The allocation to, nature, and content, of the responsibilities of parents, and how these relate to parental rights, have increasingly become a matter of concern amongst academics, policy makers and commentators (Eekelaar, Reference Eekelaar2006; Probert et al., Reference Probert, Gilmore and Herring2008; Bridgeman, Reference Bridgeman, Bridgeman, Lind and Keating2008). In Parental Rights and Responsibilities, Harriet Churchill aims to examine understandings of parental rights and responsibilities underpinning welfare state support policies, primarily of the New Labour Government of 1997–2010, to reflect upon the assumptions about families and children and the division of responsibility between the state, parents and the community upon which these policies are premised, and compare these assumptions with sociological and social policy research into ‘everyday experiences of family life, parenthood and parenting’ (p. 10).
The introductory chapter details the influences upon her analysis which include ‘well-being studies’ (p. 9) and feminist and children's rights critiques employed to highlight how changes in family policy have social justice implications. In a book about the rights and responsibilities of parents, the introduction would have been an appropriate place in which to introduce the concepts of rights and responsibilities, different understandings of these concepts and the importance of finding there to be differences between understandings informing family policy and those of parents.
The book is well-structured in four self-contained parts. In the first part, Harriet Churchill offers an interesting account of concepts of child, family and social well-being (Chapter 2); a wide-ranging discussion of social trends including demographic changes, labour market trends, crime, child maltreatment, the consumerisation of childhood and citizenship (Chapter 3); and an overview of family policy from the 1980s, the more interventionist policies of New Labour (pp. 75–7), the differing perspectives within the Coalition Government and of family policies in relation to parental rights and responsibilities across Europe (pp. 79–87).
Part Two offers a more comprehensive review of the evolution of policies of the New Labour Government in the five areas of welfare-to-work, financial support, childcare, statutory family-friendly employment rights and family and parenting support services, highlighting the tensions between the parental roles of providing for, care of and raising children. A thorough review of financial support and welfare measures leads Churchill to the conclusion that the overall aim was ‘to promote active citizenship’ on the part of parents as citizens themselves and with responsibility for raising the active citizens of the future. ‘Labour's approach, however, risked elevating paid work and economic responsibilities above parental responsibilities for caring for children, and meant the welfare system did not support parents as parents or promote key aspects of child and family well-being . . . “being there” for children or addressing . . . welfare problems’ (p. 109): a conclusion supported by the experiences of parents identified in the subsequent review of the research. At the same time, she suggests, in terms of the balance between the responsibilities of the state and of parents with regard to children, the state took on greater responsibility for the regulation and subsidy of childcare whilst parents gained rights to access childcare (p. 129) and family-friendly employment rights (p. 131); again elevating economic responsibilities over responsibilities to care.
Different conceptions of parental responsibilities emerge from the review of policies on family and parenting support services (Chapter 7). Here, the responsibility of parents to care for, and raise, their children and to secure child well-being is more prominent. The tension underpinning policies on parental ‘support’ is between a view that all parents need information, guidance and support and some need to be directed to take responsibility and to be punished for failing to do so (p. 155). Child well-being emerged as a dominant discourse of New Labour family policy informing understandings of parental rights and responsibilities. Parents were assumed to be ‘reasonable, moral, rational citizens’ anxious to secure their child's well-being but who required the support of the government to achieve this (Gillies, Reference Gillies2005: 77).
Churchill then turns to a thematic analysis of sociological and social policy research on parental experiences. The two chapters in this part review research on a range of parenting topics which highlight the unresolved tension between caring for children – financial provision and daily care, education and monitoring, safeguarding and disciplining – and providing for children through the negotiation of family friendly working practices and childcare provision. The concluding chapter deftly ties together the discreet parts of the book, drawing upon the research findings to reflect critically back upon the evolution of recent family and parenting policy. The discussion of parental rights and responsibilities in the concluding chapter (pp. 220–2) supports the view that these concepts would have benefited from greater examination. Whilst Churchill rightly observes that a number of the policy measures ‘extended’ parental ‘responsibilities for children's outcomes and behaviour’ (p. 220), they were informed by contradictory understandings of the nature of parental responsibility. Furthermore, the conclusion that parents gained ‘important new rights’ begs questions as to the nature of these ‘rights’, at least where they are rights to access to childcare provision (for those who can afford to pay), the right to ask for flexible working or a ‘right’ to parenting support (p. 221). Examination of these concepts would be essential in development of a national statement of parental rights and responsibilities which Churchill advocates in her conclusion. That said, Parental Rights and Responsibilities undertakes a comprehensive and timely critical review, informed by the research literature, of the family and parenting policies of the New Labour government and offers some bold reflections upon the emerging policy of the Coalition government.
