In this book Ruth Kastner describes and defends a mature form of the transactional interpretation (TI) of quantum mechanics, an interpretation first put forward by John Cramer in the 1980s. Most of the 9 chapters and 3 appendices are suitable primarily for a popular audience (“accessible to the interested layperson with a mathematics and / or physics background”, in the author’s words), with the exception of chapters 5 and 6 and the technical appendices, which presume something more than a layperson’s familiarity with physics, though not much more, with a little effort. The non-layperson, whether physicist or philosopher of physics, may find wanting a focused articulation and argued defense of the interpretation (the most succinct formulation is found at the opening of chapter 7), but both can be found there, within what is overall a provocative and lively introduction to the peculiarities of quantum mechanics (QM) and the challenges any interpretation must overcome.
The TI of quantum mechanics is essentially an analogue of the Wheeler-Feynman (WF) approach to electromagnetism. WF theory elevates the temporal-symmetry of the wave equation of electromagnetic radiation to a physical interpretation, treating the advanced and retarded wave solutions as real. It, therefore, makes the exchange of a photon between charges the product of a retarded wave, travelling forward in time, and an advanced wave travelling backward. TI similarly proposes that the standard quantum wave be treated as a retarded component, moving forward in time from an emitter, and postulating advanced components, moving backward from all possible absorbers. These are called the offer wave and confirmation waves, respectively. The ‘transaction’ of TI refers to the interaction between the offer wave and a confirmation wave. This interaction results in the occurrence of a spacetime event, a kind of collapse (what was possible becomes actual, and other possibilities are eliminated), but not really a collapse, for reasons of subtle metaphysical distinctions. The probability of any confirmation wave being actualized arises from the product of the amplitudes of the offer and confirmation rules. This gives a natural explanation (interpretation) of the Born rule, which dictates that the probabilities of a measurement outcome are the square of the amplitude of the corresponding component of the wavefunction obtained by projecting on the operator for that measurement result.
Chapters 1 and 2 together define and motivate the interpretational project, which rests on two ideas. The first is the “need to substantially alter one or more of our ‘basic philosophical commitments concerning reality’ in order to properly understand what the theory might be telling us.” (14) The second is a distinction between theory construction and theory interpretation—between the “map and the territory”, in the author’s figure. According to Kastner, although early theorists, such as Heisenberg and Bohr, rejected the realist models from which they’d attempted to construct quantum mechanics, making quantum mechanics a principle theory instead of a constructive one, this does not preclude the possibility of a new realist interpretation.
Chapters 3 and 4 then present the TI as a realist interpretation, one which allows quantum theory to “open the way to an entirely new and richer understanding of physical reality.” (30) On the version of TI of the 1980s the propagation of offer and confirmation waves was taken to be a temporal process, both backward and forward in time. This made the interpretation vulnerable to causal loop paradoxes and seemingly inconsistent pronouncements about the states of emitters and absorbers in experiments such as delayed choice or silent detectors (see, e.g., Maudlin Reference Maudlin2002.) The new version of TI presented in the book, called possibilist TI or PTI, does not consider the offer and confirmations waves to be spacetime objects. They are real, just not actual. They are sub-empirical and pre-spacetime.
This is the main philosophical “adjustment” in realist understanding required by the theory. When it comes to interpretations of QM, nobody wins the weirdness wars—all interpretations challenge common sense, force uncomfortable metaphysical concessions (all interpretations, that is, excepting those which prescribe liberal doses of pragmatism or, as some would say, denial.) Kastner’s updated Possibilist TI presents us with a metaphysical distinction between the actual (in spacetime), and the possible, extra-empirical, but still real.
[O]ffer and confirmation waves represent dynamically efficacious possibilities whose collective structure constitutes just such a “higher space” which ... I call “pre-spacetime” (PST). (67, emphasis in original)
Pre-spacetime (the territory) is described (the map) by Hilbert space in non-relativistic contexts, Fock space in QFT. Possible transactions are called “incipient transactions”. Absorption is the actualization of one of the possible incipient transactions. Actualized emissions and absorptions of quanta emerge as events in spacetime.
Chapters 5 and 6 are the most technical and put the interpretation to work addressing previous objections to TI. Chapter 5 describes primarily non-relativistic challenges, showing how PTI can deal with delayed-choice, interaction-free, and quantum-eraser experiments. Chapter 6 argues for the compatibility of PTI with relativity. Only emission and absorption, the endpoints of spacetime intervals, are empirical on the account. It is offered as a specifically relativistic virtue of the interpretation that it deals with absorption, which standard non-relativistic QM does not.
Chapter 7 returns to the metaphysical implications of PTI, and provides distinctions between PTI, as a kind of structural realist interpretation, and other structural realisms (PTI is weaker in that it “remains agnostic about what these sub-empirical offer and confirmation waves ‘really are’ in ontological terms”, 167) and modal realisms (the possibilities of PTI are dynamical). Chapter 8 couples the PTI to a `becoming’ view of time. These are very rich chapters philosophically, raising issues of causality, intersubjectivity, and metaphysical individuation; all of these ideas warrant more in-depth discussion. The final chapter is billed as an epilogue, and offers a reconciliation of a tension at the core of the account. The original motivation is to take the time-symmetry of the wave equation seriously, but the actualization of incipient possibilities on which the account also rests is radically temporally asymmetric. The reconciliation turns on asymmetric boundary conditions, particularly creation and destruction. Three technical appendices conclude the book.
More succinct and closely argued accounts of this interpretation can be found in the philosophical literature, but with the book, one can begin to see PTI as part of a larger approach to interpretation and philosophy. In the preface, Kastner expresses her hope that:
even if the reader does not come away convinced of the fruitfulness of the present approach, this presentation will serve as an invitation to further far-ranging and open discussion of the interpretational possibilities of quantum theory. (vii)
I expect a few readers will find themselves in the first category, but many more in the second.
