The involvement of service users in health and social care research is now considered mainstream and indeed often a requirement for research funding. This is due in no small part to those who describe themselves as survivors of mental health services. This book is a testament to how far the survivor movement has come in the long struggle to get the experiences of mental health services users taken seriously in the production of knowledge. It brings together contributions from service users, sociologists and ‘service user sociologists’ – both academics and service users – and many who identify as both – problematising the boundaries which divide the world into ‘knowers’ and their subjects.
The book developed out of a seminar series – ‘Researching in Mental Health: Sociological and Service User/Survivor Perspectives’ – organised jointly by academic and survivor researchers and itself a landmark in the history of mental health research which for many years has been a contested and conflicted area. Indeed, the opening chapter by Angela Sweeny, one of the seminar organisers describes the seminars as a ‘watershed moment’ bringing sociologists and survivor researchers together on equal terms. The series aimed to bring the two into dialogue and explore common ground, initiating a new legitimacy to survivor research. Sweeny argues the seminars also testify to the journey that sociology has undertaken in acknowledging the power of participatory and survivor-controlled research.
The book's contributors explore research hierarchies and the low status previously assigned to service user research from different viewpoints, and openly address the considerable challenges that still need to be overcome for service user and academic researchers to work together as equal partners in co-producing knowledge.
It examines the ways in which identity shapes the knowledge produced, and raises questions concerning the silencing of voices which challenge the dominance of bio-medical models of mental health within psychiatry. Together the contributions offer theorisations, problematise many of the assumptions regarding the efficacy of user-involvement and the knowledge claims and counter-claims made in its name.
There are chapters that report on collaborative research projects and the practicalities and challenges of ‘doing’ involvement well in practice (Pickard and Purtell; Gillard, Turner and Neffgen) and the ongoing difficulties of having adequate time, resources and opportunities to support meaningful involvement. Other chapters offer examples of survivor controlled research and focus on the particular ways in which voices have been silenced and marginalised by academic research and professional practice. These are explored by Staddon in relation to women service users; by Carr in relation to lesbian, gay and bi-sexual service users and by Kalathil in relation to the under-representation of racialised groups in research, arguing that attempts at involvement have largely been tokenistic.
The potential for the collective experiential knowledge of service users to transform understanding of mental health is examined by Beresford and Boxhall. They discuss the ways in which direct personal experience of mental distress can and does challenge bio-medical models. Further, that they themselves identify as educators in academic institutions and as service users, their position is to challenge the ‘conventional epistemological separation of “us” and “them” – those who make knowledge about mental health service users and those about whom such knowledge is made’ (p. 69). Thus, they address head on the position of service user knowledge in relation to academic and professional understandings of what constitutes knowledge. The key point for them, drawing on Cotterell and Morris (Reference Cotterell, Morris, Barnes and Cotterell2012: 58), is that experiential knowledge is not simply having direct personal experience of a particular phenomenon but having ‘a reflective stance on this experience’.
Lewis explores the ‘politics of recognition’ and the dangers of co-option within involvement. She draws attention to the paradox that whilst user involvement initiatives within mental health services have contributed to a degree of cultural change, this has coincided with policy initiatives that have increased surveillance and control of service users, arguing that meaningful participation cannot be achieved with consumerist frameworks.
The final chapters discuss the future possibilities for service user involvement in research, with McLaughlin setting out the case that involvement needs to move beyond ‘insider knowledge’ to plurality of knowledges. The last word is left to Patsy Staddon, the editor who cautiously reflects that although survivor research has made considerable inroads in challenging the positioning of service users as ‘objects of scrutiny’ to be researched on, they are far from being regarded as equal partners by the academic or professional establishments.
This book draws on the experiences of key contributors to this area and provides a comprehensive and accessible discussion of the challenges and tensions within mental health research. It is likely to be of interest beyond the immediate focus of user involvement in mental health research to those interested in debates about epistemology and philosophy of social science as well as those interested in participatory research methodologies. It makes for a challenging read for professionals, practitioners and policy makers in mental health services and serves as a vital reminder that these are not merely disputes about different knowledge claims, but ultimately link to inequalities, stigmatisation and marginalisation in the treatment of people who experience mental distress.
