Muslim–Christian dialogue is often headline news at the beginning of the 21st century. Extensive media coverage highlights events like the meeting between Pope Benedict XVI and King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia. However, organizations involved in administering interreligious conversations and relations get less attention. One such organization is the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue (PCID) of the Roman Catholic Church. Risto Jukko provides a thorough study of “the theological structures and argumentations of the publications” of the PCID (p. 24), and, through this analysis, he “attempts to discover. . .whether coherent theological foundations can be found for relations between Christians and non-Christians, in particular between Christians and Muslims” (p. 25).
Jukko is a Finnish scholar of Roman Catholic theology and a Lutheran minister. His perspective is that of a well-informed observer who shares Trinitarian theological beliefs with Catholic leadership but, at the same time, as an outsider, has the ability to offer critical assessments of formal Catholic Church positions and actions. Jukko does not present a history of the PCID so much as a wide-ranging analysis of the church's positions regarding relations with non-Christians as they have been presented through the work of the PCID.
The analysis starts with the statements of the Second Vatican Council (1962–65), noting the importance of Vatican II in shaping the church's approach to interreligious dialogue. This approach was institutionalized with the creation in 1964 of the Secretariat for Non-Christians (which later became the PCID). The introductory chapter sets out the basic framework, noting that the “study is based on Roman Catholic documents and their interpretations” (pp. 36–37) and concentrates on the documents and publications of the PCID. It does not examine writings of Muslims and other non-Christians except for the occasional contributions by non-Christians to PCID publications.
The second chapter provides a remarkably comprehensive survey of the major thinkers whose works shaped the approaches to dialogue taken by the documents of Vatican II. The importance of the trends of existentialism and personalism are noted, and attention is given to “the movement called nouvelle théologie,” which “profoundly influenced Roman Catholic theological thinking” (p. 49). The works of most of the major Catholic theologians of the mid-century, like Henri de Lubac, Jean Daniélou, Yves Congar, and Karl Rahner, as they relate to issues of interreligious dialogue, are examined.
Four chapters deal with specific issues of fundamental theology as it relates to interreligious relations. Chapter 3 concentrates on an anthropological theology based on faith in the one creator God. In this theological position, “especially important is the fact that God has created the human being in his image and, as a consequence, humankind as one human family” (p. 109). Chapter 4 examines the relationship between the belief in the Holy Spirit and interreligious relations. An unresolved tension at the heart of Catholic teachings relates to the universality of salvation: does the theology of the Logos and the Holy Spirit “imply that salvation is more open to non-Christians than traditionally supposed” (p. 187)? Chapter 5 discusses the theology of the “Reign of God.” Again, there is a tension between the more exclusivist and inclusivist definitions of the theological place of non-Christians. Although identification of the church with the Kingdom of God has historically been strong, more recent discussions, especially in the presentations of Pope John Paul II, have been more open. His encyclical letter, Redemtoris Missio (1990), “seems to recognize that the historical reality of the Reign of God extends beyond the Church to the whole of humankind” (p. 221).
The final chapter deals with the concepts involved with viewing “interreligious dialogue as an anthropological and theological necessity” (p. 243). A starting point for PCID-fostered dialogue is that interreligious encounter “helps an individual to grow as a human being and helps him or her to better know and understand the truth and to live by it” (p. 243). Again, Jukko notes a critical tension between the definition of the primary goal of the Church as “the proclamation and propagation of the faith” (p. 257) and the “dialogic attitude—without missionary aim” (p. 260).
Despite the title, this book does not provide much coverage of “Christian–Muslim relations.” In each of the chapters on theological issues, there are occasional observations about Muslim–Christian dialogue. Of more importance, Jukko makes effective use of the addresses of Pope John Paul II to Muslim audiences to show the Pope's positions on interfaith issues. In Jukko's presentation, the Pope's “Message to Young Muslims” in Casablanca (1985) is of special importance in defining the more open and inclusive position on dialogue. However, this book is an analysis of the theological and doctrinal positions of the Catholic Church on interreligious relations as they have been defined in the documents of Vatican II and the PCID, not an examination of the actual events of Christian–Muslim relations.
Most reservations about this book are related to the clearly stated limits on the topic. The fact that there is virtually no discussion of “liberation theology” and its relationship to interreligious dialogue is not due to a weakness in Jukko's analysis so much as to the specific coverage in the documents being analyzed. The PCID did not directly discuss or utilize concepts developed by liberation theology, even though the concept of Christians and non-Christians being cobuilders of the reign of God “when they work for the integral liberation of human persons” (p. 232) would seem to be related to works of liberation theologians like Gustavo Gutiérrez. In a similar vein, the fact that the book gives little coverage to specifically anti-Islamic positions taken by various church leaders is related to the lack of discussion and/or refutation of such positions in the coverage of PCID documents.
This volume provides an almost encyclopedic coverage of Catholic theological discussions of interreligious dialogue. Jukko provides a thorough presentation of the basic theological issues involved in Catholic thought. This book will be of great help to anyone who is interested in getting beyond the headline-grabbing events of interreligious dialogue to some understanding of the intellectual and theological issues that are involved in effective Christian–Muslim dialogue.
