Given the rhythms of American politics, it may be that there is never a bad time to publish a book on the presidency. From the ever-expanding primary “season” to the “perpetual campaign,” the president is rarely far from either the headlines or the television screen. Even so, Stephen Knott's newest book, The Lost Soul of the American Presidency, arrives at a distinctly opportune time, one seemingly tailor-made to illustrate the argument he advances. Knott's central claim is that presidential history is a story of decline and degradation. As he writes in the introduction, “this book focuses on the contrast between the constitutional or framers’ presidency versus the Jacksonian or populist, later progressive, presidency” (xiv). The passage from the former to the latter constitutes no less than a refounding, one whose negative consequences seem only to be compounded with the passage of time (xv, 144, 225–30).
The book begins by contrasting the “founders’ presidency” (chap. 1) with “the presidency of popular consent” (chap. 2). The founders’ presidency, Knott argues, was concerned principally with checking the excesses of majority rule. The presidency designed in Philadelphia reflected how committed the framers were “to the rule of law, to deliberation and reflection, and how skeptical they were of political figures and political movements promoting radical change” (15). This theory of the presidency was rooted in a sober assessment of human nature and its consequences for good governance. Prone to err, whether because of the demagogue's flattery or because of passion that overwhelms reason, the desires and opinions of the people needed to be refined, cooled, and at times resisted. While these goals could be partially achieved by an extended republic with adequate representation in a properly constructed Congress—topics about which Knott says relatively little—republican governance required a further safeguard. Defined by institutional unity, endowed with a partial check on legislative enactments, and with its selection mediated by the Electoral College, the founders’ presidency could resist majoritarian excesses for the sake of reflection and deliberation. This model was best exemplified by George Washington, with the critical guidance and exposition of Alexander Hamilton. Presidents who followed in this tradition include John and John Quincy Adams, Lincoln, Grant, Taft, Eisenhower, Ford, and Bush I.
The decline Knott traces is neither slow nor subtle. The model cast by Washington and Hamilton was quickly displaced by “a new type of president who considered the source of his power to be popular consent rather than the Constitution” (26). Forged by Thomas Jefferson, the populist presidency embraced “popular opinion as the ultimate source of presidential, and constitutional, legitimacy” (30). With this commitment to popular will and majority rule came a corresponding danger: majority tyranny. A recurring theme in Knott's account of the populist presidency is the threat posed by majoritarianism to the rights and interests of minorities, be they racial or economic. As Knott puts it, “Unpopular minorities bear the brunt of the populist presidency” (57). While Jefferson is the pivotal president in Knott's history, the period connecting Jefferson to Jackson (1801–1837) is the decisive era for the transition from the constitutional to the populist presidency. These years featured the defining characteristics and contrasts of the new presidency: “demagoguery, personality-based politics, populist flattery, presidential promotion of conspiracy theories, along with race-baiting and mob violence” (73).
The first two chapters supply both the historical foundation and the conceptual taproot for the following eight. The book proceeds chronologically, moving briskly through chapters devoted to Jackson, Lincoln, Wilson, FDR and Truman, and Eisenhower and Kennedy. The pace then quickens, with a single chapter addressing the presidencies of Lyndon Johnson through Barack Obama. We then arrive at the penultimate chapter, “The Apotheosis of the Popular Presidency: Donald J. Trump.” The book ends with a brief but well-executed conclusion that considers the prospects for renewal, which, it becomes clear, are far from promising.
Knott's book is highly readable without sacrificing clarity or insight. It would serve well as a synoptic account of presidential history for both nonspecialists and advanced undergraduate courses; by themselves, the first two chapters provide a wonderful entry point into fundamental questions of American constitutionalism. The Lost Soul of the American President could also be read profitably alongside canonical modern works on the presidency, of interest for how it both redeploys and reconfigures their narratives. While one might quibble with some particulars of Knott's narrative—the near absence of Theodore Roosevelt or the three pages dedicated to the Obama presidency, for example—the more important question is how those choices, taken together, contribute to the persuasiveness of the argument as a whole. It is in this broader compass that one of the book's conceptual cornerstones warrants closer scrutiny.
Public opinion is perhaps the principal driver of the populist presidency that, in Knott's telling, displaced the constitutional presidency. Indeed, it is the leitmotif of the presidency of popular consent. But it is not the case that the concept of public opinion started its American sojourn as “the voice of God,” as Mark Twain famously described it in 1901. Rather, Twain's provocative description captures a significant historical development: as Mark Schmeller observes in Invisible Sovereign (Johns Hopkins University Press, 2016), the understanding of public opinion itself evolved significantly in the early years of the republic, shifting from a basis in political institutions to “something emanating from outside the political sphere” (4).
One implication of this is that many early presidential appeals to public opinion were, in fact, political-constitutional arguments and not overtly anticonstitutional ploys. In this way, they reaffirmed a central commitment of the founders, that public opinion needed to be shaped and refined by political institutions. To do so, these presidents contrived ways of manifesting public opinion. Thus, where Knott's populist presidents diverged, at least early on, was in the belief that the president could adequately make public opinion safe for a constitutional republic. We see this in the numerous episodes Knott recounts of presidents attempting to mold public opinion in their favor, whether that be Jackson's reliance on both censorship and sympathetic newspapers (61–62), Wilson's creation of the Committee on Public Information (123–25), or Trump's symbiotic relationship with Fox News (208).
All of this suggests that public opinion was a moving target, itself a site of political contestation and conceptual change. Locating presidential rhetoric and leadership within this shifting landscape would produce a richer account of political development. For one thing, it would reveal that presidential appeals to public opinion are both principled and polemical—they simultaneously adduce and construct a source of authority. Doing so would also allow us to see more nuance in presidential rhetoric, such as when Lincoln contrasted public opinion, which he understood as rooted in economic interest and therefore more supportive of slavery, with public sentiment, which drew from a more abiding, morally informed source (cf. 85–86). Ultimately, this variability and instability complicate simple contrasts between those presidents who did and those who did not appeal to public opinion.
It is trite praise, though in this case nonetheless sincere, to say that a book raises as many questions as it answers. It is more significant if the illumination it provides persists even as our eyes adjust and new features of the subject come to light. That is true of The Lost Soul of the American President. Knott identifies a defining motif in American presidential history, a recurring refrain invoking the will and opinions of the people as a basis for political authority. That observation is no less true if the melody is, upon further examination, more complex, layered, and ambivalent than it may at first seem.
