This volume gathers together proceedings from the Roman Amphora Contents International Interactive Conference (RACIIC) that took place at the University of Cádiz from 5‒7 October 2015. The conference was co-organized by three important international institutions: the Centre Camille Jullian/CNRS and Aix-Marseille Université; ERAAUB - Universitat de Barcelona; and Universidad de Cádiz. Edited by Darío Bernal-Casasola, Michel Bonifay, Alessandra Pecci, and Victoria Leitch, the volume significantly advances our understanding of maritime trade in amphora-borne products in Roman antiquity, in terms of both content and methodologies. The collection concentrates on the immensely complex and pivotal issue of amphora contents. The study of materials transported in amphoras allows one to trace the movement of goods and substantially contributes to our knowledge of the Roman economy from an interdisciplinary perspective. Authors in the volume study amphora contents through a variety of methods: analysis of written sources (both ancient texts and inscriptions), study of macro remains, and organic residue analyses. The collection is in four parts – 33 chapters in total (with a Preface and Conclusions), written by an international cohort of more than 30 scholars, most of them preeminent archaeologists. The volume is dedicated to Miguel Beltrán Lloris, the famous Spanish historian and archaeologist who pioneered studies of ancient transport containers on the Iberian Peninsula.
The volume starts with a comprehensive introductory chapter by Miguel Beltrán Lloris himself. He briefly summarizes the contributions and surveys predominant methods of studying amphora contents, focusing mainly on containers produced on the Iberian Peninsula. Part one of the book follows, consisting of five chapters (by Stefanie Martin-Kilcher and André Tchernia; Franca Cibecchini; Enrique García Vargas; Jean-Luc Fournet; and, finally, J. Theodore Peña) that examine historical and archaeological indicators of amphora contents. There is a particular focus here on traditional analyses of tituli picti, which for a long time contributed the majority of data on the content of transport jars. These five chapters appropriately set the scene for more detailed analyses in the following parts of the volume. The fifth chapter, authored by Peña, merits special attention: he emphasizes that tituli picti often appear on reused amphoras and thus indicate their final (rather than initial) contents. Peña's remarks showcase how the traditional approach based on tituli picti may mislead if not treated with caution or confirmed by other types of evidence: his questioning attitude towards the dominant theoretical framework sets the tone for the remainder of the book.
The second part of the volume is perhaps its most significant. It includes a number of archaeometric analyses of organic amphora residues, taking both general and case-specific approaches. Organic residue analyses have been successfully applied to ascertain former contents of different types of ancient jars. However, the focus has predominantly been on detecting wine residues, with the scholarly community still debating what constitute adequate protocols for detection and analysis.Footnote 1 Contributions in the volume under review direct equal attention to wine and to fat residues: the study of remains of vegetal and animal fats has identified olive oil, fish/meat, and other transport jar contents. Furthermore, contributors have made an attempt to detect other relevant yet under-recognized substances such as pitch or resin, which might have been shipped in the jars, added as preservatives to different kinds of foodstuffs, or used to improve technological aspects of vessels. This section of the volume starts with a chapter by Nicolas Garnier (strangely overlooked in the Table of Contents), which provides a useful survey of methodological issues related to types of biomarkers, and their preservation, collection and detection. Garnier's chapter (together with the volume ArchaeoAnalytics: Chromatography and DNA Analysis in Archaeology from 2015,Footnote 2 and P. McGovern's “Charting a future course for organic residue analysis in archaeology,” recently published in the Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory Footnote 3) offers a perfect primer for all who are interested in applications of organic residue analyses in pottery studies. The next chapter (by Nicolas Garnier and Alessandra Pecci) examines amphora coatings and addresses the longstanding problem of the presence of internal lining (pitch/resin) detectable inside different types of containers. Garnier and Pecci's point is that although the insides of the majority of (if not all) transport jars were coated with a waterproof layer of pitch or resin,Footnote 4 few traces of this lining still remain, with its survival depending on the type of goods it came in contact with: it dissolved in contact with olive oil but endured in vessels that transported wine and fish products. Crucially, Garnier and Pecci confirm what M. Bonifay suggested several years ago: visible pitch coating can help us to distinguish between the packaging of different goods.Footnote 5 Furthermore, they make an attempt to identify and distinguish between initial and second-use contents of up-cycled amphoras by detecting residues absorbed at different stages of an amphora's life cycle. The wealth of information in this contribution demonstrates beyond any doubt that organic residue analyses have great potential in this field of study.
If the initial chapters in the volume introduce a reader to a gamut of complex issues pertaining to organic residue analyses and appropriate research protocols, the next part builds on these theoretical underpinnings to present five case studies. The authors employed gas chromatography with mass spectrometry (GC-MS) and, at times, Fourier-transformed infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR) to analyze a number of container collections. The first case study, by Hitomi Fujii, Carole Mathe, Fabienne Olmer, and Cathy Vieillescazes, considers Dressel 1A amphoras from Cosa in Etruria. The second, by Florinda Notarstefano and Mariateresa Lettieri, examines a variety of containers found in Nuovo Mercato di Testaccio in Rome, including jars from Lusitania, Tripolitania, Crete, Rhodes, Cilicia, and other Eastern Mediterranean sites. The third case study, by Nicolas Garnier and Gloria Olcese, concerns Greco-Italic forms (Van der Mersch IV and V amphoras) from the Filicudi F and Secca di Capistello (Aeolian Islands) shipwrecks, while the fourth, by Silvia Polla, Andreas Springer, Birte Gruber, Petra Tušlová, and Barbora Weissová, discusses Eastern Mediterranean amphoras discovered in Bulgaria, with types such as the Dr 24 family, LRA2, Kuzmanov XIV, and Kapitän II. The fifth and final case study, by Marshall Woodworth and Paul Reynolds concerns amphoras produced in the vicinity of Beirut.
Together, these case studies corroborate many hypotheses formulated through traditional source analysis but also yield new data that challenge former interpretations. For example, lipid analyses (identification of long chain and monounsaturated fatty acids and cholesterol) indicate that Tripolitanian and Lusitanian amphorasFootnote 6 once contained fish products and that they were coated with pine pitch (as suggested by the presence of dehydroabietic and methyldehydroabietic acids in the samples). The presence of tartrate and animal lipid residues in one sample indicates that the vessel held oenogarum – a wine-seasoned fish sauce. At the same time, traces of oleic, palmitic, and stearic acids found in residues from Cilician, Kuzmanov XIV, and Dr 24 amphoras point towards them being used for olive oil transport, while detection of dehydroabietic acids in some examples suggests that they had resin lining. In the case of Cilician and Dr 24 containers, the results corroborate the evidence from literary sources, tituli picti, container shapes, and the archaeological contexts of container production and export zones. Similarly, traditional approaches have suggested that LRA2 amphoras might have carried different products,Footnote 7 and chemical analyses showed positive results for fatty acids (both plant and animal) as well as for malic, fumaric, and glycolic acids, usually seen as indicators of fruit derivatives, showing also that this container was multipurpose. However, non-biomarker evidence sometimes suggested completely different contents. For example, it has been assumed that Kapitän II containers held wine,Footnote 8 but this identification is challenged by the results of chemical residue analyses. It should also be mentioned that residual analyses of Kuzmanov XIV containers represent the sole source of evidence on their content. Furthermore, the case studies in the volume show with almost absolute certainty that several container types (Greco-Italic types, containers produced in the Beirut area, and on Crete and Rhodes, as well as Aegean form Dr 24 similis) were used to ship wine, with tartaric acid residues (typical biomarkers for wine) discovered inside them. They were also pitched, as indicated by identification of retene and abietic acids. Strikingly, the residue analyses of Beirut amphoras (underrepresented in literary sources and thus of indeterminate content to date) excluded the handling of olive oil and fish products, since the residues found within contained no fatty acids of either vegetal or animal origin. These samples yielded no syringic acid, suggesting that Syria produced white wines that had no contact with grape skins during fermentation. Organic residue analyses also identified remains of waterproof pine pitch coating in Dressel 1A amphoras from Etruria, the Eastern Mediterranean amphoras from Nuovo Mercato di Testaccio, Filicudi F and Secca di Capistello containers, and Beirut amphoras. The last chapter in this section concerns the detection of garum biomarkers in the dolium samples taken from the famous ‘Garum Shop’ in Pompeii. The authors (Álvaro Rodríguez-Alcántara, Ana Roldán-Gómez, Enrique García Vargas, Darío Bernal-Casasola, and Víctor Manuel Palacios-Macías) employ the gathered evidence to propose, in the spirit of experimental archaeology, how this famous fish sauce might have been produced.
The third part of the book synthesizes studies concerning the contents of different amphora types. It is divided into two subsections, devoted to amphoras from the Western and Eastern Mediterranean respectively; notably, the “West” subsection is more than twice as long as the “East” (nine versus four chapters). Every contribution in this third part of the volume approaches its subject holistically and offers up-to-date interpretations of various types of evidence. The studies take into account direct evidence (tituli picti, organic remains, and chemical residue analyses) and indirect evidence (excerpts from literary sources, numismatic evidence, and data on food production facilities in the area where the amphora type was manufactured). Almost every chapter sets the results of chemical analyses within the context of data drawn from other types of evidence to put together a comprehensive picture. The contributions on Western amphoras consider the contents of Lusitanian containers (Inês Vaz Pinto, Rui Morais, Carlos Fabião, César Oliveira, and Sónia Gabriel), Iberian and Roman amphoras from Hispania Citerior (Ramón Járrega Domínguez and Albert Ribera i Lacomba), Baetican amphoras produced from the Punic to the Late Roman period (Darío Bernal-Casasola, Enrique García Vargas, Antonio M. Sáez Romero, and Horacio González Cesteros), imperial containers from Gaul (Fanette Laubenheimer), Italian and Sicilian amphoras (Simonetta Menchelli), containers produced in Adriatic Italy (Marie Brigitte Carre and Stefania Pesavento Mattioli) and amphoras made in Africa (one chapter by Michel Bonifay and another by Jihen Nacef), as well as tituli picti on Spanish containers (Piero Berni and Emmanuel Botte). Even though these chapters for the most part compile previous findings and present little new material, they constitute a reliable guide to amphora cargoes, saving the reader from fine-combing hundreds of publications for relevant data (and, by necessity, missing some of them). A cursory glance at the material presented reveals that Lusitanian amphoras (ovoid forms, types similar to Dr 7-11, Dr 14, and Almagro 50 and 51) usually carried fish or fish products, whereas flat-bottomed jars from the central part of this region (Conimbriga) by and large held wine. The studies in this subsection also highlight the lack of organic residue analyses for significant container types such as Dr 2-3 (Tarraconensian imitation of Dr 2-4): the body of evidence on contents for the entire Dr 2-3 type consists of solely six(!) abbreviated dipinti. The two chapters on the contents of African jars also stress the urgent need for chemical residue analyses; although scholars have studied the jars' distribution, typology, macro remains, and epigraphic inscriptions for ca. 15 years, we still know very little about what they customarily held. Some chapters (e.g., those regarding Baetican amphoras) concentrate on analyzing both paleocontents and organic residues, whereas others adopt a more conservative approach, preferring to focus on the jars’ shapes and origins.
The subsection on the Eastern Mediterranean mostly reassesses and compiles data gleaned through traditional approaches. It opens with a contribution that attempts to identify Eastern olive oil containers by their shape and origin (Paul Reynolds). The second and third chapters review Black Sea wine and fish sauce amphoras (Andrei Opaiţ) and reconsider literary and epigraphic evidence on Ephesian wine jars (Tamás Bezeczky). The fourth and final contribution on Eastern amphoras reviews a typology of Egyptian containers produced during the Hellenistic, Roman, and Late Antique periods (Delphine Dixneuf). Although not all of them focus on amphora content analyses, and some merely recompile old data, the 13 chapters that compose this third part of the book form a valuable and welcome contribution to the understanding of how the ancient Mediterranean trade in wine, olive oil, and fish products actually functioned.
The fourth and last part of the volume presents case studies of seven groups of amphoras: five chapters cover discoveries from the Western Mediterranean (including the Iberian Peninsula, Italy, and Sardinia), while two consider findings from the Aegean region. Although these chapters also adopt a more traditional approach, they markedly focus on macro remains; furthermore, they present new data obtained through archaeobotanical and archaeozoological analyses, demonstrating the opportunities and limitations of these research methods. Max Luaces's study on the Western Mediterranean groups scrutinizes T-7.4.3.3/Mañá C2B and questions their use exclusively for the transport of garum. The second contribution (by Alejandro Quevedo, Myriam Sternberg, and Juan de Dios Hernández García) examines local Late Antique spatheia (Águilas I Type) and Africana IID amphoras discovered in Águilas in Spain, concluding that both types contained salted fish rather than fish sauce. Next, the third Western Mediterranean study concerns groups of vessels from the shipwrecks of Arles-Rhône 3 (Latium jars, Campanian jars, and Baetican jars) and Bou Ferrer (Dressel 7-11 amphoras) discovered off the coast of today's southern France and southeastern Spain (Gaël Piquès, Núria Rovira, Margaux Tillier, Franca Cibecchini, David Djaoui, and Carlos De Juan). The so-called Latium jars or garum jars appeared to have been particularly revealing, as they yielded very well-preserved fish product residues, allowing for an accurate identification of paleocontent type (salsamenta, allec, garum). Likewise, Dressel 7-11 containers held identifiable remains of the most popular fish species (Sparidae and sardines), spices (dill, caraway, fennel, black mustard, coriander) and condiments (wine or grape/wine derivatives). The findings detailed in the fourth chapter, which investigates Dressel 21-22 amphoras from the Garum shop in Pompeii (Darío Bernal-Casasola, Daniela Cottica, Ricard Marlasca, Carmen Gloria Rodríguez-Santana, and Enrique García Vargas), confirm Emmanuel Botte's hypothesis that Italian Dr 21-22 containers held a variety of fish products.Footnote 9 They also show that the containers’ tituli picti reflected the type of product rather than the type of fish (as previously assumed); indeed, amphoras with the same tituli contained different fish species, including picarel and anchovy. The last chapter on Western Mediterranean containers describes various types of transport jars discovered in Cagliari and Nora in Sardinia (Ignazio Sanna, Laura Soro, and Cristina Nervi), dated to an interval between the 4th c. BC and 7th/8th c. CE. Although it presents a wealth of evidence regarding underwater amphora findings, this chapter does not include any analyses of macro remains or organic residue as such, it does not advance our knowledge about the subject.
Next are two case studies on amphoras discovered in the Eastern Mediterranean: the first focuses on three different types of vessels found in the Aegean during underwater excavations (George Koutsouflakis), and the second considers various types of containers (but mostly of Punic origin) from the so-called Punic Amphorae Building in Corinth (Antonio M. Sáez Romero and Tatiana Theodoropoulou). Both point to the fact that although analyses of macro remains are very informative, for the time being they do not allow us to distinguish between initial and second-use content, as indicated by studies of remains in a Lamboglia 2 type, a Proto-Dr 25 form from Makarisis, and two Zeest 72 containers from the Fornoi shipwreck. Distinguishing between primary and second-use content necessitates combining data from macro remains with detailed archaeological context studies and chemical residue analyses. The case studies open a new path for paleocontent analyses, which in the case of fish remains allows for specifying both the product type and its exact production mode, making it possible to distinguish between amphoras that carried garum and those that held salsamenta.
Overall, the contributions in the volume demonstrate that organic analyses are crucial in order to further our knowledge regarding ancient goods exchange. Traditional approaches have already reached their full potential, leaving lacunas unlikely to be filled by new discoveries of ancient texts and inscriptions. In contrast, analyses of paleocontent and biomarkers identifiable through organic residues have the potential to yield new and reliable data. The chapters that most stood out here concerned the opportunities and limitations of studies of archaeozoological macro remains, especially those that were found in vessels discovered in underwater contexts. Such analyses were already successfully developing before the publication of the volume,Footnote 10 but Roman Amphora Contents significantly contributes to the subject by providing new and interesting case studies. Analyses of archaeobotanical and archaeological macro remains can help identify the content of amphoras, but they cannot tell us whether the amphoras contained only their primary cargo or if they were reused. At the same time, chemical identifications of biomarkers require upgraded protocols and methods for increased sensitivity and accuracy, many of which are already being developed. The importance of organic residue analyses arises from the fact that divining amphoras’ contents from their shapes and places of production may lead to wrong conclusions. One striking misidentification of this kind concerns Baetican ovoid amphoras, which were traditionally (and wrongly) thought to have contained olive oil since they resemble the famous olive oil containers of the Dr 20 type. Since both types had a similar shape and came from the same region (famous for olive oil production), scholars often assumed that they held similar contents. However, organic residue analyses proved that most ovoid amphoras from El Olivar contained wine.Footnote 11 This example underscores the need to reassess our research methodology.
Although I have lauded at length the relevance and timeliness of this volume, I must close this review by mentioning its few minor flaws, ascribable not to its editors but rather to the state of the research on the subject. The collection visibly prioritizes the Western Mediterranean (21 out of 33 chapters, and eight chapters on Iberian amphora studies alone), with regrettably merely six chapters on the Eastern Mediterranean. The collection's contributions on the Eastern regions contain many lacunas, reflecting the non-academic adversities faced by researchers studying amphoras in the East. Containers produced in the Black Sea region are the most striking example, as all Pontic types (excluding Kuzmanov XIV, thanks to this volume) still await organic residue studies (or their publication).Footnote 12 Furthermore, the collection deliberately gives precedence to Roman-period amphoras, excluding material on Archaic, Classical, and Hellenistic containers and their contents that might be important for understanding long-term patterns and continuities, as well as changes introduced with the advent of Rome. Two outlier amphora groups that date to contexts beyond the Roman period are Iberian amphoras from southeastern Spain (which appear to have commonly held beer!) and Punic-tradition amphoras from Baetica. Somewhat surprisingly, the collection does not include a contribution by Patrick McGovern, a preeminent researcher whose search for the oldest wine residues opened a path to organic residue analyses of ancient pottery;Footnote 13 however, his recent studies consider containers traceable to non-Roman geographic or chronological contexts.
One potential yet significant methodological flaw surfacing across several contributions in this collection (and other publicationsFootnote 14) concerns the pervasive and unquestioned assumption that syringic acid is a conclusive biomarker for red wine. Syringic acid traces in organic residues found in amphoras originates from the breakdown of the compound malvidin (an anthocyanin primarily responsible for the red color of wine, as proved by several other publications). Although the acid's presence (as the assumed product of the breakdown of malvidin) distinctively points to the presence of wine residue, it does not constitute a specific biomarker for red wine. First, several white grape and wine varieties available today contain discernible amounts of malvidin.Footnote 15 Second, both the ancient wine production method (most probably demanding partial maceration) and the fact that ancient high-end wines were yellow (that is, contaminated with anthocyanins)Footnote 16 reveal that the end products would very likely have contained malvidin (and, eventually, syringic acid). Even so, the specificity of syringic acid as a red wine biomarker demands further research into wine residue breakdown products and ancient vinification. Hopefully, future studies will provide the most successful and reliable biomarker detection methods within the context of our enhanced understanding of ancient production methods for wine, olive oil, and fish by-products, demonstrating how production processes may hypothetically influence the presence or absence of specific biomarkers.
Notwithstanding these critiques, the volume stands out as a pivotal contribution to the ongoing research on amphora contents, opening avenues for novel methods and approaches. It is very likely to set a new trend in pottery studies, popularizing analyses of macro remains and organic residues among archaeologists. The volume opens with a coherent introduction, defines what can be traced and by what methods, lists and describes key biomarkers, and presents protocols suitable for chosen approaches and methods. In doing so, it familiarizes non-specialists with amphora content studies and new developments in the field. Fittingly illustrated with clear maps, graphs, drawings, and high-quality images, this is an extremely important publication that moves research on amphora contents a few steps forward and opens new paths in both methodology and approaches. By careful case-study examination of paleocontents, it provides new – sometimes unexpected – answers to old questions, changing our understanding of the movements of goods in the Mediterranean.
