Princeton University Press categorize this is one of their ‘trade books’, anticipating a broader audience for Hoskin's telling of the Herschel story than his usual narrowly academic one. Hoskin has clearly tried to accommodate this in his writing style. The tone is much chattier than his previous books, the goodness and badness of characters exaggerated, presumably for dramatic effect, and there is, in the introduction, an endearing glimmer of personal detail. ‘Some colleagues of mine’, he tells his reader,
have devoted their lives to Isaac Newton and have ended up loathing him as a person and regretting the time spent in his company. By contrast, the Herschels are lovely people, and it has been a privilege to become an invisible member of their family. I hope that when you finish this book, you will feel the same (p. x).
The story that follows is told, more or less, in chronological order, and although lightly footnoted nevertheless gives the sense of having been drawn from a lifetime of research. Not only is all Hoskin's work on the Herschels included, but also interwoven, and giving the Herschels' work some context, are stories taken from his other researches into the wider history of astronomy.
In the prologue Hoskin introduces his characters, then in Chapters 1 to 3 we see William grow up in Hanover, move to England, work as a musician in Bath and finally become an astronomer. Caroline is in there too, though never as much as her brother. Most of the material here comes from Hoskin's previous books, though there are also some new details hinting at William's marketing skills, as seen through the pages of the Leedes Intelligencer and the Bath Chronicle.
In Chapter 4 the book really comes into its own. Hoskin gives a wonderful account of the sense of frustration and uncertainty the Herschels experienced in the period of waiting between William's discovery of the planet Uranus in March 1781 and finally gaining a king's pension in July 1782. He then goes on in Chapters 5, 6 and 7 to explain William's work in some detail and how each part of it came about, giving a sense too of how this fit into a broader history of astronomy. Much of this is written as though William's later success was inevitable, and there are several leading sentences suggesting that certain events were a sign of things to come, but this is what it is often assumed a mass audience will need to keep them reading.
All the major, well-documented incidents are present. In Chapter 7, the Herschels build their forty-foot telescope; in Chapter 8, William gets married while Caroline discovers her first comet and then goes on to discover more in Chapter 9. In Chapter 10, Hoskin returns to William's work, giving a lucid and revealing account of the circumstances that brought about his work on the structure of the Sun and on radiant heat (or infrared), and his coining of the term ‘asteroid’.
In Chapter 11, Hoskin moves his attention to John, beginning with a quick summary of his upbringing, and an aside on Caroline's departure from the family home. He talks about William's slowing down before moving on to William's request that John join him in his astronomical surveys. In Chapter 12, following William's death, we see Caroline move to Hanover while John, with Caroline's help, checks William's existing catalogues and then takes his family to South Africa to complete the catalogue for the southern hemisphere. The story is then neatly wrapped up in Chapter 13. John finishes his survey, takes his eldest son William James to meet Caroline in Hanover and, a few years later, sends Caroline the published catalogue which he describes as the ‘completion of my father's work’ (p. 203). A few months later Caroline dies and is buried in the family vault.
Hoskin displays more empathy for his subjects in this book than in his other more scholarly work, and this works well when he talks about William and his career. William's period of uncertainty following the discovery of Uranus, the evolution of his research programme, and his gradual slowing down in old age are all beautifully and sympathetically told. However, the Herschel women do not come out so well in Hoskin's biography. Anna, William and Caroline's mother, described at one point as ‘her heartless mother’ (p. 17) is vilified, as she is in all Hoskin's work, for insisting that Caroline learn and help with time-consuming and necessary domestic tasks. Mary, William's future wife, is introduced only to explain where the family's money came from after 1788, while Caroline is portrayed as a woman entirely lacking in initiative or the ability to make good decisions. Every piece of work she pursued, Hoskin claims, was initiated or suggested by William, while her refusal of independent work as a singer and her decision to move to Hanover after William died are both presented by Hoskin as indisputably regrettable decisions. The problem here is that Hoskin often takes Caroline too literally at her word, never questioning her exaggerated statements of self-deprecation or putting them in a historical context.
The book shows an extraordinary volume of research, but then Hoskin has been researching and writing about the Herschels for nearly half a century. Where it is strongest is on his effortless explanations of William's developing research projects once he became an astronomer. His comprehensive and sympathetic treatment of William means that it could plausibly come to rival Constance Lubbock's The Herschel Chronicles (1933) as the standard introductory text to the Herschels, or at least to William. In Hoskin's account William and to some extent Caroline do, after all, come across as ‘lovely people’.
