In Cultivating National Identity through Performance: American Pleasure Gardens and Entertainment, part of Palgrave Macmillan's Studies in Theatre and Performance History series, Naomi J. Stubbs contributes to the discourse surrounding performance of national identities by calling attention to the often-neglected pleasure gardens of the nineteenth century. By examining the performances within these spaces, Stubbs considers how American identities were cultivated, constructed, and reconfigured in these sites of negotiation. Stubbs uses cultural and performance studies to explore patrons' role-playing, the performance of space, and the onstage entertainments offered. As Stubbs describes them, these spaces were “simultaneously gardens, entertainment venues, nostalgic retreats, venues for displays of technological advancement, sites of commemoration and celebration, and spaces of inclusion and exclusion” (126). Furthermore, pleasure gardens allowed for visitors to explore, rehearse, and perform various notions of what it meant to be American in the formative years of national identity, however in flux that identity may have been. Stubbs focuses her study on pleasure gardens within the United States, specifically those in New York, Baltimore, Boston, Philadelphia, and Charleston, though she references pleasure gardens abroad as points of comparison. She considers pleasure gardens in operation between 1789 and 1855 and observes in her conclusion that the influence of these gardens goes beyond this time frame. The limited number of sources on the topic set the geographic and temporal parameters of her study.
Stubbs uses each chapter to narrow in on a particular facet of American identities; nation, agrarianism, class, and race. Throughout the book, she stresses the multiplicity of identity constructions, pointing out that there is no singular American identity. In Chapter 1, Stubbs counters the notion that American pleasure gardens were mere replications of English gardens by looking at “the simultaneous alignment with and distancing from English culture” (18). Stubbs contends that proprietors looked to English versions to establish a heritage, but also distanced themselves by claiming aesthetic and moral superiority. She discusses the ways in which gardens contributed to postrevolutionary patriotism with commemorations and celebrations, particularly Fourth of July fireworks shows. Chapter 2 concentrates on the ways in which pleasure gardens served as a “bridge” (44) between notions of the rural and urban in American culture. Stubbs argues that not only were gardens able to provide a perceived rural (and moral) retreat from the city and its presumed negative attributes, but that these sites also served as liminal spaces in which nostalgia for a rural idyll calmed anxieties over modern technologies through the display of such advancements as lamps, velocipedes, and automatons within the garden. The sites “helped to allow such marvels be enveloped within the idea of rural simplicity” (62).
Stubbs dedicates Chapter 3 to the analysis of class in pleasure gardens. Exposing the false veneer of national ideals such as democracy and equality performed within these spaces, she calls attention to the exclusionary tactics (such as dress codes and refreshment fees) used by proprietors to discourage less desirable patrons. She asserts that those who gained admission to the venues had to perform the role of genteel guest through their appearance and behavior. Chapter 4 interrogates constructions of race, specifically Native American, African American, and white American, in pleasure gardens. Proprietors featured Native Americans in war dances and ritual practices, as well as in plays such as Metamora that depicted Native Americans in a stereotypic light, suggesting that they were a monolithic people of the past. Stubbs proposes that white visitors felt pity for the Native Americans, which reinforced their own perceived superiority. Though a few African American gardens existed, African American involvement in the gardens was primarily in the forms of labor (wait staff) and minstrel performances. In both cases, racial minorities were presented as “containable, knowable, and (most importantly) inferior” (102). In Chapter 5, Stubbs concludes by establishing pleasure gardens' previously “obscured” legacy in American culture (109). She weaves the influences of multiple entertainment forms together to create a tapestry that includes rooftop gardens, parks, world's fairs, vaudeville, and amusement parks.
Though she assigns each chapter an aspect of American identities, Stubbs skillfully integrates these aspects throughout the study, thus demonstrating the fluidity of identity formation. Stubbs's greatest strength is in the ways she marks and problematizes the manners by which the performances suggested ideals that bore little resemblance to reality. An example of this can be found in her discussion of the rural–urban tension, which reminds readers that the performed rural idyll “saw simple natural scenes and agrarian lifestyles as being moral, chaste, pure, and noble with the realities of hard labor and poverty carefully excised” (44–5). She also points out that proprietors and patrons of the gardens celebrated military victory within the space, but “the realities of war were rarely acknowledged” (37). The result is a study that carefully avoids simple binaries and considerations of these spaces, and instead presents the complexities involved in the construction and dissemination of identities.
The one area upon which I felt Stubbs could have expanded was her use of Michel Foucault's “heterotopic spaces” in describing the pleasure gardens. Early in the work she alludes to Foucault's notion that spaces are “imbued with multiple meanings and significations” (7), as well as the six elements he identifies for heterotopias, and makes brief mention of the concept in a few other places. I appreciate Stubbs's application of Foucault's theory, but throughout the study, I found myself wanting deeper analysis of those six elements and how they can further elucidate the pleasure gardens' role in identity formation.
Cultivating National Identity is a valuable contribution to studies involving performance, identity construction, and nineteenth-century entertainment. By considering onstage and offstage performances of proprietors, patrons, artists, and spaces, Stubbs provides a text that is cross-disciplinary in scope and successful in demonstrating the significant role of these sites in American culture and history. This well-researched project reveals much about an influential and (until now) largely ignored form of entertainment that provided Americans a space in which to formulate national identities.
