In National Federation of Independent Business vs Sebelius, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld most provisions of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA). Some commentators predicted that the Court might overturn the law's minimum essential coverage provision, known as the “individual mandate” (Tau, Reference Tau2012). This provision requires most people to purchase a minimum level of health insurance for themselves and their dependents starting in 2014. The fact that the individual mandate survived was not nearly as surprising as how and why the law was upheld.
Before the Court announced its decision on 28 June 2012, there was speculation that Chief Justice Roberts might join a majority upholding the law for the purpose of writing the opinion and limiting the ability of the federal government to expand its powers either under the Commerce Clause or Necessary and Proper Clause of the Constitution. This scenario, however, assumed that Justice Kennedy would join with the Court's more liberal members in upholding the law under the Commerce Clause. Instead, Justice Kennedy joined with Justices Alito, Scalia and Thomas and found that the ACA was unconstitutional and argued that the entire law, not just the mandate, should be struck down. It was surprising to many that Chief Justice Roberts did not join the other conservative Justices and strike down the entire law.
In this essay, I review the history of Court decisions regarding the Commerce Clause and social policy, speculate about the reasons Chief Justice Roberts joined with Justices Breyer, Kagan, Ginsburg and Sotomayor to uphold most of the law, and comment on the implications of this decision for health policy in the United States. I argue that Roberts may have been trying to both uphold the integrity of the Court as a non-partisan legal institution while simultaneously working to curtail the reach of the federal government under the Constitution. The Court has not invalidated a law as broad and significant as the ACA since before 1937. Following closely in the wake of the Bush vs Gore [531 U.S. 98 (2000)] and Citizens United vs Federal Election Commission [558 U.S. 310 (2010)] decisions, ruling to strike down the ACA may have undermined the Court's credibility with the American public. A poll taken just before the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) decision found that only 44% of Americans approved the Court's performance and “just one in eight Americans said the justices decided cases based only on legal analysis” (Liptak and Kopicki, Reference Liptak and Kopicki2012).
There is disagreement among scholars about whether interpretation of the Commerce Clause offered by the majority of the Court in NFIB vs Sebelius will significantly limit the power of the federal government in the future. Congress has rarely used the Commerce Clause to compel activity, so this restriction may turn out to be unimportant. The probability that states will fail to accept federal funding for the Medicaid expansion, even though the ruling gave them the option to do so, also seems remote. But it seems clear that the NFIB vs Sebelius decision is part of a trend by conservative Justices and legal scholars to push back against the expansion of federal power over individuals and states.
Still fighting the new deal: American conservatives and the commerce clause
Opponents argued that the ACA's use of an individual mandate was an unwarranted expansion of federal authority under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution (Article 1, Section 8). This claim was somewhat ironic because the idea of an individual mandate originated at the conservative Heritage Foundation in 1989 and was championed by Republican leaders before it was adopted by President Obama and the Democrats in 2008. Senator John Chaffee (R-RI), along with 18 co-sponsors introduced a bill (Health Equity and Access Reform Today Act) calling for an individual mandate in 1993. Although Governor Mitt Romney now argues that he is only in favor of an individual mandate if enacted by a state government, in 2009 he expressed support for the Wyden–Bennett bill, which called for an individual mandate by the federal government (Klein, Reference Klein2012).
Republican opposition to an individual mandate to purchase health insurance is relatively new, but the argument that the commerce clause should not be used to justify expanding the power of the federal government has been on the agenda of conservatives for years. When the administration of Franklin Roosevelt tried to expand the role of the federal government in the 1930s, the Court struck down several ‘New Deal’ laws as unconstitutional. In 1937, after President Roosevelt had threatened to ‘pack’ the Court and expand the number of justices from 9 to 15, the Court adopted a more expansive interpretation of the commerce clause. In NLRB vs Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp., the Court argued that the federal government could regulate activity if it had a ‘substantial economic effect’ on interstate commerce or if the ‘cumulative effect’ of an activity would have a substantial economic effect on interstate commerce [301 U.S. 1 (1937)]. In Wickard vs Filburn [317 U.S. 111 (1942)] the Court expanded the Commerce Clause again by finding that the federal government could regulate the amount of wheat grown on an individual farm, even though the wheat was intended for consumption by the farmer. The Court found that, because this decision could affect the price of wheat and have a substantial impact on interstate commerce, the federal government had the constitutional authority to regulate it. Based on these precedents, subsequent decisions relied on the Commerce Clause to justify a host of federal government laws, including the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibited segregation. The legal authority for a modern federal welfare state depends, to a large degree, on a broad interpretation of the Commerce Clause.
In 1995, with Lopez vs United States [514 U.S. 549 (1995)] the Court placed limits on the use of the Commerce Clause. The federal government argued that, because carrying a firearm in a school zone would lead to violent crime it would affect economic conditions and, as a result, the federal government had the power to regulate firearms in schools zones under the Commerce Clause. Chief Justice Rehnquist rejected this argument and claimed that it would force the Court to conclude “that there never will be a distinction between what is truly national and what is truly local”. Similarly, Morrison vs United States [529 U.S. 598 (2000)] overturned the Violence Against Women Act because it relied on the Commerce Clause to make domestic violence against women a federal crime.
The debate over the ACA's individual mandate was a continuation of efforts by conservatives to limit, if not roll back, the use of the Commerce Clause to expand the federal welfare state. In NFIB vs Sebelius, the government argued that, because everyone will need health care at some point in their lives, the mandate regulates an activity that will affect interstate commerce. The government also argued that the mandate was authorized by the Necessary and Proper Clause and the power of Congress to “to lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defense and general Welfare of the United States” (Article 1, Section 8).
Opponents, including the Court's more conservative Justices, argued that allowing a federal mandate requiring individuals to purchase health insurance would also allow the federal government to force Americans to buy anything they wanted, including broccoli. During oral argument, Justice Kennedy summarized the case against the individual mandate when he said: “Here the government is saying that the federal government has a duty to tell the individual citizen that it must act, and that is different from what we have in previous cases and that changes the relationship of the federal government to the individual in a very fundamental way”. The claim that the health insurance market was different than the market for broccoli or many other goods was barely given consideration by the opposing Justices.
The Roberts decision
When the Court's decision was announced on 28 June 2012, liberals celebrated the decision to uphold the ACA. Nested within this ‘victory’, however, were two arguments from the Chief Justice designed to undermine liberal arguments for expanding federal authority to address a range of social and economic problems. In particular, Chief Justice Roberts sided with the other conservative Justices on the Court and rejected the Commerce Clause argument for the individual mandate. According to Roberts, “The individual mandate… does not regulate existing commercial activity. It instead compels individuals to become active in commerce by purchasing a product, on the ground that their failure to do so affects interstate commerce. Construing the Commerce Clause to permit Congress to regulate individuals precisely because they are doing nothing would open a new and potentially vast domain to congressional authority”. Instead, Roberts argued that the congressional power to tax, rather than the Commerce Clause, allowed the federal government to require the mandate.
The use of the tax power argument was surprising to some. The government had invoked the tax power in its arguments and the case for upholding the law under the tax power was supported in amicus curiae briefs (Metzger et al., Reference Metzger, Morrison and Pincus2012), but none of the lower Courts had upheld the law on this basis. The claim that the federal government cannot force the states to expand the Medicaid by threatening them with cuts to Medicaid matching funds was even more unexpected. There is a long history of the federal government making funding for programs conditional on changes in state law. The adoption of state seatbelt and minimum drinking age laws, for example, happened after the federal government threatened to withhold federal interstate highway funds. Roberts justified this decision by arguing that the Medicaid expansion was really the creating of a new program. It was too coercive, in his view, for the federal government to threaten funding for the original Medicaid program in order to pressure the states to adopt this ‘new’ Medicaid program.
Preserving the court's integrity?
Why did Roberts write this unexpected opinion, particularly the decision to uphold the individual mandate as a tax while agreeing with the conservative justices that the Commerce Clause does not allow it? We may never know why the Chief Justice made this decision, but there is a strong case to be made that this was motivated by his desire to protect the Court against charges of partisanship. After the Bush vs Gore and Citizens United decisions, public confidence in the integrity of the Court suffered (Nicholson and Howard, Reference Nicholson and Howard2003; Liptak, Reference Liptak and Kopicki2012). The concern was that people might conclude that the Court is now as partisan and polarized as every other aspect of U.S. government and politics. In addition to the fact that the Court is usually reluctant to overturn major legislation, overturning the ACA would have been part of a pattern of decisions since Bush vs Gore in 2000 in which the Court adopted positions that were hostile to the political positions of Democrats. Whether the decisions were motivated by partisanship or not, the Democrats would have leveled this charge and it may have stuck (Cohn, Reference Cohn2012).
The idea that Roberts may have been motivated to protect the integrity of the Court is consistent with studies that examine the relationship between the Court and public opinion. In both salient and non-salient cases, the Supreme Court is constrained by public opinion (Klarman, Reference Klarman2004; Casillas et al., Reference Casillas, Enns and Wohlfarth2011). When a Supreme Court decision runs afoul of public opinion, particularly in highly salient cases, support for the Court declines (Durr et al., Reference Durr, Martin and Wolbrecht2000). Health reform was a key issue during the 2008 presidential election, the call for repealing ‘Obamacare’ was central to the Republican and ‘Tea Party’ strategy during the 2010 mid-term election, and was central to the 2012 presidential electoral campaigns as the Supreme Court was making its decision on NFIB vs Sebelius. It is hard to imagine a more salient or more partisan issue than the future of the ACA. By upholding the law based on the tax power while rejecting the Commerce Clause argument, Chief Justice Roberts managed to keep the Court out of a politically contentious fight while supporting conservative efforts to attack the expansion of the Commerce Clause that began during the Rehnquist Court and the Lopez decision.
What are the consequences for health policy in the near and longer-term?
While the fate of the ACA still rests on the 2012 and 2014 elections, the Court's decision made the probability of eliminating the law more difficult. Even the Medicaid decision, which makes it more difficult for the federal government to require state action, is not likely to impact the implementation of the ACA. The Court ruled that the federal government may not take away all federal Medicaid funds if states refuse to participate in the ACA expansion of Medicaid. Threatening states with federal Medicaid funds, according to Chief Justice Roberts, would have put “a gun to the head” of states and was an unconstitutional exercise of federal government authority. Some states, including Colorado, Florida, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Texas, are threatening to maintain their existing Medicaid eligibility levels after 2014. But few states are likely to walk away from that much federal money. They will be under enormous pressure from powerful constituents to accept it (e.g. hospitals, nursing homes, county and city governments).
If a state decides not to expand its Medicaid program, as called for by the ACA, it would have to reject hundreds of millions of federal dollars. If some states refuse to participate in the Medicaid expansion, this would limit the number of low income people who receive health insurance coverage under the ACA and place greater pressure on that state's health care safety net. In Texas, for example, state law requires hospitals to provide a minimum level of charity care, so the failure to expand Medicaid would place significant burdens on safety-net hospitals that provide a disproportionate share of care to the uninsured. Furthermore, since many states will move forward with the Medicaid expansion anyway, the eligibility levels for adults on the Medicaid program could be even more uneven from state-to-state than they are today.
Beyond the implementation of Medicaid expansion, the claim that the federal government is limited in its ability to coerce state action by withholding federal funds, coupled with the rejection of the Commerce Clause argument in favor of the individual mandate, may have important longer-term implications for health and social policy. Roberts may have been motivated to protect the Court by upholding this legislation, but nested in his decision were these two important efforts to limit the scope of the federal government. The decision included a narrow reading of the Commerce Clause designed to support the long-standing effort by conservatives to roll back the legal foundation of the major federal health and social policies since the 1930s. Some argue that, because the Court's arguments about the Commerce Clause and the ACA rested on the distinction between activity and inactivity, it will have little relevance to most efforts to justify federal action under the Commerce Clause. Because the conservative Justices on the Court have little regard for accepted interpretations of the Commerce Clause, it seems unlikely that the NFIB ruling will be the last time the Roberts Court will attempt to limit the role of the federal government in health care.
