In From Shame to Sin, a synthetic work pitched to a general audience, Kyle Harper contends that a shift from a social discourse on sexual morality to a theological discourse effected a fundamental, or radical to use a preferred adjective, transformation of ancient sexual morality — especially among the purportedly overlooked married householders of the Roman world. While summarizing much of the scholarly terrain, the volume seeks to make a particular contribution by its emphasis on social status, demography and the law, though most readers may rather be struck by its insistence on the importance of slavery and prostitution for the Roman sexual economy.
The introduction, ‘From City to Cosmos’, outlines the four core claims of the book. One, the Christianization of sex should be moved from the second century to the sixth; two, the law must be integrated into the study of sexuality, especially its regulation of prostitution; three, a Christian ‘libertarian paradigm’ (4) of moral agency decisively changed sexual ethics; and four, sexuality must be placed within its material frameworks, by which the author seems to mean law and slavery. In unpacking the title with its echoes of the shame and guilt cultures of E. R. Dodds, The Greeks and the Irrational, H. emphasizes that the shift from a socially embedded notion of shame to a theologically situated concept of sin signalled a transformation not merely in the language of sexual morality but also in its structure.
Ch. 1, ‘The Moralities of Sex in the Roman Empire’, surveys the sexual landscape of the Roman world primarily through the lens of the Greek novel, which H. takes to be representative of Roman imperial sexual mores. In particular, H. highlights the acceptance of same-sex eros, asymmetrical gender expectations, the importance of status distinctions (in particular, the vulnerability of slave bodies), the legal regulation of prostitution, and marriage (the inevitable outcome of the novels) as social reproduction. In general, an image of Roman society emerges in which the sexual excesses imagined by those like Suetonius found forbearance if not sanction.
Ch. 2, ‘The Will and the World in Early Christian Sexuality’, outlines sexual morality in Pauline or proto-Orthodox Christianity emphasizing its firm opposition to porneia, a term which covered a number of sexual sins, and all same-sex eros. In this chapter, H. leans chiefly on the apologists’ assertion of moral responsibility against astral determinism and, in particular, on Clement of Alexandria whose work took into account the sexual lives of average married Christians (men at least). For H., Pauline notions of sexuality set early Christians firmly apart from the mainstream of Roman society.
Ch. 3, ‘Church, Society, and Sex in the Age of Triumph’, jumps ahead to the age when Christian sexual morality found expression in law. Though noting that ‘triumph’ was slow, nonetheless Christian sexual doctrine led to the relatively equal condemnation of infidelity for men and women, the strict condemnation of homosexual sex, and limitations on prostitution. Even though an older Augustine would eventually scrap the notions of will that undergirded this Christian discourse on sexuality, a convent named ‘Repentance’ founded by Justinian and Theodora emerges as the symbol of the triumph of a severe Christian sexuality morality.
Ch. 4, ‘Revolutionizing Romance in the Late Classical World’, returns to the world of romance, but in this case charting the ways in which Christian romances (and also virgins in brothels in Jewish texts) played with the genre rules and the sexual morality of the Greek romances. With the emergence of the penitent prostitute as a Christian heroine, sexual morality, or at least its narration, has firmly left classical ideals behind. A brief ‘Conclusion: Sex and the Twilight of Antiquity’ looks quickly at the late antique Latin West where classical notions of sexual honour and shame had seemingly withered away in the face of Christian sexual morality, which, H. argues, really did transform sexuality despite Christian monastic protestations otherwise.
In general, this well-written survey of ancient sexual morality presents a compelling argument sustained by often-keen analysis of the literary sources. However, the choice to collect all the references in a single note at the end of a given paragraph and the lack of a bibliography will render the book less useful for scholars. Even the often-bracing prose can be a bit too much boom and brass: if Roman social discourse on sexuality could also be cosmological and if Christian theological discourse was also social, how radical were the differences; if legal prostitution and slavery persisted, how radical was the transformation of sexuality? Similarly, the avowedly teleological stance of the book (14) risks both flattening the Roman sexual landscape and simplifying Christian sexual discourses. In the end, From Shame to Sin is a well-told tale of ancient Christian sexual morality, smartly drawing on the most dramatic examples from literature while insisting on the importance of slavery, prostitution and the law.
