At the beginning of the twenty-first century a wave of women were elected president in Latin America. Michelle Bachelet (2006–10, 2014–) in Chile, Cristina Fernández de Kirchner (2007–15) in Argentina, and Dilma Rousseff (2011–16) in Brazil; each was elected to not just one, but two terms in office. Similarly, Laura Chinchilla in Costa Rica was elected president (2010–14), after having previously served as vice president (2006–8). No doubt, we are witnessing a moment of historical import, and, as such, expectations of social transformation, in particular of increased gender equality, are on the rise. At the same time, however, none of these female presidents publicly embraced feminist ideals of gender equality. On the contrary, some rejected feminism, as Fernández did when she asserted that she was a ‘feminine’, not ‘feminist’, leader (p. 177).
Jane Christie's timely book, Negotiating Gendered Discourses: Michelle Bachelet and Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, thoroughly analyses these conflicting gender issues and discourses and how they were dealt with by both female presidents. Through feminist critical discourse analysis, Christie's research seeks to reveal the gendered scripts or frames deployed by Fernández and Bachelet. She examines their presidential campaign speeches, their interventions in relation to recent debates on abortion, and relevant case studies of their gendered social policies. In addition, Christie conducted interviews in both countries, mostly with women leaders of human rights organisations and NGOs. Christie believes that women tend to share relatively similar lives and experiences, though shaped distinctively by time and space, as well as by class and race. These shared experiences provide a common ground for a female identity to emerge; one which is not biological, but social; fluid, not monolithic.
In the case of Latin America, motherhood is placed at the core of womanhood, and so Bachelet and Fernández strategically constructed their political discourses by aligning themselves with deep-seated beliefs on femininity and motherhood. Christie argues that this kind of maternal leadership gained renewed legitimacy thanks to female leaders of human rights organisations, such as Madres de Plaza de Mayo (an association of mothers whose children disappeared during the military dictatorship, 1976–83; their first march took place in the Plaza de Mayo, in front of the presidential palace) in Argentina and Agrupación de Familiares de Detenidos Desaparecidos (Grouping of the Relatives of Disappeared Detainees, AFDD) in Chile. Christie claims that Bachelet and Fernández made strategic use of maternal discourses because they had ‘a hidden rights-based agenda disguised as egalitarian role-based redistributive policy’ (p. 145).
Christie attributes this ‘strategic use’ to the fact that Bachelet and Fernández needed to reassert that their governments were for everybody, not just for women, while also seeking to improve women's lives. In order to accomplish this complex task, they presented themselves as embodying a new form of politics based on their feminine qualities. Bachelet and Fernández's deployment of maternal discourse was visible when they proposed to represent a more inclusive and caring style of politics and economics, one which – they claimed – emerged out of the experiential knowledge highlighted in their personal biographies.
In contrast, ‘old’ politics was framed as masculine, authoritarian, exclusionary, and based on technical qualifications. Military dictators and neoliberal technocrats epitomise this conventional style of politics, rejected by Bachelet and Fernández. Crucially, their feminine leadership was framed as benefiting everybody, not just women. In this manner, both Bachelet and Fernández were able to improve women's lives in relation to childcare, housing, and pensions, without ever being accused of governing only for women.
At the same time, however, they were not able to challenge gender inequality as such, since their maternal discourse did not allow them to progress in areas beyond or opposed to conventional femininity. As Christie states, ‘as a consequence of this silent contract, any discussion of equality is limited to themes that have already gained wide consensus, and the model stays the same’ (p. 145). In particular, Christie sheds light on how Bachelet and Fernández's maternal style of leadership was actually quite problematic. This was seen, for example, in the case of abortion: Fernández was unwilling to endorse abortion as a women's right, while Bachelet completely avoided the topic in her first term in office.
For these reasons, I believe that the main contribution of Christie's book is that it highlights the continued weight and power of maternal discourse in Latin American politics. It would seem as though Latin American female political leaders continue to be very much constrained by conventional views on femininity, invoking them so as to be granted access and recognition in the political arena. In this way, Christie's work shows an underlying paradox: that in times of increased gender equality, we end up witnessing a return to traditional role-based gender frames. As illustrated by Christie, Bachelet epitomises this paradox, being committed to women's rights, but also privileging a maternalist, rather than a rights-based, rhetoric. By contrast, Fernández seems to exemplify a much more conventional politicised motherhood, as her style of leadership is inspired by Evita, who also has a complicated historic relationship to Argentinian feminism.
However, although Christie's insights on maternalism and female political leadership are intriguing, I find her assertion that Bachelet and Fernández are somehow ‘hiding’ feminist ideals of gender equality behind the veil of maternalist discourse to be problematic. Here Christie appears to be trying to ‘read the tea leaves’ of political intention without any clear evidence to support her conclusions, and that is a risky business, with no clear gains. At the end of the day, Bachelet and Fernández's contributions to feminist ideals of gender equality will be judged by their deeds (and not by their unspoken intentions).
In summary, however, Christie's analysis shows how malleable and popular gender role-based discourse continues to be, as it played a key role in granting popular support for the election of both Bachelet and Fernández. After reading Christie's book one is left with the idea that in Chile and Argentina women are getting access to positions of real power, but the problem is how they obtain this access. Apparently, female candidates still need to perform feminine styles of political leadership in order to win office. That is a far cry from believing that female presidents would openly challenge conventional femininity and work towards increased gender equality. In other words, Christie's book shows that although women are now allowed to enter the political arena, they still have to abide by the rules of conventional gender roles.
