Diane Mutti Burke's study of small-slaveholding households in the border state of Missouri is a welcome addition to the historiography of American slavery. Previous regional studies of slavery have focussed predominantly on the states of the Upper and Lower South. Additionally, owing to availability of source material, much of this research has tended to focus on plantations (typically defined as slaveholdings of more than twenty slaves). Mutti Burke examines a variety of source material including slave narratives; Civil War pension records; and letters, diaries, and manuscripts written by white Missourians to explore how small-scale slavery in Missouri “affected the families and communities of both slaves and owners, as well as the many ways their lives intersected’ (5–6).
Wealthy planters were deterred from migrating to Missouri. The shorter 180-day average growing season deterred the large-scale commercial development of cotton, the state's border location meant slaves were less secure, and the potential threat from abolitionist interference worried prospective planter migrants. Missouri remained a haven for small-scale slaveholding. By 1860, at least 90 percent of slaveholders in seventy-four of Missouri's 113 counties owned ten or fewer slaves (49). Slave labour was central to Missouri's economic system. In contrast to the large plantations of the South, Missouri slaveholders and their slaves did not engage in the large-scale production of cash crops on big estates. Instead, Missouri was populated by farms that produced a wide variety of crops such as corn, tobacco, hemp, and livestock for household use and the marketplace.
The lives of slaveholders and their slaves were intertwined as a result of the intimate nature of small-scale slaveholding. Mutti Burke reveals that both groups laboured alongside one another in the field and in domestic tasks. From time to time, the close proximity of slaves and slaveholders ensured that enslaved people enjoyed improved treatment and material conditions, such as food and healthcare. However, conversely, slavery on such an intimate scale often left enslaved people vulnerable to outbursts of violence and sexual abuse. The social lives of black and white Missourians were also interconnected. Slaveholders, non-slaveholders and enslaved people interacted frequently, socializing at church, work frolics, weddings and holidays. At the same time, however, Missourians created their own distinct social spaces.
The small-scale nature of slavery in Missouri forced many enslaved people to look for spouses off the farm. Mutti Burke calculates that 57 percent of Missouri slave marriages were abroad marriages (201). This was an extremely high percentage compared to other southern states. Abroad marriages affected the family life of enslaved people in various ways. The greater the distance between couples, the less frequently husbands visited their wives and loved ones. However, despite these arrangements, enslaved couples created long-lasting relationships, and struggled hard to improve the material conditions of their families. Mutti Burke also documents the effects of the Civil War on slaveholdings in Missouri.
On Slavery's Border is a wonderfully written account of a subject area that has received almost no attention in the historiography of slavery. It is exhaustively researched, and gracefully penetrates the intimate world of small-scale slaveholdings in Missouri. There are a few obvious parallels to other studies of antebellum slavery in the text. The research on abroad marriage in chapter 5 broadly echoes the findings of historian Emily West's research on South Carolina (although West concludes that 33.5 percent of slave marriages in South Carolina were abroad marriages, compared to Mutti Burke's figure of 57 percent for Missouri). The discussion of authorized and illicit use of social space by enslaved people in chapter 6 concurs with Rebecca Fraser's study of enslaved courtship in North Carolina, and with Stephanie Camp's work on enslaved women and everyday resistance. Nonetheless, On Slavery's Border marvellously underscores the uniqueness of slaveholding in the border state of Missouri. Of particular note is the extent to which black and white lives interacted on a daily basis. Mutti Burke's research is refreshingly original and has much to teach us about how geography and the size of slaveholding affected the rhythms of antebellum slavery.
