Inside the Clinton White House is a masterful history of the White House told from the perspective of those who were there. Russell Riley has collated countless hours of elite interviewing into a vivid and eminently useful narrative history of the presidency of Bill Clinton. The source material is an immense collection of interviews conducted by the University of Virginia's Miller Center's Presidential Oral History Program. Scholars at and affiliated with the Miller Center recorded conversations with several dozen denizens of the Clinton administration, including key political and policy advisors (e.g., Sidney Blumenthal, William Galston), senior members of the White House staff (e.g., Samuel “Sandy” Berger, Thomas “Mack” McLarty), noteworthy officials in Clinton's cabinet (e.g., Madeleine Albright, Robert Rubin), members of Congress (e.g., Charles Robb, Thomas Daschle), and global figures who played a major role in American foreign policy of the 1990s (e.g., Vaclav Havel, Kim Dae-Jung), among others.
Riley, who serves as cochair of the Presidential Oral History Program, was present at nearly all these interviews. Indeed, according to a list of interviewees and interviewers in the book's appendix, Riley was absent from only eleven of the nearly seventy interviews. The value of Inside the Clinton White House, however, lies not in its hundreds of pages of candid insights from its esteemed roster of participants; after all, full transcripts of those conversations are easily available online through the Miller Center's website. Rather, the great contribution of this book lies in Riley's editorial acumen. Taking a relatively light touch, Riley typically provides a descriptive abstract at the start of a new discussion; examples include “The Transition to Governing,” “The Balkans,” and “Clinton's Operating Style.” He also contextualizes for the reader the broad strokes of the topic before integrating a variety of relevant quotations from different individuals in a way that creates an engaging narrative, equal parts revealing and substantive.
The section on NAFTA is an instructive case. In one of the shorter sections of the volume, Riley links Clinton's endorsement of NAFTA to the candidate's strategy of establishing himself as a new kind of Democrat, one who embraced free trade rather than organized labor, which had long been a core component of the party's coalition. In doing so, he acknowledges the ambivalence Clinton faced not only in Congress, which was then controlled by his fellow partisans, but also among members of his own administration, who took up the slogan “NAFTA? Because we hafta” (127). Introducing the topic thus, Riley precedes by integrating quotations first from individuals who worked in the trade representative's office (Charlene Barshefsky, Mickey Kantor) before segueing to passages from political actors (Al From, David Kusnet) and then to policy and administrative staff (Roger Altman, McLarty, Galston, Alice Rivlin, and Roy Neel).
Other sections are far more comprehensive; for example, the section on the 1993 budget and the stimulus package is more than twice as long as the NAFTA discussion. In these longer sections, Riley wisely breaks up the text by occasionally inserting the specific questions that were posed to various interviewees, thus giving coherence and structure to the narrative. In the section on the budget and stimulus, such questions concern the conflicts within the Clinton camp about whether to lead off with tackling deficit reduction versus Clinton's “People First” investment agenda, the role Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan played in convincing Clinton to decide to focus on deficit reduction, and the ways in which campaign ideas began to be shaped into a policy program.
The volume spans nearly three dozen such sections, which are each subsumed into one of five main segments: “Beginnings,” “Domestic and Economic Policy,” “Foreign Policy,” “Politics and the Clinton White House,” and “Bill Clinton and His Team.” The large number of topics covered means that most only receive several pages of attention, making Inside the Clinton White House a valuable resource but also one that trades depth for breadth. Scholars and students looking for overarching insight into the presidency of Bill Clinton will be well served, but those more interested in a deep dive into a specific dimension of Clinton's White House are bound to have a more hit-and-miss experience.
Despite the impressive breadth of the volume, there are some noticeable omissions, which are understandable but merit discussion. Most glaring is the comparatively minimal focus on scandals and impeachment. Clinton insiders may resent such an emphasis—Bernard Nussbaum, Clinton's first White House counsel, describes the entire notion of Clinton scandals as “phony” (308)—but Clinton's cultural reputation today hinges on the role scandals played or at least were perceived to play before, during, and after his presidency. Similarly, the fact that Clinton was only the second American president ever to be impeached makes it a central component of his legacy.
A related criticism is the relative absence of key subjects. It is not surprising that quotations from Monica Lewinsky herself do not appear, but neither do any from Hillary Clinton or Al Gore, even though each merits their own section of the book. In addition, two of Clinton's chiefs of staff—Erskine Bowles and John Podesta—are missing from the book. Similarly, Secretary of the Interior Bruce Babbitt, Attorney General Janet Reno, and EPA administrator Carol Browner do not appear, even though each of them served the entire duration of the Clinton administration. Neither do higher-profile political advisors such as James Carville, George Stephanopoulos, and Dick Morris, each of whom served a comparatively short stint under Clinton but had an outsize personality in the media. Readers interested in hearing about the perspective of these bold-faced names from the Clinton years will need to look elsewhere.
Despite these criticisms, there is still nothing else like Inside the Clinton White House available for those seeking to learn about the nation's 42nd president from sources who participated directly in Bill Clinton's presidency. The frankness of the text combined with Riley's gift for narrative and structure make this book a vital contribution to the literature not only on William Jefferson Clinton, but also on presidential politics and oral history, as well.
