Bruce McConachie's Theatre& Mind is the latest title from Palgrave Macmillan's Theatre & series to be reviewed in these pages, following Jill Dolan's Theatre & Sexuality and Erin Hurley's Theatre & Feeling. (Fintan Walsh's Theatre & Therapy is reviewed below.) According to series editors Jen Harvie and Dan Rebellato, this book is intended as a general introduction, “readable in one sitting by anyone with a curiosity about the subject” (viii). Happily, although scholarship on cognition in performance is often notoriously opaque, Theatre & Mind is remarkably accessible, and successfully introduces dominant theoretical frameworks from within the field, cogently applying them to the subjects of playing, training, acting, and spectating.
The first of three parts in this book identifies “Playing” as a prototype for sophisticated, structured forms of performance. Play is evolutionarily adaptive, improving our behavioral flexibility, letting us try out new skills at low risk, and encouraging us to identify relevant patterns in the environment. Moreover, it is a form of sociality that allows us to explore interpersonal dynamics, described here as being informed by our embodied emotions and empathic perceptions. Fauconnier and Turner's conceptual blending theory (CBT, also referred to as conceptual integration) is introduced as a unifying framework for these social processes, and is a major touchstone for Theatre & Mind as a whole. McConachie cites Edelman and Tononi in proposing that humans are uniquely capable of both developing concepts about the world and selectively integrating features of these concepts via blending. This allows us to create novel or even hypothetical blends, which might be fluidly renegotiated over time. According to CBT, children and actors selectively integrate concepts about themselves and concepts about the roles they are performing into a coherent performance; spectators do much the same, combining selected content about the actor with conceptual knowledge of the character (23).
CBT helpfully recognizes the complexity of attentive thought during both acting and spectating, substituting the fluidic metaphor of a dynamic blend for binary participation in Coleridge's “willing suspension of disbelief” (52); however, McConachie never articulates the empirical findings or neurological structures underpinning CBT, instead referring to his book's bibliography those who care to follow up on these issues. This has the unfortunate consequence of reducing CBT in Theatre & Mind to a descriptive analogy rather than a reliably “scientific” explanatory framework. Without further detail on how blending is cognitively structured or managed, readers new to the concept may lose sight of its instrumentality, so that “CBT” becomes a catchall for any kind of mental integration at any level of consciousness—a broad theory about how minds work that explains everything and nothing.
Omissions of this sort likely reflect the author's desire to reach a general audience (7), but they become problematic in light of his own stance against unfettered epistemologies. McConachie lionizes the principle of falsifiability in scientific method, relegating other branches of theory to secondary status when he claims, “testable explanations concerning the material world are better than ones that cannot be tested” (5). Nevertheless, he mostly draws upon other cognitive theorists instead of primary source material, asking his readers to place their faith in others' interpretations of falsifiable data rather than in the data itself. He also dismisses current disagreements with these particular theories as ignorable, taking place at the minute “level of interpretive synthesis” (7), which seems at odds with his call for continued revisions. By failing to acknowledge the interpretive labor performed by theorists like Fauconnier and Turner, it is unclear how McConachie might provide readers with an accurate appreciation of their authority. Skeptics of cognitive studies in theatre may therefore stumble on its rhetoric, mistaking McConachie's inquiry as a parasitic form of restatement.
On the other hand, Theatre & Mind proves conspicuously empowering through measured approaches to research application. Its second part, “Acting,” guides the reader through various approaches to actor training in the twentieth century, using cognitive data to reinterpret selected practices from Stanislavsky, Chekhov, and Lecoq. These applications are diverse, sometimes appearing as factoids about phenomena such as the use of hand gesture during speech (37), but they are characteristically insightful, illuminating both science and practice. Cultural scholars may be especially excited by intersections opened up in McConachie's introduction to corporeal elements of meaning (36), and his reconstructive account for memory (47).
McConachie also establishes an exciting conversation across pedagogies, implicitly gesturing toward a viable set of common principles for expressive embodiment. In particular, his sensorimotor account of emotional embodiment convincingly argues that “working up emotions through imitation or through memory is not really an either/or proposition in terms of our mindful bodies. Both techniques involve animating an emotional response through the sensorimotor system; one method is simply more direct than the other” (44). Such analyses demonstrate the usefulness of McConachie's work for artists and scholars alike.
The book's concluding part on “Spectating” builds upon McConachie's earlier accounts of attention, blending, and empathic understanding in audience experience, further noting the effects of emotional contagion and rhythmic entrainment (68), while gesturing toward an expansion of the performance milieu from theatre spaces to our networked culture at large (70). His analysis of Tony Kushner's Angels in America falls a little flat, seeming mostly speculative about how a generic audience member might react to circumstances suggested by the written text; however, his work is effectively recuperated through allusions to live performance in diverse productions of Hamlet. This foregrounds the immediacy and idiosyncrasy of those embodied responses that have been his chief concern thus far.
Theatre & Mind concentrates on character-driven performances of text-based work, so students of devising and postdramatic theatre may need to sift through it for gems relevant to their own interests. Still, this book represents precisely the sort of “pugnacious” scholarship that is promised by its editors (viii). It may not woo anybody already skeptical of its methods, but even critics are likely to find its subject matter both vital and compelling, and to recognize the sophistication of the ideas underlying McConachie's accessible prose. Theatre & Mind will serve as a valuable stepping-stone for newcomers to cognitive studies in performance, and a handy reference for general readers as well.
