Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T01:46:58.600Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Cellular vortex shedding from a cylinder at low Reynolds number

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 March 2021

Sanjay Mittal*
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, India
Jawahar Sivabharathy Samuthira Pandi
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, India
Mainak Hore
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 208016, India
*
†Email address for correspondence: smittal@iitk.ac.in

Abstract

Flow past a cylinder in the presence of side walls is investigated numerically for various combinations of Reynolds numbers ($50 \leqslant \textit {Re} \leqslant 100$) and aspect ratio ($5 \leqslant AR \leqslant 90$). Various attributes such as cellular shedding, dislocations, oblique angle of vortices and their structure near the end wall are studied. The complexity of the transitions in the wake, with $\textit {Re}$, increases with increase in $AR$. The flow is associated with a single cell wake for $AR=20$, at all the $\textit {Re}$ considered. For $AR$ $=90$ the flow transitions from a one-cell to two-cell wake at $\textit {Re} \sim 50$, to a four-cell structure at $\textit {Re} \sim 55$ to a three-cell wake at $\textit {Re} \sim 58$, and then to a two-cell wake at $\textit {Re} \sim 61$. The vortices near the end wall diffuse for $Re\leqslant 58$ whereas linkages form between adjacent vortices of opposite polarity at larger $Re$. The frequency of dislocations increases with increase in $\textit {Re}$. Two types of dislocations have been identified: the fork type at relatively low Re and connected fork type at larger Re. Linkages between vortices in connected fork-type dislocations may lead to ring-like structures. The end conditions and nonlinear mechanisms play a significant role in the evolution of cellular shedding. A single cell across the span is the dominant mode of shedding in the linear regime. Compared with the linear analysis, nonlinearities result in smaller oblique angles, higher shedding frequency and larger streamwise speed of the convection of vortices.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: schematic of the computational domain and the associated boundary conditions. The sketch is not to scale.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: (a) two-dimensional section of the finite element mesh M3, listed in table 1, in the $xy$ plane; (b) enlarged view of the mesh near the cylinder.

Figure 2

Table 1.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: details of the various finite element meshes. Also listed are the time-average and r.m.s. value of the force coefficients for the fully developed unsteady flow corresponding to $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60,60)$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: cellular structures in the wake for cylinders of $5 \leqslant AR \leqslant 90$ and $50 \leqslant \textit {Re} \leqslant 95$. The boundaries of the regions attributed to the respective flow structures are not exact, but indicative in nature and are based on the cases for which computations have been carried out and marked by hollow symbols. More details for the flow are given in figure 4 for the parameters indicated by solid symbols. The hatched region indicates the range of parameters where the flow loses symmetry about the mid-span of the cylinder. The range of $\textit {Re}$ along the $x$-axis is 49–96.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: spanwise variation of Strouhal number corresponding to the dominant frequency of vortex shedding and $xz$-view of instantaneous $Q$ (${=}0.0002$) iso-surface coloured with spanwise vorticity component at different time instants for (a) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 50)$, (b) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 75)$, (c) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 60)$ and (d) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(80, 54)$. The various cells and the vortex dislocations are marked. The broken lines show the indicative cell boundaries based on the vortex dislocations. All subsequent $Q$ iso-surfaces are coloured following the same convention as in this figure.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: cross-flow component of velocity ($v$), and their corresponding power spectra at spanwise separated probe locations for (a) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 50)$, (b) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 75)$, (c) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 60)$ and (d) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(80, 54)$. The probes are located at ($x/D=5, y/D=0.25$), and $z/D$ as mentioned in the figure. The amplitude of the power spectra has been normalized by the maximum value of each case.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: classification of the flow in the $AR$–$\textit {Re}$ plane on the basis of the attributes defined in table 2. The boundaries of the various regions are not exact, but indicative in nature and are based on the cases for which computations have been carried out and marked by hollow symbols. The cases for which a full-span simulation is initiated from the solution from half-span, by reflecting it about mid-span, are highlighted using solid symbols. The lower and upper limit along the $x$-axis is $49$ and $96$, respectively.

Figure 7

Table 2.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: the nomenclature adopted to define the attributes of the flow.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: $Q$ (${=}0.002$) iso-surfaces coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$) for the instantaneous flow depicting (a) diffused end vortex structures for $(AR, \textit {Re})= (60, 50)$ at $t=1350$ and (b) linked end vortex structures for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 75)$ at $t=1725$. Also shown are a few vortex lines for each case that pass through the core of the vortices at the plane of symmetry and the enlarged view of the images next to the side wall. The side wall ($z=0$) is shown for reference.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: schematic of the (a) fork-type ($D_f$) and (b) connected fork-type ($D_{fc}$) dislocations with ring-like structure highlighted in broken lines. The clockwise and anti-clockwise vortices are shown in blue and red colour, respectively. The filled circles indicate the connections between the vortices of opposite polarity.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: $xz$-view of instantaneous $Q$ (${=}0.001$) iso-surfaces coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$) for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 60)$ depicting the fork-like connection for (a) anti-clockwise rotating vortices and (b) clockwise rotating vortices at $t=1479.65$. In (a) the flow is visualized from a negative $y$ side, whereas it is seen from a positive $y$ side in (b).

Figure 11

Figure 10.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: $xz$-view of instantaneous $Q$ (${=}0.001$) iso-surface coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$) for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(70, 90)$ depicting the connected fork-type dislocation at $t=823.7$. The enlarged view of the connection of vortices with opposite polarity at the cell boundary is shown alongside. The ring-like structure formed owing to the connection of vortices is highlighted.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: $xz$-view of instantaneous $Q$ (${=}0.0005$) iso-surfaces coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$) for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 70)$ at (a) $t=1021.7$ and (b) $t=1039.2$ depicting mixed-type vortex dislocation. The transformation from fork-like structure to ring-like structure is highlighted as the dislocation convects downstream.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Flow past a cylinder with side wall. (a) Spatio-temporal variation of Strouhal number corresponding to the frequency of each cycle of cross-flow velocity component for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 60)$. The cross-flow velocity component data are obtained from spanwise separated probes placed $2.5D$ apart at ($x/D=5, y/D=0.25$). (b) The $Q$ (${=}0.001$) iso-surfaces, coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.1$), at various time instants. The cell boundaries as well as vortex dislocations are marked on the images.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Flow past a cylinder with side wall. (a) Spatio-temporal variation of Strouhal number corresponding to the frequency of each cycle of cross-flow velocity component for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 75)$. The cross-flow velocity component data are obtained from spanwise separated probes placed $2.5D$ apart at ($x/D=5, y/D=0.25$). (b) The $Q$ (${=}0.001$) iso-surfaces, coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.1$), at various time instants. The cell boundaries as well as vortex dislocations are marked on the images.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: variation of the frequency of appearance of vortex dislocations (a) $D_{1}$ and (b) $D_{2}$ with $\textit {Re}$.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: time histories of the force coefficients obtained from direct numerical simulation initiated with the steady flow for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 70)$. Corresponding enlarged views during the initial time are shown in the bottom row.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: $xz$-view of $Q$ (${=}0.0005$) iso-surfaces coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$) at different time instants for $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 70)$. Also marked in (g,h) is the fork-type dislocation and ring-like structure.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Flow past a cylinder with side wall at $\textit {Re} = 90$. (a) Variation of growth rate of the dominant mode with $AR$. The spanwise vorticity field in the $x$–$z$ plane for the real part of the eigenmode corresponding to the eigenvalue with largest real part is shown in the inset for two values of $AR$. (b,c) Time histories of lift coefficient for the direct numerical simulations initiated with unsteady two-dimensional flow for (b) $AR = 7$ and (c) $AR = 9$.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Flow past a cylinder with side wall at $\textit {Re} = 90$: spanwise vorticity field in the $x$–$z$ plane at various time instants for (a–d) $(AR, \textit {Re})= (7, 90)$ and (e–h) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(9, 90)$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Full span simulation of flow past a cylinder with side wall: $Q$ (${=}0.0002$) iso-surface coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$) for (a) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(90, 54)$, (b) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(80, 54)$ and (c) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(80, 55)$. The dislocations as well as the boundaries of the cells are marked in broken white and black lines, respectively. The broken green line is along the mid-span of the cylinder.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Flow past a cylinder with side wall: instantaneous flow structure visualized using $Q = 0.0005$ (a,d), $\lambda _2 = -0.0005$ (b,e) and $\varOmega = 0.5$ (c, f) for $(AR, Re)=$(a–c) ($60, 50$) and (d–f) ($60, 75$). The iso-surfaces are coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$). The side wall is shown for reference.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Visualization of the $(AR, Re) = (60, 70)$ flow past a cylinder with side wall with different criterion for identification of vortices: iso-surfaces of (a) $Q = 0.0005$, (b) $\lambda _2 = -0.0005$ and (c) $\varOmega = 0.5$ coloured with spanwise component of vorticity ($\omega _z = \pm 0.01$). The ring-like structure formed after the convection of fork-type dislocation is highlighted in each image.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Direct numerical simulation initiated with the eigenmodes corresponding to $\beta =0.0$, 0.2 and 0.4 superposed on the steady base flow at $\textit {Re}=100$: spanwise component of vorticity of the perturbation field at (a) $t=0$ and (b) $t=150$.

Figure 24

Table 3.Global linear stability analysis of two-dimensional steady flow past a cylinder with three-dimensional spanwise periodic perturbations at $\textit {Re}=100$: characteristic details of the eigenmodes with largest growth rate for different values of $\beta$. Here $\lambda _{r}$ and $St_{\beta }$ are the growth rate and shedding frequency, $\theta _{LSA}$ is the measured angle of inclination of the vortices, $\theta _{St}$ is obtained from the cosine rule, $\theta _{St} = \cos ^{-1}St_{\beta }/St_{\beta =0}$, and $U_{c}$ is the convection speed of vortices that is obtained from the direct numerical simulation, in the linear regime, and initiated with the corresponding eigenmode.

Figure 25

Figure 23.Direct numerical simulations initiated with the eigenmodes corresponding to $\beta =0.0$, 0.2 and 0.4 superposed on the steady base flow at $\textit {Re}=100$: time evolution of (a) the normalized convection speed, $U_{c}/U_{\infty }$, (b) normalized shedding frequency, $St$, and (c) angle of oblique vortices, $\theta$. The $(x/D, y/D)$ for the location where $U_{c}$, $St$ and $\theta$ are estimated is $(5,1.4)$, $(10,1.4)$ and $(20,0)$, respectively. The spanwise location for all the estimates is $z=L_{z}/2$.

Figure 26

Figure 24.Global linear stability analysis of a finite cylinder with side wall: spanwise component of vorticity of the eigenmodes with largest growth rate and listed in table 4 for (a) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 55)$, (b) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 60)$ and (c) $(AR, \textit {Re})=(60, 70)$.

Figure 27

Table 4.Global linear stability analysis of a finite cylinder of $AR=60$ with side wall: details of the eigenmodes with largest growth rates for different values of $\textit {Re}$. Here $\lambda _{r}$ and $St$ are the growth rate and shedding frequency of the mode, respectively. The residual for each mode is presented in parentheses.