In the last three decades the notion of “mobility” has been a key issue in our understanding of some of the central historical processes at work in the ancient Mediterranean basin.Footnote 1 A number of theoretical models, such as the “network theory,” or notions such as “connectivity” and “middleground,” are centered on mobility phenomena and emphasize the role of interactions between human groups in the development of social, political, and economic processes.Footnote 2 By their very nature, these interpretative models work with a dual perspective, one focused on wide-scale geographic phenomena and the other on the different local dynamics and their specific outcomes. A highly significant field of application for these theoretical approaches has been the “Greek colonization” phenomenon. The beginning of the postcolonial era led to a profound rethinking of this historical process. Previous notions, such as “Hellenization” or “acculturation,” have consequently been set aside; conversely, the active role of a variety of local populations in the formation process of new sociocultural and political realities has been emphasized.
When applied to the study of ancient production, and to pottery production in particular, the concept of “mobility” involves a wide range of issues. In this regard, we can explore the social and economic conditions that underpinned these dynamics of mobility, the trajectories they followed, and the outcomes they achieved in terms of production features, topographical distribution over time, and the geographical and hierarchical organization of productive centers. In recent years, these issues have been at the core of the scientific debate on red-figure pottery. The migration of Greek (Attic) craftsmen and vase-painters can explain the introduction of red-figure production in southern Italy, starting from the second half of the 5th c. BCE. Movements of single artisans or groups on an interregional scale, and their interactions with local contexts and customers, were the basis for the emergence of regional traditions and styles. As far as this phenomenon is concerned, a key factor was the rise of some “primary” cities – such as Taranto and Metaponto – as reception centers for early artisans coming from mainland Greece and as places of artistic formation for those who then went on to work in other colonial and indigenous contexts. A. D. Trendall's fundamental work has been followed by the need for new approaches to the study of vases aimed, first, at focusing on the productive and distribution processes, their specific contexts, and the profiles and variability of the agents involved; and, second, at developing new integrated datasets and comparative analyses on a local, regional, and interregional scale.Footnote 3
This field of research now includes the 2012 conference organized by the Centre Jean Bérard and devoted to the red-figure pottery from Magna Graecia and Sicily, of which the book in question constitutes the proceedings. In the “Presentazione” (7–16), the editors declare the assumptions and objectives of the volume, and outline the structure of the book in its four sections and the papers collected within them.
The first section (17–95) focuses on the Himera Painter and the Locri Group, and their activities within Sicily and southern Italy. M. Serino proposes an analysis of the Himera Painter's activity based on a group of finds from the eponymous town (19–39). The main novelty of this study consists of a new hypothesis according to which this artisan emigrated from Magna Grecia to Sicily after a formation period in proto-Apulian workshops on the Ionian coast, around the beginning of the last quarter of the 5th c. BCE. The comparative evaluation of stylistic and iconographic features of his dossier with others belonging to different workshops (such as the Sisyphus painter, Tarporley, and Amykos Painters) allows the author to outline a clear framework of connections between the Himeran production and contemporary proto-Apulian traditions, and to propose a shorter chronological gap between the beginning of red-figure production in southern Italy and Sicily. The contribution ends with a focus on one of the archaeological contexts in which some of the finds being considered were discovered (33–34). The context in question is a circular pit containing, among other things, two skyphoi ascribed to the Himera Painter. The other items found in the pit are generically dated to the second half of the 5th c. (33 n.50). The analysis of this context deserves a broader discussion. We know, for example, that the pit was located inside a room (number 12, block 2, zone II, block II), but no information is provided about this structure: When was it built? Did it have any subsequent building phases? Was it destroyed by the Carthaginians in 409 BCE as seems to be the case (see below)? The pit was also covered by a layer of rubble – perhaps connected to the obliteration of the room – which contained a Rheghion coin dated to the last two decades of the 5th c. BCE; this find would seem to constitute a terminus ante quem for the creation of the pit. However, no information is provided on the layer(s) which was/were cut by the pit, which could have provided a more detailed terminus post quem for its formation. It would have been helpful if the author had specified whether or not this data was available.
The remaining three contributions of this section are all dedicated to the Locri Group. The first considers the earliest phase of workshop activity in Sicily (41–63). Barresi analyzes a dossier of 15 vases identified as the group's early Sicilian production (42, fig. 1). He examines the stylistic and iconographic character of these works, highlighting their peculiarity in the field of Italiote repertoires. According to the author, the first phases of the workshops were influenced more by Attic models than by Italic ones. The methodological approach based on the analysis of the morphological and decorative features of the vases, and the comparison with Attic and Italiote contemporary production, is fruitful and allows the author to outline an articulated and more nuanced reconstruction of early red-figure production in Sicily.
The second paper focuses on an unpublished skyphos found in the 1970s on Gela's acropolis (the modern Molino a Vento site) and ascribed to the Locri Group by A. Santostefano (65–75). In light of the comparison with some other vases belonging to the same group and distributed between eastern Sicily and Locri, the author recognizes in this “new” find a link between the production of Sicilian workshops and that of its earliest “Locrian phase” (ca. 380–70 BCE). A significant epistemological point concerns the dating of the skyphos (72–73). According to Santostefano, its stylistic and iconographic features suggest a chronological range within the first quarter of the 4th c. (ca. 400–380 BCE). This date, however, is subsequent to the destruction of the city by the Carthaginians at the end of the 5th c. (405 BCE), but contemporary with the short-term reoccupation of the settlement (not widely known by scholars). Consequently, the author proposes a twofold interpretation: either the vase was at the site before the arrival of the Carthaginians, so it predates the fall of the city; or the vase belongs to the reoccupation phase of the site, and therefore should be dated after 405 BCE. Yet again, the information provided by the contextual data is unclear. From a stratigraphic point of view, fragments of the vessel were found distributed across a large area of the acropolis: in every case, these were identified as deriving from the upper layer of the site. It is uncertain whether these layers belonged to the final phases of the Greek polis or to later periods of the site, although the author mentions the hypothesis that the wide distribution of the fragments can be understood in light of the Carthaginian destruction (73). Furthermore, no information is provided on finds associated with the fragments under study, preventing the identification of residual or intrusive pieces.
The final chapter in the section, D. Elia's contribution, is dedicated to the “Locrian phase” of the workshop (77–95). According to the author, the chronology of its transfer to Magna Graecia could have been related to the political connection between Locri and the Sicilian poleis (and particularly Syracuse) at the beginning of the 4th c. BCE. In addition to this exegetical key, other aspects to consider are the role played by the Carthaginians on the southwestern side of the island and the related crisis, and/or decline, of vase production there at the end of the 5th c. (on this perspective, see also Santostefano, 73). Elia embarks on an articulated analysis of the Locrian production, taking recent archaeological acquisitions into account. Starting from the morphological repertoire of the vessels, the author highlights the peculiarities of this corpus and its difference from earlier Sicilian production, probably conditioned by the needs of local customers. The analytical overview proposed by Elia is very detailed, particularly in his examination of vase forms and their distribution between Sicily and Calabria; in this regard, the considerable increase of calyx and bell kraters, and the appearance of the lekane, undocumented in the Sicilian phase of the group, seems significant. His analysis of the decorative and iconographic repertoires is less systematic; these aspects are only discussed in reference to the finds he mentions, resulting in a lack of clarity regarding the overall iconographic and decorative differences between the two production phases.
The second section of the book is devoted to a specific case study, namely tomb number 100 from the Torre di Mare necropolis (Metaponto), and to the contemporary Metapontine production context. In the panorama of the western Greek apoikiai, the necropolises of Metaponto are among the best known. During recent decades, new archaeological research and an increase in the number of studies have expanded our knowledge on this aspect of the polis. The publication of the archaeological excavations in the ancient city's chora led by the University of Texas at Austin has allowed us to better define the chronology and various trajectories of settlement dynamics, as well as the social and economic profiles of the inhabitants over time.Footnote 4 This research project also includes the first complete publication of a funerary context located in the rural territory of the polis, the Pantanello necropolis.Footnote 5 As far as the urban area is concerned, the recent publication of a highly interesting grave nucleus, located in the modern Contrada Crucinia near the city's western gate, is of the utmost importance. The nucleus belongs to an aristocratic group and can be dated between the beginning and the middle of the 6th c. BCE. For the first time, it provides us with an image of the Metapontine elites during the foundation era of the polis.Footnote 6
Within this panorama we can also include the preliminary edition of the Torre di Mare necropolis, presented by A. De Siena in this volume (99–133). The necropolis was located outside the southwestern corner of the city. The first phase of archaeological excavations (2002–4) brought to light 253 tombs of different types and structures, dating from the second quarter of the 6th c. to the end of the 3rd c. BCE. According to De Siena, it is likely that the funerary area was larger than the area now visible (101). Within it, the tombs were organized by groups, probably corresponding to family clusters. Significantly, this necropolis includes at least two tombs (18 and 91) which likely belong to non-Greeks. Natives’ tombs dating back to colonial times and located within the city's territory are few and far between and often resist precise dating.Footnote 7 Consequently, tombs 18 and 91 are of great importance to our knowledge of the presence and social status of natives within the population of the polis (103–4). Awaiting the completion of the publication of the tombs discovered so far and the extension of archaeological research on the site, the author presents a group of eight tombs dated between the middle of the 5th c. and the end of the 4th c. (according to the chronological sequence, tombs 100, 93, 94, 98, 99, 101, 102, and 103). A detailed “Catalogo” (116–31) describes the grave-good assemblages found in each tomb. In particular, De Siena focuses on two red-figure vessels from tomb 100, a lekythos and a lebes, both ascribed to the Dolon Painter (see also Denoyelle in this volume), for which he also proposes an iconological exegesis (105–15). According to the author, the first vessel could represent the encounter between Paris and Helen and their marriage preparations. The second is decorated with two different scenes depicted on either side of the vase and can be identified as Paris's marriage proposal to Helen and Odysseus's embassy to the Trojans demanding Helen's return (for a different interpretation of these scenes, see Pouzadoux in this volume).
The second contribution to the section, by F. Silvestrelli (135–60), broadens our perspective on Metapontine production, exploring the wider panorama of the morphological repertoire of fine wares between the 5th c. and the end of the 4th c. BCE. This lengthy period is divided by the author into three phases (or two periods, of which the first is articulated in two phases): the first half of the 5th c., the second half of the 5th c., and the 4th c. For the most part, the finds considered in this chapter derive from funerary contexts. Considering the urban area, a particularly significant discovery is the kerameikos.Footnote 8 The long-term chronological approach adopted by Silvestrelli allows her to trace an articulated sequence of significant transformations, continuities, or discontinuities within vase shapes and productive technologies and, additionally, to speculate about possible motivations behind the selection, adoption, and modification of Metapontine vase morphologies and techniques. In this light, a particularly fruitful element is the author's systematic comparison between the pottery repertoire's preservation of traditional features and its introduction of innovations over time. According to Silvestrelli, the first important break with tradition identified (the first half of the 5th c.) coincides with the transition from Late Archaic production to that which adopted the new black-glazed technique and forms influenced by Attic models. The second break with tradition (the second half of the 5th c.) covers the beginning of red-figure pottery production in Italy and a more profound reception of Attic models and productive practices. The last chronological segment (4th c.) is characterized by the Dolon Painter's workshop activity and by the increasing presence of Apulian products in the city, a phenomenon that begins in the first quarter of the century and becomes more significant during the second half of the same period. In light of the recent discovery of new vases ascribed to Apulian painters of the early 4th c. (such as the Tarporley, Bendis, and Dechter Painters), Silvestrelli hypothesizes that these artisans were temporarily present in Metaponto (150–51). This is an appealing proposal – particularly because of the city's primary role, like that of Taranto, in the productive geography of southern Italy – but will have to be verified through future archaeological discoveries.
The section ends with M. Denoyelle's contribution, which investigates the role and influence of Attic stylistic models on the red-figure repertoire of Metaponto (161–69). It is traditionally believed that Attic models were most influential in the first stages of Metapontine ceramic production, introduced to the city by an Attic artisan, the Pisticci Painter. Using the two vases found in tomb 100 of Torre di Mare, the lebes gamikos and the lekythos ariballica (see above), as a starting point, the author draws a more articulated and nuanced picture. An interesting point in Denoyelle's discussion is the growing mastery of Italiote artisans in the iconographic themes and formal models of the Attic repertoire, which would have been decomposed and reworked according to the specific needs of the craftsman and the product's intended context.
The third section is made up of two papers. The first, by C. Pouzadoux, focuses on the iconographic exegesis of the scenes depicted on the lebes from tomb 100 of the Torre di Mare necropolis (173–87). As we have seen, De Siena identifies the scenes on either side of the vase with the encounter between Paris and Helen in the presence of Cassandra, and Odysseus's embassy to Antenor to demand that Helen be returned to the Achaeans. Pouzadoux traces an alternative hypothesis for the second scene, which shows three female figures on the left and two male ones on the right. The women are seated, two on an altar, while the seat of the third is not represented. The head of the last is bent and rests on her left hand, seemingly in thought. Behind her we find a statue of Apollo, represented as an archer. The second female figure, in the center of the trio, unveils her face in a gesture related to the marriage ceremony (anakalypsis)Footnote 9 and looks at the third woman, who is seated next to her. The two male figures are depicted standing and wearing a himation. One is a veiled elderly man, who reaches out his right hand to the other in front of him. The latter is younger and holds a long spear in one hand and a pilos in the other. Starting from an examination of the three seated female figures, Pouzadoux proposes an identification of the scene with a representation of Anius, king of Delos, and his three daughters.Footnote 10 According to different traditions, Agamemnon, Menelaus, Odysseus, and Palamedes asked the king for supplies for the Greek army at the beginning of the Trojan War. Since the vase is ascribed to the Dolon Painter, if this hypothesis were correct then this would be the earliest iconographic representation of the myth of Anius in Italy; in fact, it would precede two vessels by the Darius Painter decorated with the same theme (180). Moreover, in light of the likely presence of the Darius Painter in Metaponto – testified by some waste fragments ascribed to him from the urban kerameikos – the author proposes a connection between the Dolon Painter's workshop and the Darius Painter's formation period in the city.
From an exegetical point of view, both interpretations – De Siena's and Pouzadoux's – possess some flaws. In the first case (the embassy for the return of Helen), the lack of Menelaus in the scene would be an unusual iconographic choice, as De Siena also notes (113–14). In the second hypothesis (the embassy to Anius), Pouzadoux highlights that there are no elements that specify the identity of the king's three daughters (Oeno, Spermo, and Elais), unlike on the Darius Painter's two vases (182). Additionally, this exegesis would not explain the concerned attitude of the first woman to the far right of the trio, which would, in contrast, be coherent with a representation of Helen worried about her fate. In conclusion, in both cases the proposed exegesis prefers to include the lebes image in a small group of scenes from the Torre di Mare necropolis inspired by Iliadic themes. In addition to this vase and the lekythos from the same tomb (see above), this group is made up of another find decorated with a similar figurative theme, in this case a pelike, from tomb 98, ascribed to the Long Overfalls Painter and decorated with the scene of Ajax's violence toward Cassandra in the presence of the agalma of Athena and the priestess Theano (123, figs. 29–31). According to De Siena, “[s]i tratta di immagini che fanno riferimento a temi molto specifici, selezionati consapevolmente per marcare una precisa identità culturale” (105). The scant evidence currently available prevents us from ascertaining whether the ideological criteria underlying the selection of these iconographies can be understood within the political and cultural context of late 5th- and early 4th-c. BCE Metaponto, which was characterized by strong tensions with Taranto for the control of the Siritide.Footnote 11
The second paper is devoted to a group of ceramic fragments found in the area of the Tarentine Arsenale Militare at the beginning of the 20th c. (189–204). There are more than 400 finds, mainly belonging to monumental vases used as semata or valuable offerings within the funerary area nearby. Unfortunately, the lack of excavation reports prevents us from understanding the ancient context of these objects. A. D'Amicis presents a preliminary report of a selected number of red-figure fragments dated between the second half of the 5th c. and the end of the 4th c. BCE. She draws a schematic diachronic overview of the morphological, stylistic, and iconographic features of these finds in each production period, occasionally focusing on some particularly significant objects. Of note among them is the presence of production waste that attests to local production within the considered corpus. Despite the complete loss of the vases’ ancient context, their typological and chronological articulation and the variety of artistic personalities identified with them make this dossier a fundamental piece of evidence for our knowledge of the Tarentine productive and commercial profile over time and of the dynamics of mobility in which the polis was involved. From this perspective, the complete publication of this documented context is all the more necessary.
The fourth section, like the previous one, is composed of two contributions, both devoted to the Ascoli Satriano Painter. The activity of this painter, likely following a formative period in Campania (perhaps within the Boston Orestes Painter's workshop), is characterized by a productive phase in Daunia; all vases attributed to him were discovered here – 64 finds in total – for which we know the related archaeological context of 30. It therefore constitutes a significant case study of the issues related to mobility and dynamics of interaction between a Greek artisanal context and a non-Greek clientele. M. Corrente focuses on the “Ipogeo della situla di Hermes,” which hosted rich ceramic grave goods, including 28 red-figure vases ascribed to the Ascoli Satriano Painter (208–19). The author proposes an examination of the ceramic assemblage, as well as the morphological and iconographic features of the finds. She also highlights the selective criteria that inspired the composition of the sets and the Campanian (“Paestan”) stylistic traits documented on some of the most significant items. In this regard, a central issue is represented by the analysis of the relationship between the painter's cultural profile and production within the Daunian context (212–13). According to Corrente, the Campanian morphological and stylistic traits adopted in his repertoire represented the outcomes of his specific and conscious ideological choices, in opposition to the Daunian production context: “Il pittore è in grado di promuovere la cultura pestana nel paese di accoglienza, con una costruzione condivisa in cui le conoscenze, le innovazioni, e le pratiche adottate sono esplorazioni di un ‘secondo spazio’ culturale, nuovo e diverso. Si tratta di una sfida in cui il pittore non vede l'esperienza italiota come minaccia alla originaria identità ma come linguaggio aggiuntivo in grado di esaltare la propria forte cultura di appartenenza” (213).
This perspective, however, does not seem to take due account of the vital role of the customers in the compositional choices of their own systems of self-representation and the symbolic and ideological implications that objects and images, even of foreign provenance, acquired in their context of consumption.
The book concludes with the contribution of F. Rossi (221–31). He begins his chapter with the 2005 discovery of a tomb in Arpi which contained two vases ascribed to the Ascoli Satriano Painter. He provides an overview of the production of this artisan, examining his complete corpus as well as some specific attributions, the stylistic and iconographic characters of his repertoire, and the selection criteria of the represented figurative themes.
The volume is accompanied by a rich illustrative apparatus of the discussed finds and the comparisons provided. However, an indication of the size (or a metric scale) of all illustrated items would have been appreciated.
The work offers a wide and updated overview on the problems related to artisan mobility between Magna Graecia and Sicily, addressing many central issues such as the importance of primary centers as places of artistic formation, the relationship between artisans and local customers, and the circulation and reshaping of iconographic models. It also provides several pieces of essential information and a significant update on many important contexts and documentary dossiers. Nevertheless, beyond the specific conclusions – all laudable – reached by each individual author, as a whole the book succeeds in pursuing the aim of a historical focus that can allow us to reference these repertoires within their specific contexts of production and consumption. Evidently, it is nearly impossible to eliminate the ambiguities and problems involved in this methodological approach and in processing and comparing different kind of information sources. Issues commonly arise due to our uneven and sometimes poor knowledge of archaeological contexts, or the research methods applied during the excavations, or even an inadequate analytical approach in their study. However, the difficulties involved in the contextual and multidisciplinary analysis of various kinds of data should not be a barrier to our knowledge, but rather an incentive to improve our epistemological method. From this perspective, the work conducted by the group of scholars at the Centre Jean Bérard conference constitutes a significant attempt to pursue this path, and further work with this approach will surely follow.
