Since the 1985 International Naqshbandi Conference in Sèvres and the 1990 publication of its voluminous 750-page proceedings, Naqshbandis, there has been a burst of scholarly activity focusing on the Naqshbandi Sufi lineage. Itzchak Weismann's The Naqshbandiyya seeks in one short monograph to give an overview of the Naqshbandiyya worldwide, from the 13th to 21st centuries, in light of this new scholarship. It is a daunting task, one that would challenge even the doyen of Naqshbandi studies, Hamid Algar.
The author has organized the book into nine chapters. He first outlines the contours of a Sufi “brotherhood” before detailing the chronological development of the Naqshbandi lineage from its prehistorical beginnings in the Khwajagan to the Naqshbandiyya named after Bahaʾ al-Din Naqshband (d. 1389 in Bukhara), the Naqshbandiyya-Mujaddidiyya founded in India by Ahmad Sirhindi (d. 1624 in Sirhind), and the Naqshbandiyya-Khalidiyya, initiated by Maulana Khalid (d. 1827 in Damascus). The book concludes with a synopsis of the Naqshbandiyya in the contemporary world. Augmenting this explicitly historical perspective are eighteen helpful lineage diagrams that depict Naqshbandi sublineages of numerous regions (except Indonesia).
The author's goal is to integrate the book into “one analytical narrative” (p. xiii), which he summarizes: “[I]n times of political and social upheaval it was particularly members of the Naqshbandiyya that rose to the task, conceived new ideas for religious reform and renewal, and formed socio-religious revivalist movements to rectify the situation” (p. 11). In fulfilling this task Weismann weaves the threads of Naqshbandi continuity and change into his sometimes cause-and-effect historical approach as the text transitions from one geographical region to another. For modern transformations, in the latter two chapters Weismann seeks to show concealed Naqshbandi connections in modernist/fundamentalist organizations and thinkers (p. 133).
The author generally accomplishes these goals, particularly with respect to the early Naqshbandiyya and the Khalidiyya (which he has studied in most detail). In the early chapters on Sufism he often relies on older sources, that is, Chodkiewicz, Schimmel, and Trimingham; they do not reflect more recent scholarship on the subject, for example, Chittick, Cornell, Ernst, and Meier. Take the treatment of Uwaysi initiations. In Weismann's otherwise exemplary treatment of silsilas, the reader learns that an Uwaysi transmission is a doctrine (p. 24) instead of, correctly, an experience with a disembodied person that has been reported since the time of Uways al-Qarani.
There is only a token mention of Naqshbandi contemplative practices throughout the entire monograph. Silent and vocal remembrance of God, spiritual companionship, and concentration of spiritual energy to facilitate the disciple's progress (tawajjuh), simplified as “attention” in the text (p. 60), are all mentioned but not explained in the context of what Naqshbandis do. This major lacuna is unfortunate given that it has been de rigueur over the last decade for scholarly books dedicated to Sufi lineages to include a chapter on contemplative practices—see Ernst, Huda, and Lawrence, for example. More attention in this area might have averted this awkward statement: “Understanding the mystical teachings of Ahmad Sirhindi is largely a matter of hermeneutics” (p. 56). If only it were this simple.
The weak link in this historically informative book concerns the Naqshbandiyya in India. First, it is idiosyncratic, if not confusing, to identify those attracted to the ideas of Sayyid Ahmad [not Ahmed] Barelvi (d. 1831) as Barelvis (p. 138). When scholars of Indian Islam, such as Barbara Metcalf for example, discuss Barelvis, they are referring to one of the major Muslim groups on the subcontinent, still quite popular, named after Sayyid Ahmad Reza Khan Barelvi (d. 1921), who was vehemently opposed to the writings of Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi! Second, it is difficult to imagine how the Hindu Naqshbandis could be called a movement, much less one of the “Naqshbandi-Mujadiddi endeavors to face the empowerment of the Hindu majority” (p. 147). Third, Maulana Khalid did not reverse “Sirhindi's emphasis on the ‘inner’ aspect of shariʿa” because [Khalid] “cherished the [classical] sciences of jurisprudence and theology” (p. 89). Indeed, Sirhindi was quite concerned with both the inner and outer aspects of shariʿa and creed. Sirhindi's 536 letters often emphasize minute outer details of the shariʿa and the entire letter 67 in volume two of these Collected Letters details nineteen “outer” points of Sunni Maturidi creed.
Weismann notes that scholarly research on the Indian Naqshbandiyya “in recent years. . .has almost come to a standstill” (p. 51). Yet, since 1985 Iqbal Mujaddidi has produced a corpus of scholarship in Indian Naqshbandi studies. His latest project is editing the Persian original of Maqamat-i Ma-sumiyya (Mir Safar Ahmad Maʿsumi, 4 vols., Lahore: Diya al-Qurʾan Publications, 2004), with more than 2,000 pages on Muhammad Maʿsum (d. 1668), Ahmad Sirhindi's principal successor, and the Mujaddidiyya of the following generation. Much of this compendium is his Urdu translation, footnotes, and scholarly analysis. An eleven-volume encyclopaedia (almost 7,500 pages) of the Indian Mujaddidiyya (Muhammad Masʿud Ahmad, ed., Jahan-i Imam-i Rabbani: Mujaddid-i Alf-i Thana Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi, 11 vols., Karachi: Imam Rabbani Foundation, 2005–2007) has also been published. Although many of the articles in this tour de force are not scholarly—or simply translate into Urdu Naqshbandi research in Western European languages—the scholarly study of the Indian Naqshbandiyya is far from coming to a standstill.
Overall, The Naqshbandiyya does summarize and give an overview of the worldwide lineage in a readable manner. The text is nicely interspersed with twenty-three pictures of individual Naqshbandis, their shrines, and activities, apparently photographed by the author. Given the difficulty of writing a book like this, it is a lot to expect new analytical perspectives. However, when Weismann mentions that the Khalidiyya did not expand further west to Africa, India, or Central Asia (p. 101), one wonders how this situation came to pass given the order's rapid spread elsewhere.
Weismann has made an admirable contribution to Sufi studies, useful for nonspecialists, especially political scientists, anthropologists, and others interested in Sufism. Let us hope that many libraries order it and that an affordable paperback version is published soon.
