Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:15:34.314Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Exploiting self-organized criticality in strongly stratified turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 December 2021

Gregory P. Chini*
Affiliation:
Program in Integrated Applied Mathematics, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH 03824, USADepartment of Mechanical Engineering, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH 03824, USA
Guillaume Michel
Affiliation:
Institut Jean Le Rond d'Alembert, Sorbonne Université, CNRS, UMR 7190, Paris F-75005, France
Keith Julien
Affiliation:
Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80309, USA
Cesar B. Rocha
Affiliation:
Department of Marine Sciences, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269, USA
Colm-cille P. Caulfield
Affiliation:
BP Institute, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 0EZ, UKDepartment of Applied Mathematics & Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Cambrdge CB3 0WA, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: greg.chini@unh.edu

Abstract

A multiscale reduced description of turbulent free shear flows in the presence of strong stabilizing density stratification is derived via asymptotic analysis of the Boussinesq equations in the simultaneous limits of small Froude and large Reynolds numbers. The analysis explicitly recognizes the occurrence of dynamics on disparate spatiotemporal scales, yielding simplified partial differential equations governing the coupled evolution of slow large-scale hydrostatic flows and fast small-scale isotropic instabilities and internal waves. The dynamics captured by the coupled reduced equations is illustrated in the context of two-dimensional strongly stratified Kolmogorov flow. A noteworthy feature of the reduced model is that the fluctuations are constrained to satisfy quasilinear (QL) dynamics about the comparably slowly varying large-scale fields. Crucially, this QL reduction is not invoked as an ad hoc closure approximation, but rather is derived in a physically relevant and mathematically consistent distinguished limit. Further analysis of the resulting slow–fast QL system shows how the amplitude of the fast stratified-shear instabilities is slaved to the slowly evolving mean fields to ensure the marginal stability of the latter. Physically, this marginal stability condition appears to be compatible with recent evidence of self-organized criticality in both observations and simulations of stratified turbulence. Algorithmically, the slaving of the fluctuation fields enables numerical simulations to be time-evolved strictly on the slow time scale of the hydrostatic flow. The reduced equations thus provide a solid mathematical foundation for future studies of three-dimensional strongly stratified turbulence in extreme parameter regimes of geophysical relevance and suggest avenues for new sub-grid-scale parametrizations.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Physical attributes and parameter regime characterizing stratified turbulence. (a) Snapshot of the vorticity field in a freely decaying two-dimensional (2-D) DNS of the Boussinesq equations (in a doubly periodic horizontal/vertical domain) for $Pr=1$, $Fr=0.02$ and $Re=5\times 10^{5}$ after 30 buoyancy time units $2{\rm \pi} /N$ (i.e. $t_N=30$), where $N$ is the constant buoyancy frequency, initialized with a random vorticity field having a von-Kármán-like spectrum. Note the emergence of highly anisotropic layers, with horizontal scales $L$ much greater than their vertical thickness $h$, coexisting with small-scale, roughly isotropic variability suggestive of Kelvin–Helmholtz overturns. (b) Regime diagram adapted from Brethouwer et al. (2007). The 2-D DNSs and reduced multiscale simulations performed in the present work lie along the purple solid line, and typical values for the upper ocean and middle atmosphere are taken from Moum (1996) and Lindborg (2006). DNSs published during the past six years are also reported: ‘HT20’ (Howland, Taylor & Caulfield 2020); ‘BR19’ (de Bruyn Kops & Riley 2019); ‘LW19’ (Lang & Waite 2019); ‘PB19’ (Portwood, de Bruyn Kops & Caulfield 2019); ‘M19’ (Maffioli 2019); ‘K18’ (Khani 2018); ‘GV18’ (Garanaik & Venayagamoorthy 2018); ‘FM18’ (Feraco et al.2018); ‘LC17’ (Lucas & Caulfield 2017); ‘M17’ (Maffioli 2017); ‘PB16’ (Portwood et al.2016); ‘MB16’ (Maffioli, Brethouwer & Lindborg 2016); ‘MD16’ (Maffioli & Davidson 2016); ‘AB15’ (Augier, Billant & Chomaz 2015). Note that there is slight variability in the precise definitions of both $Fr$ and $Re$ for certain data collected in this regime diagram and that there are not sharp transitions among the various regimes.

Figure 1

Figure 2.DNS, STQL and MTQL simulations of stratified Kolmogorov flow forced from a randomly perturbed rest state with $Re_b = 1$ and $Fr=0.02$. (a) Total energy of the flow as a function of time. For the MTQL simulation, $\sigma _r$ also is plotted. (b) Maximum fluctuation growth rate $\sigma _r$ as a function of $k$ shown for three different times during the MTQL simulation. Note the saturation of $\sigma _r$ to zero at wavenumbers $k\simeq 2.5$ and the presence of weakly amplified oscillatory modes (ignored in this study), with non-zero $\sigma _i$, at small $k$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Comparison of the steady ECSs computed in stratified Kolmogorov flow for $Re_b = 1$ and $Fr=0.02$ using DNS (a), MTQL (b) and STQL (c) algorithms. The total buoyancy field (including the imposed linear profile) is shown in colour, while arrows are used to depict the isotropically scaled velocity field in each case. To accentuate differences between the QL results and DNS, the total buoyancy contours $z+\bar {b}=\pm 0.5$ are highlighted (dashed curves).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Convergence of the steady ECSs computed at $Re_b=1$ using the asymptotically reduced system (3.1)–(3.4) to the corresponding steady solution of the full 2-D Boussinesq equations in the limit $Fr \rightarrow 0$. The red symbols show the relative error computed using the total fluctuation energy obtained from the DNS (the sum of the energy in each non-zero horizontal Fourier mode), i.e. $r_{k>0}=|E_{k>0}^{{{DNS}}}-E_{k>0}^{{{MTQL}}}|/E_{k>0}^{{{DNS}}}$. The blue symbols show the relative error evaluated using the fluctuation energy only in the Fourier mode with the fundamental wavenumber $k$, again as obtained from the DNS, $r_{k}=|E_{k}^{{{DNS}}}-E_{k}^{{{MTQL}}}|/E_{k}^{{{DNS}}}$. For reference, the solid green line has a slope equal to $Fr^{1}$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Comparison of steady ECSs in stratified Kolmogorov flow for $Fr=0.01$ and $Re_b = 1$ (a) and ${Re_b=10}$ (b) computed using the MTQL algorithm. The total buoyancy field (including the imposed linear profile) is shown in colour, while the arrows are used to depict the isotropically scaled velocity field in each case.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Steady-state mean vertical profiles of buoyancy (a) and horizontal velocity (b) computed using the MTQL algorithm for $Fr=0.01$ and $Re_b=1$ (blue) and $Re_b=10$ (red). The dashed lines correspond to the unstable laminar state, with velocity profile $\bar {u}_L=\cos 3z$ and buoyancy perturbation $\bar {b}=0$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Mean quantities computed from the steady-state ECSs obtained at $Fr=0.01$ as a function of $Re_b$: (a) skewnesses $\bar {S}$; (b) flux Richardson number $Ri_F$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Maximum fluctuation-field growth rate as a function of $k$ for the steady ECSs computed at ${Fr=0.01}$ and $Re_b=1$ (blue) and $Re_b=10$ (red). The inset shows the positive growth rates that arise for small $k$; comparing with figure 2(b) confirms that these low-wavenumber modes are viscous instabilities that vanish as $Re_b\to \infty$.

Chini et al. supplementary movie

MTQL simulation of strongly stratified Kolmogorov flow.

Download Chini et al. supplementary movie(Video)
Video 20.9 MB
Supplementary material: File

Chini et al. supplementary material

Python codes

Download Chini et al. supplementary material(File)
File 8.2 KB