No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 May 2004
Over the past year, aggressive billing practices have been exposed at a number of hospitals in the United States. Despite the fact that a widower had paid $16,000 of his late wife's bill of $18,740, some 20 years after the incurrence of the bill a teaching hospital held a lien on his home for $40,000 in interest. Many years earlier the hospital had seized his bank account, and now the 77-year-old man was destitute. Only tremendous publicity caused the hospital to back down. That same week, another nonprofit teaching hospital reportedly drove a 25-year-old uninsured woman from New York City while dunning her for a $19,000 bill for a two-day stay for an appendectomy. In California, a patient was forced into bankruptcy in 2000 by a for-profit hospital from a day-and-a-half stay in the hospital that did not include any surgery but totaled $48,000 in hospital bills. These have become common stories as hospitals aggressively market, bill, collect, and foreclose, just like any other corporation. The uninsured are facing the brunt of the hospital industry's billing practices.
Over the past year, aggressive billing practices have been exposed at a number of hospitals in the United States. Despite the fact that a widower had paid $16,000 of his late wife's bill of $18,740, some 20 years after the incurrence of the bill a teaching hospital held a lien on his home for $40,000 in interest.1
Lagnado L. Jeanette White is long dead but her hospital bill lives on. Wall Street Journal 2003 Mar 13;B1.
Lagnado L. After 20 years and $16,000, a hospital debt is canceled: Quinton White gets new-found freedom from crushing, 20-year debt to hospital. Wall Street Journal 2003 April 1;B1.
Lagnado L. One critical appendectomy later, young woman has a $19,000 debt: Ms. Nix confronts facts of health-care: the uninsured are billed sharply more. Wall Street Journal 2003 Mar 17;A1.
Silber J. Costly hospital care scrutinized at hearing: Tenet and others are accused of regularly charging exorbitant fees for uninsured patients. Contra Costa Times 2003 Feb 7;D1.
The magnitude of this problem was recently spotlighted by the release of the Census Bureau's data on uninsured persons in America. In 2001, an estimated 41.2 million people had no health insurance, representing 14.6% of the overall population.5
Mills RJ. Health coverage: 2001. U.S. Census Bureau 2002 Sep;P60-220:1–23.
The fact that hospitals run as a business comes as no surprise to anyone, given that hospitals were declared businesses by court decision in 1960.6
Flagiello v. Pennsylvania Hospital. Nos. 293, 351, January term, 1964 Supreme Court of Pennsylvania 417 Pa. 486; 208 A. 2d. 193; 1965 Pa. LEXIS 442.
My purpose is to explore how hospital billing in the United States became so unequal and delineate the ethical dilemma it now poses.
Hospitals in the United States are divided into three categories.7
Shi L, Singh DA. Delivering Health Care in America 2001. Gaithersburg, MD: Aspen; 2002:287–90.
Municipal hospitals include those run by federal, state, and local governments. Federal hospitals deal with exclusive populations such as the military, veterans, and Native Americans, and the bill is paid entirely by the federal government. State and local facilities are usually not exclusive, and the governments usually only contribute a small portion to the entire budget of the hospitals. According to 2000 statistics by the American Hospital Association, municipal hospitals represent about 20% of the total number of hospitals in America.8
American Hospital Association Resource Center. Fast facts on U.S. hospitals from hospital statistics. 2002 Dec 10 [cited 2003 Apr 30]. Available from: http://www.hospitalconnect.com/aha/resource_center/fastfacts/fast_facts_US_hospitals.html.
For-profit hospitals represent about 30% of U.S. hospitals and are a growing portion.9
See note 8, American Hospital Association 2002.
Stevens R. In Sickness and in Wealth, 2nd ed. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1999.
See note 10, Stevens 1999:231–2.
Nonprofit hospitals represent about half of the hospitals in America.12
See note 8, American Hospital Association 2002.
See note 10, Stevens 1999:290.
See note 10, Stevens 1999:285.
Hospitals in the United States were originally founded on the alms-house paradigm from England. Primarily founded by charitable organizations, they provided free care with doctors who worked for charity.15
See note 10, Stevens 1999:8.
Sultz HA, Young KM. Health Care USA: Understanding Its Organization and Delivery, 2nd ed. Gaithersburg, MD: Aspen; 1999.
With the passage of the Hospitals Survey and Construction Act of 1946 (i.e., the Hill-Burton Act), hospitals were given federal money to be built or expanded.17
42 USCS sect. 291 et seq. (2003).
See note 16, Sultz, Young 1999:65.
Berk DK. Presbyterian Hospital of Dallas v. Harris: a dubious consequence of piecemeal health care legislation. American Journal of Law and Medicine 1983;9:205–24, at 209.
The courts reinterpreted the Hill-Burton Act in 1970 to require a certain percentage of charitable work to be done by any hospital that had accepted Hill-Burton funding.20
Cook et al. v. Oschner Foundation Hospital. 319 F Supp. 603, 11 ALR Fed. 677.
See note 10, Stevens 1999:315.
Utah County v. Intermountain Healthcare, Inc. No. 18565 Supreme Court of Utah 725 P. 2d. 1357; 42 Utah Adv. Rep. 12; 1986 Utah LEXIS 871.
With the passage of Medicare and Medicaid in 1965, there was suddenly coverage for a large percentage of the uninsured population in America.23
Ball RM. What Medicare's architects had in mind. Health Affairs 1995;14:62–72.
See note 10, Stevens 1999:315.
Hearings had been held on Diagnostic Related Groups (DRGs) as early as 1971 in an effort for cost containment.25
See note 16, Sultz, Young 1999:222.
Wing KR. American health policy in the 1980s. Case Western Reserve Law Review 1986;36:608–85.
Frankford DM. The complexity of Medicare's hospital reimbursement system: paradoxes of averaging. Iowa Law Review 1993;78:517–68.
Meyer JA, Johnson WR. Cost shifting in health care: an economic analysis. Health Affairs 1983;2:21–35.
To some extent, cost shifting had existed before this because costs for indigent patient care had to be covered somehow. Donations to hospitals have not made up a substantial portion of their income for many years, on average less than 1% now.29
Sloan F. Not-for-profit ownership and hospital behavior. In: Culyer AJ, Newhouse JP, eds. Handbook of Health Economics: Vol. 1B. New York: Elsevier; 2000:1141–74.
The concept of cost shifting has been used in a number of business areas but always refers to charging others to pay for others not paying their share. Although a number of hospital apologists have tried to claim that it does not exist in the hospital industry, this argument has never been logical.30
King G. Federal cost shifting is more myth than reality. National Underwriter 1995 Sept 18;99:44–6.
Spencer P. The big cost shifters. Consumers' Research Magazine 1994 Sep;77:43.
At least one hospital administrator was honest enough to describe how he did it,32
Marchasin S. Pricing health care: cost shifting: how one hospital does it. Wall Street Journal 1991 Dec 9;A14.
Wilensky GR. Solving uncompensated hospital care: targeting the indigent and the uninsured. Health Affairs 1984;3:50–62.
See note 31, Spencer 1994:43.
Bloche MG. Health care below the waterline: medical care and the charitable exemption. Minnesota Law Review 1995;80:299–405.
Clement went even farther, distinguishing between static cost shifting—the government paying less than full costs—and dynamic cost shifting—the raising of prices to some payers because others have lowered their payments.36
Clement JP. Dynamic cost shifting in hospitals: Evidence from the 1980s and 1990s. Inquiry—Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association 1997/98;34:340–50.
When Meyer and Johnson discussed cost shifting during the implementation of prospective payments by Medicare, they anticipated that insurance companies would be charged more to make up the difference.37
See note 28, Meyer, Johnson 1983:24.
Wielawski I. Gouging the medically uninsured: a tale of two bills. Health Affairs 2000;19(5):180–5.
When someone is admitted to a hospital, he is required to sign forms accepting responsibility for his hospital bill, despite not knowing the price. The type of hospital makes no difference here: all hospitals require this. Some hospitals even list their policies in print and on the Internet.39
Yale–New Haven Hospital. Financial arrangements and billing. 2002 May 23 [cited 2003 May 6]. Available at: http://www.ynhh.org/patients/admitting/finance.html.
The Social Security Act under which Medicare and Medicaid function makes it illegal for hospitals to bill patients any more than what the government allows, usually making the patient liable for only 20% of the allowed.40
42 USCS sect. 1395m (2003).
Given that the uninsured become legally responsible for a hospital bill of which they may have no idea how much it will be, they may be stuck with financial disaster. Indeed, even as bankruptcies are up in the face of the poor economy, about half of all personal bankruptcy in the United States are due to hospital bills, estimated at over 500,000 per year.41
Jacoby MB, Sullivan TA, Warren E. Medical problems and bankruptcy filings. Norton Bankruptcy Law Advisor 2000;5:1–11.
Economic justice can be mentioned only to note its lack of position in the judicial history of the United States.42
Pouncy CRP. Economic justice and economic theory: limiting the reach of neoclassical ideology. Journal of Law and Public Policy 2002;14:11–30.
Scott C. Why law pervades medicine: an essay on ethics in health care. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics, and Public Policy 2000;14:245–303.
Friedman M. Capitalism and Freedom. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1982.
See note 29, Sloan 2000:1160.
Public hospitals would have a hard time justifying such actions also, because they provide services for their constituencies with public money. Obviously, the military, Indian Health Service, and veterans hospitals do not practice cost shifting because they do not bill their patients. If a hospital supported by a city, county, or a state government practiced such billing practices, this could be a real moral dilemma. Bankrupting one taxpayer to pay the costs of another could be seen as truly capricious. But the examples in the literature do not include any municipal hospitals. I suspect that the billing practices of state-run hospitals, especially those affiliated with medical schools, may not be very different than the rest of the nonprofits, but this should be looked at in the future.
Nonprofit hospitals are the crux of this ethical question. They have been cited as cost shifting significant burdens onto the shoulders of one portion of the uninsured patients, causing incalculable financial suffering. Some might try to argue, under Rawls, that for the greater good of society, charging some more to keep the hospitals solvent would justify such actions.46
Rawls JB. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1971.
See note 46, Rawls 1971:266.
Höffe O. Immanuel Kant. Albany: Albany State University of New York Press; 1994.
MacIntyre A. After Virtue, 2nd ed. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press; 1984.
The Code of Ethics of the American College of Healthcare Executives has the stated purpose of guiding the conduct of its members. The stated objectives of the profession “are to enhance overall quality of life, dignity, and well-being of every individual needing healthcare services; and to create a more equitable, accessible, effective and efficient healthcare system” (pp. 168–9).50
Perry F. The Tracks We Leave: Ethics in Healthcare Management. Chicago: Health Administration Press; 2002. Emphasis added.
Nonprofit hospitals already reap huge economic rewards through the tax exemption by the IRS. This deprives federal and state governments of income tax revenue, and localities lose sales and property taxes. Many authors have attacked nonprofit hospitals in the last 20 years for not providing enough charitable care or community benefit to justify their tax exemption.51
Colombo JD, Hall MA. The future of tax-exemption for nonprofit hospitals and other health care providers. Health Matrix: Journal of Law-Medicine 1992;2:1–34.
Roska AKB. Nonprofit hospitals: the relationship between charitable tax exemptions and medical care for indigents. Southwestern Law Journal 1989;43:759–83.
It is rare in a discussion of medical ethics that the discussion turns to business ethics. It has been long known that healthcare in America is not close to being a free-market economy. The government interventions with their price controls have contributed to distorting it significantly. Additionally, the lack of perfect knowledge for the consumers keeps the market imperfect. As long as the patients do not know what their hospital costs are going to be and cannot compare between institutions, this will not change. But this is an important point to bring out: healthcare in America charges patients in a manner disproportionate to their ability to pay. I do not think that hospitals set out to deliberately discriminate and economically harm this class of patients. It has evolved slowly over the past 35 years of Medicare and Medicaid payments. It is indicative of how sick our healthcare system in America has become. If this is what hospitals are doing, one can only wonder what is happening in other parts of the healthcare system. Something needs to be done about it. Indeed, Connecticut has now passed a bill to alleviate this problem, and California has had a similar type bill introduced.53
Lagnado L. Taming hospital billing: lawmakers push legislation to restrain aggressive collection against uninsured. Wall Street Journal 2003 Jun 10:B1.