Cape Town's vast expanses of low-to-no income residential areas are spread across dunes and often water-logged, low-lying areas. These areas, known as the Cape Flats, epitomize the city's spatial and socio-economic inequality and stand in sharp contrast to the hilly, lush, and often breath-taking residential pockets that embed the historically white middle class. Anne-Maria Makhulu casts fresh light on the history and making of this landscape, homing in on what were once black African group areas, which were created with the ultimate intention of completely erasing their inhabitants from what the apartheid state considered a white city.
Making Freedom takes an interest in home, home making, and spatial struggles. It does so in conversation with key authors of South African urban history, critical theory, and anthropology. It dialogues with scholarship on the right to the city and citizenship, quiet encroachment and informality, and illegality and transgression. Makhulu weaves the voices and memories of a number of protagonists into this analysis, individuals who are now elderly, one of whom is also featured in the book's compelling cover photograph. Throughout the text, the recollections of these residents take the reader back to the 1950s, 1970s, and 1980s, and then through the transition into postcolonial and post-apartheid South Africa. These long passages and vivid accounts are presented verbatim and are supplemented by the author's perceptive descriptions of Cape Town that date to when she first embarked on fieldwork in the city in 1998.
Making Freedom is about the divisive making of townships — that is, the transit area and later township Crossroads, and the initial phases of the peripherally located township Khayelitsha — while it is also about the making of homes in shacks, and the liberty and relative autonomy of that process. Thus, we read descriptions of land occupation and shack construction. Home is depicted as a political site that interacts with divergent political formations. Customary rule is pitted against democratic anti-apartheid structures, while Johnson (Ngxobs) Ngxobongwana, a notorious Crossroads warlord of the 1980s, is a personality who is well known to Makhulu's interviewees. These recollections complement accounts of Ngxobongwana's own formation, which took place initially within progressive politics, until an arrest which appears to have propelled him to serve the repressive state. Respondents describe Ngxobongwana's Crossroads administration, which worked on behalf of the apartheid state, and its implication for everyday life in that area's sea of shacks.
The reader becomes well-acquainted with a number of Makhulu's respondents. One of them is Lungile Kolisi and his wife Xoliswa, who came separately to Cape Town. Their journey started in the 1950s and took several stages, all of which entailed navigating risks and overcoming restrictions on movement. We gain insight into the couples’ rural home, and into the Langa hostel on the Cape Flats where they lived in the early 1960s. For the Kolisis, life as a couple in Cape Town was later only possible ‘in the bush’, that is, in a ‘squatter’ settlement located in the shrubbery that was to become the politically notorious Crossroads. Here, as much as in the Langa hostel, domestic life was linked closely to the rural everyday. Yet the reader also learns about the realities of urban life and the routines that were used to avoid arrest. Everyday life in Crossroads was one of surveillance, raids, arrests, and deportation; residents also lived with the constant threat of eviction and destruction. Everyday life also involved strategic struggles against the state: for instance, Crossroads residents successfully mobilized to have the area declared an emergency camp, thus averting its annihilation.
The structure of this book is broadly sequential. It progresses from the origins of the townships to eras shaped by various institutions, such as the Urban Foundation and the United Democratic Front in the 1980s, and the Independent Development Trust in the early 1990s. It subsequently treats projects in Cape Town such as the Integrated Serviced Land Project (iSLP) and the Municipal Spatial Development Framework (MSDF). Makhulu contrasts the development discourse of ‘stakeholders’ and efforts to promote ‘public participation’ with colloquial discussions that depict houses with feet protruding from doors because the rooms are too small. While Makhulu is attentive to chronology, she avoids a strictly temporal approach and instead weaves the past into an understanding of the present. This perspective emphasizes continuity and thereby constructs a hard-hitting critique of the contemporary South African state and the uneven development of the country.
Making Freedom is as much about Makhulu's own journey of understanding about the making of home as it is about ‘organic traditions of everyday struggle for home’ (20). The book is a rich source for historians and those seeking to understand socio-political transformations of Cape Town. But it is also an inspiration for South African researchers, as well as those with roots in this country, to sensitively and urgently capture oral histories from an aging generation who have lived through repression, transition, and continued exclusion. This book beautifully illuminates their efforts to make and find freedom in everyday routines and transgressions.
