Although not directed at theatre professionals or contemporary audiences of Aristophanic performance, this rich academic study of the intellectual and political context of the plays undertakes an important investigation of the role and function of comic dramatic narratives. Richly steeped in classical scholarship and certainly offering a challenging read for the non-classicist, Ruffell refreshingly connects Platonic theories of art and letters with familiar cultural references to cinema and television, from Airplane! to Monty Python and South Park; both historical and modern comic material is deconstructed and analysed from various critical and semiotic viewpoints.
Ruffell's aims are clear: ‘to investigate, analyse and relate the principal areas of impossibility in which Attic Old Comedy, not least Aristophanes, operated’ (p. 18). The author explores complex questions of form and content in the genre's exploitation of metatheatre and self-reflexivity, jokes and parody, and continues an ongoing question in Aristophanic studies: whether the interrelationship of ideology and form reveals a serious purpose. The Old Comedy's ‘impossible worlds’, ‘those that involve paradoxes or other logical contradictions’ (p. 35), cannot be comprehended through deconstruction or simplistic theoretical modelling, and so the author takes pains to expose his material to widely diverse theoretical perspectives.
The episodic structure of Old Comedy, where many sequences are little more than dramatized jokes, prompts the consideration of joke structures and semiotics. Ruffell refreshingly cites The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy as analogous to Old Comedy narratives and uses it to launch a theory of jokes and an analysis of humour. He argues that although critics of Aristophanes have worked hard to interpret obscure comic references, they usually have sought to discover the ‘serious’ intent; this not only ‘downgrades the role of humour, but also begs the question about how jokes work’ (p. 57). The consideration of contemporary gags and jokes, and their critical interpretation by recent thinkers, encourages more flexible thinking about the ways Old Comedy operates, and about how the episodes depend, as jokes do, on the audience's contextual knowledge ‘to be strongly disruptive, both to shatter an existing assumption or world and reassemble it in a new form’ (p. 111).
Ruffell's succeeding chapters consider comic motivation, finding analogies in recent films with Old Comedy plots and narratives; in ‘Comic Networks’ he suggests that it is through the ‘joke-centred narrative that Aristophanes makes his most significant and ideological interventions’ (p. 157); and in ‘Entering the Metaverse’ he considers the elements of self-reflexivity and direct address that permeate the plays. Ruffell's remaining chapters, ‘The Role of the Audience’, ‘Flights of Fancy’, and ‘Continuity and Competition’, are followed by a concluding chapter on politics and ideology.
The result is a remarkable study, hugely erudite in its interrogation of the problematics of the fictional worlds and comic conventions of the Aristophanic canon. Its richness is its rigorous semiotic scrutiny of comic invention and the development of theoretical models in the context of familiar examples of contemporary cinema and television. Contrasting Otto von Bismarck's assertion that ‘politics is the art of the possible’, Ruffell contends that Old Comedy, by exploiting the impossible, ‘takes the naïve, implausible, impractical, utopian and downright silly … to interrogate Athenian politics, culture and society’ (p. 429). The book is a massive achievement, and a challenging read. Its target audience will largely be classicists and students of cultural theory, and although it may be caviar to the general there is much here to illuminate and stimulate theatre practitioners planning Old Comedy revivals.
