Philip Hardie's new book follows in the wake of the Cambridge Companion to Lucretius (2007) and draws on his work over the past fifteen years, although H.'s interest in the reception of Lucretius — particularly in Virgilian poetry — goes back to his earliest publications. Lucretian Receptions comprises revised versions of six papers originally printed in a variety of contexts, together with two important new essays. In keeping with their origins, each chapter can be taken on its own terms, although a sequential reading is rewarding and facilitated by cross-references and indices.
The first chapter, ‘Cultural and historical narratives in Virgil's Eclogues and Lucretius’, argues that Virgil's first collection is indebted to Lucretius in a way similar to his Georgics and Aeneid. Superficial reminiscences of Lucretius ‘bookend’ the Eclogues, but there are also deeper echoes on the level of the poets' respective conceptions of the historical process — biological metaphors of growth, combined with the idea of a saviour figure, provided Virgil with a model to work with in formulating his own bucolic history. Ch. 2, ‘Virgilian and Horatian didactic: freedom and innovation’, continues to investigate the challenge set by Lucretius' descriptions of time and change; Virgil, for instance, disavowed Lucretian historical gradualism at the end of his first Georgic in favour of a more dynamic view of history that fitted better with the needs of early Augustan Rome.
‘Virgil's Fama and the sublime’ is the first of the book's fresh contributions; in it, H. approaches the sublime in Virgil, following in the worthy footsteps of Heinze and Auerbach. It is long (68 pages), rich (discussing the Latin tradition from Ennius to Silius Italicus), and opens up a new set of possibilities for further studies. H.'s salient argument is that Fama in Book 4 of the Aeneid is a ‘figure for a Virgilian brand of the sublime’ that builds on the Lucretian sublime (recently discussed by G. B. Conte and James Porter). H. first shows that there is a considerable amount of Lucretian imagery in this particular section of Book 4 — Iarbas is figured as a quasi-Epicurean in his questioning of the power of Jupiter, and the flight of Fama herself bears similarities to the spread of Religio in Lucretius. H. then moves on to discuss what is sublime about Fama, and it is here that one or two comments are perhaps in order.
H. states openly that it is difficult to pin down the sublime as a concept: ‘Rather than attempting a definition here, I shall allow those aspects of the sublime, and of the history of the sublime both in antiquity and later, that concern me to emerge in the course of the following discussions.’ H.'s concern is, of course, understandable, but it would have been useful to have a solid base for his subsequent investigation of how the concept relates to Virgil's Fama. The history of the sublime is indeed complicated, and most classical scholars appeal principally to ps.-Longinus in their discussions of the sublime in ancient texts. This is probably well advised, as theories of the sublime depart quite dramatically from the ps.-Longinian tradition in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, quickly reducing one to the question ‘whose sublime?’; Samuel Monk remains authoritative on the debates of this period, and the subsequent shift in gear found in Kant has been discussed by Glenn Most (among others). H., in his characterization of the sublime, appeals not only to ps.-Longinus, but also to Boileau, Shaftesbury, Baillie, Burke, and Kant, authors who put forward theories that relied on very different frameworks; as Ashfield and De Bolla note, ‘the discourse on the sublime is transformational’, and it is perhaps simplest to investigate the sublime in Virgil using one authority at a time, since ps.-Longinus alone presents us with problems enough.
What H. has shown, however, is that discourse on the sublime throughout the ages has a particular relevance to Virgil's Fama: it is clear that Edmund Burke's ‘judicious obscurity’ is an especially productive concept here, and H.'s idea of connecting the intertextual vertiginousness of the Fama episode with the Kantian mathematical sublime is a suggestive one. Baillie, moreover, quotes from Virgil's lines on Fama in the context of his discussion on the sublime. It would, therefore, be rewarding to look at the Fama episode through the ‘optics’ of the various thinkers, using it as a test case for their separate theories. This would place the emphasis on how different conceptions of the sublime relate to this episode, while keeping them clearly distinguished from one another. Another possibility might be to carry out a study of the reception of Fama in texts that talk about the sublime.
Ch. 4, ‘The speech of Pythagoras in Ovid Metamorphoses 15: Empedoclean epos’, starts from the assumption that Ovid drew on Empedoclean texts for parts, at least, of the speech of Pythagoras. H. argues that, rather than serving as a ‘key’ for unlocking the rest of the poem, the speech places the Metamorphoses in a tradition of hexametrical epos going back to Empedocles by means of its usage of Empedoclean material, together with its allusions to other poets' reworkings of that material.
‘Lucretian visions in Virgil’, another new essay, clearly points out the similarities and differences between the visions of the world in Lucretius and Virgil — a subject H. first broached in Cosmos and Imperium. While Lucretius strives for a complete view of the world and all its properties, the Aeneid remains swathed in smoke and religio to the end. In Book 8, Hercules exposes the cave of Cacus in a scene replete with the Lucretian language of enlightenment and revelation, but at the close of the epic Aeneas still ‘sacrifices’ (immolat) Turnus. Ch. 6, ‘Horace's sublime yearnings: Lucretian ironies’, performs a similar function for Horace, H. showing that Horace self-consciously sabotages his own ‘sublime flights’. A striking example of this is Horace's metamorphosis in Odes 2.20, where the poet takes to the wing in a form that violates his own canon of poetic decorum. These two chapters pair nicely in their analyses of the varying pretensions to certainty and sublimity in Lucretius, Virgil, and Horace. This is a fertile area, and there is much room for expansion — one wonders, for instance, what we are to make of the swirl and rush of a poem like Odes 1.2, with its vision of Jupiter poised with ‘red right hand’?
Ch. 7 considers Lucretius' usage of multiple explanation — the supplying of several different possible causes for a phenomenon — and compares it with that of the subsequent tradition of epos. H. argues that Virgil served as a cataract for post-Lucretian applications of the turn; in the remythologized Virgilian world, Lucretius' certainty that the world can be explained in purely materialist ways is undermined and supernatural possibilities creep back in. Illuminating discussions of Lucan and Statius follow, where multiple explanation serves to illustrate the limitations of human knowledge rather than to exclude the possibility of supernatural explanation.
Ch. 8, ‘The presence of Lucretius in Paradise Lost’, stems from an influential paper in the Milton Quarterly and looks at the connections between the Puritan epic and its Lucretian counterpart. Both Milton and Lucretius were evangelistic poets aiming to teach rather than to narrate, and both used similar poetic techniques, even though their messages could not have been more different.
Characteristically, H. deals with great themes throughout — the rifts between different generations of authors, the exigencies of their ages, the prospects for human certainty about the world, and the history of the sublime. This is a fine collection of essays by one of the leading critics of Latin literature working today, and it can be recommended to anyone interested in the poetry of the late Republic and its influence on the later tradition.
