This small gem of a book is a major contribution to the social history of the medieval Middle East. Focusing on the gendered economy in Mamluk Egypt and Syria, Rapoport prefers the tried-and-true methods of social history over a more trendy approach using discourse theory. He draws on a wide variety of sources: literary, documentary, legal, and historical. His conclusions are revisionist both for the study of family life in the Middle East and for comparative family history.
The central thesis of the book is that marriage contracts in the late Middle Ages were increasingly concluded with cash payments rather than with the exchange of gifts. The monetarization of marriage had important consequences for marriage and family relations among medieval Muslims, and for the rights of women. One consequence of this change was that divorce was more common and socially accepted—at least among the urban, propertied classes—than it is now. Women had greater freedom to seek and conclude divorces from unwanted husbands and to remarry by their own choice.
Although some scholars, this reviewer among them, have concluded that institutions that housed divorced and widowed women were coercive, Rapoport finds that they provided shelters for women who might then remarry at the time of their choosing. Furthermore, he argues that many women found employment in the textile industry and in other trades, which gave them considerable economic independence. Thus, women had greater rights to divorce, remarry, or remain single than has previously been believed. Implicit in this conclusion is that women had greater power within marriage as well, because they had alternatives to remaining in an unhappy marriage. Furthermore, this ease of divorce also influenced marriage patterns among Jews and Christians living in the Mamluk Empire and could be described as a cross-religious consensus in many facets of marriage.
Rapoport is careful not to romanticize his conclusions. He is aware that the threat of a polygamous marriage gave men leverage over their wives, even if the threat was not always carried out. Furthermore, he notes that transfer of economic power in the form of grants of revenue in exchange for service gave the all-male Mamluk military a monopoly on much of the empire's agricultural land. Nonetheless, he argues that, broadly speaking, women in medieval Egypt and Syria had meaningful and exercisable rights and economic resources, whether they were married, divorced, or widowed. In addition to earning money through labor and receiving cash from marriage contracts, women received premortem inheritances in the form of trousseaus. Furthermore, although men did use divorce oaths with some frequency to solemnize social and political ties, there were several ways by which married couples could avoid the consequences of violating such oaths. Nonetheless, Rapoport concludes, “Divorce and manumission were an extreme manifestation of patriarchal authority, as well as its symbols, because they severed the ties that held a household together” (pp. 108–9). The improvements of the late Middle Ages were relative, and much of men's authority over their households remained intact.
Although the main arguments of the book are persuasive, there are a few aspects that are unclear. Whereas there is good evidence that propertied urban women had substantial control to remarry, or not, after being widowed or after a divorce, it seems likely that previously unmarried women had substantially less autonomy. Rapoport is aware of this point but glosses over the power exerted by parents over the choice of a first husband. One would like to know more about how such marriages were concluded. It is also unclear how previously married women met and chose their subsequent partners. The access they had, or did not have, to potential partners must have had considerable impact on their options for subsequent marriages. Rapoport shows that the monetarization of marriage did apply to the urban artisan class and that women did not have to be from a merchant or military family to have access to economic resources. One wonders, however, whether rural women had the same opportunities. Perhaps due to a lack of evidence, he has little to say about this. In studying the upper classes, he makes good use of published material on Islamic endowments (awqāf), but a systematic reading of surviving endowment documents from this period would yield considerably more data.
Although there are many more questions to be asked on this topic, Rapoport's contribution is highly significant. Based on a careful study of the literature on family history in the premodern Middle East and in Europe, he skillfully formulates important research questions and devises ways to answer them. Not only are his conclusions brilliantly original, but also his method should serve as a model for future contributions to writing the social history of the premodern Middle East.
