
The Leuven Manual on the International Law Applicable to Peace Operations (Leuven Manual) belongs to the class of publications that deserve a prominent place in every bookshelf on peace operations and public international law. The Leuven Manual provides a restatement of all international norms applicable to peace operations,Footnote 1 thereby filling a gap in a field where political priorities and situational specificities hinder a comprehensive legal regulation. Its systematic analysis of the applicable international law responds to pressing calls by practitioners, policy-makers and academics, and will serve as an indispensable tool for better decision-making in future operations.
The book is solid and balanced, relying on robust research and an editorial process that involved input from many stakeholders. Prepared at the initiative of the International Society for Military Law and the Law of War, the Leuven Manual is the result of scrupulous research and drafting extended over six years. Terry D. Gill, Dieter Fleck, William H. Boothby and Alfons Vanheusden were general editors, supported by an international Group of Experts who jointly worked on the entire text, with the input of observers from the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the United Nations (UN) and several regional organizations.Footnote 2 The final version was adopted by consensus, which gives the work a high level of authoritativeness. This methodology was certainly necessary for the achievement of a proper restatement of the norms. Also, this was the most suitable approach for dealing with the bulk of difficult legal questions related to an area of law which, in addition to lacking any codification, has developed and continues to operate as the result of political compromise between respect for national sovereignty and maintenance of international peace and security.Footnote 3
The Leuven Manual's main text is composed of 145 black-letter rules, each supported by an accompanying commentary. These rules comprise both existing law and best practices, sometimes blended in the same rule, but phrased so as to reflect the difference between legal obligations (“must”, “shall”, “have to”) and policy recommendations (“should”). The book is intended to be of assistance to those involved in the research, planning and conduct of operations. The audience thus includes national and intergovernmental policy-makers, military officers, policy officers in non-governmental organizations, and the academic community. The scope of the Manual, including its take on peace operations, is defined by its reaffirmation of the continuing validity of the principles comprising the “trinity of virtues”: consent of the parties, impartiality and limited use of force.Footnote 4 Based on this framework, the Manual covers “consensual” peace operations. It does not cover “enforcement operations” (operations directed against a State and based on a UN Security Council resolution under Chapter VII of the UN Charter) or “peace enforcement operations” (operations mandated to participate as a party to a non-international armed conflict (NIAC) on the side of the government against one or several armed groups).Footnote 5 This choice is appropriate since enforcement and peace enforcement operations remain the exception despite the increasing robustness of peace operations’ mandates.Footnote 6 Yet, consensual peace operations for the purposes of the Leuven Manual are not limited to traditional peacekeeping, but extend to multi-dimensional operations tasked with peacebuilding and conflict resolution mandates. The rules apply to missions conducted by the UN as well as regional organizations and other arrangements. They aim to cover all relevant stages of the planning and conduct of an operation.
The Leuven Manual addresses all aspects of peace operations, from the mandate to specific legal issues related to the conduct of a mission. The chapters on the applicability of international human rights law (IHRL)Footnote 7 and international humanitarian law (IHL),Footnote 8 the responsibility of States and international organizations,Footnote 9 and the individual criminal liability of peace forces’ membersFootnote 10 are among the most complete overviews in the academic literature. Besides presenting the many settled aspects concerning the sources, scope and consequences of relevant international norms, these chapters do not hesitate to engage with unsettled questions and provide policy guidance. In this sense, they stand out for their ability to strike a balance between advocacy for a higher respect for the rule of law in peace operations, on the one hand, and the current practice of States and international organizations, which occasionally are still reluctant to acknowledge the full application of relevant norms, on the other. An extensive analysis is dedicated to the institutional frameworks of regional and sub-regional organizations conducting peace operations.Footnote 11 The chapter on the implementation of a gender perspective will hopefully be adopted as a point of reference to ensure compliance with recognized legal obligations and successful practices fostering the mainstreaming of gender issues throughout the entire life-cycle of an operation.Footnote 12
The Leuven Manual does not have any major flaws in its legal findings. A limited number of issues, however, deserve closer scrutiny because of their considerable practical relevance for the establishment and conduct of peace operations. The following paragraphs of this review will selectively focus on some of them.
Rule 1.1, recalling the three principles of peace operations, should be read – and its commentary should eventually be reformulated – so as to reflect the distinction between the legal obligation for host State consent and the Manual's policy recommendation to seek the consent of all major parties to the conflict before deployment. The rule defines the first of the three principles of peace operations as “consent of the parties”. The accompanying commentary explains that consensual peace operations “rely on consent of the Host State and at the outset also on the consent, or at least acquiescence, of all major parties to the former conflict”.Footnote 13 However, this does not reflect existing law. Under jus ad bellum, military operations deployed abroad, absent Chapter VII authorization or self-defence justification, need only the consent of the host State to avoid violating its territorial integrity. The consent of other parties to an ongoing conflict is not a legal requirement to the extent that their territorial integrity is not at stake. This also applies for peace operations, both when deployed in or after an international armed conflict (IAC) and when deployed in or after a NIAC. In IACs, the mission is bound to operate on the territory of the States party to the conflict having consented to the mission. In NIACs, the prohibition against violation of territorial integrity does not affect non-State actors. The distinction, drawn by Christine Gray, between “the legal requirement of host-state consent and the practical requirement of cooperation from all significant parties involved”Footnote 14 is decisive and reaffirmed by other legal literature.Footnote 15 It does not deny the relevance of gaining the consent of the other parties to the conflict. As explained by Terry D. Gill and Dieter Fleck, “[i]n addition to the legal requirement of Host State consent, Peace Operations are also dependent upon the consent, or at the least acquiescence, of all the parties to the conflict or dispute, in order to function and carry out their mandate”.Footnote 16 Accordingly, acceptance of a peace operation by all parties concerned remains a crucial condition to ensure success of the mission and the safety of its members but is not a requirement enshrined in law.
Similarly, the Leuven Manual is ambiguous when requiring a Security Council mandate for all non-UN operations using force beyond self-defence, even when they rely on the invitation or consent of the host State.Footnote 17 Rule 3.1 correctly presents the mandate of an international organization and the consent of the host State as alternative rather than cumulative requirements. Rule 3.3 states further that “a mandate issued by the Security Council will complement and provide an additional legal basis alongside such consent”.Footnote 18 Nevertheless, according to the commentary to Rule 3.1, in case of peace operations conducted by regional organizations or other arrangements, a Security Council mandate will not be sought “when the operation does not involve the proposed use of force beyond personal self-defence”.Footnote 19 This latter sentence seems to place an unjustified limit on non-UN peace operations as it conflicts with the host State's sovereign right to regulate the use of force on its territory by foreign troops. The host State can consent to the use of force by peace operations beyond personal self-defence, such as in defence of the mandate or to protect civilians. The consent of the host State also constitutes a sufficient legal basis for such use of force in the absence of a Security Council mandate. As clarified by Eric P. J. Myjer and Nigel D. White:
Without any UN authority a NATO or other regional organization peace support operation with a coercive protection mandate will be in conflict with the UN Charter provisions, but if force is used against spoilers and not the government then the prohibition on the use of force in Article 2(4) arguably is not being violated, since the use of force is not directed against the State.Footnote 20
The commentary to Rule 3.1 instead introduces an unnecessary burden to establishing non-UN peace operations.
Three additional issues strictly related to the application of IHL in the Leuven Manual are worth highlighting. To begin with, there appears to be no reason why the Manual should exclude from its scope of application peace operations deployed in IACs without taking part in the conflict. Surely, peace operations considered in the Leuven Manual can never become party to an IAC because this would turn the mission into an enforcement operation, falling outside the scope of the book. Rule 6.2 seems to stem from this logic when it maintains that “Peace Operations which are the subject of this Manual are operations deployed to situations of non-international armed conflict”.Footnote 21 Yet the formulation used is misleading: peace operations can be deployed to situations of IAC and still remain consensual, provided they rely on the consent of the State on whose territory they are stationed. Going between warring States is notably the traditional peacekeeping function. Chapter 6 should therefore differentiate between deployment and participation in an IAC, and only exclude the latter.
Furthermore, the Manual associates the right to use force in personal self-defence with the right to use force in defence of others in Rule 12.3, though these two rights are based on different rationales. Their conflation risks hiding the different consequences that their exercise entails in terms of direct participation in hostilities.Footnote 22 Members of a peace force are considered civilians for the purposes of IHL, and civilians do not directly participate in hostilities if they use force in defence of themselves or others against violence prohibited under IHL.Footnote 23 While every attack directed against a civilian is prohibited under IHL,Footnote 24 and therefore the use of force in personal self-defence against such an attack does not amount to direct participation in hostilities, attacks against others are not necessarily unlawful. Thus, the use of force in defence of others might result in direct participation in hostilities and provoke the loss of protected status. The same applies for the protection of property, covered by Rule 12.4. Accordingly, members of a peace force directly participate in hostilities each time they use force for one of the following purposes related to the defence of others:Footnote 25 defence of another member of the peace operation who is directly participating in hostilities; defence of a member or the property of the military component of a peace operation which has become a party to an armed conflict (provided they are not already members of the military component); and defence of a member or the property of a State armed force with which the peace force is cooperating. Since all the described attacks are directed against lawful targets, they cannot be repulsed without losing protected status and therefore becoming legally targetable.Footnote 26 Moreover, when mandated to use force for the mentioned purposes on a regular basis, peace forces even risk becoming a party to the conflict, realizing the fear of most troop-contributing countries that they will be drawn towards enforcement action.Footnote 27 Given the very significant relevance of this consequence, the Manual should draw the attention of the readers more explicitly to these implications.
There is also a lack of clarity concerning the temporal scope of application of IHL to the military contingents of a peace operation that has become party to a conflict. Rule 6.4 recognizes that the conditions for the application of IHL to peace operations can be met not only by individual members of a peace force directly participating in hostilities, but also when the entire military component of an operation becomes a party to the conflict.Footnote 28 This statement is a decisive step forward regarding the law applicable to peace operations, with impact on the status of members of the military contingents involved. When IHL applies to the operation, they can be the object of attack at all times, as acknowledged by the accompanying commentary. Yet the Leuven Manual blurs this conclusion by providing in the same rule that members of the military component lose their protection “if and for such time as the operation has become a party to the conflict”, a formula which is traditionally used to limit the temporal scope of loss of protection of individual civilians directly participating in hostilities.
With regard to the application of IHL to the military contingents of a peace operation, the Leuven Manual takes a similar approach to the UN Secretary-General's 1999 Bulletin, which recognizes the application of IHL to UN forces engaged in a conflict as combatants only “to the extent and for the duration of their engagement”.Footnote 29 However, as explained by Tristan Ferraro, the Bulletin's approach conflates the temporary and activity-based loss of protection by civilians with the continuous and status-based loss of protection of combatants.Footnote 30 The result for peacekeepers would be “an illogical disparity between them and their opponents and would give an operational advantage to the multinational forces, because the opposing party in the armed conflict would continue to be subject to lawful direct attack at any time.”Footnote 31 The Leuven Manual misses the chance to rule out this disparity by excluding the notion that peace operations’ contingents can begin and end their participation in an armed conflict on their own terms by merely deciding to engage in and disengage from hostilities. This option creates a revolving-door mechanism for entire contingents. Taking a stance in this debate would have contributed to settling one of the thorniest practical issues associated with the application of IHL to peace forces.
With these considerations in mind, the ambitious objectives of the Leuven Manual can be considered altogether met. To date, there is no other contribution that has taken up the challenge of collecting, analyzing and restating the entire body of law applicable to peace operations.Footnote 32 The Manual has therefore at least as much merit as comparable projects realized in other areas of international law, notably the San Remo Manuals,Footnote 33 the HPCR ManualFootnote 34 and the Tallinn Manual.Footnote 35 The choice to supplement the restatement of existing law with best practices in the form of policy recommendations goes even beyond the book's main purpose and will hopefully contribute to the settling and development of law by practice. Certainly, this process would be bolstered if States decide to endorse the Leuven Manual, or at least parts of it. To reach that aim, the involvement in a future revision process of relevant countries, including the top troop-contributing countries and financial-contributing countries, would be highly beneficial. Twenty years after the publication of the UN Secretary-General's Bulletin and ten years after the adoption of the Capstone Doctrine,Footnote 36 the adoption of the Leuven Manual as the leading guidance for the conduct of UN missions would also represent a great step forward.
As shown by Lise Morjé Howard, one key factor for successful peace operations is their capacity to learn from the environment in which they are deployed.Footnote 37 The Leuven Manual allows for a better understanding of the legal environment of operations, and as such, it will enable better decision-making and become an irreplaceable support for the success of peace operations.
