Soltau's Fairness in International Climate Change Law and Policy begins by describing what it will not do. In his introductory chapter, Soltau writes “[t]he objective is not to further explore here the ethical and moral questions pertaining to a safe level of climate change” (p. 16). Instead, “[t]his book sets out to deepen the understanding of distributive fairness in the context of climate change” (p. 18). Soltau justifies this focus by claiming that agreement on the distributive framework is “the last-piece of the puzzle in adopting a global, long-term target” (p.18). From here, Soltau describes the science and problem of climate change as well as the role of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (Chapter Two) and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCC) and its Kyoto Protocol (Chapter Three). Soltau's analysis in these two chapters, although admirable in its scope and clarity, consumes roughly 110 pages of text while skirting around the issue of fairness.
Not until Chapter Four, “Theoretical Aspects of Fairness”, does Soltau really begin to discuss fairness. Acknowledging that his list is not exhaustive, Soltau focuses on four major principles of fairness in climate change: egalitarianism (costs should be distributed equally), responsibility (industrialized countries should be responsible for costs proportionate to their historical responsibility), need (assistance should go to those who need it), and capability (costs should be borne by those capable of paying them). Later in Chapter Four, Soltau describes the historical inclusion of fairness principles in international environmental law. Chapter Five, “Fairness in the Climate Change Regime”, considers fairness principles in action. Soltau describes common but differentiated responsibility for developing and developed countries under the UNFCC, technology transfer provisions, adaptation funds, and the clean development mechanism as exemplary of fairness principles in the present-day law and policy of climate change.
By Chapter Six, “Evaluation of Proposals for Future Climate Policy”, Soltau has drastically limited the scope of his analysis of fairness (Chapter One) and exhaustively introduced foundational information and theory (Chapters Two to Five) before finally beginning to examine proposals for post-Kyoto climate-change policy. Almost immediately, Soltau dismisses the economically efficient option of carbon taxation because carbon taxes “are unlikely to be widely adopted” (p. 231). This dismissal occurs even before Soltau identifies his “assessment criteria”. These criteria—environmental effectiveness, cost effectiveness, and institutional design—largely reiterate themes discussed in prior chapters. Halfway through the chapter, Soltau finally addresses current policy proposals, describing them briefly and evaluating them according to his fairness principles and assessment criteria. After 240 pages of build-up, Soltau's purely theoretical analysis and conclusion that “proposals that seek actively to reflect both a balance of fairness principles—responsibility, capability, need—and political and economic realities stand the best chance of being accepted and implemented” (p. 259) are disappointing in their lack of novelty.
The attention to detail, process, and theory found throughout this book renders it ideal for those seeking an introduction to climate change law and policy. For those already familiar with the subject, this deliberateness detracts from a book whose title promises moral judgment, and not history, theory, and practicality. Fairness in international climate change law and policy is an immense topic, yet Soltau drastically limits his analysis to distributive fairness of the cost of climate change adaptation and prevention. This self-imposed limitation focuses and unifies the content of the book at the expense of a deeper, big-picture analysis of fairness.
Why does Soltau explicitly choose not to “explore the ethical and moral questions pertaining to a safe level of climate change” (p.16)? Why does he perfunctorily dismiss carbon taxes because they are unlikely to be widely adopted? Why limit the discussion of fairness to abstraction, as Soltau so often does throughout this book, when one could discuss in detail the plight of the indigenous peoples of the Arctic Circle or low-lying island nations? Why not contrast billionaires with refugees? Fairness is a word used to describe circumstances that should exist, not those that do exist. Within this realm of the hypothetical, factors like religion, animal rights, ethics, ecosystems, and individual claimants must be considered.
Instead, Soltau focuses on process. He argues that distributive fairness is critical to adopting a global, long-term target. This begs the question: can one develop a fair framework before one develops a fair goal? How does one fight climate change the right way if one does not know why or how much to fight? Of course, the uncertainties of climate change make these bigger questions impossible to answer, erhaps driving Soltau to focus on the more mundane realm of distributive fairness. However, even in this area, the analysis falters because it is not grounded in any overarching moral conception or goal. I hoped for a book that wrestled with big questions, a book that humanized the climate change crisis, and a book that sought an ideal of fairness. This book failed to realize those expectations.
