Scholars from numerous fields will be indebted to Sandra Peart for providing a fully edited and annotated text of Friedrich A. Hayek’s John Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor: Their Correspondence and Subsequent Marriage (1951). The volume also includes a number of related essays by Hayek that shed light on their relationship and constitutes a worthy addition (as volume 16) to The Collected Works of F. A. Hayek. Until recently, Hayek’s study of Mill and Taylor seemed destined to be bypassed by the march of Mill scholarship. For example, some feminist writers since the 1970s have felt uneasy with the apparent ambiguities in Mill’s liberalism, to the point of challenging the coherence of his political philosophy and the consistency of his commitment to ending the subjection of women. Additionally and paradoxically, while Hayek was an important figure in the early years of the new Toronto Mill edition, few have linked up his research (particularly on Mill’s correspondence prior to 1848) with the completed edition of Mill’s Collected Works. Peart has done so with considerable skill, and her annotation of Hayek’s texts and notes plus an extensive introduction have transformed Hayek’s somewhat narrow and dated study of the relationship between Mill and Taylor into a significant contribution to Mill scholarship itself. Peart’s success is partly due to her historical skills and partly to her willingness to address a number of contexts where interpretive problems concerned with Hayek, Mill, liberalism, socialism, and the history of economic thought are critically considered.
What prompted Hayek to begin his study of the Mill–Taylor correspondence is not entirely clear. There is little in it to shed light on Mill’s economic ideas. Some insight might be gained by examining the selected correspondence with Jacob Viner (pp. 332–353) and related essays included in this volume. Viner was an ideal correspondent. He combined a broad knowledge of intellectual history and the history of economic thought with a love of detail and the ability to encourage Hayek to discover increasing amounts of Mill–Taylor correspondence. Although Viner wrote to Hayek in London, the London School of Economics (where Hayek was employed) had, by the end of 1941, moved to Peterhouse College in Cambridge for the duration of the war. Despite obvious wartime conditions, Hayek seemed content with his position, remarking that “Cambridge is not a bad place to live in war time” (p. 336). However, references to the loss of important archives in the Blitz, and the obvious inability to access continental libraries, made the recovery of potential Mill archives an imperative rather than an idle antiquarian pastime.
The archive collected by Hayek and his correspondents soon reached 400 letters written by Mill, of which only 30 had been published earlier in The Letters of John Stuart Mill (1910), edited by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Elliot had apparently concentrated on, or had access to, mainly Mill’s correspondence after 1848. For this reason Hayek concentrated on collecting Mill’s earlier correspondence “in my spare time” (p. 349), and hoped to produce an edition of Mill’s letters up to 1848. As the size of the task increasingly dawned on him, he began to retreat from such an enterprise. The letters were eventually produced as part of the new edition of Mill’s Collected Works (volumes 12 and 13), edited by Francis Mineka. Although Mineka proposed that Hayek should be co-editor, Hayek declined, but subsequently wrote an introduction to the volumes (see pp. 322–331). Hayek also supported the work of Michael Packe in his 1954 biography of Mill and wrote a preface to it (see pp. 314–315).
On the question of why he began his collection of Mill’s early correspondence and particularly that with Harriet Taylor, there is no clear answer. He seems to have adopted a role during World War II of a collector and editor of Mill’s early correspondence, either out of an attempt to connect with a new radicalism in Mill or possibly even out of boredom. Another motivating factor might have been Hayek’s dissatisfaction with Mill’s Autobiography, which he feared would be among Mill’s most influential works, more influential perhaps than his great works like the System of Logic (1843), Principles of Political Economy (1848), or On Liberty (1859). Nevertheless, Hayek’s estimation of Mill’s writings and reputation at this time seems much too pessimistic, particularly as Mill’s Collected Works, which would completely change our understanding of his thought, had not yet begun publication. Hayek’s pessimism may also have led him astray to concentrate overly on the materials for Mill’s biography and on the relationship between Mill and Taylor rather than on Mill’s philosophical, political, and economic texts.
At the beginning of his book Hayek suggests that his object in this volume is “no more than an attempt to fill this particular gap—material for a future biography rather than an attempt at an appreciation” (p. 14). He also believes that without a serious understanding of Taylor’s influence on Mill, no account of Mill’s life is possible. But Hayek’s discussions of Mill and Taylor and the influence of Taylor on Mill (note the themes of rationalism and romanticism) are misleading precisely because he concentrates so exclusively on Taylor and Mill and omits to consider other aspects of Mill’s life and thought (see pp. l, 13–14). How can Hayek virtually ignore the accounts of rationality in Mill’s Logic, which was written and published in the 1830s and 1840s? Note that Mill gave more credit to Alexander Bain than to Taylor for assistance with its production, and after her death he even removed or modified some criticisms of Auguste Comte she had made in an earlier edition of book VI, which he had originally included under her influence.
As for the importance of Comte at this stage in Mill’s career, one should recall that Mill first presented himself to Comte as an ardent disciple and refused to publish his own Logic until Comte had published the final volume of the Cours de philosophie positive. The theme of rationality in Mill cannot be understood through Taylor alone, and the importance of Comte, Jeremy Bentham, and numerous other thinkers requires careful attention. The main problem with Hayek is that his concentration on Mill and Taylor made this careful attention irrelevant, if not impossible.
Peart writes correctly that “we are left with a Mill …, who remained something of a puzzle through the mid-twentieth century and beyond” (p. xxviii). She points out that Hayek believed that the Autobiography was “singularly unhelpful.” I have argued that despite Hayek’s careful research on his chosen topic, he could initiate but not fully establish his own position, due to the absence of the Collected Works and his somewhat narrow concentration on Mill and Taylor.
Hayek (and Peart) have also developed important insights into issues concerning Mill and Taylor. Peart writes that “all in all, the evidence that Hayek brings to light below on the ‘women question’ suggests strongly that their views were congruent early on and throughout their lives, as opposed to Taylor moving Mill towards an interest in or sympathy for women” (p. xxxvii). One might add that Mill’s views had also been influenced by his contact with those of Bentham, who strongly supported women’s emancipation. In this connection we might draw attention to Hayek’s discussions of one of the circles in which both Mill and Taylor mixed in the 1830s. This was the group surrounding William Johnson Fox and his journal, the Monthly Repository, and the Unitarian community in London. Not only did it bring Mill and Taylor together, but it also included Harriet’s husband, John Taylor, also an important radical figure. Despite their separation, he remained close to Harriet, and was nursed by her at the time of his death in 1849 (see pp. 151–161). Hayek provides a careful account of this material, such as the role of the Flower sisters and others in Harriet Taylor’s life, and how Mill (and Taylor) fit into the radical intellectual, moral, and religious community surrounding Fox. Nevertheless, Hayek has some difficulty making sense of Mill’s role in this context. He provides us with numerous useful details of their lives in the 1830s, though Hayek fails to refer to Mill’s extensive “Notes on the Newspapers” (see Collected Works, vi, pp. 149–280), published in the Monthly Repository during the Parliamentary year 1834, where Mill attempted to establish a new conception of radicalism that clearly differed from that prevalent in the Fox circle. If known at all, this text would have been known mainly through the Collected Works, where it has been printed, and not through Hayek’s research.
To conclude, a number of obvious questions surrounding Mill and Taylor seem resolved by Hayek and Peart. Hayek is particularly insightful regarding the numerous illnesses both suffered throughout their relationship, leading one to wonder how they managed physically to work together at all. But they were a team, and their relationship was very close. It was based less on influencing each other to accept or reject particular doctrines and more on how doctrines already shared could be best expressed. If Mill was more intellectual and dialectical, Harriet’s role was based more on strong feeling. Mill was more cautious and prepared to qualify and balance various positions they had adopted.
To the frequently asked question as to whether Mill and Taylor consummated their marriage, or, indeed, had a sexual relationship at all, we come as close to a definitive answer as one can find, even though it depends on a summary of opinions rather than on direct evidence. According to Peart, “Hayek’s collection does little to clear up with finality the mystery of whether the relationship was platonic or sexual before or even after their marriage” (pp. xxxi–xxxii). She refers to a variety of recent opinions (including those of Michael St. John Packe, Michael Jacobs, Nicholas Capaldi, and Richard Reeves) and Hayek’s own view in a footnote (p. xxxiin). The footnote refers to an unpublished essay by Hayek (“J.S. Mill, Mrs. Taylor, and Socialism,” pp. 298–312) found in the study of his son Laurence after the latter’s death, and contains the remark by Hayek that he was “convinced the relationship was purely platonic” (p. 305), perhaps echoing a comment of Thomas Carlyle in a letter to his brother, John (p. 85n) that “I do believe that the whole thing is strictly Platonic still!” (March 1839). In another letter to John Sterling, written in 1837, Carlyle refers to “His Platonica [Harriet Taylor] and he [Mill] are constant as ever: innocent I do believe as sucking doves, and yet suffering the clack of tongues, worst penalty of guilt” (p. 80). I recall asking John Robson, when the edition was nearly completed, if he thought that the marriage was ever consummated, and he replied that he did not believe that it was, because, among other reasons, both Mill and Taylor were in constant ill-health. I agree with Hayek, Peart, and Robson, but would like to discover some direct evidence as to what Mill and Taylor thought of these issues of sexuality.
