Interdisciplinary research and dialogue, the promotion of which was a major reason why Elias Mossialos and I established HEPL, has, for a long time, been a keen interest of mine. Fortunately for me, a key mission of my own institution, the London School of Economics and Political Science, is to advance interdisciplinarity in the social sciences, although, admittedly, in practice some are keener to embrace this mission than others.
Speaking from my own disciplinary perspective, I am convinced that economics can be enriched by knowledge of and input from other disciplines. In this I am good company: I have heard George Akerlof and Tony Atkinson, to name but two eminent economists, express a similar viewpoint in public gatherings. Indeed, this belief is partly why I have devoted most of my research hours to behavioural economics. However, enriching economics requires a good knowledge of economic theory, perhaps more than to which I can lay claim. Economics is, after all, a rigorous discipline that has much to offer, and attempts to inform the approach without a good grounding in its theoretical foundations often amount to a mistaken critique of what economics entails, and risks throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I have little doubt that similar arguments apply from the perspectives of sociology, political science or any other area of expertise.
Moreover, people with different disciplinary backgrounds are often suspicious and somewhat dismissive of each other. They are informed and driven by different ideological convictions appertaining to the causes of human behaviour and how the world works. Thus, even when a person from, say, Discipline A, attempts to incorporate into his own disciplinary framework insights from elsewhere, others from, say, Discipline B, often criticise him by claiming, albeit accurately, that those insights have been well known elsewhere for years. However, they forget that Discipline A, although undoubtedly imperfect, has aspects that are worth preserving. Thus, attempts to enrich Discipline A with well-established findings from elsewhere ought to be applauded, not jeered.
Interdisciplinarity is hard work. It requires people, from all sides, to engage in an open and accessible debate about the postulates of their own disciplinary perspectives, and to be willing to accept criticism, and modification, of those postulates whenever appropriate. When a person has invested so much time in getting to grips with their own discipline, and if they were, as they no doubt often are, attracted to that discipline because of the ideology that underpins it, an open process of self-criticism is rare. Moreover, professional rewards do not tend to support interdisciplinary work, with academic promotion driven by publishing in rather narrowly defined fields.
Having written these foreboding paragraphs, however, I still do sense that many, perhaps most, people think that an interdisciplinary direction to research and dialogue is, at least in theory, a good idea. I therefore issued a call to people to propose and, when accepted, write a perspective on the benefits or otherwise of interdisciplinarity. Perhaps reflecting the difficulties posed above, only a small number of people volunteered to offer a perspective, and even fewer followed their proposals up to acceptable completion. In the pages that follow, Calum Paton offers a theoretical and conceptual perspective on what interdisciplinarity means with respect to health policy analysis, and David Chinitz discusses interdisciplinarity principally in terms of the development of institutional economics. My perhaps unrealistic hope is that these musings might inspire us to assess more openly and critically the validity of our own disciplinary beliefs.
