Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:38:19.686Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Osteology and phylogenetic affinities of the middle Eocene North American Bathornis grallator—one of the best represented, albeit least known Paleogene cariamiform birds (seriemas and allies)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 June 2016

Gerald Mayr*
Affiliation:
Senckenberg Research Institute and Natural History Museum Frankfurt, Ornithological Section, Senckenberganlage 25, D-60325 Frankfurt am Main, Germany 〈Gerald.Mayr@senckenberg.de〉
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Bathornis (“Neocathartes”) grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming is based on a partial skeleton, which is the most substantial record of the North American Bathornithidae and one of the most complete fossils of a Paleogene stem group representative of the Cariamiformes. So far, however, an assessment of the evolutionary significance of this important fossil has been hampered by the limited published osteological data. Moreover, cariamiform affinities of B. grallator and its true “genus”-level identity were recognized after the last comprehensive revision of the Bathornithidae, and some of its features were incorrectly portrayed in the original description. Here, the B. grallator holotype is restudied and the taxonomic composition and phylogenetic affinities of bathornithids are revised. It is suggested to restrict Bathornithidae to the taxon Bathornis, from which the putative bathornithid Paracrax differs in numerous features, with even cariamiform affinities of this latter taxon not having been established beyond doubt. B. grallator was a flightless bird and has recently been hypothesized to be the sister taxon of the likewise flightless South American Phorusrhacidae. The present analysis, however, supports a position outside a clade including Phorusrhacidae and Cariamidae (the cariamiform crown clade). Owing to their terrestrial way of living, Cariamiformes appear to have been prone to a loss of flight capabilities. B. grallator shows close similarities to a flightless cariamiform bird from the Paleogene of Europe, but the phylogenetic significance of this resemblance is difficult to assess owing to the limited material known of the latter species.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © 2016, The Paleontological Society 
Figure 0

Table 1Species of the Bathornithidae recognized by Cracraft (1968, 1971), with data on their stratigraphic and geographic occurrences and the published fossil material

Figure 1

Figure 1Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377), skull in (1) right lateral, (3) ventral, and (5) dorsal view in comparison to (2, 4, 6) the reconstructions of Wetmore (1944). (7, 8) Mandible in (7) left lateral and (8) dorsal view. Neurocranium and beak of the fossil are now separated and were assembled for the photos; note also that the dorsal nasal bar is now broken. The arrows in (4) indicate erroneously assumed processus basipterygoidei, and the framed area in (6) denotes the incorrectly reconstructed rostrolateral rim of the orbit. In (2) and (4) the original lettering was removed. Scale bar equals 20 mm.

Figure 2

Figure 2Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377). (1–3) Skulls (dorsolateral view) of (1) B. grallator, (2) Cariama cristata (Cariamidae), and (3) Coragyps atratus (Cathartidae). (4–6) Tips of upper jaws in ventral view of (4) B. grallator, (5) C. cristata, and (6) C. atratus. (7) Upper and lower beak of B. grallator in articulation. (8) Neurocranium of B. grallator in right lateral view. cho, choanal opening; lac, lacrimale; pal, palatinum; pmp, processus maxillopalatinus; pmx, processus maxillaris of palatinum; pop, processus postorbitalis; sup, processus supraorbitalis; zyg, processus zygomaticus. Scale bars equal 20 mm.

Figure 3

Figure 3Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming, skull details. (1) Neurocranium in dorsolateral view. (2, 3) Detail of otic region in (2) lateral and (3) ventrolateral view. (4) Otic region of Cariama cristata in ventrolateral view. (5, 6) Detail of lacrimal-ectethmoid complex of (5) B. grallator and (6) C. cristata. (7, 8) Left quadrate in ventral view of (7) B. grallator and (8) C. cristata. (9–11) Left quadrate and jugal bar of (9, 10) B. grallator (in 10 the matrix was digitally removed) and (11) C. cristata. cdl, condylus lateralis; ect, ectethmoidale; idn, incisura ductus nasolacrimalis; lac, lacrimale; orb, processus orbitalis of quadrate; pop, processus postorbitalis; por, processus orbitalis of lacrimale; psm, processus suprameaticus; sup, processus supraorbitalis; unc, os uncinatum; zyg, processus zygomaticus. Scale bars equal 20 mm.

Figure 4

Figure 4Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377). (1–5) Right pterygoid in (1) medial, (2) dorsal, (3) dorsolateral, (4) lateral, and (5) ventral view. (6–8) Right pterygoid of Cariama cristata in (6) medial, (7) lateral, and (8) ventral view. (9–11) Right pterygoid of Coragyps atratus in (9) medial, (10) lateral, and (11) ventral view. (12) B. grallator, ossified tracheal rings. (13, 14) B. grallator, axis and atlas in (13) dorsal and (14) right lateral view. (15, 16) C. cristata, axis and atlas in (15) dorsal and (16) right lateral view. (17) B. grallator, ?13th praesacral vertebra (dorsal view). (18) 13th praesacral vertebra of C. cristata. (19–21) B. grallator, 14th or 15th vertebra in (19) dorsal, (20) right lateral, and (21) caudal view. (22–24) 15th vertebra of C. cristata in (22) dorsal, (23) right lateral, and (24) caudal view. bpt, facies articularis basipterygoidea; fac, facies articularis caudalis; fap, facies articularis palatina; liz, lacuna interzygapophysialis; pvt, processus ventralis; spi, processus spinosus; tra, tracheal rings. Scale bars equal 10 mm.

Figure 5

Figure 5Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377), wing and pectoral girdle bones. (1, 3) B. grallator, right scapula as it is preserved and (2, 4) with proximal end digitally reassembled; the dotted area indicates the reconstructed part of the shaft. (5, 6) B. grallator, right coracoid in (5) dorsal and (6) ventral view. (7, 8) Right coracoid of Cariama cristata in (7) dorsal and (8) ventral view. (9, 10) Fragment of distal end of right humerus in (9) caudal and (10) cranial view. (11, 12) B. grallator, fragment of distal end of right ulna in (11) ventral and (12) distal view. (13) Proximal portion of right ulna of C. cristata in cranial view. (14–16) B. grallator, proximal portion of right ulna in (14) cranial, (15) dorsal, and (16) caudal view. (17, 18) B. grallator, incomplete left carpometacarpus in (17) dorsal and (18) ventral view. (19, 20) Right carpometacarpus of C. cristata in (19) dorsal and (20) ventral view. (21) B. grallator, left phalanx proximalis digiti majoris. acr, acromion; brd, osseous bridge connecting processus acrocoracoideus and processus procoracoideus; cdd(h), condylus dorsalis of humerus; cdd(u), condylus dorsalis of ulna; csc, cotyla scapularis; ctd, cotyla dorsalis; ctv, cotyla ventralis; faa, facies articularis alularis; fas, facies articularis sternalis; ins, incisura nervi supracoracoidei; ocn, olecranon; pac, processus acrocoracoideus; sct, sulcus scapulotricipitalis; std, sulcus tendineus; tbc, tuberculum carpale; tir, tubercle at incisura radialis; vpr, ventral projection at base of os metacarpale minus. Scale bars equal 20 mm.

Figure 6

Figure 6(1, 3, 5) partial left humerus of Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377) in comparison to (2, 4, 6) the humerus of “Ameghinornis minor” from an unknown horizon of the middle Eocene to Oligocene Quercy fissure fillings in France (from Gaillard, 1939, fig. 4). (1, 2) caudal view, (3, 4) ventral view, (5, 6) cranial view. The dotted lines in (1) and (5) indicate the reconstructed hypothetical outline of the complete distal end of the B. grallator humerus. mdr, midline ridge. Scale bars equal 20 mm.

Figure 7

Figure 7Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377), pelvis, and femur. (1, 3) fragmentary pelvis of B. grallator in (1) dorsal and (3) right lateral view. (2, 4) Pelvis of Cariama cristata in (2) dorsal and (4) right lateral view. (5) B. grallator, fragmentary portion of left ilium and pubis in lateral view, with (6) the corresponding part of the pelvis of C. cristata (the dotted line indicates the approximate position of the fossil fragment). (7) Right femur of C. cristata in cranial view. (8, 9) Fragmentary right femur of B. grallator in (8) cranial and (9) caudal view; the grey area in (8) indicates the reconstructed (and hypothetical) shape of the broken caput femoris. act, foramen acetabuli; ctr, crista trochanterica; fio, foramen ilioischiadicum; fob, foramen obturatum; ftr, fossa trochanteris; iob, impressiones obturatoriae; lic, linea intermuscularis cranialis; pub, pubis. Scale bars equal 20 mm.

Figure 8

Figure 8Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377), tibiotarsus and tarsometatarsus. (1–4) Right tibiotarsus in (1) lateral, (2) cranial, (3) medial, and (4) caudal view. (5–8) Right tarsometatarsus in (5) dorsal, (6) lateral, (7) medial, and (8) ventral view. Scale bars equal 20 mm.

Figure 9

Figure 9Bathornis grallator (Wetmore, 1944) from the middle Eocene of Wyoming (holotype, CM 9377), right foot. Identity of the pedal phalanges as inferred by (1) Wetmore (1944) and (2) in the present study. The dotted line indicates a reconstructed proximal part of the penultimate phalanx of the third toe; the asterisked phalanges were found in articulation (according to Wetmore, 1944). (3) Pedal phalanges of Cariama cristata (phalanges of hallux and third toe from right foot, those of second and fourth toe from left foot of same individual and mirrored). The toes are numbered; the first four phalanges of the fourth toe of Cariama are shown in articulation, the ends of the phalanges are indicated by the arrows. snv, sulcus neurovascularis. Scale bars equal 20 mm.

Figure 10

Figure 10(1) Strict consensus tree of eight most parsimonious trees resulting from the primary analysis of the character matrix in the appendix (L=79, CI=0.55, RI=0.66). (2) Strict consensus tree of 15 most parsimonious trees (L=77, CI=0.57, RI=0.68) obtained after exclusion of “Ameghinornis” from the analysis. Full circles denote unambiguously optimized characters, open circles homoplastic ones; the numbers refer to the characters in the Appendix. Unsupported nodes are collapsed in all trees; bootstrap support values are indicated next to the internodes.

Figure 11

Figure 11Right humeri (cranial view) and left coracoids (dorsal view). (1, 6) Cariama cristata. (2, 7) Bathornis grallator (holotype, CM 9377; both bones mirrored). (3, 8) Paracrax wetmorei (holotype, AMNH F.A.M. 42998). (4, 9) Elaphrocnemus phasianus (humerus: NMB Q.W.1755, mirrored; coracoid: NMB Q.D.242). (5, 10) Opisthocomus hoazin (Opisthocomiformes, both bones mirrored). ins, incisura nervi supracoracoidei; pac, processus acrocoracoideus; ppc, processus procoracoideus. Scale bars equal 10 mm.

Figure 12

Table A1