This is a helpful book, especially for evangelicals and those who interact with them. Its purpose is ‘to bring an evangelical doctrine of Scripture into conversation with the implications generated by some important themes in modern biblical scholarship – particularly Old Testament scholarship’ (p. 13). The author recognises that many conservative Christians affirm the Bible as God's word but then face profound difficulty reconciling this affirmation with the implications of biblical criticism. This work addresses the difficulty in a way that is both sympathetic and challenging to evangelicals. Written for a popular audience, it seeks to reframe the nature of debates regarding the inspiration of scripture. The author writes, ‘The problems many of us feel regarding the Bible may have less to do with the Bible itself and more to do with our own preconceptions’ (p. 15). Calling its audience away from such preconceptions, the book offers the image of the incarnation as a way of understanding biblical inspiration: ‘as Christ is both God and human, so is the Bible’ (p. 17). In addition to the introduction and conclusion, the book has three chapters, which each address an issue that is problematic for many evangelicals. The second chapter examines whether the Old Testament is unique, given its parallels with ancient Near Eastern literature. The third analyses how one can affirm the unity of the Old Testament when it displays a great deal of theological diversity. The fourth explores whether New Testament writers misuse the Old Testament, for example by ignoring original context.
All three chapters follow a similar format. First, they show how biblical and extra-biblical evidence presents perplexing questions for evangelicals. Next, the chapters examine which presuppositions make this evidence problematic. Finally, they conclude that such presuppositions need to be re-evaluated given the incarnational quality of scripture, which allows one to view evidence with greater honesty while still maintaining a high view of the Bible. The second chapter, for example, examines an array of ancient Near Eastern writings that have obvious points of continuity with the Bible (e.g., Enuma Elish). Then, the chapter examines the problems created by such parallels, such as whether the Bible can be affirmed as special revelation when it shares so much in common with other ancient Near Eastern material. It then calls into question the chief assumption behind such problems, namely that divine revelation entails uniqueness from culture. Appealing to the ‘incarnational analogy’, the chapter argues that as Christ was located within the culture of first-century Palestine, so the Old Testament is situated in its own culture. Thus, one should expect the Old Testament to answer the questions of its time, not those posed by modern, Western assumptions. The chapter concludes that Christians affirm the Bible as God's word ‘not because we can make sense of it all but despite our inability to do so at times’ (p. 66). Similar arguments are made with respect to theological diversity (e.g., the Old Testament displays considerable diversity because the divine word, like Christ, is revealed in the particularities of history) and the New Testament use of the Old Testament (e.g., one should not expect New Testament writers to use modern standards of interpretation; they used the hermeneutical principles and traditions of their time, just as Christ used many conventions of his time).
This work addresses an important problem. Many evangelicals feel torn between the scripture that has profoundly influenced their lives and the findings of scholarship that seem to challenge their high view of the Bible. This book skilfully speaks to its audience, reflecting a thorough knowledge of how evangelicals think and the matters that concern them deeply. Though it often lacks originality, it does synthesise a great deal of material with clarity. The author makes the findings of biblical scholarship accessible to his popular audience, including a glossary and annotated bibliographies for further explanation and study. Although many evangelicals will have disagreements with Enns's claims, he is a thoughtful conversation partner. This work, moreover, is helpful not only for evangelicals but also for teachers of the Bible, who frequently receive questions that Enns directly addresses.
This work, however, has several key omissions. First, it lacks a detailed discussion of how the analogy between Christ's incarnation and the Bible both works and breaks down. For Enns, ‘the incarnational analogy’ means primarily that the Bible is connected to its environment, just as Christ was connected to his. What else does it mean to think of the Bible as fully human and fully divine? Are there cases where the analogy breaks down? Though Enns makes occasional attempts to address such questions (pp. 19–21, 168), readers are left uncertain about the extent of the connections between Christ's incarnation and the Bible. Another omission is the lack of attention to other issues in biblical scholarship that trouble evangelicals. This work does not adequately discuss the discontinuity between archaeological findings and biblical accounts of the exodus and conquest. There is, moreover, little discussion of Old Testament authorship (e.g., Isa 40–66), which some evangelicals tie to issues of inspiration. Furthermore, this work does not address texts of the Old Testament that are notoriously difficult to reconcile with a high view of scripture, such as those that appear to condone genocide or misogyny. Enns's work does not set out to answer such questions, but one hopes that the author would address these problems in a future volume. The clarity, sensitivity and accessibility displayed in this book would be welcome in further studies.
