To silence the mourning of dead victims is to legitimize the violence against them. In Postcolonial Grief, Jinah Kim refuses such a closure of the settler colonial Pacific Arena order by revealing the “missing Asian bodies” as spectral beings of insurrection. The existing framework for dealing with the victims of Japanese and American militarism in the Pacific Arena has focused on seeking closure and reconciliation. Kim pungently criticizes this neoliberal framework for co-opting biopolitical narratives of healing that legitimize state violence and for muffling the dissenting narratives of colonialism. Drawing on theories of Fanonian anticolonial psychoanalysis and neoliberal biopolitics, Kim offers a comparative analysis of grief and mourning practices as a resistance to imperial reconciliation, drawing from examples including Los Angeles, Japan, Peru, and South Korea. This book is well suited for scholars and students in Asian American and postcolonial studies, as well as readers who are interested in the themes and theories of mourning and melancholia in general.
Kim's interdisciplinary and transnational investigation of the abject subjects in literary and filmic representations provides remarkable insights into discussions of melancholia and state violence. For instance, in chapter 1, through a reading of Frantz Fanon's “Colonial Wars and Mental Disorder” from Wretched of the Earth and Hisaye Yamamoto's “A Fire in Fontana,” Kim demonstrates how melancholia has been pathologized among Algerians by the French colonial state and how postcolonial grief is co-opted by the state as racialized injury in the US neoliberal context. Kim deftly connects the racialized injury of Japanese American internment to Black dispossession during Jim Crow, “[linking] the histories of loss and of racism” (p. 39) to challenge a resolved, settled past through the practice of grievance.
This linkage dovetails with Kim's reading of the Los Angeles Riots of 1992 in chapter 2, in which she connects Asian American and Black struggles in a postcolonial ordering. Instead of understanding the riots as simply racial conflict, Kim harshly criticizes the government interregnum during the LA Riots by interrogating US militarism and articulating the ways that white supremacy justified the racial construction of Others and pitted them against each other. As Kim notes, “immigrants . . . were forced to fratricide” (p. 62). Kim captures the confluence of military violence and white supremacy over Guatemalan and South Korean immigrants in this context through her analysis of two literary works. The setting of Sa-I-Gu—state absence during the LA Riots—enables the protagonist's revenge killing within the chaos in The Tattooed Soldier.
The third and fourth chapters examine the postcolonial afterlives “as abject ghosts and conjured spirits,” providing perhaps the most interesting analysis of the book. Japanese colonization and US geopolitical dominance over the Korean peninsula has resulted in a lingering han (grief and resentment) among Koreans; however, such violence “is sought to be covered over by a narrative of American heroism and interracial fraternity” (p. 78). To prevent victims’ stories from being covered and closed, Kim gives shape to the analytic “transpacific noir” to draw our attention to “the margins, border zones, and minor subjects” (p. 71), calling for an acknowledgment of American empire—and so a refusal to forget the past trauma. The most intriguing analysis of “afterlives” leads to Kim's conceptualization of bachi (罰 divine punishment) in reading Naomi Hirahara's Summer of the Big Bachi. Kim argues for bachi as “an alternative juridical, ethical, and religious model to think about the afterlives of the atomic bomb” (pp. 82–83). This insight provides new perspective to understand postcolonial afterlives by employing the concept of bachi not only to surpass the limits of existing moral and judicial system but also to problematize the current models for reconciliation.
Continuing the lines of her arguments about disrupting this closure of reconciliation through mourning the dead victims in chapter 4, Kim contributes a gendered reading of death and mourning through an investigation of Teresa Ralli and José Watanabe's Antigona. In this version of the well-known story of Antigone, Kim points out, Antigone is murdered by the state for refusing to stop mourning her dead brother. Kim interprets Antigone's later choice not to become a mother as being “equated to a life lived in death” (p. 107). Death is erased to be disappeared by state terrorism in liberal humanist frameworks. Drawing on Diana Taylor's concept of “percepticide” and “the disappeared” of Peru's civil war, Kim critiques a hypervisibility of state violence relative to the US knowledge production that blinds people and even forces “looking away” to become instinctive (p. 89). The book ends with Kim's figurative “watery graves,” which refers to the bones risen from the seas between Japan and Korea as an unsettling force to protest against Barack Obama's historic visit to Hiroshima in 2016.
Kim gathers disparate material from Asian diasporic literature and culture into a coherent argument of how liberal nation-states silence past violence and police the speaking of loss. Postcolonial Grief covers new ground by providing a new understanding of the biopolitical regime of mourning in the Pacific and connects this biopolitics to theories of grief and melancholia. Kim problematizes the ways that representations of Asian bodies in pain “are sensationalized, aestheticized, and reproduced as desired image in American popular culture and politics” (p. 22). She also insightfully raises the ideas that political violence has constructed the Pacific “as a rejuvenating site for U.S. capitalism” (p. 17) and that the pain of Asian bodies has been forcefully forgotten. This is not a book seeking healing or reconciliation. It contributes a much-needed call to rethink the neglected trauma and pain that has been co-opted by the current neoliberal framework, stressing that “to be healed” is to “accept colonialism as a regular state of being for the colonized” (p. 25). This book allows the dead and disappeared Asian bodies to come to light, and in doing so to destabilize the postcolonial order by resisting being forgotten. It is crucial to remember the dead through forms of mourning and grievance for the purpose of preventing future violence.
Still, further questions linger around the ethics of forgetting: Is forgetting solely tied to appeasement or betrayal? How can we be cautious of fetishizing wounds and woundedness as we mourn the past? In this sense, I wish this book had pursued discussions of mourning loss vis-à-vis stopping violence, discussions of ways that victims might find within the refusal to forget a new start devoid of violence, and discussions that would allow readers to better understand the politics of mourning at both disruptive and constitutive levels. In sum, however, Postcolonial Grief contributes an important work of cautioning the state violence and militarism by beautifully weaving transdisciplinary archives together to produce a richly documented and mind awakening volume.
