No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 January 2004
DISSERTATION AWARDS
For the best doctoral dissertation completed and accepted in 2001 or 2002 in the field of comparative politics.
Award Committee: Anthony Marx, Amherst College, chair; Stathis Kalyvas, University of Chicago; and Aili Tripp, University of Wisconsin, Madison.
Recipient: Julia Lynch, Harvard University
Dissertation: “The Age of Welfare: Citizens, Clients and Generations in the Development of the Welfare State”
Dissertation Chair: Bruce Cain, University of California, Berkeley
Citation: By linking political economy and political competition Lynch specifies the conditions under which social welfare policies tend to benefit older versus younger citizens. She argues that a generational bias in social welfare programs emerges when these programs are occupational rather than citizenshipbased and political competition is particularistic rather than programmatic. This novel argument is empirically supported against various alternative hypotheses through a broad combination of tools, including in-depth historical case studies and large-N analysis. The question is theoretically and politically important and the demonstration is superb.
She has an interesting well delimited project, excellent operationalization, and good historical and comparative dimensions. Lynch starts with an excellent introduction that lays out the thesis, states the significance of the problem, offers competing perspectives, provides key definitions, draws on historical perspectives, and suggests her own explanation for the age-orientation of welfare states. The dissertation goes on to expand on the introduction with a background on the three categories of countries grouped according to their social policy regimes regarding age-orientation of social policies followed by three chapters that examine three key mechanisms that affect ageorientation of social policies in Italy and Netherlands. The conclusions are generalized in a chapter that looks at overall statistical trends in age-orientation of social spending in 20 OECD countries and the final chapter succinctly draws conclusions and implications of the study. The dissertation is clearly written and flows well. The data, which draw on fieldwork interviews and statistical analysis, support the conclusions. It has all the attributes of a superb dissertation.
For the best doctoral dissertation completed and accepted in 2001 or 2002 in the general field of federalism or intergovernmental relations, or state and local politics.
Award Committee: Thad L. Beyle, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, chair; Laura S. Jensen, University of Massachusetts; and Ronald E. Weber, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee.
Recipient: Thad Kousser, University of California, Berkeley
Dissertation: “How Term Limits and Professionalization Reshape America's State Legislatures”
Dissertation Chair: Bruce Cain, University of California, Berkeley
Citation: Thad Kousser looks at the two competing themes of legislative reform of the past four decades—professionalism starting in the 1960s and then the term limit movement starting in the late 1980s and early 1990s. He neatly ties in his former experience in the New Mexico and California legislatures, four on-site visits to the states of California, Colorado, Maine and Oregon, and statistical analysis to explore how these competing themes have affected legislative leadership stability, committee roles, legislative achievement by individual members, legislative-executive bargaining, and production of policy innovations.
Awarded annually for the best dissertation in the field of public law.
Award Committee: C. Neal Tate, Vanderbilt University, chair; Rebecca Mae Salokar, Florida International University; and Daniel R. Pinello, John Jay College, CUNY.
Recipient: Jeffrey Kaplan Staton, Florida State University
Dissertation: “Judicial Activism and Public Authority Compliance: The Role of Public Support in the Mexican Separation-Of-Powers System”
Dissertation Chairs: Lee Epstein and John Carey, Washington University, St. Louis
Citation: Jeffrey Staton's dissertation is truly innovative and exciting. It crosses several intellectual boundaries and unites multiple traditions of inquiry. It employs positive political theory (embodied in an elegant game theory) to structure empirical analysis (using simultaneous equation models) of significant questions about the performance and functions of courts. It unites the rich ideographic description and analysis of area studies with the nomothetic concerns of modern comparative politics and the theoretical questions posed by compliance and impact studies in judicial politics. It contributes rigorously to the literature on courts and their publics. It is a case study with considerable potential for generalization beyond the contest of its particular case. Its inquiry is relevant to questions of substantial normative importance. All told, “Judicial Activism and Public Authority Compliance: The Role of Public Support in the Mexican Separation-of-Powers System” is all one could wish a Corwin Award winner to be.
For the best doctoral dissertation completed and accepted in 2001 or 2002 in the field of policy studies.
Award Committee: Steven Vogel, University of California, Berkeley, chair; Paul Rich, University of the Americas; and Jocelyn Elise Crowley, Rutgers University, New Brunswick.
Recipient: Kristin Goss, Georgetown University
Dissertation: “Disarmed: The Real American Gun Control Paradox”
Dissertation Chair: Robert D. Putnam, Harvard University
Citation: Goss's dissertation seeks to unravel a specific puzzle: Why does the United States lack a strong gun control movement, despite the public's consistently high support for gun control as shown in public opinion polls? Goss adopts a cost-benefit model to explain why gun control advocates have failed to forge a broad-based, sustained, and powerful movement. She contends that gun control advocates have lacked government agency sponsors to socialize the costs of political activity; they have failed to frame their case in a way that would individualize benefits to supporters; and they have been unable to devise an incremental strategy that would reward supporters with a series of small victories over time.
Goss marshals three distinct types of evidence to make her case. She reviews the history of the movement; she presents comparative case studies of other movements; and she reports on an original survey of gun control activists.
The award committee members were especially impressed with Goss's ability to tackle this puzzle in a methodologically innovative manner. The dissertation addresses a timely and important topic, and sheds new light on the problem in refreshingly clear prose.
For the best doctoral dissertation completed and accepted in 2001 or 2002 in the field of international relations, law, or politics.
Award Committee: Jeffrey W. Taliaferro, Tufts University, chair; G. John Ikenberry, Georgetown University; and Ashley J. Leeds, Rice University
Recipient: Stephen G. Brooks, Dartmouth College
Dissertation: “The Globalization of Production and International Security”
Dissertation chairs: Bruce Russett, Alexander Wendt, and Geoffrey Garret, Yale University.
Citation: Stephen Brooks addresses three significant puzzles at the intersection of international political economy (IPE) and security studies: the conditions under which states pursuing autarkic policies are a significant disadvantage in military technology relative to states with open trade policies; the conditions under which conquest produces significant economic rewards; and the conditions under which regional economic integration has a positive effect on states' military security.
The dissertation presents case studies of the Soviet Union's response to changes in military technology and global production in the 1970s and 1980s; the economic returns of the Soviet empire in Eastern Europe during the same period; and the waning of the long-standing Argentina-Brazil military rivalry in the 1990s. Changes in global production have shifted the scales in military technology against states with autarkic policies and toward states with open economies. From the mid-1970s onward, the Soviet Union faced deep and inevitable relative decline because of lack of access to foreign direct investment (FDI) and information technologies. Furthermore, as the Soviet experience illustrates, the economic benefits of conquest are extremely low for developed states. The most interesting finding is that increased competition for FDI promotes regional stability by encouraging traditional security rivals Brazil and Argentina to pursue policies of greater economic integration.
Brooks makes several theoretical contributions. First, he shows how material forces other than the relative distribution of military and economic power shape the parameters of states' external behavior. Second, he identifies a hidden bias in Kenneth Waltz's neorealism: that anarchy compels states to react to the mere possibility of international conflict, instead of the subjective probability of conflict. By explicitly incorporating rationalist assumptions, Brooks resolves several empirical anomalies for neorealism. Third, he specifies the relationship between grand theory and mid-range theories. Finally, he integrates realist and liberal hypotheses linking economic interdependence and international stability.
We welcome this young scholar to the community of academics concerned with peace and stability in international politics.
Given for the best dissertation in the field of American Politics.
Recipient: Tracy Elizabeth Sulkin, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Dissertation: “Rethinking Responsiveness: Campaign Themes, Legislative Agendas, and the Politics of Issue Uptake”
Dissertation Chair: Bryan Jones, University of Washington
Citation: This is a bold, innovative dissertation, which addresses one of the most important questions in the study of democratic politics—how campaigns contribute to representation. Congressional scholars have traditionally separated the study of campaigns and elections from the study of legislative behavior. With this dissertation, Professor Sulkin recognizes that both subfields are grounded in the idea that legislators, whether in Washington or as campaigners, are strategic actors. Building on this insight, Professor Sulkin identifies the issues raised by challengers in campaigns, then demonstrates that legislators in office subsequently incorporate their challengers' issues into their own legislative agendas. For evidence, she examines news coverage of recent congressional campaigns and analyzes the legislative activity of winning senators and House members in the term following the campaign. In its originality, breadth, theoretical contributions, and findings, this dissertation makes a major contribution to scholarship on Congress and on representation. We are pleased to congratulate Professor Sulkin and her committee at the University of Washington, consisting of Professors Bryan Jones (chair), John Wilkerson, Lance Bennett, and Peter May.
For the best doctoral dissertation completed and accepted in 2001 or 2002 in the field of political philosophy.
Award Committee: Joanna Vecchiarelli Scott, Eastern Michigan University, chair; Lisa J. Disch, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis; and Nathan Tarcov, University of Chicago.
Recipient: Arash Abizadeh, McGill University
Dissertation: “Rhetoric, the Passions, and Difference in Discursive Democracy”
Dissertation Chair: Seyla Benhabib, Yale University
Citation: The committee unanimously takes the greatest pleasure in awarding the Leo Strauss Award for the best Dissertation in Political Theory (2001-2002) to Arash Abizadeh. His remarkable thesis, “Rhetoric, the Passions and Difference in Discursive Democracy” is a tour de force. It marshals a remarkable defense of the modern liberal polity that marries the Enlightenment dream of the abstract rule of law with the freedom of plural passions and interests to generate a model of deliberative democracy in which citizens do not hesitate, as he says, “to speak truth to power.” Abizadeh's work, to borrow from Deleuze and Guattari's evocative metaphor, is a rhizomatic study spreading laterally to do its work in the intermezzo between the binary opposites of political rule and freedom, rational discourse and the rhetoric of the heart, liberal multiculturalism, and national mythic narratives of passion and identity. His goal is to clear a path toward a reflexive understanding between citizens in which there are no received truths placed beyond clarifying debate and modification. Through concentric circles of argument focused on the defensible boundaries of public discourse in a democracy, Abizadeh stakes his claim to making the “imaginative dimensions of national identity … subject to discursive political contestation.”
What has particularly impressed the committee is Abizadeh's strategic negotiation of this highly contested terrain. He moves from Aristotle to Benhabib and Habermas, nodding in the direction of most of the notables in the canon of democratic theory along the way, but also delving deeply into contemporary writers on community and identity such as Gopal Balakrishnan, David Miller, Joseph Raz, Anthony D. Smith and Charles Taylor. All these problmatizers of liberalism are given their due, but Abizadeh never mutes his own distinctive critical voice in the process.
Accordingly, Abizadeh has no particular sympathy for the liberal argument that cultural identities are beyond the reach of reflexive discourse and that their “conventionalist moralities” need to be preserved as he puts it, like “engendered species.” Religious fundamentalists, he argues, can privately practice their beliefs as they will, but he “fails to see good overriding reasons … (to) put the apparatus of the state at their service” by insulating them from critical reflexivity. He extends his argument to “aboriginal groups” which thinks should be given political autonomy “only insofar as they revise their traditional gender hierarchies along more egalitarian lines over time.” And in an irony fully worthy of the most hardcore Modernist, he connects Rousseau's argument that the “greater the insecurity of the patria's territory, the greater the consequent violence of the exclusionary sentiments that must be fostered in the hearts of citizens” to what he terms the “the dark side” of Quebecois culture nationalism.” He notes its anti-Semitic rhetoric which he implies is deliberate and a function of the need to evoke an antecedent, pre-political basis for national identity.
Abizadeh's defense of the middle ground, precariously located between ossified state-imposed uniformity and shifting boundaries of cultural conformity is not meant to reimpose a “modernizing utopia,” he says, where differences are flattened in the name of an abstract, denatured definition of democratic discourse. His alternative vision, no less idealistic for all its rhizomatic connections, is a compelling vision of democracy which appeals to the partly rational and partly emotive realm of Rousseau's “heart” where passions, reason, and narrativity can find make a common home. Rationalization of boundary claims, in this context, is a multi-vocal process composed of a variety of argumentative strategies, where thematizing some identities does not necessarily entail assimilation to others, but does require a commitment to open discourse as a shared fundamental value. Arash Abizadeh has, in our estimation, created a work of considerable intelligence and striking expression which meets the Aristotelian standard of rhetoric which he invokes to define his model of discourse— more a work of art than of instrumental logic.
For the best doctoral dissertation completed and accepted in 2001 or 2002 in the field of public administration.
Award Committee: Roy T. Meyers, University of Maryland, Baltimore County, chair; Daniel Carpenter, Harvard University; and Barbara J. Nelson, University of California, Los Angeles.
No award given.
PAPER AND ARTICLE AWARDS
For the best paper presented at the previous year's annual meeting. Supported by Pi Sigma Alpha.
Award Committee: Gregory A. Caldeira, Ohio State University (chair); Jean R. Schroedel, Claremont Graduate University, and Richard Valelly, Swarthmore College.
Recipient: Larry M. Bartels, Princeton University
Paper: “Economic Inequality and Political Representation”
Citation: The responsiveness of elected representatives to the preferences of the citizens they represent is an essential element of democratic politics. Studies of the nature and quality of political representation, and of citizens' political resources, have therefore constituted a large and important body of work. Yet, for all of the studies of inequalities in political participation and resources, Bartels points out, no one has studied in a systematic fashion whether representatives are more responsive to some citizens than to others—and in particular whether affluent citizens's preferences count more heavily. Thus, Bartels poses a critical question for our democratic polity: do the preferences of wealthier, better-educated, and more active citizens exert more influence over the votes of their representatives than do those of poorer, less educated, and less active citizens?
Using state-level surveys and roll-call data for the U.S. Senate over the course of the 1988–1992 elections, Bartels clearly demonstrates, with an exception here and there, that senators, in their overall voting patterns and on roll calls across several policy areas (minimum wage, civil rights, government spending, and abortion), are much more responsive to more affluent citizens than to those with modest incomes. The numbers are stark: “On average, my estimates suggest that constituents in the 75th percentile of income distribution have almost three times as much influence on senators's general voting patterns as those at the 25th percentile, and several times as much influence on specific salient votes.” And this pattern is even more pronounced among Republican senators. Part of the disproportional influence of the affluent, Bartels concludes, derives from their tendency to be more active in voting and contacting senators; and, he argues, the precise mechanisms by which affluence translates into greater influence require much further research. Based on detailed analysis of the data, Bartels comes to a sobering conclusion: “These disparities are especially troubling because of the potential for a debilitating feedback cycle linking the economic and political realms: increasing income inequality may produce increasing inequality in political responsiveness, which in turn produces public policies increasingly detrimental to the interests of poor citizens, which in turn produces even greater income inequality.”
Bartels's paper is a model of first-rate scholarship. He has identified a substantively important issue, one so far neglected in empirical research, and one of great contemporary relevance with terribly important normative implications for the health of democratic politics in the United States and of great interest to a wide variety of political scientists and perhaps to the reading public. The data he has chosen, state-level samples of citizens and Senate voting, are exceptionally welladapted to studying the question he has identified; and he handles the difficulties inherent in these data with admirable candor and aplomb, using sophisticated statistical techniques with a very light touch. Part and parcel of Bartels' graceful analytic presentation are its clear and crisp prose, well-constructed tables, and very telling figures.
That we should give this Award, named after a distinguished student of the Senate as an institution, to Professor Bartels for a study of the Senate's responsiveness is a not only a happy coincidence but also entirely appropriate.
For the best article published in the American Political Science Review during 2002.
Award Committee: Michael S. Lewis-Beck, University of Iowa; Joanne Gowa, Princeton University; and Paul Pierson, Harvard University.
Recipients: Stephen D. Ansolabehere, Massachusetts Institute of Technology; Alan Gerber, Yale University; and James M. Snyder, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Paper: “Equal Votes, Equal Money,” December 2002, American Political Science Review
Citation: In “Equal Votes, Equal Money,” Stephen Ansolabehere, Alan Gerber, and James Snyder ask a question of great importance to democratic political systems: does representation matter? In a series of decisions that began with Baker ν. Carr in 1962, the Court ordered that popular representation in state legislatures conform to a one-person, one-vote rule. At the time of Baker, only two states conformed to this rule. By 1972, every state in the union did so. This virtually simultaneous change in representation in 48 states offers a wonderful natural experiment for assessing representation's impact on government action.
The existing literature concludes that the Supreme Court decisions had no effect: state spending levels evidence no change in response to the implementation of the one-person, one-vote rule. The authors argue, however, that this is the wrong place to look. Baker ν. Carr implies that it is the distribution, not the level, of state spending that should shift. Thus, they collect county-level data from state reports to the Census of Governments before and after the Court's decisions (i.e., 1957, 1962, 1967, 1972, 1977, and 1982). The authors begin with two simple but compelling scatterplots that together show a sharp change in the relationship between per capita state transfers and an index of representation between 1960 and 1980. The authors then use both cross-sectional and panel-data analyses to estimate the effects of the rule change, holding other influences fixed. Their analyses show that doubling a county's representation increases its share of state spending by about 20%. They then subject this finding to a long series of eminently sensible robustness tests.
The paper, the authors conclude, provides “a clear and simple lesson:” representation does matter. We find that the paper delivers another equally clear, simple, and powerful lesson: an important question and an elegant and rigorous analysis of the appropriate data can change our understanding of politics. “Equal Votes, Equal Money” richly deserves the 2003 Heinz Eulau Award.
BOOK AWARDS
For the best scholarly work in political science, published in 2002, which explores the phenomenon of ethnic and cultural pluralism.
Award Committee: Allison Calhoun-Brown, Georgia State University, chair; Rodolfo O. de la Garza, Columbia University; and Melissa Nobles, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Recipients: Paul Sniderman, Stanford University; Thomas Piazza, University of California, Berkeley.
Book: Black Pride and Black Prejudice (Princeton University Press)
Citation: Paul Sniderman and Thomas Piazza's Black Pride and Black Prejudice is a thought provoking book that challenges much of the conventional wisdom about how feelings of racial distinctiveness are associated with racial prejudice, intolerance, and American cultural values. The conventional wisdom suggests that those with strong feelings of racial solidarity are more likely to be prejudiced against non-blacks, more likely to be intolerant, and less likely to subscribe to American cultural values. Utilizing imaginative experiments as well as conventional survey items, Sniderman and Piazza establish that the conventional wisdom is in large part incorrect. The basic finding of the book is that racial pride is not associated with prejudice, a desire for racial separatism or anti-American values. By carefully examining different forms of racial identification, the factors that undergird it, and the impact that it has on inter-ethnic conflict and cooperation, Sniderman and Piazza not only help us better appreciate and understand the true nature of identity politics but in the process offer compelling insights into the role of education in the construction of identity, into the levels of suspicion and mistrust that persist in the African American community, into the deleterious effects of prejudice and intolerance especially on racial identity, and into distinctions that exist between mass and elite opinions. The book is a significant contribution to the literature in that it highlights the complexity of African American political attitudes. How can racial justice be embraced within the context of American political values? As importantly in this examination, Sniderman and Piazza provide a window into the contemporary meaning of solidarity, identification, equality, fairness, freedom, and justice. All those interested in racial and ethnic politics but no less those interested in American political philosophy, political culture, public opinion, or experimental methodologies will find this a very illuminating and important project.
For the best political science publication in 2002 in the field of U.S. national policy.
Award Committee: Dr. Amy Fried, University of Maine, chair; Frederick C. Harris, University of Rochester; and Nelson W. Polsby, University of California, Berkeley.
Recipient: Daniel J. Tichenor, Rutgers University.
Book: Dividing Lines: The Politics of Immigration Control in America (Princeton University Press)
Citation: Dividing Lines is a superb work of public policy analysis which combines a narrative of the development of immigration policy with a compelling theoretical approach. The work has a remarkable historical sweep, covering changes from the early 19th century to the threshold of the 21st century. Tichenor's analysis of such a long time period enables him to work in an exemplary way with the idea of path dependence, as this and other theoretical touchstones are integrated into the account. Furthermore, the book has an explicit and fully developed political analysis. This can be seen in its discussion of not only the politics that led to immigration policy, but also the way that new groups of immigrants affected existing political groups and coalitions and thus shifted immigration politics and policy. Tichenor's archival and historical research is greatly enhanced by his over 100 interviews with policy-makers and lobbyists. Finally, Dividing Lines addresses some key fundamental issues in American political thought and political culture, including nationhood, identity, and the place of rights and rights claims in the United States.
For the best book published in 2002 on women and politics.
Award Committee: Mary E. Hawkesworth, Rutgers University, chair; Suzanne B. Mettler, Syracuse University; and Cindy Simon Rosenthal, University of Oklahoma.
Recipient: Louise Chappell, University of Sydney.
Book: Gendering Government: Feminist Engagement with the State in Australia and Canada (University of British Columbia Press)
Citation: Louise Chappell's Gendering Government is a cogent examination of the complex ways that feminist activists in Australia and Canada have shaped government institutions and policies over the past three decades. In addition to documenting how women in two federal systems have engaged and worked within the state, Chappell also provides a sophisticated and nuanced analysis of the role that specific state institutions have played in shaping women's political mobilizations and choices about strategic gender interests. Exploring how the institution of federalism shapes feminist activism, Chappell presents an insightful account of the institutional arrangements most permeable to feminist influence and deftly dispels any lingering doubt that feminists have crafted significant social change through the state.
Gendering Government provides an ideal example of feminist political science, an approach to the study of politics that is equally sophisticated in its understandings of competing disciplinary paradigms and of feminist scholarship across a range of disciplines. Chappell draws equally from the theoretical insights of neo-institutionalism, comparative federalism, political culture, contemporary ideologies, social movements, political opportunity structures, the theory of gendered institutions, conceptions of difference and intersectionality, feminist jurisprudence, state feminism, and anti-state feminism. Chappell integrates these diverse intellectual traditions in order to demonstrate that feminist scholarship can contribute substantially to political scientists' understanding of the political world and that political science can contribute substantially to feminists' understandings of strategies for social change.
Chappell analyzes the complexity of “women's interests” and makes visible the intensive political work that underlies every articulation of a “women's political agenda,” a dimension of women's political activism that has too often been neglected. By comparing feminist activism in two federal systems in their historical contexts, she illuminates concrete institutional obstacles and constraints, as well as possibilities that have structured feminists' political accomplishments in political parties, parliaments, courts, and bureaucracies.
Chappell carefully analyzes multiple spheres of feminist contestation, encompassing constitutional structures as well as NGOs and social movements, to illuminate a rich array of tactics that feminists have developed to improve women's lives. She is attentive to issues of race, class, and ethnic difference and provides an explanation of how and why white, educated women's interests so often occlude the needs of other groups of women within liberal democracies. Chappell also makes it painfully clear that feminist gains are fragile and susceptible to revocation. This somber lesson is of particular import as fundamentalist forces gain ground around the globe.
For the best book published during 2002 on government, politics, or international affairs.
Award Committee: Kathleen Thelen, Northwestern University, chair; Jean C. Oi, Stanford University; and John F. Padgett, University of Chicago.
Recipient: Mark R. Beissinger, University of Wisconsin, Madison.
Book: Nationalist Mobilization and the Collapse of the Soviet State (Cambridge University Press)
Citation: This book provides a compelling explanation—and a gripping account—of one of the most important political events of our time. The question motivating the research is genuinely puzzling: how was it possible that a mighty superpower, the Soviet Union, could simply vanish from the historical stage within the space of a few years? This book examines the structural preconditions but also, more importantly, the process through which, as Beissinger puts it, “the seemingly impossible in 1987 … became the seemingly inevitable by 1991.”
Beissinger provides a convincing alternative to teleological, deterministic accounts of nationalism that attribute the success or failure of nationalist movements to enduring traits of particular groups (nationalist “predispositions”), explanations in which deep structural characteristics make nationalist action either futile or inevitable. Beissinger's alternative explanation of the rise of successful nationalism emphasizes the independent impact of events and nationalist strategies, and shows how structure and agency interacted in an unfolding tide of nationalist mobilization. Structural features help account for how and where the first nationalist movements began to emerge in the 1980s, but as Beissinger convincingly demonstrates, constraints played a diminishing role as a tide of nationalism gathered strength in the region. The impact of events and processes in temporally and spatially connected nationalisms produced a dynamic that explains how nationalism in countries lacking the structural prerequisites (“improbable nationalisms” as Beissinger calls them) could nonetheless succeed as a result of linkages to other unfolding nationalisms and the ability of politicians to “ride nationalism's tidal force.”
The importance of the question, the scope of coverage, the quality and depth of the research, the integrated use of quantitative and qualitative methods, and the clear and compelling writing—all of these factors make this a model for books in comparative politics and political science in general. Beissinger masterfully weaves detailed historical knowledge of a series of events to show their connectedness and interaction in a convincingly argued dynamic analytical framework that sheds a penetrating new light on the process and consequences of nationalist mobilization.
CAREER AWARDS
The John Gaus Distinguished Lecturer Award honors the recipient's lifetime of exemplary scholarship in the joint tradition of political science and public administration and, more generally, recognizes and encourages scholarship in public administration.
Award Committee: Charles Wise, Indiana University, chair; Patricia W. Ingraham, Syracuse University; and Shui-Yan Tang, University of Southern California.
Recipient: Johan P. Olsen, ARENA, University of Oslo.
Citation: Johan P. Olsen is an extraordinarily innovative and productive scholar. Either alone or in collaboration with colleagues, he has written or edited 18 books and written more than 100 book chapters and articles, many of them in leading international journals. Through these publications he has given students, colleagues, and members of the public knowledge and insight which is of considerable value and inspiration for those interested in democratic governance and how political-administrative systems work and change. He has made major contributions to the international research community in the fields of public administration, political science, and organization theory. The topics that have been essential in Johan P. Olsen's scholarly works include organizational decision making and learning, processes of organizational and institutional change and the influence institutional have on policymaking and identity formation, and democratic governance and institutional design. He has devoted much of his professional effort to the ways that institutions, and particularly political institutions, work and should work, and the processes through which they are organized and reorganized.
Johan P. Olsen in his collaboration with Professor James G. March has had major influence on the study of political institutions and public policy. They have gone beyond the existing paradigms and pointed to new ways of looking at organizational decision-making and the political process. In 1972 they formulated, in collaboration with Professor Michael D. Cohen, the Garbage Can Model of decision-making in organizations. This model established a basis for studying loosely coupled organizations and nonroutine decisions. The role that simultaneity, ambiguity, and symbols might play for decision outcomes was highlighted and has provided scholars in several fields with a new and highly useful theoretical framework to employ in the study of organizations.
A second result from the fruitful cooperation between March and Olsen is their work on experiential learning under ambiguity, which was first introduced in 1975. The third of their major contributions is the development of a broad institutional perspective on political life launched in the mid 1980s through the concept of “the New Institutionalism.” It was founded on three basic ideas: that human action is based on a logic of appropriateness, that meaning is constructed through political and societal processes, and that institutions normally adapt more slowly than their environments. The New Institutionalism has had major impact on research and study in public administration, and political science and has influenced the work of a whole generation of scholars.
Johan P. Olsen has developed theoretically oriented and empirically based studies of political institutions in Norway, Scandinavia, and Europe through an explicit combination of theories of decision-making in formal organizations and democratic theory. This special mixture of public administration, political science, and organization theory, together with a strong empirical focus, has given Olsen's research on political institutions and political life a strength and innovation which is internationally acknowledged. Since the 1970s he has been internationally recognized for his contribution to public administration and political science as well as organization theory.
Olsen has been a leading scholar and innovator in four major research programs in Scandinavia over the past 30 years. The first was the Study of the Distribution of Power in Norway (1972–1982). The Power Study has been characterized as the big leap forward for Norwegian political science, and was the most influential research project regarding the conceptualization and empirical description of the political-administrative system in Norway. The success of this project resulted in the launching of a similar program in Sweden in 1985, and he became one of the leaders of the Study of Power and Democracy in Sweden. The power projects have made a most significant contribution to the expansion of democracy in the Nordic states. The third large research program in which Olsen was a leading figure was the Program on Organization and Management systems from 1987–1997. This program gave birth to the Norwegian research center in organization and management in Bergen. The last of Olsen's main research programs is ARENA (1994–2003). ARENA is an advanced research program on the Europeanization of the nation-state, located at the University of Oslo. The focus of ARENA is on the implications for the nation-state of evolving European system of governance, in particular the European Union. It has developed into an international center of excellence in Europe for studying the process of European integration.
Johan P. Olsen has also been a leader in establishing a strong Scandinavian-American network that was formalized in the Scandinavian Consortium for Organizational Research (Scancor) in 1988. Scancor established a research base at Stanford University for collaborative research, and more than 200 scholars from Scandinavia have undertaken research at Scancor over the past 15 years. He has developed and nurtured an exchange of theories and research findings that has enriched both American and European scholarship. On the international scene, he has also made major contributions while serving as a member of the boards of a wide range of the most outstanding research centers in the field and on the editorial boards of several of the most important international journals in organization theory and political science.
Johan P. Olsen's work represents a combination of how political-administrative institutions actually work, how they might work, and how they should work. He focuses on the potential for democratic governance in the tension and interplay between environmental determinism, purposeful actors, and historically developed institutions. Instead of purifying explanations based on one dominant dynamic, he has taken up the challenge to develop more complex explanations regarding how institutions are structured, how they operate, and how they are transformed. In his work on organization theory, public administration, modern democracy, modern bureaucracy, administrative reform, institutional change, and the Europeanization of the nation-state, Johan P. Olsen has persistently employed theories of organization which are consistent with the complex empirical realities of change and which clarify the process underlying the contextual details.
Johan P. Olsen's life-long contributions to public administration, political science, and organization theory exemplify the highest standards associated with the Gaus Award.
Presented each year in recognition of notable public service by a political scientist.
Award Committee: David Vogel, University of California, Berkeley, chair; Christopher Howard, College of William and Mary; and Pauline Vaillancourt Rosenau, University of Texas, Houston.
Recipient: Mark O. Hatfield, former Senator of the State of Oregon.
Citation: The American Political Science Association is pleased to present the 2003 Hubert H. Humphrey Award for distinguished public service by a political scientist to Senator Mark Hatfield.
Mark Hatfield received an M.A. in Political Science from Stanford University and served as an associate professor of political science at Willamette University for six years. His long and distinguished career of public service includes three terms in the Oregon State legislature, four years as Oregon secretary of state, and two terms as governor of Oregon.
In 1966 he was elected to the U.S. Senate where he served for three decades, retiring in 1997.
Hatfield chaired the Senate Appropriations Committee and also served on the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources and the Rules Committee. He played a critical role in increasing funding for the National Institutes of Health and was an active supporter of environmental legislation. Well-known for his independence, he was a prominent participant in debates over American foreign policy, taking controversial positions on the war in Vietnam, a nuclear freeze, and the Gulf war.
In 1997, the Government Printing Office published a large historical study of American vice-presidents, which he initiated and helped edit. Hatfield is currently serving on the faculty of the department of government at the Hatfield School of Government at Portland State University.
Presented each year to honor a major journalistic contribution to our understanding of politics.
Award committee: William A. Galston, University of Maryland, Chair; Larry J. Sabato, University of Virginia; Virginia Chanley, Florida International University.
Recipient: Thomas L. Friedman, New York Times
Recipient: Adam Clymer, New York Times
Citation: The events of September 11 have changed our politics in many ways. The U.S. public is focusing more intently on foreign affairs than it has since the fall of the Berlin Wall, and the dynamics of U.S. domestic policy have shifted dramatically. Understanding these post-September 11 political developments requires not only a wide range of substantive knowledge, but also diverse methods of analysis. Each of this year's award recipients exemplifies a distinct mix of substantive and analytical excellence that has enormously enriched our comprehension of contemporary politics.
Thomas Friedman, foreign affairs columnist for the New York Times since 1995, joined the newspaper in 1981 and was appointed Beirut bureau chief in 1982. In 1984, he was transferred to Jerusalem, where he was Israel bureau chief for the next four years. He served as the chief White House correspondent and the chief economic correspondent in the Washington bureau before assuming his current position. In 2002, he won his third Pulitzer Prize, this time for commentary. His award-winning books include From Beirut to Jerusalem (1989), The Lexus and the Olive Tree (2000), and Longitudes and Attitudes: The World in the Age of Terrorism (2002).
Drawing on a vast knowledge of Middle Eastern history and politics, Friedman's reporting has illuminated the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, relations between the United States and Saudi Arabia, and the sources of anti-American sentiment, among many other key issues. Friedman's columns cut to the heart of complex political questions and are models of clarity. Throughout his career, and especially since September 11, Friedman has helped U.S. citizens and policy makers better understand America's unique and changing role in the world.
Adam Clymer's remarkable career as a reporter began in 1960. He joined the New York Times in 1977, focusing on the role of public opinion in politics. Among his many assignments at the Times, he served as polling editor from 1983 through 1990, assistant Washington editor in charge of congressional coverage from 1991 through 1997, and Washington editor from 1997 until 1999. He was named chief Washington correspondent in April 1999, writing on key issues in American politics and government. He is the author of Edward M. Kennedy: A Biography, published in 1999. He is now serving as Washington Director of the National Annenberg Election Survey.
Throughout his career, which began when Hubert Humphrey was a candidate and included an assignment as The Times' political editor for the 1988 presidential campaign, Clymer has combined a mastery of survey techniques and interpretation with a shrewd understanding of the relation between issues, tactics, and public opinion. It has been said that he has “the ability to make music out of polling data, a talent editors everywhere covet.” In his passion for precision, he has often consulted with political scientists on matters of survey interpretation, serving as an important bridge between academic research and the world of political reporting.
Presented every two years to recognize a person whose published work and career represent a significant contribution to the art of government through the application of social science research.
Award Committee: R. Kent Weaver, The Brookings Institution; James J. F. Forest, U.S. Military Academy; and Laura Stoker, University of California-Berkeley.
Recipient: Joseph S. Nye, Jr., Harvard University.
Citation: The career of Joseph S. Nye, Jr. embodies the highest ideals of the citizen-scholar. Currently dean of the John F. Kennedy School of Government and Don K. Price Professor of Government, Harvard University, Joseph Nye has produced scholarship on international relations and governance that speaks to both political scientists and practitioners.
Joseph Nye received his undergraduate degree from Princeton University (summa cum laude), held a Rhodes Scholarship at Oxford University, and earned a Ph.D. in political science from Harvard University. He then began his academic career at Harvard, where he is revered by his students for his teaching. He has been a remarkably productive scholar, earning a worldwide reputation for books such as The Paradox of American Power: Why the World's Only Superpower Can't Go it Alone and Power and Interdependence (with Robert Keohane). From his earliest work on common markets in East Africa and Central America to later studies of non-state-actors in international relations to his recent work on governance in several contexts and on the role that the United States should play in a world where it is the only remaining superpower, Joseph Nye has sought to bring critical thinking and social science knowledge to bear on the leading issues of the day—and to do so in ways that would lead to a better and safer world. Recognizing the importance of timeliness and brevity in reaching a policy audience, he has also been a frequent contributor to op-ed pages and major opinion journals.
Nye has also spent several years in government, applying his keen intellect and political understanding to addressing the important challenges faced by our nation's leadership. He served in the Carter administration as deputy to the under secretary of state for Security Assistance, Science, and Technology, and chaired the National Security Council Group on Nonproliferation of Nuclear Weapons. In the Clinton administration, he was chairman of the National Intelligence Council and assistant secretary of defense for International Security Affairs, before returning to Harvard to became Dean of the Kennedy School. His many accomplishments in government include his work on East Asian security in the turbulent post-Cold War period of the mid-1990s. At a time when U.S. policy was in flux, he authored a Pentagon study reaffirming America's commitment to the region at an historically critical and uncertain moment. Throughout his long career, Joseph Nye's accomplishments as scholar, teacher, academic leader, and public servant have been a model for the profession.
Presented every two years to a political theorist for a work of exceptional quality that is still considered significant after a time span of at least 15 years since the original date of publication.
Award Committee: Peter Berkowitz, George Mason University, chair; George W. Downs, New York University; and Jane Flax, Howard University.
Recipient: Albert O. Hirschman, Princeton University.
Book: The Passions and the Interests: Political Arguments for Capitalism before its Triumph (Princeton University Press)
Citation: The Passions and the Interests is an exemplary work of intellectual history. Hirschman's small gem has greatly contributed to our understanding of the roots of modern capitalism and of the indissoluble links between economic thought and political philosophy. At the time that he wrote his book in the 1970s, the conventional wisdom held that capitalism represented a radical break with the pre-modern past. Hirschman showed that as it emerged in the 17th and 18th centuries, capitalism was in fact defended on the basis of ideas about its political benefits that reflected a gradual transformation of pre-modern notions about the perennial challenge of reconciling unruly human passion with the imperatives of political order. The defense was worked out across Europe over several centuries. Before the rise of capitalism, thinkers had sought to explain how the passions that led to political disarray could be suppressed, or harnessed, or played off against each other. Capitalism's pioneering theorists discovered an alternative for dealing with the passions: they argued that society could take advantage of the reliable and universal interest in making money and acquiring property by inducing individuals to devote themselves to the commercial life. By encouraging individuals to place their interests ahead of their passions, commercial life would not only yield increased economic benefits but also play a critical role in securing liberty and peace. This political argument for capitalism flowered in the 18th century, particularly in the thought of Montesquieu and James Stuart. Its decline was in part precipitated by Smith's The Wealth of Nations, which stressed the economic benefits of capitalism while calling attention to the moral harms connected to the relentless pursuit of material selfinterest and the thoroughgoing submersion in the division of labor.
Hirschman's deft reconstruction of background notions and patterns of moral and political thought placed old ideas in a new light and, in the process, illuminated the politics of his day and ours as well. As he notes in the Introduction, his book grew out of concerns with practical issues regarding “the likely consequences of commercial expansion for peace, or industrial growth for liberty.” The question of the extent to which economic expansion has “salutary political consequences” or, as Hirschman puts it elsewhere, “the meaning of economic progress for freedom” remains, to say the least, timely in this era of globalization. Yet, now as then, The Passion and the Interests serves neither party nor fashion. And this is as it should be. As Hirschman suggests in the concluding lines of his book, the task of the history of ideas is “not to resolve issues but to raise the level of debate.” Indeed, we owe Albert O. Hirschman a debt of gratitude for raising the level of the debate about the moral and political foundations of capitalism and, in the process, providing a model of how intellectual history should be practiced.