Hezbollah: A Short History is a timely and easy to read primer on the past and present of Hizbullah and the Shiʿi community. The need for such a text is best understood when one takes note of Hizbullah's position within the complex political landscape of Lebanon and the Middle East—and in light of such comments as those by an Israeli brigadier general, quoted by Norton, who says that Hizbullah is “by far the greatest guerilla group in the world” (p. 140). In fact, Hizbullah has transcended those early days of its inception as a guerilla group. As Norton retells it, Hizbullah is now also a provider of social services and health care, in some cases surpassing the services provided by the Lebanese government: it has a research institute, an advanced television station, and its own reconstruction unit, Jihad al-Bina. Above all, it plays a key role in Lebanese parliamentary political life.
The social and political history of the Shiʿi community is one of disenfranchisement, compounded by the community's overall submission to the political norms of the time—the most notable is acquiescence to a predominantly Maronite–Sunni National Pact agreement that is the basis for Lebanon's confessional system. Norton narrates the political history of the Shiʿa in Lebanon, briefly scanning the rise of imam Musa Sadr, his role in empowering this community, and his disappearance in Libya in 1978. In Lebanon, Sadr is generally acknowledged to be the initial spark that led to a political awakening in the Shiʿi community, a spark that has not gone unnoticed by Norton as he recounts the history of Hizbullah.
Norton places Hizbullah in the context of a post-Sadr Shiʿi community and summarizes the party's worldview. He explains Hizbullah's open letter of 1985 in terms that the novice reader can grasp and that the scholar on Lebanon will welcome. He shows that there is no mention in the letter of what type of state Lebanon would be once free of external and internal domination, except that if given the free will to choose, the Lebanese would choose an Islamic state. Even then, Norton says it is not made clear what this Islamic state would look like and whether it would be on the Iranian model of “clerical rule under the concept of the wilayet al-faqih” (p. 39). Moreover, he reinforces an idea propounded by other scholars that the open letter is practically obsolete even among the highest cadres of Hizbullah.
This book makes an important contribution by recounting three relations in the domestic Lebanese scene that involve the Shiʿi community. The first is Norton's assessment of the breakdown of relations between the Palestinian and Shiʿi communities. His references to this throughout the book might be seen as a response to critics of Hizbullah who say that the party is fighting a resistance for the Palestinians rather than to secure Lebanon's borders and that Hizbullah's struggle is not a Lebanese cause but a Palestinian one. Within this context a second relationship appears, this time between Hizbullah and the Lebanese Resistance Detachments, or Amal, the political party founded by Sayed Musa Sadr. Norton briefly scans their clashes, major battles, and contests for political power. In the third relation, Norton has a different take on Hizbullah–Syrian relations than the one often heard. He suggests that “Syria has no overall interest in seeing Amal or Hezbollah (or any other political force) triumph in Lebanon, and its strategy in Lebanon has consistently followed the principles of Realpolitik. . .The Hezbollah leadership understands this and maintains its strategic alliance with Damascus, ever mindful that alliances of convenience are expendable by definition” (p. 35).
Norton tackles the July 2006 war but falls short of making a useful contribution to this subject. He claims that Lebanese politics is very delicate, especially at this critical juncture after the 2006 war with Israel. Yet his treatment of the present, in a book tracing the historical record, does not capture the delicate nature of current politics, nor is it successful in providing a deeper analysis than the daily press.
Another drawback is the length devoted to the Shiʿi ritual of ʿAshuraʾ. Although his explanation is well developed and at one point refers to Hizbullah's influence on the ritual, it is uncertain why a book on the history of Hizbullah should allocate so much space to this moment in Shiʿi religious tradition. To highlight the centrality of religion in the party's ideology and structure by focusing on the speeches of Hizbullah's Secretary General Sayed Hassan Nasrallah given during ʿAshuraʾ rather than on the ritual itself would have been more useful and a less repetitive take on similar scholarship on the subject.
For first-time readers on Lebanon and Hizbullah I highly recommend Hezbollah: A Short History, because Norton allows for a quick and cursory, yet at the same time very nuanced and sensitive, understanding of the history of Hizbullah and the Shiʿi community, complete with a thorough index and useful bibliography. Moreover, novice readers will likely appreciate how Norton's narrative style simplifies this complex topic. However, minor printing mistakes might throw off the reader, most noticeably on p. 142, where U.N. resolution 1701 is referred to as resolution 1702. For seasoned academics or policy analysts, this book will serve only as a refresher on the history of post-Sadr South Lebanon but will not satisfy the reader who is looking for an in-depth understanding of Hizbullah. Judging from the title of the book, I believe Norton achieved his goal of producing a highly accessible text on a complex issue for newcomers to the Lebanese scene.
