I. Introduction
‘At the heart of the particular problem of a unique impartial resolution of the perfectly just society is the possible sustainability of plural and competing reasons for justice, all of which have claims to impartiality and which nevertheless differ from – and rival – each other. Let me illustrate the problem with an example in which you have to decide which of three children – Anne, Bob and Carla – should get a flute about which they are quarrelling.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 12–13)
Each child in Amartya Sen's example has a reason why he or she should get the flute. Anne is the only one who can play it; Bob has no toys; and Carla spent time making the flute: utilitarian theory supports Anne, economic egalitarian theory supports Bob and libertarian theory supports Carla (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 13–14). Each basis to entitlement is valid and alone would be sufficient reason for an allocation. The point that Sen makes in using this ‘three children and one flute’ scenario throughout his treatise on justice is that each of the children has compelling arguments in support of their entitlement to the flute: one child's reason why he or she should possess it is as good as the next child's, and different resolutions could be effected that are equally valid and, dare the word be used, just (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 14–15).
This conundrum offered by Amartya Sen forces a consideration of how to value which child should get the flute; or, more pertinently for purposes of this paper, what is the just decision for these children? The answer seems to depend on the position that is taken about the definition of justice. Sen's approach to justice challenges the normative conception of justice flowing from state-sponsored, rule-based judicial institutions. Sen questions why an imposed decision such as one delivered by a judicial tribunal should result in justice whereas an agreement between the three children regarding their selection as to who is best worthy to receive the flute would not result in justice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 396). It is this premise that Sen explores in his work, and it is his theories on justice that are applied in this paper to determine whether the private dispute-resolution process of mediation can result in a just resolution for its participants. In other words, can the agreement reached consensually between parties through a mediation process result in justice for the parties as would an imposed decision delivered by a judicial tribunal?
II. The normative landscape of the mediation process
A normative conception of justice is particularly acute in the private dispute-resolution field and, in particular, in relation to the mediation process. The presence of justice or the perceived lack thereof provides fodder for debate in the literature. Explorations of justice in mediation have tended to be positivist in nature or relying on a legal consciousness analysis. Genn and Fiss, for example, argue that there is no justice in private processes of dispute resolution, including mediation (Genn, Reference Genn2012a; Reference Genn2012b; Reference Genn2010; Fiss, Reference Fiss1984; Reference Fiss2009).Footnote 1 For them, justice can be delivered only by state law through its juridical institutions – very much a Rawlsian conception (Rawls, Reference Rawls1971/2009; Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 78–85, 135).Footnote 2 Others argue that there is some form of justice working in mediation such as popular, restorative or procedural justice or access to justice, all of which offer a way to attach a conception of justice to the mediation process (Merry et al., Reference Merry and Milner1993; Ewick et al., Reference Ewick and Silbey1992; Reference Ewick and Silbey1998; Blake et al., Reference Blake, Browne and Sime2012; Herrman, Reference Herrman2006; Hanycz, Reference Hanycz2008).Footnote 3 These forms of justice do not satisfy the contention that justice can be delivered only through the application of normative rules by judicial institutions of state. While this remains an area of controversy within the mediation scholarship, the relevance of an exploration into the ability of mediation to deliver justice and the nature of that justice lies in the positioning of mediation in civil justice. Mediation is no longer merely an informal dispute-resolution process – it is often part and parcel of an overarching civil justice system in which settlement has become a key objective.Footnote 4
This institutionalisation of mediation in civil justice supports Abel's assertion that the state has moved into the private realm of dispute resolution by encouraging private disputing processes (Abel, Reference Abel and Abel1982).Footnote 5 As such, the issue of whether mediation delivers justice is an important one for proponents and critics alike. It is a debatable one, as noted above, and dependent on the form of justice at issue. The search for justice in mediation is stymied by the manner in which the issue is often framed by a legal view of justice, where justice is based on positivist theories of law. In that framework, given its nature as a private consensual resolution process, the argument that mediation cannot deliver that form of justice is not surprising. Such a framework, however, offers too restrictive a worldview.
III. Sen's justice framework for mediation
This paper seeks to challenge the current positivist paradigm through which mediation's ability to deliver justice is assessed. It explores the question of whether the mediation process can deliver a substantive form of justice that is comparable to the justice delivered by the juridical institution. It does so through Sen's conception of justice and, more particularly, its elements of objective reasoning, rational choice and freedom of choice. It will conclude that, while mediation may not in its current form deliver a substantive form of justice, it has the possibility of achieving it. It is this possibility that will elevate mediation's value as a dispute-resolution process.
Amartya Sen's theory of justice allows this possibility. Through the integration of (1) objective reasoning, (2) rational choice and (3) freedom of choice as forming the basis for a just decision, Sen's theory of justice rejects the positivist view of reliance on the just institution and, in particular, the Rawlsian construction of ideal justice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 78–86). These three elements create a framework that is pluralistic in nature, offering a view of justice that is not dependent on legal conceptions nor ideal notions of justice yet offering a form of justice that is substantive in nature. It takes a wholistic approach where restrictive categories of description are eschewed in favour of an all-encompassing theory of justice. As Twining states, Sen is not interested in the ideals of justice, but is more interested in what can be achieved in the real world (Twining, Reference Twining2011, p. 69). It offers an opportunity to move away from the law in the search for justice in mediation and to answer the conundrum described above: why should the judge's decision be just but not the decision of the actors to the dispute?
IV. Data collection of the mediation process
This examination of the mediation process and its ability to deliver justice relies on ethnographic data obtained about the mediation process through a participant-observation research project reported in an earlier work where the author was a participant-observer at a British organisation offering conflict-resolution services (‘the Organisation’).Footnote 6 An ethnographic study is one where ‘thick description’ of data collection leads to an interpretative exercise of the phenomenon observed’ (Geertz, Reference Geertz1973, pp. 16, 20). It is not the collection of data for quantitative purposes, such as attempting to establish a preponderance of evidence. Rather, it exposes patterns of action and structures for qualitative study. Further, the field is often not entered with a specific purpose. Indeed, the original project was entered to seek what Malinowski refers to as the imponderabilia of life: ‘… there is a series of phenomena of great importance which cannot possibly be recorded by questioning or computing documents, but have to be observed in their full actuality. Let us call them the imponderabilia of actual life’ (Malinowski, Reference Malinowski1922/1984, p. 18). In other words, there was no specific search for justice in the data as it was being observed. It is for purposes of this paper that the ethnographic data have been reviewed again for what they say about the mediation process in relation to justice. The data herein report on the lived experience of the participants to the process.
Over a continuous period of twelve months in 2006 and 2007, the author attended thirty-eight civil and commercial mediations conducted through the Organisation as a participant-observer. The mediations attended were randomly selected subject to three conditions: the author was available on the date the mediation was scheduled, the mediation involved a civil or commercial dispute, and the mediation was within a two-hour train-ride radius from London, England. The identity of the mediator was not relevant in this random selection process.
The mediators observed were mediators who had been accredited by the Organisation after successful completion of the Organisation's training programme of forty hours including lecture, role-play study and assessment.Footnote 7 They were trained according the Organisation's mediation model, which includes (1) the preparation phase involving the initial contact to mediate and preliminary communication with the parties, dealing with documentary exchange and learning about the history of the dispute; (2) the opening phase dealing with the arrival of parties at the mediation, private pre-mediation meetings with the parties, and the opening joint sessions at which the parties make opening statements; (3) the exploration phase involving private meetings and/or joint sessions the aims of which are to build relationships and trust, information exchange, clarification of issues and interests, and ‘preparing the way for settlement negotiations’; (4) the bargaining phase during which the mediator facilitates movement by working creatively, negotiating, overcoming barriers, coaching the parties and ‘shaping’ the settlement; and (5) the concluding phase dealing with the finalisation of the settlement agreement (De Girolamo, Reference De Girolamo2013, pp. 68–71).Footnote 8 This mediation framework is used by other organisations for civil and commercial mediations as well as for court-connected mediations; as such, it is a common one that continues to be relevant today.Footnote 9
The observed mediators were a mix of practising and non-practising lawyers (reflective of the majority) and other non-lawyer professionals having particular subject-matter expertise. They were senior and experienced mediators, and were members of the Organisation's panel of mediators subject to the Organisation's code of conduct for mediators.Footnote 10 The mediations involved civil and commercial disputes, often at some stage of litigation or contemplated litigation.Footnote 11 Additionally, during most of the mediations, parties in dispute attended with legal counsel.
The author attended these mediations primarily as an independent researcher and also as an assistant mediator. Parties were aware of the purpose of the author's attendance as a researcher. The label of assistant mediator is somewhat of a misnomer, as very minor administrative tasks were performed in this role such as taking notes and acting as a sounding board to the mediator during private times. The lead mediator had full responsibility for the conduct of the mediation. Detailed notes were taken continuously throughout the process about the process, about what parties said during the process, their gestures and their behaviour. As this was an ethnographic endeavour, there were no guidelines to follow in determining what to note – the pen rarely stopped. The role of observer permitted the author to step back from the process in order to see the process.Footnote 12
Sen's approach to justice fits well with the ethnographic enterprise, where parochialism is shed for an expansive, creative approach to investigation. It is justice as revealed by the data and conceived by Sen that provides the focus for this investigation. The aim is twofold: to change the justice narrative from one of restrictive normative rules to expansive pluralistic conceptions and, correspondingly, to change the mediation narrative as to expectations surrounding its ability to deliver justice.
V. The mediation process and Sen's Idea of Justice
5.1 Introduction to Sen
Amartya Sen rejects the notion of ideal justice premised on the just institution – what he refers to as transcendental institutionalism (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 410; Reference Sen2011). Sen pits his theory of justice against that of Rawls, who talks about societal institutions as being the source of ideal justice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 25). Sen says that, for Rawls, political and societal institutions of the sovereign state provide justice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 78–80). Such theory invokes the social contract of rules and arrangements for the attainment of justice. Justice is the product of the legal system through its courts and legal rules, as established by the state founded on the social contract.
The Sen theory, on the other hand, focuses on social realisations and human lives; it is one of social choice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 410–412). Sen's view is based on the practicalities of human life and a recognition of the plurality of choices and outcomes. Most importantly, it is a view that is not premised on law: it rejects the institution, including its rules and actors. In other words, justice is not juridical in nature: it is not about the law nor what the law determines is just.
Neither, however, does Sen descend to a popularist view of justice, which has equally been the focus of justice arguments within the private realm of dispute resolution; he rejects the notion of popular justice just as he rejects the notion of institutional justice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 274, 284–286).Footnote 13 Using the experience of pain and medical policy as an example to support his rejection of popular justice, Sen illustrates the way in which subjective views are not helpful to well-being: when people are in pain, one cannot measure the pain experienced. Further, if people are experiencing pain and do not articulate this state of being, it does not mean they are not in pain, but it does mean that doctors cannot apply medication to lessen the pain. Sen says there are many factors that may limit the decision on whether one feels pain or whether to articulate experiencing pain such as culture, education and custom; merely because one does not feel or articulate pain does not mean there is no pain. As a result, one cannot rely on the self-assessment of pain by an individual as a determinant for setting medical policy.
For Sen, a subjective evaluation of people's well-being cannot be a standard for justice (not that he uses the word here); he refers to pain, pleasure and happiness as being subjective standards that are irrelevant in the determination of the well-being of society as a whole (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 286). Arguably, this applies to his theory of justice: subjective views are coloured by people's experiences, their culture and their customs, and cannot be translated into decisions that advance justice claims. Individuals become acclimatised to deprivation, accepting injustices as normal; therefore, subjective views cannot be markers of justice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 274).
In Sen's conception, justice is objective, impartial and rational. It is also plural in its recognition of the diversity of values espoused by individuals and, as such, it is evolutionary and not decisive (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 89, 110, 200, 125). It does not rest on juridical conceptions of justice or on the personal satisfaction stories of actors. For Sen, through objective reasoning, rational choice and freedom of choice, a good agreement can be reached in terms of what he refers to as ‘the reasoned judgment of justice’ (Sen, Reference Sen2011, p. 325). These elements are not one-dimensional: objective reasoning needs a degree of impartiality, rational choice requires sustained reasoning, and freedom of choice requires capability and fairness of process.
5.2 The mediation process
How, then, is this relevant to mediation and the quest for justice in the process? The nature of the mediation process differs from that of the civil adjudicative process, which is a rule-based, public and institutional process of decision-making by an arbiter selected by the state. Mediation is a private self-determinative process, where a third party is invited into the process by the parties to assist them to achieve a resolution of their dispute, the responsibility for which rests solely with the parties in dispute. In mediation, there is a convergence of rules and process on one hand and structures and processes on the other hand. First, rules provide the basis for claims that create the dispute and are used to influence outcome. Outcome, however, is dependent on social interaction that occurs during the process. Second, there is also the convergence of structure and process: mediation offers a structure of dispute-resolution processing and operates within the larger societal structure of a rule-centred juridical institution (De Girolamo, Reference De Girolamo2013, pp. 15–16; Reference De Girolamo2012, pp. 122–123).
Mediation is institutional in nature, where rules, process and structure collide within a civil justice paradigm. It is this nature of mediation, both as an institution itself and often situated within a state juridical institution, that creates an expectation that mediation delivers justice, triggering a debate as to whether it does deliver justice and, if so, in what form. Institutional and thus ideal justice is equated to third-party decision-making in the neutral and open forum of a state court. Mediation is consensual party-led decision-making in a private forum and thus arguably not capable of delivering such justice.Footnote 14 The reliance on legalism, however, is too limiting. To explore justice through such a lens will inevitably lead to a conclusion that mediation does not provide substantive justice given the nature of its process as a consensual, private one and the fact there is no third-party decision-maker. Sen's theory, however, offers the mediation process the possibility of justice by moving the discussion beyond a Rawlsian model of the just institution and offering a conception of justice that is both substantive and non-juridical. This will be explored through the application of Sen's three elements to the mediation process, analysed through ethnographic data.
VI. Sen's three elements and their application to the mediation process
6.1 Objective reasoning
Objective reasoning, says Sen, requires an open mind about information, reflection, interaction and debate (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 40, 49). Debate must occur where the perspective of others is received and acknowledged (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 337, 162, 88). On a macro level, Sen refers to this element as one of public reasoning:
‘Public reasoning is so important in the approach I am trying to present, that to make room for it as a valued ability of a group of people – to speak to each other, to discuss pros and cons, to scrutinize together – must be very central.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2011, p. 334)Footnote 15
Dialogue through reasoned communication is one element of objective reasoning. The reasoned encounter must occur on an impartial basis. It is to the impartial outsider that Sen turns, fuelled by a need to move away from parochial values and understandings because they prevent proper assessments of justice. Justice, according to Sen, cannot come from narrow conceptions of perspective.
6.1.1 Discursiveness
Communication and dialogue are important elements for the objective reasoning criteria of Sen's theory of justice: in particular, they require people to be open-minded about information, to interact with others, to debate and to reflect, all suggesting a discursive quality to the formulation of objective reasoning. When one looks at the process of mediation, these characteristics are evident: all parties discuss their positions and interests during the initial joint session; parties tell their individual stories to the mediator in private meetings; mediators relay information and give advice to the parties; and parties interact throughout the process.Footnote 16
For mediators, ‘mediation is the opportunity to hear what the other side is telling [the] client; there are two sides to every story; the same facts yield different views and to hear the views is quite important’.Footnote 17 Furthermore, the private meeting is for dialogue – to air things that parties did not want to say to the other, but wanted to say to the mediator.Footnote 18 Mediators make clear to the parties at the beginning of the mediation session to ‘make sure you have your say; it is really important for you to have your say … [and] hear what they have to say and for you to know what you need’.Footnote 19 While mediators may not believe that solicitors will agree on the issues, the exchange between parties is important ‘because clients need to know the other side's case’.Footnote 20 Another says: ‘We learned a lot.’Footnote 21 For the mediator in that case, face-to-face communication is key:
‘Sometimes lawyers come here hating each other and that, sometimes, correspondence is so bad that they would not want to place it before a judge and then they come to the mediation and are civil. It is the social act that is sometimes necessary.’Footnote 22
One mediator talks about the mediator role:
‘[The] key skill of [the] mediator is to put himself in the shoes of parties and do this to enable parties to do this too; if you could get the parties to view the dispute through the eyes of the opponent it is hard to be in dispute and it helps to settle.’Footnote 23
Another mediator talks to the parties about the need to ‘have a debate while together; to get it out on the table’.Footnote 24 Another tells the party that this is the ‘one chance to eyeball them before court. Take advantage of it and say what you want. Be commercial, constructive. Get it off your chest’.Footnote 25 For one party, there was no prejudice in ‘coming here today to listen to what you [the opposing party] have to say and come to resolution and if it is not to our satisfaction, we will take further steps’.Footnote 26 One counsel, after setting out what is important to his client, says to the other before discussing legal positions: ‘I need to go through [this] so it's not palm tree justice – I am going through the building blocks.’Footnote 27
All participants in the mediation process, including mediator, disputants and legal representatives, have the opportunity to talk about the dispute. This is seen both subjectively in their articulated views and objectively through the interactions that occur during the process. The ethnographic data show that positions are bantered about; interests and motivations are discussed; facts are relayed; and evidence is challenged. It is all about discursive social interaction around a table. In mediation, decision-making occurs on the basis of what each party knows in relation to the dispute. As one mediator says to a defendant: ‘As you get more and more information, the better able you are to judge what is the right thing to do.’Footnote 28
Does this social interaction of the mediation process meet the criteria offered by Sen? Is there enlightenment from divergent views? Is there comparative analysis? Are there social realisations? Sen speaks of the need for the assessment of justice to occur through interactive dialogue. In his formulation of justice, Sen speaks to the openness of decision-making, which is not reliant on institutional rules and actors (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 337). For Sen, it is important that parties talk to one another, to learn from others, to consider the other's perspective so as to make adjustments to perceived alternatives and their rankings, and thus be able to reach a ‘reasoned judgment of justice’ (Sen, Reference Sen2011, p. 325). We see in the shape of the mediation process and through its actors’ voices that mediation seeks enlightenment from divergent views, offers comparative analysis and provides social realisations. Talk, talk and more talk is a staple of the process,Footnote 29 meeting Sen's criteria in this regard.
Discursiveness alone, however, is not enough to establish the first element of objective reasoning; the second – ‘impartiality’ – needs now to be considered.
6.1.2 Open impartiality
For Sen, parochial views must be overcome for justice to be achieved. Personal views are insufficient to construct justice. He says: ‘Our entire understanding of the world, it can be argued, is thoroughly dependent on the perceptions we can have and the thoughts we can generate, given the kind of creatures we are’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 169–170). In other words, we depend on our human capacities and an understanding of the world based on our experiences. However, this does not mean that we cannot expand beyond them. Sen's anti-parochial voice offers the opportunity to move beyond what he sees to be positional subjectivity. It is the perspective of the outsider that is required to ensure the implications of actions or inactions are fully understood. Sen refers to this requirement as ‘open impartiality’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 123, 130, 144, 405). Initially, it is not clear whether Sen requires an impartial judge for this requirement (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 401). Given his position on transcendental institutionalism, however, it is unlikely that Sen would require such a figure to be central to his theory of justice. Judges are institutional actors and Sen has moved away from reliance on the just institution. Given Sen's propensity against the social contract theory of the just institution while requiring open impartiality, it would seem that the outsider is not an institutional judicial voice; it is an anti-parochial voice. The anti-parochial voice comes from an outsider – a person who is outside the community and who helps to expand our thinking about the way we see and experience things (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 123–130). Sen refers to this as the requirement of open impartiality.
As regards the mediation process, Sen's outsider is arguably found in the persona of the mediator. In mediation, the parties make decisions based on their view of the case as enlightened by the mediation process. As noted by ethnographic data, the mediators portray themselves as a neutral and impartial observer and as an outsider to the parties. Specifically, we see that they have regard to their ‘neutral’ function as having no interest in the dispute and no opinionFootnote 30; not favouring either partyFootnote 31; or being impartial.Footnote 32 They see themselves sitting outside of the dispute, forcing the parties to consider objective views of their positions. They portray themselves as the dispassionate voice or the disinterested bystander. As one mediator states: ‘Mediation enables the neutral to reflect on their [the parties’] interests.’Footnote 33 These self-reflexive views of mediator operating as impartial third party facilitating the dialogue between the parties and positioning them towards resolution are generally supported in the mediation literature. Evident in many definitions of this mediated process is the description of the third-party intervener as being neutral, impartial or independent, having no interest in the parties, the dispute or its outcome (Moore, Reference Moore1996, pp. 51–53, 197–198; Lang and Taylor, Reference Lang and Taylor2000, pp. 161–162, 179–181; Nauss Exon, Reference Nauss Exon2007–2008; Roberts, Reference Roberts2007, p. 69; Roberts and Palmer, Reference Roberts and Palmer2005, p. 197; Blake et al., Reference Blake, Browne and Sime2012, p. 177). Some argue that the mediator must be independent, impartial and without bias.Footnote 34 He is there to assist the parties in their negotiation as a facilitator in what might be described as an anodyne manner.Footnote 35
The data on this point, however, say otherwise yet, interestingly, provide additional support for the concept of the Sen outsider via a different iteration from this self-reflexive view by mediators about their perceived neutrality or impartiality. The data disclose active mediators who evolve through multiple identities during the course of the mediation process. Through these identity shifts, the mediator takes on opposing party voice and adviser voice in addition to his or her facilitator voice, all adding distinct outsider views to the process.Footnote 36 Arguably, these identities provide a fortified societal voice: we have the third party who has been invited into the dispute taking on more than a perceived third-party ‘neutral’ role and actively participating in the dispute from many perspectives. Traditional concepts of impartiality or neutrality expected from mediators as described in the literature (as earlier noted) may arguably be lost as a result of these interventions. However, for purposes of Sen's justice framework and the concept of ‘open impartiality’, these evolving identities serve to strengthen this view of mediator as outsider. The evolving identities push the parties to consider all aspects of their position and to move beyond parochial boundaries they have established for their dispute.
The mediator voices, therefore, take the dispute beyond the boundaries set by its actors. As Sen states, the impartial spectator is a ‘device for reasoned self-scrutiny’ explaining as follows:
‘There may not, of course, be any really impartial spectator in the world, but we can persuade ourselves to look at the values and priorities that others have, and then examine them all with as much objectivity as we can bring into the exercise. Attempts at being objective can be helped by our putting on other people's hats – even their identities – and asking ourselves: how would our choices, our values look to them.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2012, p. 104)
Sen requires this form of impartiality through the outsider's anti-parochial voice – the impartial spectator draws on the perspective of others and keeps parties’ values under scrutiny (Sen, Reference Sen2012, p. 107). Through the mediator's evolving identity as party, adviser and third-party facilitator, a certain objectivity is forced upon the parties.
Furthermore, the mediator may not be the only actor to provide the anti-parochial voice. The data also suggest that mediators view the legal representatives attending mediation as objective outsiders.Footnote 37 In one case, the lack of counsel led to lack of resolution and therefore the opportunity to achieve justice, in whatever form:
‘Here there was a problem. The parties were extremely subjective of their position and there was no touchstone of objectivity, which lawyers provide. No touchstone of saying there are risks and cost consequences … . Lawyers would work with the mediator and reinforce the message of the mediator. This wasn't here.’Footnote 38
Legal representatives can play a significant role in mediations. They are often present during the process. While many cannot see beyond their own contrived arguments, others provide a sounding board to their clients and become the voice of reason.Footnote 39 The presence of these legal representatives arguably provides additional outsider voice.
It is this concept of open impartiality together with public reasoning that comprise objective reasoning, the first requisite element of Sen's concept of justice.
Having met the requirement of discursiveness and open impartiality, it would appear that the mediation process offers the opportunity for objective reasoning to occur in decision-making. The second requirement in Sen's theory of justice – rational choice – must now be explored.
6.2 Rational choice
The decision must also reflect rational choice, the second element of Sen's theory.
Sen describes rational choice as a choice based ‘on reasoning that we can reflectively sustain if we subject them to critical scrutiny’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 180). It exists where decision-makers have critically analysed their choices and the decision is supported by sustainable reason (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 180–181). Sen recognises too the diverse motivations behind decisions and the alternative choices available to individuals, all of which can be supported rationally (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 183, 187). As a result, rational choice cannot be predicted (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 183). However, as long as decisions can be justified, notwithstanding the motivations underlying them, the refusal of other alternative choices does not mean justice is lacking in the choice made (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 200). As Sen states:
‘… we have different types of competing reasons of justice, and it may be impossible to reject them all with the exception of just one set of complementary principles that cohere nicely and entirely with each other. Even when a person does have a clearly favourite priority, such priorities may vary from person to person, and it may be difficult for someone to reject altogether possibly well-defended reasons to which others give priority.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 200)
Rational choice involves the prioritisation of values by the parties. As Sen says, people value things differently and accordingly there is more than one way to come to a decision.
Consider the Sen example of three children and their flute. All three have justification for wanting the flute and being given the flute:
‘Indeed, even entirely impartial judges, who are not moved by vested interest or by personal eccentricity, may see the force of several disparate reasons of justice in a case like this, and they may well end up differing from each other on what decisions should be taken, since the competing arguments all have some claim to impartial support.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 200)
A valuation of what is important to a party must be undertaken. In mediation, this can be the need to be heard, the need to challenge, the need to be acknowledged, the need for vindication or the need to be told by a decision-maker that a party is right.Footnote 40 For example, in one mediation, an apology was the value sought rather than economic gratification.Footnote 41 One reason may be as valid as another – the choice is personal.
Often, the choice is a financial one. Mediators commonly talk to the parties about making ‘reasoned’ offers and being able to explain the offers.Footnote 42 This is about both the justification for and acceptance of an offer. In this regard, the data show that parties in mediation seem to justify offers by relying on the existence of litigation risk. Parties are made to reflect on the litigation risk they face if they pursue their disputes through the courts including the uncertainty of litigation, the cost of litigation and the time involved in litigation. For example:
‘We are saying here we have a very strong case. Yes, we could win. Yes, we could lose. It is not a cut and dry case. There is litigation risk. If they are thinking of a large amount of money, we will need to walk out. I don't have a large amount of money; it is all gone. To pay even the amount given is a struggle and I would need time to pay.’Footnote 43
For this party, rational choice in mediation required weighing litigation risk against the offer.
Parties have their personal motivations and alternative choices available to them in the pursuit of resolution. During mediation, the third party works with the parties to assist them with understanding their choices, many of which provide valid reasons why parties would choose to either resolve their dispute at mediation or continue the dispute through to an adjudicative process. Choices at mediation are made in relation to what has been discussed throughout the process: parties analyse the options available to themFootnote 44; they ensure that their position is clearly stated to the other party and to themselvesFootnote 45; and they make decisions on the basis of a critical analysis of their alternatives. Decisions are also subject to critical analysis through mediator and legal representative participation. The elements of objective reasoning (as discussed in the previous section) provide the foundational underpinning of rational choice. As long as these decisions can be justified while recognising the pluralism of values that can be attributed to the decision, then rational choice would be realised.
6.3 Freedom of choice
The final of the three elements comprising Sen's theory of justice is freedom of choice. Freedom of choice is necessary for the realisation of rational choice, invoking two concepts: capability opportunities and fairness of process (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 232, 296). Capability is the actual ability of people to choose: it focuses on the ability of the individual to make use of the choices available to them. As Sen points out, a theoretical ability is no ability if it cannot be realised as a practical ability.
Capability is not the only factor in assessing justice however; there must be fairness in the process of choice, says Sen. Justice cannot be interested only with
‘overall opportunities and advantages of individuals in a society. The subject of fair process and a fair deal goes beyond individuals’ overall advantages into other – especially procedural – concerns, and these concerns cannot be adequately addressed through concentrating only on capabilities.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 297)
And, further:
‘A theory of justice – or more generally an adequate theory of normative social choice – has to be alive to both the fairness of the processes involved and to the equity and efficiency of the substantive opportunities that people can enjoy.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 296)
In other words, it is not only about the individual's ability to realise opportunities; it is also about the social process leading to the decision. Freedom of choice is about individual capability within a social construct.
6.3.1 Capability
The importance of the freedom-of-choice element of Sen's theory and its connection to rational choice lies in the opportunity of an individual to pursue her goals: any decision must be as a result of a party's free choice. It is not sufficient that the individual attains his objective – it must come from his free choice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 228). For example, a person does not have free choice if someone requires or demands her to choose a particular objective even if that objective is the desired objective because there would be no freedom in the process of that choice (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 229–230). Freedom of choice refers to the opportunity to take action and the ability to do so. To illustrate his point, Sen uses the example of two people who have stopped eating: one is a person fasting and the other is a malnourished person. Both people are starving – one of his own accord and the other through circumstance. Sen says that you cannot take the outcome of starving and say it is the same for both people because only one has made the choice to starve (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 237). The other has not and therefore does not have capability of action in the Sen sense. Justice lies in the opportunity of choice and the ability to choose. Essentially, this requirement appears to be about self-determination: the capability of an individual to make decisions and thus be able to choose their destiny rather than being given a destiny not of their choosing.
In addition to this quality of self-determination, Sen requires social perspective and public engagement for there to be true capability. Regarding social perspective, individuals decide on the basis of individual capacities, but are influenced by the values of and relations with society (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 245). As a result, capability is not linked only to individualism: society is connected to the execution of that individualism. Sen seems to be saying that society needs to play a role in the exercise of capability (Sen, Reference Sen2013, p. 311). People do not make decisions in a vacuum: social influences impact individual decision-making (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 245).
In applying this to mediation, it may be expected that a social perspective is lacking given the private nature of the process. On the contrary, the social and normative framework of mediation is very influential in parties’ decision-making. De Girolamo, in her study of legal culture, found:
‘[Mediation is] a dispute resolution process that allows parties to pursue their own personal pragmatic solution through a social process infused with legal under and overtones. Parties have the freedom to choose self-determination instead of imposed order, yet self-determination exists within a blended framework of social process and legal rules, norms and structures. … The references to rules and the litigation process throughout the social exchange impact the actions and decisions of the parties. They cannot avoid them nor do they practically avoid them for all their assertions that they are doing so. They work on the level of legal rules and structures: the law of the books and the structure of the adjudication process is a formidable presence in the discourse between these two parties. They are used to threaten, increase bargaining power or persuade: whatever the purpose, they exist and form a fundamental basis to the interaction of these parties. It is not social interaction alone that leads to resolution: it is law with all its trappings through the guise of social interaction. The social interaction at the heart of negotiated order is achieved through invocation of legal rules, norms and structures. … law permeates every level of the social interaction that occurs. It compels action, it constrains action and it determines outcome despite its non-adjudicatory nature. Social and legal interaction provides the source of legal culture: it is law as it impacts conduct of everyday life.’ (De Girolamo, Reference De Girolamo2012, pp. 143–144)
It is the convergence of rules, norms, structures and process that connects the individual to the social in mediation. Societal institutional values of law impact the process: individuals make decisions in the face of the legal values espoused by the society in which they live. Their act of self-determination is guided by social influences they are subjected to.
While Sen requires social perspective, Sen is against a view that encapsulates only society's view of what is good and just. The freedom-of-choice element of Sen's theory recognises that decisions are made within a context of social influences while focusing on individual capability. The individual must participate and determine what is good for themselves. However, to protect against a subjective view of the justice experience, capability also requires public engagement. Individuals sometimes cannot see beyond their state – they accept their fate and live with it (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 274–275). Public engagement assists individuals to move beyond a restricted view of their capabilities by engaging in objective reasoning and experiencing the open impartiality of outsiders (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 245).Footnote 46 Objective reasoning then becomes inextricably linked to capability through the concept of public engagement, which occurs through its elements.
In mediation, do the parties who accept the terms of an agreement they have negotiated see beyond a self-reflexive and limited worldview of their position in coming to their decision? Recall from the earlier discussion that the mediator's interactions within the process are multidimensional: the mediator becomes the anti-parochial voice as discussed earlier. This is realised when the mediator takes an active role in the process, taking on several identities during the course of the mediation, evolving from party voice, party adviser voice and third-party facilitator voice (De Girolamo, Reference De Girolamo2013, pp. 149–152, 200–205). Arguably, this fact of the mediator as an active participant, taking on the role of the third-party intervener, party and party adviser represents Sen's societal voice and, together with the social influence of normative values on decision-making, help establish social perspective and public engagement in the process of free choice.
Turning now to the concept of self-determination as a feature of capability, mediation appears to offer freedom of choice in the party's movement towards resolution. Arguably, parties have the freedom of choice with respect to both process and outcome. Mediation is voluntary and parties are invited to the table – they are not coerced into engaging fully in the process.Footnote 47 Furthermore, it is a process steeped in the philosophy of self-determination where parties are actualising a choice by first participating in the mediation process and second by determining whether to resolve their dispute (e.g. Kovach, Reference Kovach2015, p. 773; Nolan-Haley, Reference Nolan-Haley2015, p. 737).
This self-determinative nature of mediation seems to satisfy Sen's capability requirement. However, when we look at the data of the actors’ experiences, we see that capability is not straightforward. In one mediation, for example, the mediator was of the view there was no justice in the agreement and that the settlement was ‘not the best or fairest settlement he ever saw’ because he felt that there was a power imbalance favouring one party over another with the stronger party taking advantage of a mistake made by the other party.Footnote 48 For this mediator, there was no real capability in reaching the outcome. In another case, a claimant accepted a settlement because the costs of litigation were too great. For this claimant, ‘I am walking away with less today than if I fight for what I know is right in a year’.Footnote 49 He also says that he was ‘outmaneuvered’ by the defendant.Footnote 50 The lack of capability may not always be so overtly observed, however. In one case involving an insurance company seeking repayment of monies paid under a policy of insurance from the widower of an insured, sympathy for the widower appeared to impact decision-making, resulting in a favourable outcome for the widower.Footnote 51
Capability may not always present even though the outcome is self-determinative. The ability of mediation to meet the element of capability in Sen's theory of justice runs into difficulty when the self-determinative nature of mediation and the ability of the parties to choose freely become stymied due to factors at play during the process, such as economic, cultural, legal or emotional power, where such power or lack thereof influences choice. As the data suggest, these types of factors can put into question the ability of parties to choose an outcome.
Some might argue, however, that a decision made in the face of the exertion of economic, cultural, legal or emotional power, for example, during the course of the process may still be recognised as a justifiable rational decision. Freedom of choice may continue to be realised through rational choice in that the rational choice has recognised the limitations to the opportunities available due to such factors in the choice made. This raises the question of whether something can be a rational choice on the one hand, but not a free choice on the other. According to Sen, the decision may be the outcome of rational choice, but a rational choice may not necessarily be a free choice where the element of true capability is missing. Capability is needed within the rational choice that is made. Without it, there would be no justice in the choice. In mediation, the ability to exercise freedom of choice by a party in decision-making may be restricted as a result of the exercise of actual or perceived power by the other.Footnote 52 As a result, it is this aspect of capability, or the lack thereof, that may create a barrier to attaining a substantive form of justice in mediation.
6.3.2 Fairness of process
Freedom of choice is not only about capability; it is also about fairness of process. It must be reflected in both process (fairness of process) and outcome (the result of capability). In this regard, Sen is interested in the comprehensive outcome that is reached as opposed to a culmination outcome. Comprehensive outcomes are concerned about the process leading to the achievement of the outcome as well as the outcome itself, whereas culmination outcome is concerned solely with the outcome obtained, without regard to process (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 230). Sen says:
‘… the idea of freedom also respects our being free to determine what we want, what we value and ultimately what we decide to choose. The concept of capability is thus linked closely with the opportunity aspect of freedom, seen in terms of “comprehensive” opportunities, and not just focusing on what happens at “culmination”.’ (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 232)
In other words, there is a need for a proper process underlying decision-making: justice is not only about the decision; it is also about how you come to the decision.
Turning to his use of the word ‘freedom’, the concern for Sen at a micro level of analysis appears to be the need for the individual not to be constrained in his or her choice in any way – there must be liberty of action in the choice that is made. It is a true liberty that Sen seeks: one that frees the individual from any impediment towards realising rational choice.Footnote 53 Sen speaks of fairness of process in relation to the advantages that individuals have and the opportunity for them to realise these advantages. The specific nature of fairness of process in its relationship with capability, however, is unclear: Sen speaks of equity and efficiency on one hand, and fairness of process generally on the other (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 296). Fairness of process can arguably be seen as a composite of the other elements of Sen's theory of justice: full participation in the decision-making process, open communication among all players, the existence of rational choice and real capability (with its attendant elements of opportunity to choose, social perspective and public engagement) in the exercise and realisation of rational choice. A fair process is one, therefore, where rational choice is exercised through capability, and objective reasoning supports decision-making. Any process that prevents the actualisation of rational choice, after a process of objective reasoning, is a flawed process. There must be no barriers to the progression to and exercise of rational choice for freedom of choice to be realised and, with it, fairness of process. From the Sen perspective, this concept of fairness of process appears to be the foundation of a building block: it is what ensures the other elements are present for justice. It allows capability to be exercised through objective reasoning and rational choice.
Fairness of process in mediation is manifested in the dispute-resolution literature by the phrase procedural justice. Elements of procedural justice are said to include a need and desire for an opportunity by parties to tell their story and to control its telling, consideration of their story in a fair manner by the mediator, and to be treated with dignity and respect (Welsh, Reference Welsh2001, p. 792). Procedural justice is also seen as including concepts of equal access and treatment as well as the neutrality or impartiality of the third-party intervener (Hyman and Love, Reference Hyman and Love2002, p. 192). Parties, in essence, want to be treated fairly and be given the opportunity to be heard. In the mediation literature, there seems to be some consensus that this is one area in which mediation excels – that mediation provides procedural justice, if nothing else (e.g. Hollander-Blumoff and Tyler, Reference Hollander-Blumoff and Tyler2008; Welsh, Reference Welsh2001). Indeed, parties to the process speak in terms of such elements of procedural justice. For example, one mediator tells the parties:
‘I honestly can say I do not take sides; … these are all individuals with their own agendas, much are valid and need to be respected; I do not think of when I will get the next mediation from the defendant but to treat each with equality.’Footnote 54
Further, he says that the process needs to be treated with pride and respect.Footnote 55 For parties in another mediation, the process was necessary for resolution: ‘… to be brutally honest, I think we could not get there without it.’Footnote 56 The claimant in the same case said that the process was ‘effective; it was easy’ and another defendant representative said that the process was good.Footnote 57 Important for another actor in the process was the ability to participate in the process: ‘I find mediation better than the court process because at least I can say something. I just had to sit through it [court].’Footnote 58 His solicitor also added: ‘You feel disempowered. Mediators are trained to deal with this …. It is important that people do not think they are part of a grinding process.’Footnote 59 A mediator in another case likens the process to a day in court, telling a party that ‘it is your day in court’.Footnote 60
For these actors of the mediation process, a concept of procedural justice seems to relate to purely procedural aspects of the process: being heard and treated with respect; receiving assistance from a perceived third-party neutral; and being given the opportunity to participate fully in the process and reach resolution. The reference to a party's ‘day in court’ is a common one, evoking the positivist view of a just arena. Mediators imply by their words a process which is similar to a juridical process, as if to strengthen the value of the mediation process itself and suggesting a congruency in outcomes. What a court provides, mediation also provides. Implicit in this is a suggestion that a just process leads to a just outcome.
This particular concept of procedural justice is further assisted by the presence of legal counsel at the mediation, which also emphasises a congruency with court proceedings. Legal counsel ensure their clients are not procedurally bullied. In one mediation, the solicitor was late and the unrepresented party agreed to begin the process without its solicitor. The opposing counsel proceeded to cross-examine the party: the party was not protected from a grilling. The mediator in the case wondered whether he should have let it happen.Footnote 61 Counsel protect their clients and ensure procedural fairness to the extent it is within their control. For the mediator: ‘Mediation is fair when both have legal advice. My concern is when the government pushes it and parties do not have legal advice.’Footnote 62
The issue of fairness of process is not a neat and tidy one, as suggested by these views of procedural justice. Several issues arise in mediation that can tip the balance away from fairness of process, such as factors of economic, cultural, legal and emotional power, mediator tactics, the private nature of mediation and the lack of institutional safeguards. For example, not all experience a positive process. In one case, a defendant solicitor commented that the claimant was not at the mediation in good faith.Footnote 63 Another party who came to agreement felt bullied by the other side: ‘Every trick is being played here to knock me down. … I am being done.’Footnote 64 A similar feeling is expressed by another claimant: ‘I am feeling beaten up.’Footnote 65 Comments such as these seem to be suggestive of the close connection between Sen's requirement for capability of choice and fairness of process. They seem to articulate a frustration parties can feel when they do not get what they want or are stymied in their ability to choose. It would seem that, where there is capability within the exercise of rational choice, there is fairness of process; where there is a lack of capability or sustained reasoning underlying a choice made, fairness of process is undermined and, with it, freedom of choice. In such circumstances, the requisite element of freedom of choice is vulnerable to attack, and with it the sustainability of the presence of justice in the outcome.
VII. Conclusion
Sen's theory of justice is a comparative one of alternatives – people must make decisions from the choices they have available to them (Sen, Reference Sen2013, p. 310). For Sen, the reality of life needs to form part of the ‘justice’ conundrum and, as such, it is a practical idea of justice he offers (Sen, Reference Sen2013; Reference Sen2011, p. 319). Ideal justice is not possible, according to Sen. As a result, to achieve justice, we must work with what we have through a comparative theory where alternatives are available and choices are determined on the basis of objective reasoning, rational choice and freedom of choice (Sen, Reference Sen2011, pp. 321–324). For Sen, the goal for any process should be the enhancement of substantive justice rather than the search for the unattainable in the form of ideal justice.
We can see that the elements of Sen's theory are interwoven: they are not only dependent on each other to form the whole, but they are intrinsically linked to one another. Objective reasoning requires debate and impartiality, essentially public engagement as he later describes (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, p. 245); rational choice requires scrutiny and justification, ostensibly coming from the process of objective reasoning; and freedom of choice requires ability to make use of opportunities and fairness of process in the rational choice that is made, embodying both an individual and social perspective (Sen, Reference Sen2009b, pp. 296–297, 245). Together, they form for Sen a theory of justice.
Mediation in its current form falls short of achieving just outcomes. The weakness rests with the last of Sen's three elements: freedom of choice. This, however, is not an insurmountable problem as that presented by a positivist view of justice. The need for the impartial decision-maker in an open forum sanctioned by state laws prohibits mediation from ever delivering justice, according to the positivist frame. By moving away from this restrictive frame and applying Sen's theory of justice, the opportunity for mediation to offer a substantive form of justice is made possible. Justice within the pluralistic, expansive view of substantive justice conceived by Sen is attainable through a private dispute-resolution process such as mediation. More work needs to be done, however, to achieve this goal. The exploration in this paper provides the first step to recognising what is possible for mediation and its delivery of justice.
In summary, objective reasoning, the first of Sen's three elements underpinning his theory of justice, appears to have been made out: there is dialogue, interaction, debate and reflection in the mediation process; and, while the issue of impartiality is not as clear, mediation offers the Sen conceptualisation of impartiality as anti-parochial voice. As for the second element of rational choice, this too appears to be evident in mediation. As long as decisions can be justified through scrutiny, critical analysis and sustainable reasons, a rational choice can be made. Through the active role of all actors to the process, including the social interaction that occurs, the challenges that are made, the parties’ understanding of the choices they face and the reasoned decisions that are made as a result, rational choice in decision-making is possible.
It needs to be stressed, however, that this achievement of the first two elements of Sen's theory occurs as a result of the nature of the mediation process and the active role of mediators in ensuring objective reasoning and rational choice occurs. In this regard, there needs a recognition that mediators are more than mere facilitators: they provide the anti-parochial voice through their fugitive identity as party, party adviser and third-party intervener. For proponents of mediation to continue to advocate mediation as offering justice, this needs to be addressed as a dominant feature of the mediation process. In so doing, the first two elements of Sen's theory would be well met. In view of the reality of the process as evidenced by ethnographic data, there should be no barrier in this regard.
It is with the last of the three elements of Sen's theory of justice that mediation may run into substantive difficulty. Freedom of choice is vulnerable to attack in terms of both capability and fairness of process.
Turning first to capability, while it appears that the social perspective embedded within capability is evident, the individual element of parties realising actual ability of choice is vulnerable. For example, any power imbalance, arising from actual or perceived factors such as those described earlier, existing between parties would serve to lessen the element of freedom of choice in mediation as it would impact the process and outcome. For proponents of the process, if they are to argue that justice can be obtained through mediation, barriers to freedom of choice such as the presence of power imbalances must be dealt with. This is not easily resolved given the conflicting views in the dispute-resolution literature about the appropriateness of the mediator to actively redress issues of power arising during the process. This debate needs to come to the fore and steps taken to recognise the impact of such barriers on the realisation of justice in the process. The difficulty is not insurmountable, however. It is something that can be addressed with a consideration of the mediator's actions during the process and a determination of what actions are necessary to ensure the elements of freedom of choice are satisfied.
As for fairness of process, this seems to be intertwined with the capability issue as discussed earlier: where capability exists and the other elements made out, fairness of process is less likely to be an issue; however, where they do not exist, fairness of process will likely be missing. The focus therefore should be on ensuring freedom of choice through the existence of a real ability to choose the offered rational choice.
This exploration of the possibility of attaining justice in mediation moves away from a restricted concept of justice to Sen's expansive, plural view that incorporates both individual and societal values. It gives mediation the chance to prove to its detractors as well as its proponents that a substantive form of justice can be sought through its process. This review indicates that justice is possible, but work needs to be done to achieve it. Mediation theory and its attendant practice should be revisited. The revisitation should encompass the actions that a mediator needs to take to ensure that the requirements of Sen's objective reasoning, rational choice and freedom of choice have been satisfied during the mediation process and, ultimately, justice achieved.
