Studies of migration, emigration, immigration, transnationalism, diasporas, and the like seem to be on the increase for every region of the world, including the Middle East and North Africa. This book, however, is virtually alone in its particular niche within that literature: a study of the relationship between the state and its citizens residing abroad. Laurie Brand's Citizens Abroad: Emigration and the State in the Middle East and North Africa focuses on four states: Morocco, Tunisia, Lebanon, and Jordan. Brand's sources include interviews that were both on and off the record, newspapers, scholarly literature, and observation during extended trips to all four states between 1999 and 2003. Brand limits the scope of her investigation to four states rather than trying to cover the entire Middle East and North Africa region, which would either have resulted in a very long book or in patchy coverage of the subject matter. By selecting four countries, Brand is able to do justice both to their commonalities and their many differences.
Modern states have citizens, fixed borders, and complex bureaucracies and make efforts to assert and maintain sovereignty. Brand uses the modern state and its citizens as a frame for analyzing the attentions paid by states to those citizens who have left, highlighting how outreach, management, and diplomatic efforts are operative vis-à-vis emigrants in each of the four featured states. Although earlier waves of out-migrants from the Middle East and North Africa departed from colonial territories and often headed toward the metropole of their respective empires, contemporary migrants cross state borders and move from one state to another. Their destinations are diverse; although many still emigrate to old colonial centers in Western Europe, others can be found in the Gulf, the Americas, and in Africa. Brand documents how the governments of Morocco, Tunisia, Lebanon, and Jordan gradually assumed a proactive stance toward out-migrants, seeing their departing citizens as retaining their original national identity even as they were in the process of acquiring a new identity (and often citizenship) in the new location. In many of their destinations, expatriates were initially seen as temporary workers who would eventually return “home.” In more recent decades it became apparent that most would not return, and it was during this same period that a rise in bureaucratic attention paid to the out-migrants arose in their states of origin.
As Brand shows, Morocco, Tunisia, Lebanon, and Jordan have striking differences in their histories of and approaches to out-migration. Lebanon's population has been leaving in great numbers since the late 19th century. Although some of these same people have returned, many Lebanese out-migrants have lived, and live, a transnational life, with multiple citizenships and in two or more countries. In contrast, Jordan has had comparatively little out-migration, and the Jordanian “state-sponsored expatriate-related institution” (p. 19) that Brand analyzes is simply a series of conferences organized by the government since the 1980s. Tunisia, Lebanon, and Jordan have all used a claim that their wealth lies in human resources to justify cultivating an ongoing relationship with their citizens who have left. In all four of the featured states, the state itself was a relatively new institution (even if aspects of its claim to legitimacy were not new). These new states were preoccupied with building institutions on many fronts and dealing with a variety of challenges such as war, shifting borders, and the question of who could acquire and retain citizenship. The growth of each state's interest in its citizens abroad was part of the broader project of building a postcolonial state in the first place. One of the strengths of this book is the thorough way in which Brand contextualizes state efforts at expatriate outreach within internal state processes and challenges.
Moroccans started leaving for Western Europe in significant numbers in the years before World War II. Although many found employment and acquired citizenship in Europe, the majority remained outside the European social, political, and economic mainstream. Their dissatisfaction gave rise to civil unrest in a number of European cities, such as in Brussels in 1991. The story of Moroccan emigrants to Europe is political and religious in addition to economic and is bound up with ongoing authoritarianism at home and fear of Islamism by many Europeans. Morocco began to pay attention to its emigrants in the context of labor and economic concerns. By 2004, remittances represented 9 percent of the GDP according to the International Monetary Fund (p. 67). Starting in the 1970s, the state expanded its expatriate outreach efforts, setting up “friendship societies,” a Ministry of the Moroccan Community Abroad (from 1989 to 1997), and a foundation concerned with Moroccan residents abroad. Although all three institutions “fell short of reaching their goals” (p. 88), they nevertheless represent important efforts by the state at reckoning with its citizens abroad.
“Given Tunisia's size and resources,” Brand writes, “the extent of the programs and activities it sponsors abroad are impressive” (p. 130). Tunisians began migrating to Europe, especially France, during World War I and continued during the following decades and after independence in 1956. Like Morocco, the Tunisian regime sought to control and repress its citizens both at home and abroad, especially during the Bourguiba years (1957–87). It was also concerned with labor, fearing a brain drain. In a series of development plans beginning in the early 1960s, the state promoted Tunisian labor abroad, encouraged migration to Libya and the Gulf, and advocated for job training in specific professions. Brand shows how the state eventually came to see emigration as favorable as long as emigrants retained ties to home. Recent developments in Tunisian state efforts in Europe include the promotion of Arabic-language lessons and radio and television programming.
Of the four states profiled in the book, Lebanon stands out as the one with the most expatriates and returnees and in which they have played the most significant role. Lebanon has long been spoken of as being “a bird with two wings,” one resident and the other abroad. The preindependence government formed in 1941 included a ministry concerned with foreign affairs and “Interests of the Lebanese Abroad” (p. 126). Although that particular effort was short lived and the ministry's portfolio reduced to exclude emigrants the following year, it was an early effort in a series—some more successful than others—to make expatriate affairs an official concern of the state. Lebanon was set up as a confessionalist state in which the citizen stands before the state as a member of one of numerous sectarian communities with complex interrelations (as opposed to in neighboring states, which are confessionalist in their own way but with fewer recognized categories). As Brand argues at multiple points in the book, confessionalism has been an important factor in the attention paid by the state to Lebanese expatriates.
The young Jordanian state faced unique challenges, the most pressing of which stemmed from its involvement in Palestinian affairs. Jordan both absorbed and disenfranchised Palestinians in the course of various events such as the 1967 war. Palestinians came to constitute a large proportion of its population. Meanwhile, increasing numbers of Jordanian citizens (a large proportion of whom were of Palestinian origin) were migrating to oil-rich Arab states to work in the oil industry. By the 1980s there was growing interest in these expatriates on the part of the Jordanian state, which wished to assert greater sovereignty over them, and on the part of the migrants themselves, who faced challenges such as economic reintegration upon returning from abroad. The government responded by offering three conferences, which represented “a chance for the expatriate delegates to discuss their living and working conditions and to seek assistance” (p. 200). Although Brand focuses on the three conferences that took place in the 1980s, she notes that the government has continued to sponsor more events, such as one in 2001 that focused on expatriate and other business investors.
Citizens Abroad: Emigration and the State in the Middle East and North Africa stands to become a classic. It not only offers a new perspective on the development of independent Middle Eastern and North African states and the attention they paid to their departing citizens, but it also offers a sound starting point for future researchers. Brand's model of analyzing international migration at its point of origin with attention to the state could easily be applied elsewhere. One interesting place to start could be to flip the model on its head and apply it to states whose citizens have migrated into the Middle East and North Africa in large numbers, such as Sri Lanka and India and several states in sub-Saharan Africa.
