muslims) over blacks for admission at Gordon College only reinforced the precolonial elitist structure. Through intensive utilization of historical records, the reader gets a vivid account of the college's enrolment policy, the embedded meaning of the term “Sudanese” in Egyptian–British relations, and the shift of that meaning from “black” to “nationalist.”
In Chapter 3, Sharkey peers deeper into the everyday life of young North Sudanese males at Gordon College. Here she shows how the college, as a cultural space established by the British to produce skilled labor for the regime, was redefined through the agency of its students in a manner that worked ultimately against British interests. In a spirited style, this chapter introduces the reader to many of the young educated men who received a privileged and highly regimented education at Gordon College. These men were exposed to European-based character building and a global linkup through print and visual media and the postal system that was established by the British. Students graduated from the school as potential effendiyya and “went on to describe themselves as a new generation (jīl) engaged in a dual liberation struggle against both foreign colonialism and home-grown backwardness” (p. 66).
In Chapter 4, the author follows these young Gordon College graduates and elaborates on how they were placed—on the basis of British policies of “Sudanization”—as employees of the regime. Sharkey asserts that through its different phases, Sudanization policies were shaped and transformed by different factors, such as a pragmatic approach to reduce the cost of administration by employing locals; the eagerness of the British to minimize Egypt's role in the Sudan, especially after the 1919 uprisings; the distrust by high-ranking British officials of the graduates after the 1924 uprisings; and the world economic depression.
The question of how nationalism was structured by the complexity of ambiguous relations between the effendiyya and the colonial system on the one hand, and the effendiyya and the Sudanese population on the other, is the main focus of Chapter 5. Here, the author shows how the anticolonial and antihomegrown backward sentiments of the nationalists were expressed through literature, poem, and on-the-job resistance. Sharkey argues that new work technologies, such as the postal service, made it possible for nationalists to communicate and hence crystallize nationalist ideologies, which found expression in the Arabic and Islamic culture of elites.
In discussing Sudan's independence in Chapter 6, Sharkey provides insightful analysis into how the nationalists faced the challenge of defining the new Sudanese nation. She argues that structural factors, such as the state system and geographic borders inherited from the British, together with the ways “early nationalists viewed themselves as the standard-bearers of modernity” (p. 132), actually influenced the establishment of Arabism and Islam as the framework for cultural homogeneity. Sharkey contends that civil war(s) have erupted in the Sudan because the present is deeply imbued with past inequalities, which structured how the definition of the Sudanese nation was put into political practice.
In an encapsulated conclusion, Sharkey highlights the main route by which elite Gordon College students were transformed into nationalist champions. Here, the reader is enticed into recapturing the main discussion of the book, as the author provides a brief overview of the main themes discussed in the book: conditions of colonial educational enrollment and employment, literary and poetic nationalist sentiments, professional experience and nationalist ideologies, and finally, the engineering of nation and national unity after independence.
The book fulfills its claim of answering the questions of how colonialism worked on the ground, how national identity formed, and what the consequences of the interaction between colonialism and nationalism were. It breaks profound new scholarly ground by focusing on the relation and interaction between colonialism and nationalism, which are often placed as oppositional categories. Moreover, the book is enriched by archival materials, personal biographies, and descriptions of social encounters that make it a delight to read. Perhaps a more explicit focus on the question of how nationalist sentiments developed among marginal groups, namely, non-Arabs, non-Muslims, and women, would benefit the book and widen its readership. Nonetheless, this is a sublime book that comes highly recommended for scholars of African studies, history, sociology, and the history of colonialism.
