In The Israeli–Palestinian Conflict, Beverly Milton-Edwards, a professor of politics and an international affairs expert from Queens University Belfast, explores the emotional, compelling, and often frightening story of the struggle for justice in Palestine–Israel. Through a vast array of cultural relics and historical documents—from films and media to archived U.N. studies—Milton-Edwards takes the reader on a journey through the “charred and twisted landscape of increasingly envenomed enmity” (p. 2) that has come to characterize the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. Relying on critical, thorough, and scholarly examinations of these sources, Milton-Edwards compels the reader to view events through the lens of objectivity. By sympathetically presenting all sides of the conflict, the author uses this lens to cinematically zoom in and out of various pivotal events that have come to shape the current conflict.
Unlike other studies on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict that make claims of objectivity but remain drenched in polemics, The Israeli–Palestinian Conflict professes and delivers an objective analysis throughout the book, one meticulously chronicled chapter after another. Milton-Edwards's cogent study uses extant resources to explain “why and how it went wrong” (p. 6) in this conflict, one that is “deeply felt across the Middle East and beyond” (p. 147). She undertakes this gargantuan task through nine chapters dealing with the areas she deems most critical to unraveling the complexities of the issue. At the end of each chapter is a “further reading” section, where a comprehensive bibliography of relevant resources is made available to readers so they do not become “vulnerable to the vagaries” (p. 79) of spurious or tendentious accounts of the conflict.
In this well-written, meticulously referenced study, Milton-Edwards avoids such vagaries by whipping up a delicious entrée of facts presented from myriad angles and, like a good teacher, leaves the reader to make conclusions of his or her own. Through the unfailing objectivity that seems to permeate each page of the book, Milton-Edwards also attempts to “challenge the collective memory at large within” (p. 73) both Palestinian and Israeli societies. For instance, she asks whether the creation of Israel was the result of “extreme violence against unarmed civilians” (p. 68), a “series of myths” (p. 17), or “Western guilt at not stopping the genocide against Jews” (p. 55) in Germany and ultimately leaves the reader to decide. Yet, most if not all of the facts required for making a conclusion are provided by the author, making it an invaluable resource for policymakers, students, and others interested in the ongoing Israeli–Palestinian conflict.
Overall, Milton-Edwards weaves together a perceptive, challenging, and singularly compelling portrait that enables her readers to reexamine deeply held views on the nature of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict and the influence that economics, politics, and other dynamics have played and continue to play in shaping it. Rarely has a book spoken so insightfully and eloquently to those interested in working toward a just, durable, and lasting peace in the region. In sum, this is not simply another book in the Israel–Palestine genre. Historians, cultural experts, and politicians have written insightful accounts of this issue, but few have approached the subject with the same transparency, accountability, and attention to detail as Milton-Edwards. Beverly Milton-Edwards’ The Israeli–Palestinian Conflict should be the textbook of choice on this issue because of its scope, neutrality, and thorough scholarship. I am certain that Israelis, Palestinians, and other stakeholders in the struggle who read this book will agree.
