In this important, original and well-conceived volume, Daniela Bleichmar and her co-editors offer an impressive overview of Iberian and Ibero-Atlantic scientific activity in the early modern period. Science is a capacious category, encompassing cosmography, medicine, pharmacology, metallurgy, natural science, nautical science and cartography as well as other related disciplines. The editors of this book have brought together well-established as well as up-and-coming scholars in a volume that offers helpful broad-brush accounts of the existing historiography as well as narrower case studies. The diversity and pervasiveness of science's function within the Iberian empires is clearly conveyed, and the book has been beautifully produced by Stanford University Press.
The book's main purpose is to ‘show that the Spanish and Portuguese empires were active participants in the practices of science during the early modern period’, a subject that has been relatively neglected in the Anglophone literature or at least not fully integrated into the historiographical mainstream. As Jorge Cañizares-Esguerra, one of the scholars who has been most responsible for the renaissance of Ibero-American scholarship on the history of science, shows in his introductory essay, science was the ‘handmaiden of the Iberian empires’ (p. 1). Moreover, the Americas had a sizeable impact on the development of European science and medicine, and the interaction, instead of a unilateral flow, between the ‘core’ and the ‘periphery’ needs to be more fully appreciated. The 15 essays cannot be treated individually in a review of this length, but the uniformly high quality of the contributions should be noted. Several of the essays are especially innovative or stimulating and deserve extended treatment.
Martha Few's essay ‘Medical Mestizaje and the Politics of Pregnancy in Colonial Guatemala, 1660–1730’ shows how indigenous and European medical traditions interacted, came into conflict with each other and were often reshaped under colonialism. Pregnancy, she notes, was approached in terms of ‘local understandings of illness causation and conceptions of health and healing [were] neither wholly European nor Mesoamerican, nor completely religious or scientific’ (p. 146). Timothy Walker's ‘Acquisition and Circulation of Medical Knowledge within the Early Modern Portuguese Colonial Empire’, also pays attention to the collaborative interaction of indigenous healers and European physicians, surgeons and pharmacists. As he demonstrates convincingly, ‘Indigenous people of the Portuguese colonies thus made important contributions to “Western medicine”’ (p. 248). The essays by Few and Walker reveal how the development of European science had more than a casual or indirect connection to overseas empire. Moreover, these essays show how scientific practices, like religious ones, emerged from syncretic processes resulting from inter-cultural encounters.
Perhaps the most interesting essay in the collection reveals the way in which scientific discourses often intersected with, and were inextricably linked to, areas of human endeavour that the modern world does not consider intimately connected. Daniela Bleichmar's brilliant chapter ‘A Visible and Useful Empire: Visual Culture and Colonial Natural History in the Eighteenth-century Spanish World’ shows how drawing and illustration were a tremendous, and underappreciated, aspect of early modern science. Focusing on the scientific expeditions of the late eighteenth century, Bleichmar shows how every expedition, ‘whether it was focused on natural history, astronomy, geography, navigation, exploration, or cartography, employed draughtsmen and produced numerous images as part of its stated goals … Images were not ornamental secondary products but the central concern of many expeditions, at times the most important: the bulk of Spanish expeditions’ output consisted of illustrations' (p. 308). As Bleichmar persuasively demonstrates, ‘visuality made the empire's nature identifiable, transferable, and appropriable’ (p. 309).
Science in the Spanish and Portuguese Empires is a well-conceived, well-edited volume which offers a glimpse into the exciting transformation that is under way in the field of the history of science in the Ibero-Atlantic. The lion's share of the essays are well-written and not jargon-laden, and it is imaginable that many of the essays could find their way into postgraduate and even advanced undergraduate syllabi.
