Angenette Spalink’s Choreographing Dirt: Movement, Performance, and Ecology in the Anthropocene provides a compact performance studies assertion that “ecological matter matters,” to suggest that choreography of bodies—technical, gestural, even compacting movements—both leave and are left with interactions with dirt (13). From the transfer of radioactive dirt in Fukushima Prefecture due to the 2011 earthquake to her own compression of earth by “trudging through a swamp,” Spalink takes seriously how a “shift from the studio to the swamp” might shift performance studies’, and particularly ecotheatre’s, attention to the body to a recomposed body that is always in relation to dirt (4). Choreographing Dirt joins the fold in environmental studies projects that are attuned to the vast material impacts and possibilities of performance beyond what is represented onstage to look at what is underneath it.
Taking up Mary Douglas’s effectual determination that dirt is “matter out of place,” Choreographing Dirt surveys contemporary performance and dance where dirt performs alongside, with, and through human bodies (30). Spalink steers the view from how dirt is constructed to examine what processes move matter to becoming “out of place,” reminding us that dirt still inhabits space, affecting bodies and ecologies, even when moved through colonial extraction, artistic intervention, or scientific field research (19, note 9). Spalink’s method efficiently catches up performance studies to the developments taking place in soil sciences: charting terms, studies, and interlocutors across the two fields, including the provocative argument of “performative taphonomy” in Chapter 1, “Performative Taphonomy: Excavating and Exhuming the Past in Suzan-Lori Parks’s The America Play.” The use of scientific knowledge does not limit the project, but rather offers a method in which Spalink traces, through surveying interviews with the playwright, artistic directors, and scenic designers, which materials were used to convey dirt in The America Play, including cork, gravel, and a floorboard stage. Spalink argues these materials perform as historiographic and archaeological remains (26). Throughout the text contemporary soil studies are cited almost evenly with humanistic frameworks, modeling what many in ecotheatre, such as Theresa J. May, have propositioned: In what way would encountering new modes of knowledge about the nonhuman actors in performance (including developments in how soil is conceived of in scientific research) alter the how when it comes to matter mattering (48)?
For Spalink, movement becomes the mode of analysis in which to render dirt an operative material in performance, rather than a category of discard or otherness. She effectively asserts across her case studies to “take movement seriously” and draws on foundations of movement from Susan Leigh Foster and dance studies broadly (97). The introduction of Choreographing Dirt attends to developments in ecotheatre and environmental humanities, and thoughtfully considers what it might mean to read against soil, to propose the always culturally constructed nature of matter through her term biogeocultography (2).Theatre, especially but not limited to Western theatrical traditions, is often at its root about constructing space through matter out of place. For example, in Chapter 2, “Staging Extraction: Peat’s Vitality in Pina Bausch’s The Rite of Spring,” Spalink addresses not only the human performers’ choreography with dirt, but also how the peat itself affects the human bodies. She argues that peat is not-not-animate simply because it is a displaced soil removed from the bacterial, mycelial, and fungal life that renders it active in a natural environment, but because the peat material “conceivably contains human remains from ancient religious rituals” (54).
Spalink takes field shifting provocations from ecotheatre scholars such as Una Chaudhuri to chart, map, and touch the movement of matter in performance. The performances Spalink surveys take place in the United States, often on proscenium stages, and are not sustainable utopias, an important offering to the field of ecotheatre in conceiving new ecological meaning from the use of dirt. This method continues in the second half of the book, with Chapter 3, “A Dirty Pas De Deux: Dirt, Skin, and ‘Transcorporeality’ in Eveoke Dance Theatre’s Las Mariposas,” which examines how the dance performance utilizes dirt as a metaphor for murder. The chapter unearths a whole host of possibilities for rethinking soil as an actant and contributor to the meanings of performance. Chapter 4, “Mycelium in Motion: Choreographing Care in Iván-Daniel Espinosa’s Messengers Divinos,” most explicitly rehearses what a dirty praxis offers performance studies. Examining this durational butoh performance, Spalink posits that dirt, soil, and any of its mimetic materials assert a relational practice, assuming an ethics of nonhuman interaction. Largely built off of Maria Puig de Bellacasa’s Matters of Care: Speculative Ethics in More than Human Worlds (2017), the chapter, which incorporates interviews with choreographer and director Iván-Daniel Espinosa, charts the “ecological ethics of care” (79) that are undertaken by the performers both in preparation for, and execution of, performance with fungi. For example, by attending to the preshow rituals, such as the consumption of mushroom tea, Spalink recomposes the human body in relation to dirt by scaling attention to nonhuman matter, especially fungi (92–3).
The final chapter, “Conclusion: Moving with the Trouble,” like the book as a whole, complicates and extends nonhuman performance into plant studies, nuancing how animacy is activated, and subsequently perceived, within a predominantly human-centric performance practice. Choreographing Dirt commits to thinking through scales of movement with dirt, attending not only to material composition, but also to sensory encounters of touch, consumption, and sound. These bodily modes are not accidental or inherent to performing with dirt, but are modes that can be traced, articulated, and complicated through choreographic and scientific discourse.
Choreographing Dirt joins early voices of performances studies scholars taking up environmental humanities and the field of science and technology studies. While movement remains a main intervention, the book additionally affords emerging scholars a map for a mixed-method approach of performance and soil science—fields that can work in concert. Performance and soil science are compacted into Choreographing Dirt’s trudge in which Spalink “develop[s] a rhythm and [her] body adjusts to the way that the terrain has altered [her] movement” (99). As she narrates her own position through material swamps and conceptual fields, there remains space in Choreographing Dirt’s interrogation of the sticking points of scientific methods, with perhaps a greater need for resisting scientism. The scale of the work, while certainly multiplicious, is importantly narrow: soil science remains the prominent scientific field, allowing for a nuanced companionship as Spalink “tread[s] alongside three botanists” to ask what to do with dirt, and what dirt is doing to us (99).
