Despite titles suggesting otherwise, these two recent books on the Catholic Church's engagement with the sciences break with tradition and concentrate on the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Both books are entirely devoted to the interaction between the Catholic Church and science, rather than between Catholics and science. Thus neither looks substantially beyond official Vatican sources, approved publications (such as La Civilta Cattolica) or self-consciously Catholic scientists. The books do, however, offer slightly different perspectives and approaches; Don O'Leary, a scientist and historian, is consistently critical of Church officials, while Peter Hess and Paul Allen, both Catholic theologians, maintain a neutral to positive stance. What is more, O'Leary's main concern is really the biological sciences, and evolution in particular, rather than modern science as a whole. (If you were to read only these two books on Catholicism and science, you would come away with the idea that evolution is the single most important issue in the history of the relationship.) The small amount of space devoted to the physical sciences tends to dilute a coherent structure rather than add to it. That said, overall, O'Leary engages more fully with the debates he discusses, and his book reads more like a complete project than Hess and Allen's, which seems to me flawed in its conception.
What Hess and Allen provide is not so much a synthesis as a summary. Although they seem generally to accept the complexity thesis about Church–science interaction, they have failed to see that complexity requires clear explication. They pinpoint no themes and offer no arguments about the Catholic Church and science, aside from occasional references to the views of others. Discussion of some of the complex philosophical issues raised tends to be too limited to be useful. To take but one example, Aquinas gets barely three pages, but his writings and philosophy continue to be referred back to in later chapters, and with very little explanation of the changes in interpretation. If the ordinary reader – or even this overeducated reader – is to have any success at following the subtleties of new interpretations of old philosophies, more assistance is needed, not least in deciding whether the individuals chosen are representative or unique. And although the twentieth century is dealt with in greater detail than is any other century (it is the focus of the final three chapters), here too there is a tendency simply to describe the writings of one thinker after another. This makes reading tiresome and creates confusion.
O'Leary's book manages to provide a greater level of synthesis. The chapters are roughly chronological, with the first five chapters focused on the nineteenth century and the next six on the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. The early chapters would serve very well for introducing students to the subject, and represent one of the few general overviews of the relationship between the Church and science in the nineteenth century. As the book wears on, however, O'Leary's account tends more towards summary of positions rather than analysis of attitudes, and the detail of his examination of evolution is not matched in his discussion of any other topic. Unfortunately, much of the material he covers on the Church's engagement with evolution and evolutionists has appeared recently in M. Artigas, T.F. Glick and R.A. Martinez's Negotiating Darwin: The Vatican Confronts Evolution (2006). O'Leary comes to similar conclusions as Artigas et al., but cannot have seen their book before his own was completed. The only other substantial flaw in the work is that O'Leary occasionally lets his own opinions on the Church show through a bit too much – as when he calls the editors of La Civilta Cattolica ‘narrow-minded, intolerant and aggressive’ (p. 45). Remarks of this type tend to undermine the generally balanced and thoroughly researched view which O'Leary presents.
O'Leary's most significant addition to scholarship on science and religion may be his two chapters dealing largely with Vatican II and the papacy of John Paul II. These are a very useful source for historians of the twentieth century, presenting a concise overview of the implications of the Second Vatican Council and the hierarchy's growing unease regarding birth control and genetic technologies. John Paul's reign saw the reopening of the Galileo case with a special commission. Unfortunately, O'Leary's focus on biological science means that this commission and its findings receive relatively scant attention. Still, his book would be a good starting place for any historian interested in Catholicism and science in the twentieth century.
