Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:34:24.930Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Towards the detection of moving separation in unsteady flows

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 August 2015

Philippe Miron*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, LADYF, Polytechnique Montréal, Montréal, QC, H3C 3A7, Canada
Jérôme Vétel
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, LADYF, Polytechnique Montréal, Montréal, QC, H3C 3A7, Canada
*
†Email address for correspondence: philippe.miron@polymtl.ca

Abstract

In many engineering systems operating with a working fluid, the best efficiency is reached close to a condition of flow separation, which makes the prediction of this condition very important in industry. Provided that wall-based quantities can be measured, we know today how to obtain good predictions for two- and three-dimensional steady and periodic flows. In these flows, the separation is defined on a fixed line attached to a material surface. The last case to elucidate is the one where this line is no longer attached to the wall but on the contrary is contained within the flow. This moving separation is probably, however, the most common case of separation in natural flows and industrial applications. Since this case has received less attention during the past few years, we propose in this study to examine some properties of moving separation in two-dimensional, unsteady flows where the separation does not leave a signature on the wall. Since in this framework separation can be extracted by using a Lagrangian frame where the separation profile can be viewed as a hyperbolic unstable manifold, we propose a method to extract the separation point defined by the Lagrangian saddle point that belongs to this unstable manifold. In practice, the separation point and profile are initially extracted by detecting the most attracting Lagrangian coherent structure near the wall, and they can then be advected in time for subsequent instants. It is found that saddle points, which initially act as separation points in the viscous wall flow region, remarkably preserve their hyperbolicity even if they are ejected from the wall towards the inviscid region. Two test cases are studied: the creeping flow of a rotating and translating cylinder close to a wall, and the unsteady separation in the boundary layer generated by a planar jet impinging onto a plane wall.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2015 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Flow geometry and parameters of the rotating and translating cylinder test case.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Fixed unsteady separation for the time-periodic flow with $U_{0}=0$, ${\it\omega}=2{\rm\pi}$ and ${\it\beta}=6$: (a) $t=0$, (b) $t=3.2T$, (c) $t=6.4T$, (d) $t=9.6T$, (e) $t=12.8T$ and (f) $t=16T$. The Lagrangian separation profile (red) is shown with the instantaneous streamline (grey) emanating from the zero skin-friction points. Fluid particles are initially placed on material lines aligned with the wall using two different colours (blue and green) depending on their location with regard to the predicted separation profile at the initial time $t=0$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Moving separation with $U_{0}=0.3$ and ${\it\beta}=0$. Material lines (blue and green) initially aligned with the wall at $t=0$ in (a) are then advected in time and seen in a reference frame moving with the cylinder at times (b) $t=4$, (c) $t=8$, (d) $t=12$, (e) $t=16$ and (f) $t=100$. Instantaneous streamlines are shown in red (note that in (f) the blue line shows material points that have been attracted and ejected from the wall by separation, then wrapped around the cylinder and finally transported to its left side; since other points are left behind the cylinder, they end up being disconnected from the material line).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Separation pattern defined around a Lagrangian saddle point of coordinates $\boldsymbol{x}_{s}=(x_{s},y_{s})$, including an attracting material line (unstable manifold) $\mathscr{M}(t)$ and a repelling material line (stable manifold) $\mathscr{N}(t)$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Prediction of moving separation with $U_{0}=0.3$ and ${\it\beta}=0$: (a) $t=0$, (b) $t=0.8$, (c) $t=1.6$, (d) $t=2.4$, (e) $t=3.2$ and (f) $t=4.0$. Particles (seen in a reference frame moving with the cylinder) are released with a colour (blue or green) depending on their initial location relative to the red straight lines that correspond to the tangent to the stable and unstable manifolds predicted by (3.5). Grey lines are instantaneous streamlines (computed in the moving frame) passing close to the separation point.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Extraction of the separation point and angle for the flow with $U_{0}=0.3$, ${\it\beta}=0.5$ and ${\it\omega}=2{\rm\pi}/5$. In (a), contours of the FTLE field are visualised (levels increase from blue to white) together with the LCS (red) extracted at $t=0$ with the algorithm presented in Farazmand & Haller (2012). ${\it\lambda}=\int _{0}^{t}S_{\Vert }({\it\tau})\,\text{d}{\it\tau}$, computed as a function of $s$, the initial curvilinear coordinate on the LCS at $t=0$ normalised by the length of the LCS, is visualised in (b) through isocontours (from blue to white). The origin of $s$ corresponds to the point on the LCS in (a) where $x=0$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Prediction of moving separation with $U_{0}=0.3$, ${\it\beta}=0.5$ and ${\it\omega}=2{\rm\pi}/5$: (a) $t=0$, (b) $t=T/5$, (c) $t=2T/5$, (d) $t=3T/5$, (e) $t=4T/5$ and (f) $t=T$. The legend is the same as in figure 5. The dotted line indicates the trajectory of the separation point.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Tracking of the separation point and of the separation profile over time. In (a), the coordinates of the separation point are plotted in different ways, and in particular are compared to those of the cylinder. (b) Shows the position of the LCS and of the cylinder for three time instants in a reference frame moving at the velocity $U_{0}$. The separation point is indicated by the circles and the theoretical prediction of the slope of the separation profile at the separation point is indicated in red: ——, $t=0$; – – –, $t=1.0$; $\cdots \cdots$, $t=2.4$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Physical mechanism of the unsteady separation in an impinging jet with PV and SV denoting the primary and the secondary vortex, respectively (adapted from Didden & Ho 1985).

Figure 9

Figure 10.Visualisation of the region impinged on by the vertical jet. (a) Contours of the out-of-plane vorticity (the blue and red colours correspond to a clockwise and a counter-clockwise rotation, respectively). (b) LCS material lines coloured by the FTLE averaged along each line (values increase from light to dark red) superimposed on the FTLE contours (increasing from blue to white).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Contours of ${\it\lambda}=\int _{0}^{t}S_{\Vert }({\it\tau})\,\text{d}{\it\tau}$ (a,c,e) and instantaneous values of the tangential strain rate $S_{\Vert }$ (b,d,f) as a function of the normalised curvilinear coordinate $s$ (same definition as in the legend of figure 6, oriented from left to right) and the integration time $t$. (a and b) correspond to the LCS identified by ${\it\gamma}_{1}$ in figure 10(b), (c and d) to ${\it\gamma}_{2}$ and (e and f) to ${\it\gamma}_{3}$. Red crosses indicate the instants from which $S_{\Vert }$ at the points $p_{i}^{{\it\gamma}_{j}}$ preserves a positive sign.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Advection in time of LCSs ${\it\gamma}_{1}$ (dotted line) and ${\it\gamma}_{2}$ (solid line) detected in figure 10. The characteristic points extracted in figure 11 are simultaneously followed in time at $t=10.05$ (a), $t=14.95$ (b), $t=18.25$ (c), $t=21.05$ (d), $t=25.45$ (e), $t=29.65$ (f), $t=30.95$ (g) and $t=40.65$ (h). In all plots, the three points of ${\it\gamma}_{1}$ ($p_{1}^{{\it\gamma}_{1}}$–$p_{3}^{{\it\gamma}_{1}}$) are marked in green while the four points of ${\it\gamma}_{2}$ ($p_{1}^{{\it\gamma}_{2}}$–$p_{4}^{{\it\gamma}_{2}}$) are marked in red. Orange points are points close to the characteristic points of ${\it\gamma}_{2}$ that are used to indicate if locally we have a stretching or a compression. Time instants where $S_{\Vert }$ becomes positive correspond to red crosses in figure 11.